*Rules & Legislation Committee on 2026-11-12 10:30 AM - Nov 12, 2026

November 12, 2026 · Rules Legislation Committee

Subscribe via RSS: Oakland City Council Rules Legislation CommitteeOakland City Council Meetings

Agenda

1. Approval Of The Draft Minutes From The Committee Meeting Of October 29, 2026

27-0182 Attachments: View Report

Attachments (4)

2. Determination Of Schedule Of Outstanding Committee Items

27-0183 Attachments: View Report View Supplemental Report - 11/05/2026

Attachments (2)

3.0. Subject: Ethical Investment Policy

From: Members Of The Public, Oakland Divest Committee Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution Of The Oakland City Council (1) To Amend The City Of Oakland Investment Policy To Prohibit Investments Of City Funds Or Holding Any Investment Or Ownership Stake In Any Companies That Facilitate And Enable State Violence And Repression, War And Occupation, And/Or Severe Violations Of International Law And Human Rights. This Includes, But Is Not Limited To (A) Mass Incarceration And Detention Industries, Including Those Which Use Prison Labor, (B) Security, Defense, And Military Industries, Including Transportation Of Goods, (C) Companies That Facilitate And Enable Violations Of International Law And Human Rights As Part Of The Israeli Occupation Of Palestinian And Syrian Lands And/Or As Part Of Israeli Apartheid; (2) Directing The City Administrator Or His/Her Designee To Examine The City's Holdings And Future Investments To Assure That The City Complies With This Policy And Set Forth An Implementation Plan Shared At The First Finance Meeting In May 2027; (3) Directing The City Administrator To Send A Copy Of The Resolution To Governmental Retirement Systems And Local Jurisdictions To Adopt A Similar Investment Policy; On The Finance And Management Committee - Date TBD 27-0103 Sponsors: Member(s) of the Public City of Oakland Page 4 Printed on 11/10/2026 4:53:12PM *Rules & Legislation Committee Agenda - SUPPLEMENTAL November 12, 2026

Attachments (1)

3.1. Subject: Request To Amend Existing Professional Services Agreement With ChildCare

Careers, LLC From: Human Services Department Recommendation: [TITLE CHANGE] [NEW TITLE] Adopt A Resolution Amending Resolutions 89937 C.M.S. And 90922 C.M.S. To Authorize An Increase In The Professional Services Agreement With ChildCare Careers, LLC By An Additional $800,000 For A Total Amount Not To Exceed $2,050,000 For As-Needed Substitute Teacher Staffing Services For The Contract Period Fiscal Year 2022-2027; On The November 17, 2026 Life Enrichment Committee Agenda [OLD TITLE] Adopt A Resolution Waiving The Local/Small Local Business Enterprise Program Requirement And Waiving The Competitive Bidding Process And Authorizing The City Administrator To Execute A Third Amendment To A Professional Services Agreement With Childcare Careers, LLC To Increase The Amount Of The Previous Contract By An Additional $800,000 For A Total Amount Not To Exceed $2,050,000 For As-Needed Substitute Teacher Staffing Services For The Contract Period Fiscal Year 2022-2027 27-0193 Sponsors: Human Services Department Legislative History 10/29/26 *Rules & Legislation Scheduled to the *Special Life Enrichment Committee Committee

Attachments (1)

3.2. Subject: Delinquent Real Property Transfer Taxes Assessment Of Liens

From: Finance Department Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution (1) Confirming The Report And Notice Of Liens For Delinquent Real Property Transfer Taxes With Penalties, Interest, And Administrative And Assessment Charges, And (2) Overruling Any Protests And Objections Related To The Liens Included In Said Report And Authorizing The Recordation Of Liens, And (3) Directing The Notice Of Lien And Assessment Charges Be Turned Over To The County Tax Collector For Collection; On The December 1, 2026 City Council Agenda As A Public Hearing 27-0227 Sponsors: Finance Department

Attachments (1)

3.3. Subject: Resolution In Remembrance Of The Ghost Ship Fire Tragedy

From: Councilmember Gallo Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution In Remembrance Of The Tenth Anniversary Of The Ghost Ship Fire Tragedy; Honoring The 36 Lives Lost; And Calling For A Moment Of Reflection And Silence; On The December 1, 2026 City Council Agenda As A Ceremonial 27-0228 Sponsors: Noel Gallo Rule 24: The Council Rules Provide That “Advisory Resolutions,” Including Ceremonial Resolutions, May Be Scheduled Directly To Council City of Oakland Page 5 Printed on 11/10/2026 4:53:12PM *Rules & Legislation Committee Agenda - SUPPLEMENTAL November 12, 2026

Attachments (1)

3.4. Subject: Acceptance Of Funding And Technical Assistance For BayREN

Decarbonization Showcase Program From: Office Of The City Administrator Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution (1) Accepting And Appropriating Technical Assistance And Gap Funding In An Amount Not To Exceed One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($100,000) From The Bay Area Regional Energy Network (BayREN) For Electrification Improvements At The Clinton Recreation Center, (2) Authorizing The City Administrator To Negotiate And Execute A Grant Agreement With Trybe, Inc. In An Amount Not To Exceed One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($100,000) For Eligible Project Costs; And (3) Adopting Appropriate California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Findings; On The December 8, 2026 Public Works And Transportation Committee Agenda 27-0226 Sponsors: Office Of The City Administrator

Attachments (1)

3.5. Subject: Working Solutions CDFI Small Business Lending And Technical Assistance

Contract From: Economic And Workforce Development Department Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution Awarding A Contract To Working Solutions CDFI To Provide Small Business Loans And Technical Assistance To Oakland Small Businesses And Administer The City’s Existing Revolving Loan Fund For An Initial One-Year Term For FY 2026-2027 In An Amount Not To Exceed Three Hundred Thousand Dollars ($300,000), With Two One-Year Options To Extend In An Amount Not To Exceed Three Hundred Thousand Dollars ($300,000) Per Year, For A Total Contract Amount Not To Exceed Nine Hundred Thousand Dollars ($900,000) Over Three Years, Contingent On Available Funding; On The December 8, 2026 Community And Economic Development Committee Agenda 27-0220 Sponsors: Economic & Workforce Development Department

Attachments (1)

3.6. Subject: EPA Brownfield Grant Subaward

From: Housing And Community Development Department Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution Authorizing The City Administrator To (1) Enter Into A Subaward Agreement With The County Of Alameda For An Amount Not To Exceed $19,728 And (2) Accept And Appropriate Subaward Funds For Staff Costs Associated With Implementing The 2026 Environmental Protection Agency Brownfield Assessment Coalition Grant; On The December 8, 2026 Community And Economic Development Committee Agenda 27-0231 Sponsors: Housing And Community Development Department City of Oakland Page 6 Printed on 11/10/2026 4:53:12PM *Rules & Legislation Committee Agenda - SUPPLEMENTAL November 12, 2026

Attachments (1)

3.7. Subject: FY 2025-26 Cultural Affairs Division Operations And FY 2027-29 Strategic

Outlook From: Economic And Workforce Development Department Recommendation: Receive An Informational Report From The Cultural Affairs Division Of The Economic & Workforce Development Department On Its FY 2025-26 Operations, Programs, And Activities, Including The Cultural Affairs Commission, And An Overview Of Current Initiatives And Strategic Priorities For FY 2027-28 And FY 2028-29; On The December 8, 2026 Life Enrichment Committee Agenda 27-0221 Sponsors: Economic & Workforce Development Department

Attachments (1)

3.8. Subject: Program Year 2025-2026 Annual Report, Early Childhood And Family Services

From: Human Services Department Recommendation: Receive An Informational Report On Program Year 2025-26 Activities And Accomplishments Of The Early Childhood And Family Services Division; On The December 8, 2026 Life Enrichment Committee Agenda 27-0222 Sponsors: Human Services Department

Attachments (1)

3.9. Subject: Ordinance Amending Chapter 8.70 Of The Oakland Municipal Code

From: Councilmember Wang Recommendation: [TITLE CHANGE] [NEW TITLE] Adopt An Ordinance Amending Chapter 8.70 Of The Oakland Municipal Code (Nuisance Vessels On Oakland Waters) To: (1) Expand The Definition Of “Nuisance Vessel” And Add The Definition Of “Dock” And “Docking”; (2) Establish Docking Time Limits And Limit Anchoring And Mooring Time To Four (4) Hours; (3) Reclassify Violations As Infractions; (4) Establish A Graduated Fine Structure; And (5) Include Vessel Impoundment As A Remedy And Grounds For Appeal; On The December 8, 2026 Public Safety Committee Agenda [OLD TITLE] Adopt An Ordinance Amending Chapter 8.70 Of The Oakland Municipal Code (Nuisance Vessels On Oakland Waters) To: (1) Expand The Definition Of “Nuisance Vessel” And Add The Definition Of “Dock” And “Docking”; (2) Establish Docking Time Limits And Limit Anchoring And Mooring Time To Four (4) Hours; (3) Reclassify Violations As Infractions; (4) Establish A Graduated Fine Structure; And (5) Include Vessel Impoundment As A Remedy 27-0213 Sponsors: Wang Legislative History 11/5/26 *Rules & Legislation Scheduled to the *Public Safety Committee Committee A Title Change Was Read Into Record And Accepted City of Oakland Page 7 Printed on 11/10/2026 4:53:12PM *Rules & Legislation Committee Agenda - SUPPLEMENTAL November 12, 2026

Attachments (1)

4. Review Of Draft Agendas, Pending Lists, City Council And Committee Meetings

27-0184 Attachments: Draft November 17, 2026 Special Finance And Managment Committee Agenda Draft November 17, 2026 Special Public Works And Transportation Committee Agenda Draft November 17, 2026 Special Community And Economic Development Committee Agenda Draft November 17, 2026 Special Life Enrichment Committee Agenda Draft November 17, 2026 Special Public Safety Committee Agenda November 19, 2026 Rules And Legislation Committee Agenda Finance And Management Committee Pending List Public Works And Transportation Committee Pending List Community And Economic Development Committee Pending List Life Enrichment Committee Pending List Education Partnership Committee Pending List Public Safety Committee Pending List Rules And Legislation Committee Pending List Port Liason Committee Pending List

Attachments (15)

5. Subject: Appointment To The City Planning Commission

From: Office Of The Mayor Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution Confirming The Mayor's Appointment Of Deidra Somerville To The City Planning Commission 27-0188 Sponsors: Office Of The Mayor and Jenkins Attachments: View Report View Resume View Legislation Legislative History 10/29/26 *Rules & Legislation Scheduled to the *Rules & Legislation Committee Committee Council President Jenkins Added As A Co Sponsor Open Forum Adjournment City of Oakland Page 8 Printed on 11/10/2026 4:53:12PM *Rules & Legislation Committee Agenda - SUPPLEMENTAL November 12, 2026 Americans With Disabilities Act If you need special assistance, including translation services to participate in Oakland City Council and Committee meetings please contact the Office of the City Clerk. When possible, please notify the City Clerk 5 days prior to the meeting so we can make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility. Also, in compliance with Oakland's policy for people with environmental illness or multiple chemical sensitivities, please refrain from wearing strongly scented products to meetings. Office of the City Clerk - Agenda Management Unit Phone: (510) 238-6406 Fax: (510) 238-6699 Recorded Agenda: (510) 238-2386 Telecommunications Relay Service:711 MATERIALS RELATED TO ITEMS ON THIS AGENDA SUBMITTED TO THE CITY COUNCIL AFTER DISTRIBUTION OF THE AGENDA PACKETS MAY BE VIEWED IN THE OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK, 1 FRANK H. OGAWA PLAZA, 1ST AND 2ND FLOOR, OAKLAND, CA 94612 FROM 8:30AM TO 5:00PM * In the event a quorum of the City Council participates on this Committee, the meeting is noticed as a Special Meeting of the City Council; however, no final City Council action can be taken. City of Oakland Page 9 Printed on 11/10/2026 4:53:12PM

Attachments (3)

Agenda Items

  1. 00:12:11 Appointment to the City Planning Commission The committee heard from the mayor’s representative, the nominee and public speakers before unanimously advancing the appointment to the December 1 Council consent agenda.
  2. 00:18:12 Ethical Investment Policy After extensive public testimony supporting and opposing proposed investment restrictions tied to human rights abuses, the committee placed the proposal on the finance pending list with no specific date.
  3. 00:44:36 Resolution in Remembrance of the Ghost Ship Fire Tragedy The clerk explained that the remembrance resolution could proceed directly to Council under Rule 24 as an advisory or ceremonial resolution.
  4. 00:45:03 Delinquent Real Property Transfer Taxes Assessment of Liens Staff requested bypassing committee for the delinquent transfer-tax lien public hearing, and members questioned the justification for direct Council scheduling.
  5. 00:53:17 Review of Draft Agendas, Pending Lists, Council and Committee Meetings The committee approved agenda changes involving the special Public Safety meeting time, towing contract, cannabis report, Council directives report and prompt payment policy report.

Transcript

Warning: This transcript is automatically generated by machine and may contain errors, including misheard words, misattributed speakers, and omitted passages. Always listen to the audio or video recording before assuming the transcript correctly reflects what was said. Do not rely on the transcript alone for quotation, reporting, or any other purpose where accuracy matters.
Is it attention everybody there is a fire alarm
Going off. Good morning and welcome to the rules and legislation committee of Thursday, November 12th
2026
Happy diabetes awareness month before I call roll
I will give over speaker card instructions if you would like to fill out a speaker's card in any item
You must fill out a card before the item is called for discussion or 10 minutes after the start of the meeting
This meeting was called to order at 10 39 a.m. So your last opportunity to turn in a speaker's card will be 10
49 a.m. Or before the item is called for discussion
On roll today. I have councilmember Brown present councilmember five present councilmember Ramachandran is excused and chair Jenkins
Present showing three members present today in one excuse. Do you have any announcement? Yes, absolutely
Thank you so much for being here
absolutely so I realize there is
a mince public interest in one
of the items right that I don't
will go on it- we will take
item five first.
You're out of order that's the
first warning- secondarily.
I have to take my mom to the
hospital I have to get my mom
from the hospital.
Speaker time will be one minute
I need to leave here by a
certain time.
And we will not have quorum.
I'm going to leave here.
5. Appointment to the City Planning Commission
Good morning, everyone.
I can be very brief because I know there's a lot of items in the agenda.
Yeah, the mayor's very excited to appoint Deidre to the Planning Commission.
We've been coordinating with Council President Jenkins and his office.
She brings a diverse range of experiences and is someone that is excited to serve.
And so we're excited to move her forward.
Great.
Thank you for that.
Does she want to have words?
Somerville if you would like to address the committee you are unmuted. Oh thank
you very much. One second. I am happy to be considered for this role. I'm a member
of the Eastmont 30 Y neighborhood council. I've been serving there since
moving to East Oakland recently and I'm very happy to support Oakland in all
of its endeavors and to support the commission and all the work that you are endeavoring
to do at this time. Thank you.
Thank you so much. Let's go to the public speakers, unless council members have something
to say. Nope. All right.
Move me to the public speakers. I have Ben Gould, Mrs. Adolabala and Blair Beekman in
any order please approach the podium. We have one minute.
Good morning council members. I'll be brief. My name is Ben Gould. I'm here speaking as
an individual.
I have no objections or support for DJRA as an individual, I think it's wonderful we have
people applying to the Planning Commission because we saw we couldn't have meetings there
due to quorum issues.
However, with the passage of Measure EE, I want you to remind you that the role of council
is to provide oversight and evaluation of the Mayor's nominations to commissions.
The Planning Commission serves as both a policy advisory body for the City Council, as well
as the quasi-judicial arm that makes decisions around approving projects.
And so I encourage you to take your roles as council members responsibly and seriously
and evaluating candidates for all commissions, this being the first one being put forward
when considering whether to approve the mayor's proposals, given the mayor can also veto recommendations
that you may want to approve otherwise.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Moving to Mr. Beekman, please unmute yourself and begin your comments.
Hi, Blair Beekman.
Thanks to look for the work on this item.
this can be a good choice.
I, as always, I'm concerned how planning goes for the future of Oakland, you know
the future of planning so goes the future of Oakland. You know we have to do
these things well and I think we're trying to set a new standard how we
work in Oakland and having good planning and real estate development is
It's just a really important concept
that we understand for the future of Oakland.
I'm understanding that that's how,
it's with our good social services programs,
we develop a better Oakland.
So good luck that this can be a good choice
and that we work towards a future of Oakland
that is for everyone.
Thank you.
That was the last speaker.
Move approval.
On the motion by council president Jenkins,
second by council member Brown,
to approve the staff recommendation.
Council Member Brown.
Aye.
Council Member Ramachandran is excused.
Chair Jenkins.
I'm sorry, Council Member Fyfe.
December 1st, Council on Consent.
Aye.
Jenkins.
Aye.
Motion passes with a vote of three ayes.
One excused, Ramachandran.
Moving back to the regular order of the agenda,
starting with item number one,
which is approval of the draft minutes
of the meeting of October 29th, 2026.
I do have two speakers.
Let's go to the public speakers.
Blair Beekman and Mrs. Asada Olabala, for item two.
I may take myself on this item, sorry about that, I passed.
Thank you, I do not see Ms. Olabala.
I'll entertain a motion.
On the motion by Council Member Brown,
second by Council Member Fai.
To approve the draft minutes,
Councilmember Brown.
Aye.
Councilmember Fyfe.
Aye.
Councilmember Ramachandran excused, Chair Jenkins.
Aye.
Motion passes with a vote of three ayes, one excused.
Going to item two, which is determination
of outstanding committee items.
Anything from the administration?
We have no changes.
Anything from my colleagues?
Let's go to public speakers.
Blair Beekman.
Hi, Blair Beekman.
This item can be a lot like what you're going to deal
with the public items or agenda items for,
so I'll just wait till that time to speak at that time, thank you.
I'll entertain a motion.
So moved.
Second.
On the motion to approve the pending list,
moved by Councilmember Fyfe,
second by Councilmember Brown.
Councilmember Brown?
Councilmember Fyfe?
Aye.
Chair Jenkins?
Aye.
Motion passes with a vote of three ayes,
now going to item three, which is new scheduling.
3.0. Ethical Investment Policy
Starting with item 3.0
Adopt a resolution of the Oakland City Council to amend the city of Oakland investment policy to prohibit
Investments of city funds for holding any investment or ownership staking companies that facilitate and enable state violence and repression
War and occupation and or severe violations of international law and human rights this includes
What is not limited to a mass incarceration and detention industry industries?
including those which use prior labor, security, defense, and military industries,
including transportation of goods, companies that facilitate and enable violations
of international law and human rights,
as part of the Israeli occupation of Palestine and Syrian lands and or
as part of Israeli apartheid, directing city administrator or
his or her designee to examine the city's holdings,
and future investments to assure that city, the city complies with this policy
Instead for directing the city administrator to send a copy of the resolution to government or retirement systems and local jurisdictions
To adopt a similar investment policy. This is asked to go to the finance and management committee
Item 3.1 is a title change. I will read the new title
adopted resolution amending resolution eight nine nine three seven and nine zero nine two two
To authorize an increase in the professional services agreement with childcare careers by an additional eight hundred thousand dollars
for a total amount not to exceed two million fifty thousand dollars for as needed substitute
teacher staffing for the contract period of fiscal year twenty two through twenty seven
on the november seventeenth life enrichment committee agenda item three point two a resolution
affirming the report and notice of liens for delinquent real property transfer taxes penalties
interest and administrative and assessment charges and overruling any protest and objections
related to the liens included in said report authorizing the recordation and
directing the notice of lien and assessment charges be turned over to the
county task collector for a collection on the December 1st City Council agenda
as a public hearing. Item 3.3, a resolution in remembrance of the 10th
anniversary of the ghost ship fire tragedy honoring the 36 lives lost and
calling for a moment of reflection and silence. This is asked to go to the
December 1st, 2026 City Council agenda as a ceremonial as your rule state we
will put that on consent item 3.4 a resolution accepting and appropriating
technical assistance and gap funding in an amount not to exceed $100,000 from
the Bay Area Regional Energy Network for electrification improvements at
the Clinton Recreation Center authorizing the city administrator to
Negotiate and execute a grant agreement with tribe Inc in an amount not to exceed
$100,000 for eligible project costs and adopting appropriate sequel findings
This is asked to go before the December 8th public works committee public works and transportation committee agenda
I'm 3.5 a resolution awarding a contract to working solutions
To provide small business loans and technical assistance to Oakland small business
Businesses and administer the city's existing revolving loan fund for an additional one-year fiscal year 26 to 27 in an amount not to exceed
$300,000 with two one-year options to extend in an amount not to exceed
$300,000 per year for a total contract amount not to exceed
$900,000 over three years
Contention on available funding on the December 8th
2026 CED committee
Item 3.6 a resolution authorizing the city administrator to enter into a sub-award agreement
for the county of Alameda for an amount not to exceed
$19,728 and accept appropriate sub-award funds for staff costs associated with implementing the
2026 environmental protection agency brownfield assessment coalition grant on the December a CED agenda
item 3.7
Receive an information report from the cultural affairs division on programs and activities
including the cultural affairs commission and an overview of current initiatives and
Strategic priorities for fiscal year 27 through 28 and 28 through 29 on the December 8th Life Enrichment Committee agenda
I'm 3.8 receive an information report on program year
25 to 26 activities and accomplishments for the early childhood and Family Services Division on the December 8th Life Enrichment Committee agenda
Item 3.9 is a title change. I will read the new title. Adopt an ordinance admitting Chapter
8.70 of the Oakland Municipal Code to expand the definition of nuisance vessel and add
the definition of dock and docking. Establish docking time limits and limits anchoring and
mooring time to four hours. Reclassify violations as infractions. Establish a graduated fine
structure and include vessel impoundment as a remedy and grounds for appeal. This is asked
to go to the December 8th public safety agenda.
And that does conclude your new scheduling items.
Thank you so much.
Item number three is a item that members of the public
are submitting via rule 24.
Is there a member of the public?
So we're gonna read rule 24, section four.
The rules and legislation committee shall not schedule
any item proposed by a member of the public
unless the member of the public
submits documentation with the scheduling request
demonstrating that they contacted each council member
to request a council member sponsor for their scheduling item
or refused or received no response within 48 hours.
Does someone have it printed out?
If not, it's okay.
Did you guys send it to the other council members?
If not, it's okay.
Ken, is there one representative
that can come to the microphone, please?
Emails were sent and then from our understanding
I think in the last three years
we did a roll.
We sent it to the city
administration as well as
yourself, President Jenkins.
I received it.
The other council members should
receive it.
Can you guys forward it to them
real quick?
To send the totality of those
responses?
Okay, yeah, definitely.
Okay.
And then, yeah, that's fine.
So, I want to make it clear,
right, rule 24 states, the
rules and legislation committee
members of City Council. A standing committee of the City Council, the Mayor, the City Administrator,
the City Attorney, City Auditor, or a member of the public to a standing committee and
or full council for consideration. May not shout. Wanna make that abundantly clear?
Definitely. And we hope you will. Thank you.
Thank you. Alright. Let's go. Yeah. So, one minute speaker time. They're gonna forge you
I do want to thank you so much
for your time this evening.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your feedback.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your time.
And as a standard procedure we will take those in chambers first and then move on to the Zoom speakers.
Miss Asada Ola Bala, Jonathan Mates-Mooching,
JB Lebovich, Fatima Yousaf,
Vish Soro, Imaan Munir,
Blair Beekman, Josh Beth, Pamela Drake,
Kathy Sade Kenny, Sarah Amir,
Patti Jocelewicz, Yaya Abuzaid,
Russell James Ward, Michael Vinson,
Fatima Yousef, I believe that might be a duplicate,
Salah Aiden Abari, Madeline Stacy, Jess Yonos Kobakaya,
sorry if I said it incorrectly,
Melinda Starr, Aiden Kelly, Steven, Ellen Jacobus,
Don Roberts, Angel YR, Lex Anderson,
I believe that may be a duplicate.
Ben Gould.
Vish sorry can't see your last name clearly with local 2320 Layla Hayani Petra Marar.
Nick Slater and David S go ahead.
Hi my name is Jonathan mates motion.
I'm a district two resident of Oakland.
Oakland should focus on Oakland problems.
There are so many things that I'm concerned about with this proposal but mainly I would
like the city council to focus on the problems of Oakland and making Oakland
better and not allow people to pull international politics concerns into a
meeting and wasting all of your time on an issue that you have no control over.
We need you to focus on Oakland. Since my children have been at Skyline high
school, there have been three shootings, but we are having trouble getting
Oakland to work with the school district to support, uh, needed this for the
supports needed for our children. Let's focus on Oakland problems, not
resolutions that target one group and not resolutions that fuel hate in our
community. Oakland can do better, please reject this resolution today. Thank you.
Good morning, I'm JB Liebovich representing the Oakland Jewish
Alliance. We support ethical investing but Oakland divest proposal selectively
targets Israel under the guise of ethical investing. That's not sound
public policy. Look at Alameda County. Its ethical investment policy is on hold. The
county needs an independent review of its reliance on the UN criteria and the risk of
lower returns that could strain county budgets. Oakland risks repeating those problems. What
about investment safety, liquidity, diversification, costs? Who decides which companies are prohibited?
And the proposal calls for an implementation plan after adoption. That's backwards. Please
do not schedule this for finance. At a minimum keep it pending until city finance staff,
independent investment experts and the city attorney provide written assessments. Oakland
divest proposal is neither responsible governance nor sound investment policy. Thank you.
My name is Steven. I'd like to cede my time to Jake Sullo. Good morning to you all. One
second. One second. I'm sorry, sir. What's your name? Jake Steven in. My name is Sullo
I will back for you.
My name is Ellen, I'd like to see my time as well.
So your name is Salah, Steven, and Ellen?
May I proceed?
Thank you, good morning to you.
I just wanna mention to you the impact
of what we're doing here.
I'm a Palestinian, and I run a nonprofit here,
and there are many nonprofits
that are running right now in Palestine.
And I have family there,
And when I talk to them, I say, what are you doing?
And here's the new term that's been adopted
by the entire nation, all we're alternating kids to school.
I say, what is that first time?
I say, what does that mean?
They say, OK, you know, we can't leave the house abandoned
by itself.
And we can't leave the mother by herself.
So I take two kids today to school.
And tomorrow, I take three kids to school,
and the first two kids.
say why do you need the rest? They say because settlers would come in the house
and take it over and then it's the end of our lives. What I'm asking you is to
consider what we're discussing here is that Oakland need not higher
profitability from any place that's combining income with horror. My entire
nation is living in horror and the horror is real and I say so how what
what happens when a settler walks in oh they just come and live in the living
room and they'll start using the bathroom while you're living there yes
while we're living there and what do they do they turn on the faucet all the
time and the water and electricity by the end of the month you got three
thousand dollar bill and if you want to pay it back well you're welcome to pay
it back but you can give up the house and we'll take over and we'll change it
our name. And they'll do that for an entire year. I have one people that
they're intergalactic and water bill turned into $75,000 in one year while
the settlers are erroneous and still going through the court. I want to tell
you a couple of stories that happen because they're relevant. My brother-in-law
lives in San Mateo, has been saving his life time saving 1.2 million piece in a
piece of land in the outskirts of the city of Janin,
went with the interior designer and civil engineer
to decide to make a little investment of a retail.
And when he got there, he found the Israeli flags everywhere.
And before you know it, he had about 14 people surrounding him.
They put him on the floor in the sun
with the stones on the black burning his flesh.
And they kept on saying, you can't move.
And every time they move, they start shooting at them.
And finally, they had all the 17 people
walk on them and they said didn't you know that this has been land has been
confiscated he said it's just my how my my retirement my whole thing they said
okay if you don't leave right now you will we will threaten you so now what
they take in that land which is 1.2 million dollars and the mountain before
it and three trailers came and they're starting a settlement so there thank you
mr. Salah your time is up good morning my name is Iman I was born and raised in
and my grandpa opened a small business here over 50 years ago.
After he expanded to provide fresh produce in an area historically regarded as a food desert,
our family business is recognized in the East Bay Express for its contributions to the community.
We attended Santa Fe in North Oakland,
which also happened to be the first distribution site for the Black Panthers Free Breakfast Program,
with which our very own Mary Lee was a volunteer.
And I learned about the party's work as a child from our longtime neighbor and customer, Mr. Robbie Seal.
but it was horrifying to learn how our government attacked those that dared to stand against systemic oppression.
These past few years, we've seen Oakland become almost unrecognizable in ways.
But I know those who truly love our city will always stand with the oppressed and respect the legacy of those who laid the groundwork before us.
It would be a shame as a model whose city is love life to fund the weapons actively ripping children to shreds.
Please vote yes on this ethical investment policy so we can focus on...
Thank you ma'am your time is up. Hello my name is Sarah, long time resident of
Oakland, born and raised here, a teacher here. I'm also part of the Nafid
Collective which is the people's movement for Sudanese liberation and I
wanted to make a connection between the counter-revolutionary war that's going on
in Sudan and how our money funds Israel. Long story short UAE, that
that facilitates genocide in Sudan
is also paid off by Israel.
But something that someone said
was how we should focus on Oakland's problems
and this is an Oakland problem.
The money that we get, that we pour into taxes here
is then being invested towards genocide, towards murders,
towards things the average Oaklander will not accept.
If you give them a gun in their head,
tell them to kill a kid, they wouldn't do it.
At what point in the paying people offline, is that okay?
This is an Oakland problem and you should support this.
Thank you.
Hello, my name is Yahia Bouzaid.
I'm a policy coordinator with the Council
on American Islamic Relations, San Francisco Bay Area.
And I respectfully urge you to adopt or vote yes
on the ethical investment policy
and schedule it for the December 8th finance meeting.
Oakland has a rich political history
that you don't need me to educate you on.
We all know it.
But what you may not know
is that people around the world know Oakland.
When I lived in the Middle East in 2011
during the revolutions, people held posters
saying they stood in solidarity with Oakland, California.
So that speaks to our impact as a city.
And I urge you, in this time where we see backsliding
in the Bay Area, to be a beacon of progress
of this city and a beacon of
standing up for ethics and
rules that reflect the unbending
nature of Oakland so let me
read thank you sir your time is
up.
Hello council my name is Aiden
Kelly I am an elected officer
of you a W. I'm here on behalf
of you a W. region six we
strongly support this policy
and I hope the council will
My name is Patti Josselowitz.
I am a long time Oakland resident,
a proud member of Oakland's Jewish community.
I urge you to reject this divestment policy.
Oakland City Council must focus on Oakland.
The International, Discussed, and City Hall should,
should be International Boulevard.
One second, pause our time.
Let's be respectful of all speakers.
Please continue.
International, Discussed, and City Hall
should be International Boulevard.
Whatever your views on the Middle East,
the effect here in Oakland has been unmistakable.
Many Jewish residents feel increasingly unwelcome
and unsafe.
We've witnessed hostile rhetoric, hateful graffiti,
and growing division in our city.
None of that helps Palestinians, Israelis,
or the people of Oakland.
Our city council should be focused on the issues
that matter most to Oaklanders, public safety,
economic recovery, homelessness,
and restoring trust in our city,
not adopting divisive international political resolutions.
Oakland has always been strong us when we bring people together, not when we
single out one. Hi, everybody. My name is Kathy Saade Kenny.
I'm a resident of Oakland, uh, district one,
and I'm a proud Palestinian American.
And today I'm speaking for indivisible East Bay.
We have about 12,000 members and, um, they support this effort.
Um, you've heard the reasons why, um, sorry,
We urge you to move this legislation forward
and vote yes at every stage of the City Council process.
Over the past three years, Israel,
with American weapons and military support,
has killed tens of thousands of children,
sorry, yeah, 20,000 children,
hundreds of journalists,
and has targeted hospitals and healthcare systems,
and just yesterday a strike on the Nasser Hospital in Gaza
killed at least six people, including a...
Thank you, your time is up.
Good morning council members, my name is Ben Gould.
I serve on the Budget Advisory Commission
as well as on the board
of the Alameda County Jewish Democratic Club
but today I'm speaking as an individual.
I'm asking you to take no action on this item.
This item does not serve Oakland residents.
Oaklanders want and deserve a government that works for them
and when uses the tax dollars wisely,
which we saw with the votes on both on Measure E
as well as Measure EE.
But rather than help Oakland service residents,
this item intends to hijack our city's resources
to attack a foreign country 7,000 miles away.
Moving this forward provide no benefit to Oakland residents.
Instead, it would waste city council and staff time,
potentially worsen the city's credit rating,
risk exposing the city to lawsuits,
and could undermine our efforts
to attract new revenue-generating businesses to Oakland.
We need our resources to deliver services
and infrastructure for Oaklanders.
We do not need the city to be getting involved
in foreign conflicts.
This item should be rejected out of hand.
Thank you.
My name is David.
I'm an Oakland resident and I am with JCRC Bay Area,
which represents 70 synagogues and Jewish organizations
and more than 30,000 supporters across the Bay Area.
I urge you to vote no on item three.
Oakland is facing a $100 million structural deficit.
The proposal risks further destabilizing
the city's finances by forcing the sale
of its $47 million corporate bond portfolio,
despite corporate bonds representing
just 2% of the city's investments.
Oakland already has policies
addressing socially responsible investing,
including restrictions on firearms manufacturers
and fossil fuel companies.
This proposal adds sweeping restrictions
that could jeopardize existing investments
and limit responsible financial management.
Finally, Singling Out Israel creates a divisive forum
for foreign policy debates
and risks further alienating Oakland's Jewish community.
Oakland deserves responsible investment policies
that are practical, consistent, and financially sound.
Please vote no on item three, thank you.
There's a mic on the table.
My name is Zameen, I'm an Oakland panhandler.
Please stop the genocide, like my brother here,
or don't play a hand in the genocide,
like my brother here saying, the world is becoming
a global village if you don't have shame from the world.
ashamed from your children if we stop to date they would be banging on the city
halls tomorrow moving to the zoom speaker mr. Beekman please unmute
yourself and begin your comments all right where begins um Oakland is really
trying to define themselves as a city of love life and that means decision making
that is not practicing harm to other people we want to learn to do that in
Oakland. So this is an important matter you're trying to figure out. Thank you.
I think our love for Israel really asked Israel how can they address their really
difficult current situations in terms of dialogue and not war, not continual war. How do we do that?
Oakland's trying to ask that right now. There are ways that we can be supporting the efforts of
Israel towards a drawdown for still offering them support but asking for a
drawing how can open city council work towards that sort of philosophy at this
time which seems an important concept that can respect Israel and ask for a
future without or or Israel has a can have an important responsibility thank
you mr. Beekman for your comments at this time all names have been called so
If people want to speak up down and write for mom if you came here and you want to speak
please
proceed
When everybody who wants to be heard to be heard, please
Yeah, as long as you have a card
3.3. Resolution in Remembrance of the Ghost Ship Fire Tragedy
And through the chair while we're waiting I did
Neglect to read the rule 24 on item 3.3, which was a revolution
I'm sorry a resolution in remembrance of the ghost ship fire tragedy the rule 24
On the face of the agenda is the council rules provide that that advisory
Resolutions including ceremonial resolutions may be scheduled directly to council and additionally
3.2. Delinquent Real Property Transfer Taxes Assessment of Liens
We do need a rule 24 reason for item 3.2
Which is the delinquent real property transfer taxes, so staff is in the building for that
Also, if your name was called and you do wish to speak please approach the podium because I have read all the speaker cards
Good morning council
So far for the item with our entity report
We are going to request to bypass committee and going straight to council
Because it's a public hearings. We'd like to request to bypass committee
Doesn't have to bypass committee is there urgency like a time urgency I
believe that finance and management committee
Okay.
Is there anybody else who filled out a speaker card that would like to speak?
Public speaking, convinced?
Yep.
Thank you so much.
Unfortunately, I can't get into my email.
I'm not sure what that's about.
Okay.
Outlook is down, but no matter.
I think first off I would say that while I have,
I do have some questions about the resolution
that was sent over,
specifically questions to our finance department.
The rules and legislation committee is a scheduling body.
And so it wouldn't be appropriate for me
to be asking detailed questions about this item
at this time.
And so I am okay with sending this item
That is what we're going to do
and that's what we're going to
do.
That's what we're going to do
and that's what we're going to
do.
We're going to do the finance
committee.
And this is going to be the last
rule twenty four section four we
will be changing the rules.
Thank you.
Has there been any
conversation- president Jenkins
with the finance chair about a
date specific or.
Is councilmember on the
agenda and available.
Council president Jenkins and
members of the rule committee I
cannot reach her she's ill
that we need to be able to
provide support moving into the
finance committee.
This sounds like a request.
And maybe I'm not reading it
correctly, I definitely want to
meet with the groups that are
here speaking today to find out
what the city of Oakland's
investment policies are and
where we actually invest our
taxpayer dollars.
And I do want to say that it's
who are asking us to investigate our investment policy
and then to have other Oakland residents say
Oakland residents don't want to investigate
or interrogate our investment policy.
So I'm a little challenged with the conversation
I'm hearing today, but what I wanna find out
as an elected official is where we do invest our resources
and I don't wanna single out just one individual country
I wanna look at what's happening in our sister cities
that are also under oppressive governments
or other investment policies that could be problematic
for the city of Oakland that are,
that run contradictory to what our city's values are.
I don't think it does us a disservice
to interrogate that and to make good decisions.
So I'm fine with scheduling it to the finance committee.
I just need to know what the chair says.
So we can either, there's two things that are going on,
right, so, oh, there's more.
I would like to talk to the groups first.
Honestly, I need to talk.
We need to, I need to be able to go
and go through the legislation with you.
So I would support putting this,
I'll follow your lead, council president.
Okay, so there's two options.
We could leave it rules pending, right?
Unless you guys want to state that like they've complied.
Because the action that you take means that they have complied
with the letter of the law and the spirit of the law.
So we could put it pending there,
or we could put it pending in finance,
being that we cannot reach the chair.
OK.
I'm happy to go with the will of the body.
I need to review the legislation with the organizations.
And I want to hear from the opposing organizations today,
too, because, again, the logic that I heard on the record
does not compute with me.
OK.
So you're out of order.
Yeah, that's what they said.
So we'll place it on.
OK, so pending no date specific finance.
I'll entertain a motion.
no date specific, I'll entertain a motion, we didn't have any changes. Okay. Council
McPherson. I need to be, I want clarity. Are we saying pending no date specific for the
Rules Committee or the Finance Committee? Finance. I'll approve that motion. And I guess
just saying this out loud, then ensuring that we're connecting with the chair of the Finance
committee to get the item scheduled for finance and so I I mean I second it. On
item three we have a move by councilmember five second by councilmember
Brown noting that item 3.0 will be going to the finance pending list no date
specific and noting the rule 24 is for item 3.2 and 3.3. Councilmember Brown
aye. Council member five? Aye. And chair Jenkins? Aye. Motion passes with a vote of three
4. Review of Draft Agendas, Pending Lists, Council and Committee Meetings
ayes going on to item four which is review of the draft agendas and pending
lists, City Council and committee meetings. I have two speakers on this
item. Good morning council. Bridget Ruiz-Reveso, policy director for
councilmember Wong the December I'm sorry the November 17th special public
safety committee one second your long distance councilmember Wong would like
to move that to five o'clock I know that that was an offer last week and we just
needed to confirm that councilmember Brown excellent thank you so much I
I wanted to, I'm not seeing the draft agenda,
but it's for the December 1st city council meeting.
My item honoring the WNBA Golden State Valkyries
and celebrating MVP Gabby Williams,
wanted to move that to January 19th,
the council meeting on January 19th, 2027.
Can I do that?
Through the chair, that rules agenda
will be in the packet next week.
I mean, that council agenda will be in the packet.
make a motion to aye aye.
Okay all right so I'll hold.
Good morning Tracy Jones.
Police services manager for
Oakland police department.
For the special public safety
committee draft agenda.
Opie D would like to move item
number five from.
November seventeenth to
December fifth I'm sorry
December eighth.
Public safety.
Said November you're moving
item what item number five.
17th to December 8th. Okay. Through the chair to clarify you said on the
November 17th Public Safety Committee you're moving item 5 which is the OPZ
APD towing contract? That's correct. Thank you. Thank you. Through the chair we move
from the city administrators office to the for the draft agenda for November
17th for CED. Staff has requested that item number four, the Cannabis Info
Report be moved to the January 26th CED and we've already asked them Council
Member Gayo for approval. Through the Chair also the administration requests
that for the draft November 17th FMC special meeting that item number six on
Council directives be moved to December 8th to match the corresponding report
to public safety committee.
I'm sorry, I missed that.
It's okay.
For FMC, November 17th,
item number six to December 8th.
Perfect.
Iris.
Hi, thank you.
Good morning again.
Iris Merrins, Chief of Staff to Councilmember Ramachandran.
I wanna draw your attention to the pending list,
and we'd like the informational report
for the city administrator.
I'm sorry. We'd like the informational report for prompt payment policy to be added to the November 17th Finance and Management Committee.
Said that one more time. So the prompt payment information report on the city's prompt payment policy. What what day is that on for the November. It's on the pending list currently.
and to move to the Finance and Management Committee
on November 17th.
Thank you. OK. Thank you.
Any speakers?
Mrs.
Sada, Ola Bala and Blair Beekman.
Hi, Blair Beekman.
Yeah, you know, from the horrific acts from Hamas,
they were asking questions.
They wanted answers.
It's really important.
I think Israel kind of works towards answers towards dialogue
and peace and not war to solve the horrific acts of Hamas.
Good luck how we go about that.
And Oakland, you're trying to find the way to do that
for both sides, for all sides.
Good luck in your effort.
I wanted to comment that you have a Safe Streaks 2025 study.
You're supposed to...
Mr. Beekman, are you still there?
Sounds like we lost him.
Oakland, an example of, you know,
we're trying to address a better principled future
for ourselves by leaving Flock
and leaving their concepts of continual war
they're basically following.
We're trying to find a well-principled future
that doesn't practice.
Thank you, Mr. Beekman.
Mr. Chair, that was the only speaker
as I do not see Ms. Oluwala.
Okay, so noting item number one from FMC
moved to November 17th,
item number six from FMC moved to December 8th, CED,
item number four moved to the pending list, public safety,
item number five to December 8th.
Public safety meeting being scheduled
for a special five p.m. in the prom payment,
pending FMC informational report to November 17th.
I'll entertain a motion.
On item four moved by Council Member Brown,
seconded by Council Member Fyfe,
to approve item four as amended.
Council Member Brown.
Aye. Council Member Fyfe.
Aye.
Chair Jenkins.
Aye.
passes with a vote of three ayes noting that councilmember Ramachandran is
excused as we've already dispensed with item number five moving to open forum
Jimmy Pratt Blair Beekman and missus out of Alabama and Ellen Jacobus please
approach the podium or raise your hand on zoom please approach the podium in
any order hi my name is Ellen are we able to see time for open forum okay
thank you I'm a member of the Oakland divest coalition I want to say thank you
Thank you so much for hearing us today.
We've been here before, and I know we've been reaching out
to all of you.
You've all gotten our emails and emails from everyone else.
I wanna say thank you for the time that you have taken
and will take to continue to meet with us
and talk through this legislation
and our vision for the Oakland of the future.
Thank you.
Thank you.
I'm sorry I don't have a card for you for open forum.
Moving to the Zoom speaker,
unless Jimmy Pratt is in the chambers.
Jimmy Pratt, moving to Blair Beekman.
Please unmute yourself and begin your comments.
Hi, Blair Beekman.
Yeah, I'm concerned about the ongoing efforts.
It's really the time we have to start introducing
the future as a community process, the weaving flock
and what our welcome people values are about
in looking for a new ale vendor as a community process.
it means asking the questions of practicing public safety still,
but having better principle plays in the process.
I really try to make an important emphasis that as we're doing this,
we also need to be talking about how we can be reducing some surveillance technology
in local neighborhoods while still respecting public safety.
There's a lot of redundant extra tech that we have in place that you guys know
And that know that we can reduce some tech while still maintaining best practices
I think that has to be a part of the conversation in leaving floss for a new
Better principle deal your vendor in the future or perhaps no
Had you for item three, but not this item
When
One second we'll check with the clerks. No not for open forum. All right. Thank you. All right. This meeting is adjourned