Good afternoon and welcome to the Community and Economic Development Committee Meeting
of Tuesday, November 17, 2026.
The time is now 1.31 p.m. and this meeting may come to order.
Before taking roll, I will provide instructions on how to submit speaker cards for items on
this agenda.
If you're here with us in chamber and would like to submit a speaker card, please fill
one out and turn one into myself or a clerk representative, no later than 10 minutes after
the start of this meeting or before the item is read into record.
And speaker requests were due 24 hours
prior to the start of this meeting.
This meeting came to order at 1.31 p.m.
and speaker cards will no longer be accepted
10 minutes after, making that time 1.41 p.m.
We'll now proceed with taking roll.
Council members, five?
Present.
Ramachandran, excused.
Unger?
Here.
And Chair Brown?
Present.
Thank you, we have three members present,
one excused, Ramachandran.
Chair, before we begin,
do you have any announcements at this time?
Yes, well thank you so much, everyone,
for joining us at the community
and economic development committee.
I wanted to take a moment to extend a warm welcome
to the students from Oakland High School,
the Law and Social Justice Academy.
Thank you so much for joining us today,
and that is my only announcement.
Okay, thank you so much.
Noting that item one, this is a special meeting,
so there are no minutes to be approved.
reading in item two determination of schedule about standing committee items
and we have one speaker for this item excellent thank you so much any changes
or announcements from the administration thank you chair there are
no changes at this time perfect thank you so much we can hear from the one
public speaker thank you calling in the name that sign up to speak on item number
too, Miss Asada Olliballa. There is no city in this country that can provide services,
resources, or benefits without having a preference or priority component because you can't do it for
everybody. The city of Oakland has a high housing preference order that is completely unacceptable.
Your preference order is that you have displaced households, neighborhood
residents, Oakland residents and workers. That's it.
Now the city of Berkeley has a preference order for housing.
It includes displaced due to foreclosure,
displaced due to eviction, uh,
families with children, homeless and people at risk of homelessness.
It has persons who are residents of neighborhoods,
parents or guardians living in red line neighborhoods.
And the ones that are not in their list,
citizens should be a preference.
Veterans, there's no way a veteran should be on the street.
There's no way.
There's no way that a senior should be on the street.
The 52% of the homeless in the city of Oakland are seniors.
Anybody that has a health or mental condition.
We got so many preferences that could be prioritized.
The preferences that you have,
you gotta readdress preference for housing in this city.
It's unacceptable.
Thank you for your comments, Chair.
That concludes all speakers on this item.
Perfect, thank you so much.
I'll entertain a motion.
So moved.
Perfect, second.
Thank you.
We have a motion made by Council Member Unger,
seconded by chair Brown to accept the determination
of schedule of outstanding committee items
as is, on roll, council members five?
Aye.
Ramachandran excused.
Unger?
Aye.
And chair Brown?
Aye.
Thank you motion passes with three ayes, one excused,
Ramachandran to accept the pending list as is.
Reading in item three,
receive an informational report
on anti-displacement programs including rent adjustment
program annual report by the housing
and community development department
for fiscal year 2025 to 26.
And we have 10 speakers on this item.
Thank you.
So for this item,
I know that it will be a joint presentation
from our team,
from the housing and community development.
Hello, council members.
Hugo Ramirez, HCD Deputy Director.
I'm joined today by Claudia Flores
of Community Development and Engagement,
also known as CDE.
And by Jesse Levitt of the Rent Adjustment Program,
also known as RAP.
These two units comprise HCD's Community Development Division,
which I lead and which is responsible for implementation
of our Anti-Displacement Strategic Action Plan, or ADSAP,
which Council accepted in March, 2026.
This annual report for fiscal year 2526
encompasses performance reporting
for targeted homelessness prevention
and eviction prevention programs, the RAP annual report,
and progress on the implementation strategies of the ADSAAP.
In this informational report,
we'll provide an overview of the strategic frameworks
of both HCD and the ADSAAP,
the implementation strategies of the ADSAAP,
fiscal year 2526 performance by both CDE and REP,
and a look ahead at 2027.
HCD's mission is to improve our neighborhoods
and to ensure our residents have safe
and affordable housing.
Before I share how we do this,
it's important to share where HCD
and its community development division
fit into the larger spectrum of housing investments.
As you can see here, the city's housing investments
range from policies and services
that promote housing stability for our residents
to the facilitation of market rate production
and everything in between.
As you can also see, our sibling departments
have an important role to play in housing, homelessness,
and anti-displacement in their respective areas
on this spectrum and in other spheres of influence,
such as economic development and cultural preservation.
The focus of today's annual report
is on the leftmost side of the spectrum,
city-wide stability policies and services
and targeted prevention.
HCD's role focuses on the three P's approach
of preservation of existing affordable housing,
production of new affordable housing, and today's focus,
the protection of Oaklanders from displacement.
HCD's Community Development Division is responsible
for implementing services and policies
that protect Oaklanders from displacement.
CDE oversees our community-based anti-displacement programs,
such as targeted homelessness prevention,
eviction prevention, fair housing,
code compliance relocation, among other programs.
CDE also administers the city's formula-based grants
from the U.S. Department of Housing
and Urban Development, or HUD.
RAP implements Oakland's rental housing laws
by providing services to rental property owners and tenants.
Every year, RAP interacts with thousands of tenants,
property owners, and property managers.
Its core function is to administer a petition process
to adjust rents for units covered
by the rent adjustment ordinance,
also known as rent control.
Other functions include annual rent registration,
counseling, and education outreach,
and partnerships with community-based organizations,
some of which are here today.
Policy and administration,
and the implementation of other rental housing laws,
such as the Just Cause for Eviction ordinance.
The AD SAP was developed using the City of Oakland's
Racial Equity Impact Analysis, or RAIA, process,
which as you can see here,
starts with naming the desired future condition.
All residents are securely housed
and living in thriving, healthy communities,
including those most impacted by racial disparities.
We then analyze disparity data to identify disparities,
where the disparities are highest,
and we engage our most impacted residents
to deepen our understanding,
and to devise strategies to reduce these disparities.
We then implement, evaluate, and improve
following the same process continually.
So we developed this equitable investment framework,
this pyramid, to prioritize our extremely limited
departmental resources to have the greatest equity impact
on our residents at highest risk of housing loss
and long-term deep poverty.
The ADSAP describes in detail the disparity data
to support why homelessness prevention
is our highest anti-displacement priority.
The persistent disproportionality of homelessness
among black residents who account for 56%
of Oakland's unhoused population,
despite representing only 21% of our overall population.
This is both our greatest unmet need
and our greatest opportunity for equity impact.
This framework also names other high priority,
other high priorities addressing the needs
of our most vulnerable tenants, homeowners,
and small property owners.
And finally, the foundation of this pyramid
is a protective policy environment
that promotes housing stability.
And as you can see here,
RAP implements most of these foundational policies
and CDE, the Housing Stability Direct Services,
though both programs implement both policy
and direct services.
All right, so before we move on to performance,
the implementation strategies of the AD SAP.
So, we set out to implement
the following high-level strategies.
Prioritize services to residents most impacted
by housing disparities, improve housing habitability,
increase small property owner viability,
strengthen tenant protection policies,
and increase the viability
of intergenerational home ownership.
Since this annual report is year one of the ADSAP,
some of these implementation strategies
will launch next fiscal year.
I'll touch on these in the look ahead
at the conclusion of our presentation today.
So I will now ask Claudia Flores to present
on performance of the Community Development
and Engagement Unit, or CDE.
Good afternoon council members, Claudia Flores, HCD staff.
So I'm gonna go over some of the data
and the outcomes from the contracts on this slide
for homelessness prevention, eviction prevention,
fair housing, or in-house code compliance relocation,
and as well as some preliminary information related
to the displaced tenants from recent fire emergencies.
In terms of targeted homelessness prevention,
we all know that it's dramatically more cost effective
to keep our most impacted residents house
and to help them after they have lost their housing.
This slide has some of the outcomes
from the targeted homelessness prevention program
that includes all funding sources.
So Alameda County and others leveraged
to support Oakland residents.
As you can see on this slide,
the last fiscal year, the Key People House Collaborative
reached 4,000 residents.
And this Oakland outreach was primarily focused
in West and East Oakland.
They process over 3,000 applications.
They deliver close to $4 million
in direct financial assistance
to stabilize over 800 households.
65% of those households identified
as black and African-American households,
which is critical as our black Oakland residents account
for 56% of the unhoused...
Can you hold one second?
Mrs. Sada.
We are 100% interested in what you have to say
in your feedback, but I think myself and my colleagues,
we would like to hear the complete presentation
and then we can hear from you.
Thank you.
During public comment.
Okay.
Please continue.
This is important as this population accounts
for 56% of the unhoused population
despite being 21% of the city's population.
Now this is just one of several efforts
the city of Oakland is doing,
so it is one of the efforts contributing to the trends
that are at the bottom of this slide
where you can see a decrease in the point in time counts
between 2024 and 2026 and a parallel decrease
in homelessness among black Oaklanders
of approximately 14% during the same time period.
Though I will say that for the overall,
it was a 19.6%, so there's still some work to do
in terms of doing better for most at-risk populations.
This is just, this is the same program,
but just the city funding, which is 3.6 million
of both CDBG, as well as fund, $18.70.
And you can also see the logos of the partner organizations
at the bottom for the Key People House program.
For this and the other contrast we will see in subsequent
slides is that CBO partners are meeting and exceeding
their contract goals for the most part, which
is positive in terms of ability to meet the contract,
but also speaks to the high need for these services.
Some highlights for this contract include serving
over 143% of the targeted goal,
preventing immediate loss of housing
for all of the 496 households
who receive financial assistance.
And there's still some ongoing follow up
to checking on longer term stabilization
for these households.
For the eviction prevention contract,
which is 1.1 million from 1870 source funds.
The partner logo you can also see
at the bottom of the slide
for the Oakland House Insecure Collaborative.
Similar to the last slide,
this collaborative has met and exceeded
most of the contract goals
in terms of number of clients that receive services
and also have positive outcomes
in legal representation and consultation cases.
The contract is serving very close to half
of our black African-American residents,
which again is important given the data I just shared
in terms of over-representation and homelessness
as well as other housing-related outcomes.
For the fair housing contract,
that's a little bit over a quarter of a million dollars
in primarily CDBG funds led primarily by EVCLC.
And again, the contract goals were all met or exceeded.
And there were over $100,000 in financial benefits
secure for the tenants served.
And again, the majority of residents who were served
identified as black or African-American.
The Code Compliance Relocation Program
is an in-house program.
Can I have the slides again, please?
Funded by CDBG dollars and the ordinance.
Sorry, I'll just keep reading my slides.
It assists property owners and tenants navigate
their rights and responsibilities
when tenants have to relocate temporarily
due to code compliance issues.
In a minute you'll see how many tenants and property owners
were informed of their rights and responsibilities,
that's close to 200.
As well as the breakdown of owner paid
as well as CCRP relocation payments.
So they were close to 60 payments
and the total for all of the payments around $276,000.
Thank you.
Next slide.
This is, I have the controls here, yes.
I'll give you a minute to take a look at it.
And this is the last slide.
Unfortunately, this past year,
over 170 households were also displaced by fire events,
and HCD plays a part in the city response
and activating partners to support tenants.
For these events, these were not funds
that our department had programmed,
so we staff brought some emergency resolutions to council.
And for these unexpected events,
we rely on flexible funding like Boomerang, 1870 funds,
and for our 27-28 scope of work and our budget next year,
we will include a contingency plan
for these services for future emergencies.
We all know that El Nino is here,
and unfortunately we might see additional emergencies.
And HCD, together with other city agencies,
are central to the preparedness.
We've been responsive, and we'll continue to be responsive,
and we also want to thank the partners
to mobilize quickly to support displaced Oakland residents.
We will also, we're still evaluating the data
for all of these households.
So we'll have, we can send additional information
on specific outcomes.
I will now turn it over to Jesse
to talk about the Rent Adjustment Program.
Good afternoon, Chair, members of the committee.
I'm Jesse Levitt, Assistant Program Manager for RAP,
and I'm gonna talk today about a few aspects of RAP's work.
Starting with our in-house performance, so the quick context, RAPA is divided into four
units.
We have an administration policy unit, which oversees really the whole management of the
program, and then the other three units are lifted here.
So starting with the rent registry, that team is the group that's responsible for implementation
of the rent registry program.
They maintain the database.
They inform owners of the requirements, and they support compliance through a ton of outreach
to owners and technical assistance. And what we wanted to note here is that our compliance
rate at the end of the fiscal year was 72%, meaning 72% of owners who need to comply complied.
We're really happy with that number. The first year that owners had to comply was fiscal
year 22-23, and that was 55%. So we've really done a steady increase, and we're working
to get all the way up to 100 percent. In terms of what we do to kind of help compliance,
in addition to lots of mailings and phone calls and emails, during the registration
period, which is January through March, we also held a number of workshops for multiple
owners to provide them with information and help. And we also provided two day a week
in person drop in support for owners every week during that registration period.
The next unit that we have is the hearings unit,
which is our quasi-judicial body that resolves disputes
between tenants and owners about rent.
And just to kind of give a sense of the quantity of work
that's coming in and the types of work,
there were almost 300 petitions filed last year
with the rent adjustment program.
And the main grounds for tenants
were decreased housing service,
which means that a tenant filed a petition
alleging that the bundle of services
that that household got reduced,
though their rent remained the same.
And so they file a petition asking for a decrease
in the rent for the period
where the bundle of services was lower
to reflect that decrease in services.
The main grounds of petitions for owners
is capital improvement pass-through,
which means an owner is seeking to improve
property in a way that primarily benefits the tenants and they want to
pass through the cost of those improvements or percentage of the cost
of those improvements to the tenants and that would be things like new flooring,
painting, fencing, security, things like that. And then finally on this slide we
have the counseling team which provides counseling to tenants and
owners and really anybody who wants to call to find out more about Oakland's
rent laws, so it could be property managers, or realtors, or prospective tenants, or owners.
That team provided almost 4,000 community members with counseling in the fiscal year.
The top concerns that they gave support around were rent increases, the Just Cause Ordinance
and eviction notices.
They also year-round, that team, two days a week provided in-person counseling sessions,
which were well used and I think people really appreciated.
That team also provided 15 workshops in the fiscal year
that were attended by almost 300 community members.
We also, as you know, have contracts
with external organizations for the provision
of RAP related services to owners and tenants.
That's primarily focused on preparation for
and representation at RAP hearings and board appeals.
So we have a contract with Center-Ligal
to serve low and moderate income tenants,
and we have a contract with
East Bay Rental Housing Association
to serve small property owners.
These contracts expire in 2027.
And as I think Ugo will speak to a little bit more,
we are engaged in a RAP-REA process,
and we're really looking at the recommendations
that come out of that, the data that comes out of that,
to help inform and fine tune our service goals
as we start the procurement process
for these representation contracts in early
or the first half of 2027.
And then finally, I wanted to give a brief status update
on RAPS finances, which improved significantly
in the last fiscal year.
We see that as primarily due to the city council
approved fee increase from 101 to $137 per coverage unit.
We also worked with finance on collection of RAP fees, including overdue fees, so that helped a lot.
And then where we could be implementing cost control, so like reduction in staff travel, things like that.
And what this means for us that we're really happy about is that we really can fully, hopefully fully implement the recommendations that have arisen from the RAP REA,
including fully staffing RAP,
which is at one third of its authorized staffing.
It's authorized for 33 staff and we have 11 vacancies.
So we're really excited about being able to do the work
that we have now identified if necessary.
Thank you so much, I'm gonna pass it back to Ugo.
All right, well, looking ahead to 2027.
Again, fiscal year 2526 is the inaugural reporting year
for the ADSAAP, and some strategies are not expected
to be implemented until 2027.
I will highlight these five items on the screen.
The RAP REA is an ongoing collaboration
with the Department of Race and Equity,
examining the petition process and contracted services.
We are following the REA process
and will develop data-driven recommendations
for policy and service improvements,
including proposed ordinance amendments
and reprocurement of all contracted services
among other strategies to increase trust and access,
improve customer experience and streamline processes,
and to drive performance evaluation and accountability.
In 2027, we'll also finalize the development
of our home ownership strategy.
Community engagement is ongoing
as we're co-hosting community engagement sessions
with Mayor Lee and your offices on December 5th and 7th,
thank you chair brown councilmember houston and council president jenkins for co-hosting our
session yesterday evening in 2027 we'll also explore the development of a community development
block grant or cdbg funded small business development program for small property owners
we hope to conclude negotiations with the county for the remaining lead settlement funds
We're finalizing the development
of the Equitable Lead Hazard Abatement Program or ELHAP
before we start the competitive procurement process
at the start of the year
to select a community-based organization
to administer to manage the loan and grant administration,
the lead remediation, the project management,
and the tenant support services components.
The city's working group,
responsible for the development of the program,
comprised of the city administrator's office,
the city attorney's office, planning and building,
race and equity at HCD,
will present to the council in the first half of 2027.
We'll present the following,
the proposed city and county terms
for the remaining settlement funds,
which also must be approved by the board of supervisors,
ELHAP program design and implementation timeline,
and the planned prep launch
by the planning and building department,
who I believe is here today.
And then finally, as Claudia presented
on the Code Compliance Relocation Program
and the critical role the HCD plays
in activating its anti-displacement partnerships
to stabilize our most vulnerable tenants displaced by fire.
A reminder, we had three mass displacement events
in six weeks, just a month and a half ago.
Our community suffered, again,
those mass displacement events.
HCD's response would not have been possible
without the emergency authorization resolution
and availability of fund 1870,
the Affordable Housing Trust Fund.
So as we brace Guilinio extreme weather, which is imminent,
the availability of this flexible funding source
will continue to be critical to HCD's ability
to stabilize our most vulnerable tenants,
displaced by fire, flood and code enforcement action
in a post-PRIP environment.
So that concludes our presentation.
I'm happy to take any questions.
Excellent, thank you so much.
As always, for the comprehensive report,
I know that some of our public speakers
were anxious to engage,
and so I would like to hear from the public speakers first.
Calling in the names that sign up to speak
on item number three.
In no particular order, you can come up to the podium,
state your name before making your comment,
or raise your hand on Zoom to be easily identified.
David Boatwright, Brandon Kitayawa, David Hall,
Asada Ollawala, Emily Wheeler, Mark Diaz,
Richard Hag, Juan Conum, Blair Beekman, and Derek Barnes.
Again, if you're in as, sorry, as standard practice,
we will take in-person speakers first
and then Zoom speakers.
David Boatwright, District Four.
I spoke about this in CED open forum September 22nd, after such a thorough report on anti-displacement
earlier this year, I think an equally thorough report concerning housing for the last ten
years is overdue.
I recommend five points, how many single multiple family units completed per year, how many
persons were housed, total amount and average per unit spent, average time from approval
occupation and 5 percentage of type by type of construction new refurbished
prefab etc. A recent modular housing project on Edes Avenue took one
and a half years to construct and then six months to fully occupy for 350,000
per unit very cost-effective compared to total to hotel refurbishment at 500
to 1.1 million, but way too long to occupy.
Thank you.
Good afternoon, council members Brown, Fife, and Unger,
as well as city staff.
Thank you for your service to the people of Oakland.
It's really much appreciated.
My name is David Hall.
I'm one of the directors of the Tenants Rights Team
at Central Lagala La Raza,
and we've been working with the city of Oakland
for quite some time.
Oakland's anti-displacement efforts are a critical part
in protecting Oakland citizens,
particularly low-income renters and communities of color.
The programs that were discussed by the city staff,
Oakland Housing Secure, which encompasses eviction defense,
which is a consortium of the East Bay Community Law Center,
eviction defense center, Unity Council,
appeal in central Ligal, provide critical services
to keep people in their homes,
or to at least give them a path to a soft landing
to getting into new housing,
which is ultimately homelessness prevention of its core.
I also wanna shout out the rent adjustment program,
which is a non-judicial way to deal
deal with some of these issues before they even get to the point where folks are in court
and are in need of an attorney.
This is an incredibly important program for the citizens of Oakland.
And finally, I would be remiss if I didn't mention the city code enforcement relocation
efforts, particularly with the three tragic fires recently.
I can say that Oakland's sort of response to this, gathering together all of the stakeholders,
the city's efforts to gather the data that's not only going to tell us are we are we getting good
information from the city and the city's efforts to gather the data that's not only going to tell
us are we are we getting good information from the city and the city's efforts to gather the data
that's not only going to tell us are we are we getting good information from the city and the city
Um, you need to implement them and you need to know if they're working well.
And so I want to salute the city, um, the city's efforts to gather the data that's
not only going to tell us, are we, are we getting good outcomes, but are we reaching
the right people?
And I think this, this report contains a ton of data and a lot of work for folks that without
this work, you know, we need, we need this work to tell if the ordinance that we have
are doing a good job.
So, uh, good afternoon council members.
My name is Brandon Kitegawa with regional asthma management and prevention.
for part of that public health institute
based here in Oakland.
I'm here again today to reiterate the need for urgency
to address lead hazards with the funds the city was awarded
and a 2019 legal settlement with paint companies.
We have been actively urging the city
to move on this issue for the past three years.
In that time, we have seen city staff make progress,
but at every step, there's always delays.
And so as the report showed today,
we're still eight to 12 months away from implementation
I'm not sure if this is the
number one priority that's
what we've been hearing.
Was sort of where we are for
the last three years.
We're asking the city to treat
this digit this issue with
urgency delays can no longer be
acceptable and the remaining
steps should be fast track to
the extent possible.
Thank you.
Good afternoon chair Brown
again and city council.
Derek Barnes with East Bay
rental housing association of
course we support the program
prevention kept about 884 households housed Oakland homelessness fell
remarkably and that's real progress and we think that stable housing also
depends on stable housing providers I think many of you who were on the call
last night heard me make some critical points about the preservation of our
legacy owner operators and homeowners small buildings of two or two to nine
the housing providers fund the
rent adjustment program for the
most part the fee went up 36%
and some in the same year
allowable rents only rose like
a .8% in that fiscal year and
the program now has a surplus
which is good. And we see that
the housing providers fund the
rent adjustment program for the
most part the fee went up 36%
and some in the same year
allowable rents only rose like
good. And we support using those funds in ways that may be new to the program but I
think are really valuable in terms of the preservation of our small property owners.
Let's see, second, 91% of the eviction notices are for non-payment of rent and I think that
bears some attention because I think we can divert some of those funds to keep renters
in their household really kind of going upstream and addressing the problem where it starts
to begin with and third the plans promised review of how these laws affect small owners
isn't necessarily in the report but I think we should also make it possible to track how
the things are impacting the small owner operators are we keeping them here are we not keeping
them here which is another comment I made last night thank you.
Sorry, Ms. Brown, got to help me sometimes.
The city of Oakland does not have a formal, legal, or amicable definition for the term
Oakland, so why are we writing reports with that term?
You cannot talk about displacement with any validity if you're not willing to discuss
gentrification and its impact on displacement in this city.
You cannot have a substantial report on displacement
if you're not talking about the impact
of being a sanctuary city
and how that adds to displacement of citizens.
You have a report that says
that you gave 496 clients financial assistance.
That's an important element, financial assistance.
Breakdown by demographics of race, who got money?
Look at what Center de la Gaza is doing in terms of servicing.
50% of their services are going to the Latino Hispanic community only 18% of
the highest impacted group, which is for, uh,
I don't know what it is because now you're starting to use,
I'm gonna get into this.
You're starting to use this term black slash African American black because
you have had so many immigrants who are coming into this country,
this city who are black.
They're not foundational.
They don't have ancestry connected to enslavement.
They are becoming a dominant group.
When you identify that they are 21% black
slash African Americans, only 12% of this city
is what you call African American.
The other 8% is African, Cubans, Latinos,
black Latinos and so forth.
We are being pushed out of this city.
So you have to, just like I came here and told you,
stop using that term, BIPOT.
You made a statement that in the report,
Asians, Latinos, and African-Americans...
Thank you for your comments, Ms. Olavala.
Thank you, Ms. Olavala.
Before switching to Zoom users,
I would like to go ahead and note the presence
of Council Member Ramachandran on Zoom.
Council Member, if you can unmute yourself
and have your camera on,
and state if there are anyone over the age of 18
and state the reason of your just cause.
Thank you, emergency circumstances
and no, there's no one above the age of 18.
Okay, thank you and then you just need your camera on
for the remainder of the meeting.
Yes.
Thank you.
Now switching to Zoom users, Emily Wheeler.
You can unmute yourself and begin your comment.
Hello, my name is Emily Wheeler.
I am here representing the Oakland Tenants Union.
We are an organization of tenants,
tenants rights advocates working for a better Oakland.
We are here to support
the proactive rental inspection program.
It's such a great idea.
I used to be an OT counselor
and the vast, vast majority of the people we spoke to
came to us because they were having trouble
getting repairs done.
That's something that I can also personally attest to.
I have not had a landlord
who would not try to give me the run around or delay, delay, delay when I asked for repair.
Sometimes these repairs are huge habitability issues and tenants are often frightened of
contacting their landlords for fear of retribution.
I myself, even though I know my rights better than many, am often scared to reach out to
my landlord so I can only imagine what others go through.
A proactive rental inspection program would, in a large way, take this out of tenants hands
by having an expert city inspector come in
and deal with habitability concerns
and proactively find the landlord.
Again, like everything, everything that we ask for,
this would not affect good landlords
in any way, shape or form.
And I also just wanted to end my comment
by noting that Mr. Barnes actually did not give
the full picture when it came to the RAP fee,
which is legally allowed to be 50% passed on
in 50% to the tenants as long as the landlord pays on time.
So I would respectfully argue that we both fund rep.
And thank you so much for this report.
We know that a big part of managing homelessness
is making sure that we stop the bleeding,
that more people aren't getting kicked out of their homes
and onto the streets.
And I'm happy to see the city take action on that.
Thank you for your comments.
Richard Haig, you can unmute yourself
and begin your comments.
Hello council, hello Distinguished Council.
My name is Richard Haig.
I'm a district one resident
and a proud member of the Oakland Tenants Union.
I'm speaking today in support
of a proactive rental inspection program.
A close friend of mine is currently displaced
due to a pervasive mold issue impacting their housing.
The landlord had been previously hostile
to tenant complaints,
which resulted in the tenants being disincentivized
from reporting an issue out of fear of retaliation.
Nor are the tenants themselves experts
who are able to diagnose potential issues
before they became problematic.
So not only are the tenants of this building
now displaced due to health hazards,
but the landlord faces costly structural remedies
and a potential legal battle.
This could all have been avoided
with a positive outcome for all parties
if a proactive rental inspection program
had been implemented,
could have caught the issue early on. A proactive rental inspection program would improve our
community's health, help landlords avoid costly rush jobs, and keep more people housed.
Thank you for your time council members. We hope you will jump at this chance to proactively
improve Oakland living for thousands of residents. Juan Conum, you can unmute yourself and begin your
comments. Hi, I'm Juan. I'm a D4 resident and a member of Oakland Tenants Union. The work the
department is doing is great but it's important that we don't keep delaying the start of proactive
inspections. The program in DCE found that, and I'm quoting here, a complaint-based system
is insufficient to maintain safe housing standards for all residents, especially our most vulnerable,
the poor, the elderly, the non-English speaking, the vast majority of properties that were named
in slumlord lawsuits. Those are the ones initiated by DC's Attorney General. Had not received any
recent complaints and the worst properties had never received a single complaint. We should keep
doing what we're doing but we need to go further. We need to copy other cities where they've seen
85% or even 97% reductions in lead poisoning in children who they don't get to choose where they
live and so thank you for this report. Keep doing what you're doing. The proactive rental program,
the proactive inspection program can't keep being delayed. It's been nine years since the city first
had a report saying that it was desperately needed and it would benefit both tenants and
small landlords tend to have less, tend to show up less on the data because they tend to maintain
that probably is slightly better. And as we've seen nationally, we've seen a blue wave across
the country. People want improvements, people want change, people are sick of the status quo,
so please make sure this actually gets done in 2027 and doesn't get pushed back yet again. Thank
you. Thank you for your comments. Shane, please unmute yourself. If you signed up to speak for
item four please let me know what name you signed up under Shane Shane Westby
if you signed up to speak for item four please let me know what name you signed
up to err what the name was hello hi Shane did you sign up to speak for item
four and if so what name did you sign up under I signed under Shane Westby I do
apologize I do not have a speaker card for you
Alyssa Johnston you can unmute yourself if you sign up to speak on item four
please let me know what name you signed up under.
I apologize, I do not have a speaker card
under Alyssa Johnston.
And lastly, John, you can unmute yourself
if you sign up to speak on item number four.
Please let me know what name you signed up to speak under.
John, I see that you're unmuted, I cannot hear you.
Okay, I do not have a speaker card
under the name John either.
At this time, all names that did sign up
for item number three have spoken.
Perfect, thank you so much, Councilmember Unger.
Yeah, I just had a question about the surplus,
the $5 million surplus.
Do you think that we're going to have surpluses going forward?
Are we going to maintain that as a reserve?
What are our plans for that money to like,
we're gonna spend it down over time or use it for,
I mean, obviously it's a one-time surplus,
but I don't know how we're gonna use it going forward.
Thank you for the question through the chair.
That's right, it is very much a one-time surplus
really resulting from years of a structural deficit
and significant delinquencies.
So this coordinated effort between Oakland HCD
and our finance department's revenue management bureau
resulted in a recovery of those delinquent funds.
In terms of the use of that fund,
It will continue to fund RAP.
Again, RAP had been operating at a structural deficit
for several years now.
It will enable us to unfreeze the 11 frozen positions.
RAP is authorized for 33 positions.
Only 22 of them are filled,
thereby kind of reducing the wait times for hearings
and for cases to be resolved,
more additional counselors, hearing officers.
So that's the plan, is to finally unfreeze those positions
to better serve our tenants and property owners.
Perfect, thank you so much.
I definitely have a handful of questions,
but Council Member Feve first.
Just to, through the Chair, to Ugo,
I didn't hear the last part about how the funds
are planning to be spent.
Did you say over time, or what are you thinking?
Through the Chair, the funds will be spent
through the normal biannual budget process
in which our department will submit
our proposed departmental budget,
including the unfreezing of those 11 positions,
which is ongoing.
And that's the priority from the presentation
that I heard is to unfreeze those positions.
Through the chair, that's right.
We have an ongoing racial equity impact analysis
for the WRAP program that will include enhanced services,
more responsive services, better processes,
and those implementation strategies will require resources,
particularly staffing resources.
So yes, the plan is to, through the biennial process,
engage in that process as a department
and fully fund RAP's positions.
And I guess I would have to understand then
what would be the funding source
if we bring on new staff for those ongoing positions?
through the chair, and I'm not sure if the finance department is in the room, but it
is that same source that RAP uses, and I'm sorry I don't know the code off the top of
my head. Actually, Kat probably does, but it's the RAP fund, so the proceeds from that
fee included in our master fee schedule is what funds the RAP fund.
And with the emergencies that you handled, that all occurred within six weeks.
First of all, I have to say thank you so much.
My district was deeply impacted by fires in a couple of spaces and the way that you all
just jumped into action was incredible.
I was at some of the emergency centers helping give out socks and things like that.
But where that's from 1870, correct?
the chair that's correct. RAP is funded through the RAP Fund where as CDE the
other unit in our community development division that one is primarily funded by
1870 as is most of HCD staffing so the staffing resources necessary for HCD to
step up which was our honor and our privilege to be there for a displaced
tenants was made possible because of 1870. So how will that be impacted in
in future years, future fiscal years?
Do you know?
Well, through the Chair,
to the extent that fund 1870 will continue
to be made available for affordable housing
and our three P's approach,
it's really the preservation of that fund
that will enable ongoing HCD ability
to respond to the needs of our community.
Okay, so then I just have a couple other questions,
Well, maybe four questions about other parts of the report,
which I find to be very, very helpful.
It feels like in most of the areas
that the goals have been exceeded
in terms of the number of people served.
But I do have some questions about small property owners,
and I'm glad that Derek Barnes is here
because it looks like the 84 applicants were served
according to the report, but what was the goal number?
is, can that be shared?
Every other section had goals.
Yeah, through the chair, something that over the course
of the racial equity impact analysis process,
we surface a lot of opportunities for improvement.
One of which is the data development opportunity
and our partnership with the East Bay
Rental Housing Association.
And Derek is here and perhaps if he knows that metric
off the top of his head, I would love, excellent, he does.
So yes, so that in terms of the demographic data
of our small property owners,
as well as other kind of areas within RAP,
that's something that we've identified
and I'm very excited as we finalize the RIA
in terms of these opportunities for improvement.
But I will ask Derek to maybe fill any informational gaps
in their performance metrics.
Yeah, so my question was, it looks like total applicants
served was 84.
Was there a goal set around the number of people
that you wanted to serve?
Yeah, so initially, council member five for that,
I think the initial goal in the contract was like 240.
But I think working with the RAP team,
I think we thought that bringing that down to 120
made more sense.
It was more realistic given the number of actual petitions
that RAP gets each year.
So then it got reduced to 120.
So we are well on our way to exceeding that,
especially for this year that we're in,
this part of the contract that we're in.
And that contract ends June 30th of 27th?
Correct.
So we are technically in the second part
of that two-year contract, because I
believe that began October 1st, if I'm not mistaken.
And so how many people tend to be,
how many landlords are actually attempting
to utilize these services?
Oh, boy.
So one of the remarkable things about this program
that we devised was really built around compliance.
And we don't talk about that enough,
but a lot of the people that come
in through what we're calling the spores program,
the small property owner representation services,
are served by just having them understand
that RAP exist, number one, because a lot of people
don't know that that program is out there, which
is just shocking, after almost over a decade of being
in place.
Number two, they don't know what they need
to know to be compliant.
So RAP fees, rent registry, business license tax,
I mean, I think more than about 95% of the people that call in
do not know that they are responsible for those things.
So we help and assist and move them through that process to getting compliant.
Are there other organizations that do what you do in Oakland in the East Bay?
Not really. I mean, there's,
there are some that kind of do some things like for instance, um,
but not exactly like Hera is someone,
there's a partner that we work very closely with for more legal support.
We don't provide legal support.
And I think that's a whole nother part of the confusion that may be in the
public ever. As an organization doesn't supply legal assistance and we don't do
that through this program. But Hera will provide homeowner like legal assistance
and to small property owners. And why is the why is the demographic data so low
here because it looks like it says that Oakland small property owners are three
30% reported, non-Oakland residents are almost 30%,
and then people not recorded with,
unrecorded addresses are almost 40%.
Yeah, so there's a, I think in the report itself,
there may be an error, and I caught that literally
on my way over, that 3%, I believe, should be 33%,
because it's looking at.
What, really?
Yeah, and I just caught it, like I thought,
I went through the report, I'm like, oh my God,
This is, anyway, it should be,
because I think it speaks to like 21% of the 84 total,
which should be around 33%.
So that's one adjustment that needs to happen
in the report.
That's a huge discrepancy.
That is, that's, yeah, that's, that math thing, math thing.
Okay, and then.
You're certainly paying attention to the details,
Council Member. I mean.
And yeah, so what is the process to get this just overall
in some of these other areas?
Because that's just one of the areas that's very low numbers
in terms of what data is being recorded.
Yeah, it's a great question.
And so I think I took Ugo's point about the REA
and the involvement that we've been involved in with RAP.
We're finding better ways to collect that data.
And so through this entire process,
Remember, this program is only three years old.
It takes about two to three years
in order for us to get full lift on a program like this.
So I think we're in good shape moving forward.
But I think it's through the connections
that we have with Hugo and his team
to help us find ways to get that information so that they
have what they need for the rare reporting.
And so I think we're well on our way now to doing that.
I think we've improved our processes in collecting
that data moving forward.
so we'll be able to see that in the next budget cycle then?
Correct.
Because if, I'm gonna be very direct,
if the issues are that there are no other organizations
that provide the services that you provide,
and then we have 92.1%, this is just an example
of gender non-recorded information.
I mean, if, then I wanna see a better report out
on the demographic data, because everybody else
is reporting very clearly.
Yeah, may I make a recommendation?
Because I did think about that.
And I think maybe it makes sense to maybe come back
in a few months with an updated report, kind of given
where we are in this cycle, so that you can
see some incremental improvement.
And what I want to see from HCD is a confirmation
of what we're hearing verbally.
So if there is something that can be reported,
where you have more data that's not an oral report,
but actual numbers that that be compared
or vetted through city staff so that there can be
some confidence that what we're investing in
is actually getting the results,
particularly around race equity here,
which Mr. Barnes, you know, is important to me.
And me too.
And that's one of the things that we've talked about
in the past because I'm interested in hearing
And I'm wondering if you're
saying that you're not
pushing small property owners
out of the city.
But it looks like a lot of them,
the majority of them, don't live
in the city right now.
I think I can say that through
my own membership, I know that
that's not true, the majority of
our owner operators that have
rental property in Oakland
actually reside here.
So I'm fully confident that the
data that we will be sharing,
I want to see that.
I definitely want to see that.
And so, and thank you for being present to answer these questions because there are a
lot of loose ends here for me and I look forward to HCD being able to confirm this information.
I would like to see if we can get an update before the end of the fiscal year of the information,
the data that Mr. Barnes is saying that they can provide.
I think that would be really beneficial to come back to this committee sometime maybe
in the spring if possible.
through the chair. Thank you. We take your concerns very seriously and I apologize for the oversight if there was an error in reporting. We could absolutely follow up as part of this item actually with updated information. So to the extent that there were errors in our reporting will work with the team and provide this committee with updated numbers.
I'll also reiterate that HCD will
re-procure all contracted services.
And part of that re-procurement
of all these contracted services
for both RAP tenants and RAP property owners
will entail extensive outreach to potential respondents.
So while, of course, we value our partnership
with Abran, with Centro Legal,
we are most interested in the best service
for our tenants and our property owners,
and we'll follow our competitive procurement process
and the outreach that it entails.
And so as Derek said, the period is September to October,
so it's a little past the fiscal year,
but we will be re-procuring all contracted rep services.
I see, okay, thank you for sharing that.
My last couple questions.
Thank you, Mr. Barnes.
Thank you, Council Member Fife.
It's taken a long time.
We're not there.
I've heard some decent things about the outreach efforts
and conversations with HCD.
Have some other concerns, I see.
Are you coming up to answer the question?
Yes, Al is assistant director at the Planning and Building.
When can we give the community
who's come to our city council meeting so many times
asking about a timeline for this project?
I've been to several middle schools
and had lots of community conversations about this.
What is the timeline for actually being able to launch?
And what can we tell our community groups
about something that is more, I don't know,
just realistic about how this program is moving forward?
Through the chair, at PBD, we have developed a program.
we are waiting for the work that HCD is doing
with the Alameda County,
because what ends up being agreed upon in that meeting
will dictate what type of program we're going to launch.
So we're waiting for that conclusion
to make sure that what we launch,
one does not displace a large number of people
that we as a city cannot support
and at the same time make sure that the program effectively
goes through the large rental property,
the number of rental properties that we have in Oakland
is around 100,000.
So we have to do X number of inspections
in order to make the program run efficiently.
So we have determined what the cost would be,
what the personnel needed in order to accomplish
that will be.
So on our end, we are ready to move forward
as soon as this negotiation with the county is concluded.
We will be coming to you with a proposal
that lays out what the fees need to be,
what additional budgeted amount that we would need
we need to bring it to council
in order to move the project into launch.
So the city side is ready, planning and building,
HCD, we're just waiting on the county?
As far as the program is concerned
and the structure of the program on our side,
PBD is ready, we have,
but we do need to bring it to council
in order to get your approval for the additional fees
that we would need to put in our Master Fee Schedule.
would have to put in fees on top of the settlement funds that we got from the lawsuit? Is that...
Because this is going to be an ongoing program. So fees will have to be established in order
to keep this program going. Who would the fees be paid by? Ongoing fees.
Go ahead. Thank you. Through the chair, I also just wanted to clarify a couple of things
that PRIP community engagement is scheduled
to be carried out within a couple of months, I believe.
In fact, I think it may start as early as next month.
So there's the community engagement
to refine the program design of PRIP.
And then in terms of the equitable
lead hazard abatement program,
which will be administered by HCD,
the lead remediation, the lending, the grant making,
the project management, the focusing on extremely low
and very low income tenants and small property owners
with financial hardship.
That is, as you know, council member,
a community-based program,
and so we haven't begun
the competitive procurement process for that,
which takes several months,
and then the contracting after that.
So to the assistant director's point,
there are multiple work streams
that we are working on concurrently,
including the city-county settlement negotiation,
the program development of LHAP,
and the competitive processing contracting that will entail.
As well as the updating of the master fee schedule
because PRPS, proactive rental inspection programs,
are cost recovery programs.
Certainly a portion of the settlement funds
will jumpstart it, kickstart it,
but in terms of the ongoing support for the program,
it is a cost recovery program.
And interim city administrator Lake
issued a letter in response to the coalition partners
who reached out to the city,
detailing kind of where both PRIP and ELHAP are,
and we look forward to the ongoing
and inclusive community engagement
to finalize the development of both programs.
Is there anything that we as electeds
for the city of Oakland,
is there anything for us to do,
any role for us to play through the chair
to the city administrator?
Thank you for the question through the chair.
I think if you can, and I'm sure staff will keep you
apprised of the public community process
for the remaining pieces of both of these programs,
and so we'd like your participation
and making sure that information
gets out to the community for sure.
And then, of course, you will be,
the programs will come back to this body.
Okay, this is something that I was working on
with community groups before I was an elected official
regarding lead abatement
and trying to get a proactive rental inspection program
in the city of Oakland.
And so we see the lead settlement monies
as a way to kick that off,
but also understand that 100,000 is a lot of units
to cover in the city of Oakland.
So I recognize that,
But I just wanna make sure that there's consistent
communication with the community groups
and that you all are explaining thoroughly
so they don't have to reach out to my office
and there as a go-between,
cause you all know a lot more than we do
to share with them what the issues are.
And I understand that there's been a recent email,
so I appreciate that.
And just wanna be kept abreast of the process
as it moves forward.
So thank you.
I'm complete.
I took up way too much time, but thank you.
Thank you so much. So thank you. I do have a couple questions. I guess I'll start first with
I'm not sure if you wanted to forward it forward this item to the full council because I am interested in
Table 13 being updated the with the with the accurate data
And so I'm not sure what what you all wanted. Did you want to forward this report to the full body?
Yes, it can be on consent, but in any note Kent is here the wrap annual report does require approval by the council
I think also we can update table 13
Well, I just I just know the table is table 13
I don't know the page number so we can update and correct any type of graphical or other errors
Before we submit it in the next packet. Okay, that sounds great
So first off I wanted just to say thank you. I know that the HCD team is currently holding just so many important initiatives to ensure
We're taking care of you know Oaklanders
and so to two components that I really want to call attention to
Are of course is going to one around the anti like displacement and homelessness prevention
category and as you mentioned we had a great conversation last night around home ownership
where we got a lot of really good feedback from the community and so in reviewing the
data which I thoroughly enjoyed it was just a lot of really good information and data
and so it really got my wools turning around just some of the solutions and seeing some
consistencies so a couple questions from the report first question do the providers that
are currently providing homelessness prevention services, do they use the same portal to like
record the data or like what is the like kind of the mechanism where you're able to
get this information from?
So specifically the targeted homelessness prevention program, it's actually a best,
it's a model program in the state of California, Oaklands, we were the trailblazer.
And so it is one database and the application for rental assistance for this homelessness
prevention rental assistance has an embedded risk assessment.
So these risk factors that are most predictive of homelessness.
So it's very data informed.
And yes, all of that data, including rich demographic characteristics is recorded in
a single system database.
Very good.
And then when the report states unduplicated,
can you define that for me?
Yes, unduplicated means a household might receive
multiple instances of service.
So maybe my family and I receive rental assistance today
and two months from now receive case management services.
I am one unduplicated household,
rather than two instances of service.
So unduplicated means that these are unique households
served by the program.
I see, thank you.
And then my next question,
I notice in some of the tables
that sometimes the data is presented
where it breaks down specific racial groups.
And I guess I'm seeing where Latino and Hispanic
isn't represented.
I just was curious why, and then maybe it's
following under other, so I just had a question
around that kind of inconsistency.
I see, I now better understand your original question.
So the Targeted Homelessness Prevention is one program
with multiple outreach partners in East and West Oakland,
but I believe you're referring to
the Eviction Prevention Program,
which is another coalition of providers
led by Central Legal but also includes
Addiction Defense Center and Asian Pacific Islander
Legal Outreach and other organizations.
So there is sometimes in the data collection
different terms that are used
and sometimes different methods for collecting
especially racial and ethnic data.
In fact like the federal
structure is kind of a two-part question.
So there are differences in the data collection.
Again, as I alluded to earlier, this data development,
in terms of better data quality, more consistent metrics,
that's something that we are working on
for the next annual report,
so that we could have more consistency across programs,
even if they're administered by different providers.
Okay.
And then my last question is on table 23,
around the eviction notices and the breakdown by zip code.
Thank you so much for including that and just kind of calling attention to the zip code nine four six one two
Where it had one thousand three three hundred and seventy seven
eviction notices and when I kind of like pulled up that zip code, it's
Concentrated in and around like the downtown area. That's and yeah, and so I just wanted I guess like as we
Continue to record this data and information
What I'm curious about is like are these new art are these you know?
tenets that are moving into some of the newer developments and like
Because what I noticed during the pandemic was like some of the newer developments were offering like move-in
specials where the cost of the rent would be reduced and then following like a year of being a renter
Then the cost of the unit would actually go back to like the actual price
And so so I just wanted to call attention to that that like I'm curious if this is also a part of like
These eviction notices because I believe like as you scroll down the data then shows
90 failure to pay rent
cases
5062 91 percent and so just I guess like I'm just trying to
Figure out like what is this correlation and then you see this zip code where I think we all can see that a lot of the newer
Developments in our city is in this zip code
as a footprint
Something I'm very excited about and again
It speaks to the resources that rap has to finally unfreeze these positions is an actual analyst position to
Regularly look at this rich data in our rent registry in our eviction
Our termination notice filings to try to make sense of them a zip code is a pretty large
geographic area it might very well include Chinatown given that
The non-payment of rent is the leading cause of eviction in any community really it's a money issue
affordability issue I
Inticit I would expect that it's primarily that but again as we kind of hire
Fully staff rap will have the ability to do more meaningful analysis so that we could be more proactive in preventing those evictions
Yeah, you're reading my mind because the and and there's um, I guess like
Continuity or consistency in conversation because in our conversation last night around home ownership
The chat there's a lot of voices in the chat that was talking about
the income gap, and I know that kind of in,
I think it was also during the pandemic,
there was a lot of movement around
like guaranteed income programs, right?
And so as I'm looking through this data
and seeing this gap, and we know that in 2027,
we're gonna have new leadership like at the state level.
And so maybe from these conversations,
we're able to determine that actually
we need to bring back programs
like some type of guaranteed income pilot
that would work to kind of one key people house, right?
And then to close these gaps that we're seeing.
So I just wanted to offer that like,
just from my quick hits of analysis.
And so thank you.
Thank you, Chair.
Yeah.
Council Member?
Okay, and so is the recommendation
to send this to the full council, I believe, right?
With the supplemental report, okay.
Colleagues?
Well, yes, I'll make the motion to accept staff recommendation and move this to the full city council about whatever date that is
second
Thank you. Thank you and for clarification. The update is to table 13 of the report
Correct is to generally make technical updates as needed. Okay. Thank you
So that's a motion by councilmember five seconded by councilmember Unger to approve the recommendations of staff and to receive and forward this item
on consent with the request of staff to provide in a supplemental report an updated report
to reflect any typographical errors on rule council members five aye ramachandran aye
hunger aye and chair brown aye thank you motion passes with four ayes to receive it forward
this item to the December 1st City Council agenda on consent reading in item four adopt
Reading in item 4 adopt the following pieces of legislation one an ordinance authorizing the city administrator to apply a designation type of
Regional servicing Park to the open space designation for the Martin Luther Martin Luther King jr
Regional shoreline area and adjacent open space parcels including the Oakland port field property pursuant to planning code section
seventeen point eleven point zero two zero point C and adopting appropriate sequel findings and
An ordinance authorizing the city administrator to negotiate and execute a license agreement with the nonprofit
Oakland United Club Inc or its affiliate for the repair maintenance
improvement operations and scheduling of the Oakland field athletic
Sorry, the Oakport field athletic complex at 58 1 5 Oakport Street
I'll clean for a term of 15 years at a base license fee of five hundred dollars per month within with annual increases of
plus 15% of net sponsorship revenue after initial capital repairs and
replacements and adopting sequel findings and we have seven speakers on
this item. Excellent thank you so much. Go ahead. Good afternoon. Hello council
members. I'm Quincy Williams and I'm the assistant capital improvement project
coordinator for Oakland Parks Recreation and Youth Development and I'm here to
on the item at hand. OPRID has limited playable athletic fields so in 2024 we
decided to publish a request for proposal for the lease maintenance and
improvement of Oakport Field. In 2025 OPRID conditionally awarded
Oakland Soccer Club with this RFP. Oakland Soccer Club which is now under
the umbrella of open united has met with the city which includes appear widely real estate building and planning and the mayor's office. Some of the tasks that have been completed because of this project are prac approval. A race and equity analysis has been produced as well as a term sheet. So this is supported by the community. And this project upon its completion.
of the city to try to make sure
that the research will prove
financially successful to the
city for years to come.
I will now turn it over to the
real estate director, Brenda
Moriarty, for details regarding
this particular project.
Good afternoon, through the
chair, Brenda Moriarty, director
of real estate for the city, and
I'm going to walk us through the
details of what's being proposed
here.
Two different ordinances.
of a license agreement with Oakland United.
So first, this is zero SN on where we're talking here.
This is an aerial shot of the field in question.
It's got that red star on it.
That's the Oak Port Athletic Field Complex,
which is currently a pair of fields
with a rundown fence and a rundown bathroom
in a parking lot in poor condition.
It's behind the East Bay Mud facility near the Coliseum.
It's part of a larger like 40-some acre parcel,
but the project that we're gonna be talking about today
is not a license agreement for all of that.
It wouldn't include the wetlands.
It wouldn't include the trail.
It's just for the athletic field component of this.
On the next slide, oh yeah,
this is a credit to Oakland United.
This is their picture.
This is a view of the field looking out towards the bay,
so a really beautiful setting, obviously.
And you can even just see from this picture
kind of field conditions are not great.
So, as Quincy mentioned, the OPRYD Park Rec Youth Development Department issued a request
for proposals for the field in 2025.
They got two bidders and selected the Oakland Soccer Club after a view of the proposals.
The Oakland Soccer Club, or OSC, and their partners created a new nonprofit organization
called Oakland United to take on the project and actually do the implementation, including
the negotiations with the city.
The Park Rock Advisory Commission, our PRAC,
voted to support this proposed license agreement
on October 14th.
So here's what the license agreement terms look like.
It'd be a 15-year exclusive license agreement,
meaning it would give Oakland United the exclusive right
to maintain and manage a publicly accessible,
multi-sport athletic field facility there at Oakport Field.
Oakland United would implement an initial capital
capital projects to improve the condition of the field today.
So resurfacing the field, fixing the fence,
repairing the bathroom, everything that's there,
like improving it and just bringing it back
to a quality baseline.
They would then repair, maintain, and operate the facility
throughout the remainder of the 15-year term.
And they would also exclusively manage scheduling
for use of the field, subject to an access policy
that would be subject to the city's review and approval.
So we would have to say so on the guiding,
you know policies on how the field is scheduled.
There would be an advisory council to Oakland United
that would include a variety of stakeholders,
including the city.
So the city would have a seat on the advisory council
as would an unaffiliated community member.
That advisory council would inform the access policy.
There would be at minimum at least 55% of the time
the field have to be available for no fee public use,
which could look like just open gate drop in,
just show up with your friends, play some soccer,
or it could be through partnerships
with youth service providers
that are running programs for free,
or it could be through the city's own allotment
of time at the field.
The city would have a certain amount for itself,
for things like town camp, et cetera.
So at least 55% of the time,
weekdays and weekends for that kind of thing.
The fees would be set for the master fee schedule,
so the city gets to control the fees.
And there would be quarterly and annual reporting,
So quite a bit of oversight on the city to make sure the expectations are set and all these kinds of parameters that we're talking about here
These were informed by the racial equity analysis that Quincy mentioned
So there was a study to figure out like to actually look at the data find out who uses the field today
How much when what are the conflicts whose who stands to lose who stands to gain?
What do we need to design to ensure that this is equitable?
The city would have the ability to regain control of the scheduling if there's a breach of the X of the requirements under the agreement
The last part on the terms just as far as the economics are concerned the city would receive a base run of five hundred
Dollars per month increasing three percent every year
that would be offset to the extent this happens with
Revenue coming in from advertising or sponsorship or naming rights, which Oakland United may use to help fund the operation of the field
the first
Tronch of money coming in and that forms this advertising revenue and whatnot that will go to first just paying for that first
Capital project about four million dollars to rehab. What's there hundred percent goes to that
After that's paid for and the field is back into a good shape at that point this revenue sharing begins
The city gets 15 percent every dollar the remainder goes Oakland United
Only for operating maintaining repairing the field so it's all just going to get reinvested in the in the field
So just analysis on this, you know, a port field would remain a public park
It would remain in the city's public park system. There would still be public access. There'd be a great deal of city oversight
this would leverage four million dollars in private funds to bring the field back to a to a condition that the city is
May not be capable of bringing it to
And then would also leverage four and a half million dollars
Ongoingly over the life of the agreement 15 years in repair maintenance about three hundred thousand dollars a year
So I'm a little over nine million dollars in private private capital
And then this would be you know, it's a substantial amount of in-kind consideration
In lieu of substantial cash rent
So it's not you know
This is not like a market rent arrangement in recognition of all the the benefits that the organization would bring
So that's the license agreement. That's one of the two ordinances the second and final ordinance
This will just take a moment is a regulatory thing
Basically every opens the open space zoning designation in Oakland
is the zoning designation for all of our parks in open space.
In Oakport Field, and Martin Luther King Regional Shoreline,
all the open spaces around there
are appropriately zoned open space.
The zoning code has nine different classifications
of types of open space, from resource conservation area,
which is all about kind of wildlife habitat,
but that sort of thing, to like, you know,
neighborhood mini park, and that sort of thing,
and athletic fields is in that mix too.
Every open space is supposed to have a category.
This one never got it, for some reason lost a dime.
That's set by PRAK, never happened, but just last night,
PRAK corrected for that.
They recommended what this ordinance would do,
which is to apply to this whole area here on the map.
So inclusive of Oakport Field,
inclusive of MLK Regional Shoreline,
all the open spaces in that sort of pink polygon,
that it get the region serving park designation.
So that would allow for the continuation
of everything that's going on out there today,
East Bay Regional Park's regional park,
as well as the athletic field at Oakport,
all, it's just all status quo.
And so, yeah, we recommend that we do this
to clean up the zoning code.
Again, would allow all the existing uses to continue,
including the athletic field at Oakport
so that this partnership could continue
or for this partnership to happen.
And like I said, Prac voted to support that last night.
So that's it.
Staff recommends approval of the two ordinances.
We're here for questions.
Excellent, thank you so much, Brendan.
You do an amazing job of explaining complex things
very easily and also taking good care to ensure
that the agreements that the city enters into
are supportive of community use as well, so thank you.
I know that there is someone here from Oakland United
wanted to invite you up if you wanted
to just share a few words.
I am interested in the, I guess,
the coalition of community-based organizations
that you are currently working with
and who would have access to the field.
Yeah, thank you.
Good afternoon, Council and committee members.
My name is Cody Palan.
I'm the Executive Director of Oakland United.
I wanna start by thanking the city staff.
We worked on this project to date.
includes OPRD, real estate, public works, planning,
and more.
Oakland United was founded on the idea
that every child in this city deserves an excellent space
to play at and an equally excellent program to play in.
Through our work to renovate and steward amazing spaces
to play, we act as the infrastructure backbone
of the Oakland Sports Equity Coalition.
Convened by Positive Coaching Alliance,
this coalition consists of over 40 of our city's best free
or affordable sports programs, who collectively
serving over 27,000 youth in service of play equity in Oakland.
Together, this coalition and program cite a lack of public safe spaces as one of their
biggest limiting factors to serving more youth.
And so we at Oakland United are excited to partner with those organizations and the communities
to address this issue and get more youth playing on great spaces and in great programs.
I'm really proud of the fact that this project has been shaped with and by the District 7
and District 6 communities around Oakport.
spent the last year plus engaging and working with existing users, local
programs, local schools, and at-large community members around Oakport to
ensure that ownership of this process was shared by those stakeholders. I grew
up playing an Oakport field and I've always thought about what would be
possible for Oakland if that space is one of the best public facilities in the
Bay Area. Today I'm really excited about the reality of moving that one step
forward to be impossible. Directly related to your question, Oakland Sports
equity coalition like I mentioned is a coalition of 40 orgs that provide free
or affordable programs. Our theory of change is that if you are an
organization like those orgs of which there are many even some not even in the
coalition yet we want you to access these spaces at no cost so in turn you
can continue to make your programs as free or as affordable as possible for
more kids in the city. Despite the fact that there's 27,000 kids being served by
that coalition a report came out a few years ago that shows that 14% of
The kids in the city meet the daily recommended dose
of activity in Oakland.
So we know there's a lot of work to be done
to get more kids playing consistently.
And we see this field, this space as the first step
in creating a model and partnership with the city
that could be applied to more spaces.
There's no doubt that our theory of change
is pointed at youth because that's the future of Oakland.
So I just wanna thank you for your time today
and considering this.
I did wanna quickly note that
we had some additional program partners
I think they were hoping to speak on zoom.
They were unable to register
because of an error when they tried to register yesterday.
And I'm happy to share like more direct feedback
on what they encountered after the meeting,
whenever appropriate, but yeah, just thank you for your time.
Excellent, thank you so much, Cody.
Real quick question while you're there.
I think I recognize in the report
that I guess there's some funding gaps
or there's some work to be done financially
to upgrade the park.
What's your plan to do?
what's your plan to do that?
So we've raised over $7 million over five years
in commitments to date.
As mentioned in the report,
we're likely gonna invest upwards of 5 million plus
into the field directly
and then ongoing stewardship throughout.
As a new organization,
we are relying heavily on individual philanthropy.
That's gotten us really far.
Candidly, we're fiscally sponsored at the moment
because as a new organization,
we have applied for our 501c3,
but we're just waiting on the IRS
to give us that determination.
Once that's in, as someone who's worked in nonprofits
for over nine years now, I see us as being very competitive
for consistent foundation funding,
but long-term, as the public good we see these spaces
as being, we think will be competitive for buckets of state
and federal funding, of which there are large amounts
of these days, especially as the tide turns
towards recognizing that access and youth sports
is a huge issue and the health benefits,
the social emotional benefits, the college and career
and academic benefits that getting more kids
and more programs is being spoken about nationally.
We've had endorsements from Congresswoman Latifah Simon,
Attorney General Rob Bonta, and as we grow this,
I do believe that we'll be able to access
those buckets of money so that these fields are amazing,
not just for a decade, but decades to come.
Excellent, thank you, and I think that there's an upcoming,
like is it the parks program grant
or something at the state level that?
Exactly, so we are, you'll hear a little bit about this
in a moment, but in partnership with SupplyBank.org,
who's doing a greater Bay Shore Restoration project
on the shoreline there, that involves an incredible
nonprofit office space, we're partnering with them
to apply for the state parks program grant,
which would allow each organization to potentially get
a refund of $4.5 million roughly for this park
and Bayshore Restoration projects once complete.
Excellent, thank you so much.
Colleagues, any additional questions?
Council Member Fyfe?
Thank you for doing this through the chair, Cody.
This is an amazing opportunity for East Oakland.
It's similar to what we have with Ramondi
in terms of the stewardship of an external body
to the city of Oakland and I think just with youth sports
we need more of it, we need a lot more of it
and we've seen just with FIFA the amount of people
that are interested in soccer and I know in my district
I've had several organizations reach out to me
to try to rehab spaces in West Oakland for youth soccer
so I'm just wondering, I have two questions,
how do other, how would other youth soccer organizations
interact with your organization to utilize the field?
What would that look like?
Has that plan already been put in place?
And we'll start there.
And if you have other organizations under you,
you said like several organizations
that are part of your program, how does that work?
So we aren't a specific sports program.
We'll never have our own team
or anything like that on the field.
We just serve as the infrastructure
for the great programs in the city.
So if you're a football, baseball, soccer,
any field related program right now that's operating,
we want you to be able to access these fields.
How does that work then?
If they have different specifications,
I'm not a sports person.
Oh yeah, that's...
So you can line, there's multi-sport surfaces
that you can line for a multitude of sports
for American football, soccer, lacrosse, rugby, baseball.
And you can change it?
You don't have to change it,
but there's different colored lines.
So from above, it looks a little crazy,
but on the field, you can see what sport you're playing
and play within it.
You can even do smaller fields
for younger children within that.
So I could be happy to send you something after this
that shows how that's done,
and that's what we intend to do at Oakport Field,
because it's not just a soccer-specific field at all.
It's a multi-sport facility.
To your question about the organizations
that are looking to rehab spaces
or get on great spaces,
they definitely should reach out to us
via the contact info on our website.
They should also consider joining
the Oakland Sports Equity Coalition
if they're not already part of it.
Because that's the cohort of organizations that are vetted
that we know are providing quality, caring,
coach and mentorship services to youth
that we want using these spaces.
And they have resources to help train coaches in programs
to become better mentors, better stewards for youth.
So it'd be a great, a lot of synergy there.
So how do I get them connected with your organization?
You said on what, the website?
There's our website and our director
of community engagement, Oscar Cervantes, he's back there.
He's the one who's in charge of connecting these spaces
to the community.
He'll be the one who's gonna check in with them
after they reach out to us.
And so will there be spectator seating
with this investment that you all are putting into the field?
At Oakport, we're still part of the community engagement
process to decide how we want seating to be available,
whether we're prioritizing more play or seating.
We're considering like moveable bleachers
so that during certain games,
If a cohort of parents want to be able to access those,
we can push them onto the field.
But then during the week when we want to maximize
the amount of space for kids to play,
we can push them back to the fence line.
Okay, well I'll make a motion to adopt these ordinances
since there's two pieces of this legislation.
I assume that it will require two readings.
Once forwarded to council, to ordinance 12,
I believe we need to check.
Theresa, when's the next place to date?
We do have a question.
If it's okay while you're
checking on that I did want to
invite of Evelyn.
I think she wants to say a few
words on behalf of councilmember
Houston.
Yes thank you can remember
brown- Evelyn Vega chief of
staff to councilmember can
Houston who cannot be here
today but he asked me to be here
to convey his support for both
action items for this item.
Thank you.
Excellent thank you.
I don't have time for that.
I have two more minutes.
I have two minutes prior to readings, correct?
Yep.
I can second that motion.
And we can hear from the public speakers.
Thank you.
Calling in the names that sign up to speak on item number four,
Cody Pylon, Pui Man Wong, Alexander Ibarra, and Mrs.
Sato Obala, and Blair Bregman.
Good afternoon, Chair and committee members.
My name is Pui Man Wong.
and policy at SupplyBank.org, a local nonprofit developer for the Oakport
community campus. I'm here in strong support for item 4, the region serving
park designation, as well as a 15-year license agreement with Oakland United
for Oakport Field. So Oakland desperately needs safe, accessible, and well-programmed
public fields, as all of you have indicated. Revitalizing Oakport Field
anchors a broader community-led coalition vision along the East Oakland
Shoreline. It will include 160,000 square foot affordable nonprofit center
called Oakland Community Campus to over a mile of Bay Trail habitat restoration
along the MOK Regional Shoreline. And third, modernized East Bay Mudd workforce
that will serve about 1.5 million regional residents in
the in this area. So advancing these ordinances support a
national model for recreational equity. Climate resilience and
waterfront access. So I urge the committee to vote yes on this
important item number four. Thank you. Good afternoon
members of the committee. My name is Alex Ibarra. I'm a 16
year old senior at Colosseum College Prep. I would like to
color prep academy in East Oakland. Growing up playing soccer here one of the
hardest parts was finding somewhere to play. We'll maintain fields especially in
that part of Oakland are very hard to come by. My own high school team we have
to play SSR Chavez Field which is in Fruitvale. It's about a 30 to 45 minute
bus ride. Our practice time especially in the winter is cut short because the
lights do not come on. A lot of times our players are getting here at 435 p.m. so
they only get 20 minutes of play time. Oakport Field is just a few minutes from
school and fixing it would mean kids in East Oakland not just at the school
could practice and play close to home so depending on time on the bus that takes
away from time with their family time with homework it would just make their
life overall easy and while writing my college essays I keep coming back to the
same idea that kids shouldn't have to leave their communities to find
opportunities and Oakport would provide that for these people while keeping it
public and affordable for youth programs is exactly the kind of investment I want
to see in my community every kid in Oakland deserves what sports have given
and me no matter what part of town they live in.
Graduating high school soon,
but I want the kids coming after me
to have a field in their own neighborhood.
I urge this committee to recommend approval
of the old Portfield License Agreement with Oakley Knight.
Thank you.
Thank you, Alex.
Chair Brown, could you have Alex come back up?
He said something I thought was really powerful
and I wanted to make sure I had that quote yet.
Yeah, absolutely.
You said kids shouldn't have to leave
their communities to what?
I said that kids shouldn't have to leave the communities
to find opportunities.
I like that.
OK, I'll attribute it to you when I say it again.
Thank you, I appreciate that.
Thank you, Alex.
So just to follow up to what you just said,
foundational black people shouldn't
have to leave their community because of gentrification
and sanctuary city status that pushes them out.
We are in a stage where you're looking
at a resurfacing, not resurfacing, a change, a domination that excludes us.
So people want soccer and appreciate the capacity.
But you keep using that word equity and you keep looking at all children and all Oaklanders,
which is not an official legal term.
I don't know why.
but y'all don't wanna use the term citizen.
But the capacity to, at some point,
get to where we really have equity,
and this 81-year-old lady don't have to keep coming here
since 2007, saying foundational black people
need an opportunity to be a part of a fair process.
And I'll continue to come and do it every chance I get.
So this soccer field, what is the element of security
that we have a million dollars
to pay in safety that can be
guaranteed at this site.
That because this area is one
where you have to consider that
component.
Thank you for your comments.
Chair that concludes all, sorry,
all names have been called for
this item.
Perfect and I believe that we
had a motion and a second.
Yes, thank you.
We have a motion made by
councilmember Fife, seconded by
chair Brown, to approve the
and we'll move on to agenda on
role sorry on consent on roll
council members five aye
Ramachandran aye younger aye and
chair Brown aye thank you motion
passes with four ayes to four
both pieces of legislation to
the December 1st City Council
agenda on consent moving on to
open forum calling in the names
that signed up to speak miss
Asada a la Bala so I just want
to let all the white people know
And, I think it's 1990, California was 67% white, and 2000, California was 45% white.
In 2026, California is 38% white.
What are y'all doing to the white people?
Where are they going?
Are you pushing them out too?
Now, the next state with, they'll laugh, Ms. Lee,
the next state with the lowest number is Hawaii 21.
Y'all gotta help them out, too.
But something is happening.
And we have a demographic change that is substantial.
And why are we losing so many people?
I don't know.
But you also have this race thing.
Now, listen to this one.
Thank you for your comments, Ms. Olibala.
Chair, that concludes all speakers on open forum.
Excellent, thank you for everyone who came out today.
This meeting is adjourned.