Good morning and welcome to the finance and management committee meeting of
Tuesday, November 17, 2026. The time is now 9 36 a.m. and this meeting may come
to order. Before we begin, I will provide instructions on how to submit speaker
cards for items on this agenda. If you're here with us in chamber and would like
to submit a speaker card, please fill it out and turn one into myself or a clerk
representative, no later than 10 minutes after the start of this meeting, or
before the item is read into record. Registering to speak via Zoom is now due
24 hours prior to the start of this meeting time. This meeting came to order
at 9 36 a.m. and speaker cards will no longer be accepted 10 minutes after
making that time 9 46 a.m. We'll now proceed with taking roll. Council members
Brown? Present. Unger? Here. Council member Wong we have on Zoom. This is Malay
the city attorney's office just want to prompt councilmember Wong to provide a general description
of the circumstances relating to the remote appearance and clarifying whether there is
anyone over the age of 18 with you in the room. Councilmember Wong, we have you muted?
Can you hear me now? Yes, we can hear you. Okay great. Circumstances are related to travel
and there's no one in there who's with me.
Okay, thank you.
Noting the remote participation for Councilmember Wong
and then Chair Ramachandran.
Present.
Thank you.
We have four members present and Chair,
before we begin, do you have any announcements at this time?
I do, thank you.
We will hear today's items as scheduled two, three, four
and then we will jump to item seven,
the prompt payment policy report
and then wrap up with items five and six.
So just one item moving on forward.
Thank you.
Okay, noting the change of the order
to hear item number seven after item number four.
Continuing with the order of the agenda
as today is a special meeting,
there are no minutes to be approved.
Moving on to item two,
which is the determination of schedule
of outstanding committee items,
also known as your pending list.
And we have two speakers that signed up for this item.
Okay, anything from staff?
Nothing at this time, thank you.
Thank you.
We can move to speak.
Calling in the names that sign up to speak on item two,
Miss Asada Olavala and Blair Beekman.
We've gotta stop ignoring the public.
I have asked you on several occasions,
the ABC security contract expired September the 30th.
And when are we going to deal with that contract
for security of city facilities being negotiated and settled.
I also am concerned about the fact that it appears
fiscal spending is going on without transparency.
And I'll give you one example.
The arrangement that you have with the city ice center
for validation of parking, there's no clarity
on how you are reimbursed or if you're even being reimbursed.
Having discussion with staff members,
you supposedly have, I don't know if it's a signed contract
or just a verbal arrangement,
that they pay you a set amount of money every month.
We need to have clarity on any fiscal spending
that goes on in this city.
I'm glad we have the ICE Center.
It's a necessary and valuable component
to the city, but we can't make arrangements
to give perks to people unless you go through a process.
The last thing I wanna say is we have to identify
when there are pertinent needs for contracts
to be put in place.
Last night at the Measure NN meeting,
the fire chief was saying he doesn't have the money
for the ventilation system that needs to be placed
At all of the stations in order for the safety,
when the firefighters are exposed to the exhaust
from the fire trucks, that impairs their health.
Every fire station.
Thank you for your comments.
Chair, that concludes all speakers on this item.
Thank you.
Is there a motion?
So moved.
Second.
Thank you.
We have a motion made by council member Unger,
seconded by council member Brown,
to accept the determination of scheduling
of outstanding committee items as is
on roll council members.
Brown?
Aye.
Unger?
Aye.
Wong?
Aye.
And Chair Ramachandran?
Aye.
Thank you, motion passes with four ayes.
To accept the determination of schedule
of outstanding committee items as is.
Reading in item number three.
Receive an informational report on the operational
and financial status of city-owned parking garages,
evaluation of parking operator performance,
and review of city parkings operation alternative
and there are three speakers on this item.
Thank you, how many minutes will you need?
Good morning, finance committee members.
Through the chair, my name is Jose Segura,
assistant revenue tax administrator
with the finance department.
Before you today, it's an informational report
providing an update on city-owned parking garage operations.
The report covers parking system evaluation,
garage utilization, enforcement challenges,
and deferred maintenance priorities.
First, regarding the evaluation
of the city's current gate-less parking system,
staff identified several challenges,
including lower revenues, payment compliance,
enforcement, and technology reliability.
Garage revenues remain approximately 17%
below pre-pandemic levels,
while citation revenue represents
only a small portion of total garage revenue.
Based on these findings,
staff recommends returning to a gated system
to improve revenue collection
and an operational oversight.
Sure, thank you.
The estimated costs,
I'll backtrack a second just to make sure
that we capture this.
So based on the challenges that staff has identified,
staff recommends returning to a get it system
to improve revenue collection and operational oversight.
The estimated costs include approximately 1.5 million
in one time capital costs for the six garages
and 1.12 million annually for live attendance.
Staff is also exploring automated payment alternatives
to reduce the staffing needs.
Regarding garage utilization and enforcement,
current technology limitations make it difficult
to accurately measure garage usage
and compare activity from year to year.
Citation activity is also affected by enforcement resources,
technology limitations, and changes in enforcement schedules.
Looking at other cities, we're seeing similar efforts
to modernize parking operations,
improve financial sustainability,
And finally, the report identifies default maintenance priorities with a focus on life safety, regulatory compliance, critical building systems, security, and preventative maintenance first.
With this, I conclude my presentation.
Thank you for your time, and I am happy to answer any questions that you may have.
the right to make sure we have
a lot of power compliance
critical building systems
security and preventative
maintenance first.
With this I conclude my
presentation thank you for your
time and I am happy to answer
any questions that you may have.
Thank you so when this was last
heard a couple of months ago I
was very concerned at the fact
that we don't make money off of
our garages and I know Oakland's
not alone as a city in doing so
explore things like moving away from the gateless system,
other technology updates, and garage by garage,
understanding, I know the next item relates to this as well
when it comes to the contract.
Can you talk about what changes that you're,
you mentioned that we'll need a budget edition of 1.5 million.
Can you talk a little bit more about what the funding
that is needed and how much more money we anticipate collecting, because right now we're
not off of our garages, which should be a revenue generating function.
So what, so in terms of what revenue is needed to implement a gated system?
Could you speak a little closer?
So just to clarify, are you asking about the budget that's needed to implement a gated
system or an improved access system to the garages, or in general the budget that's needed
for the garage operations, I'm sorry.
I mean, you mentioned one, I heard 1.5 million
that you said that we need to be able
to then make more money, so what are we investing,
what are you proposing we invest the 1.5 million in,
and how much more will that yield for the city?
Because as of now, we make almost no money.
Sure, so the 1.5 million is an estimate
as to how much it will cost to bring back the gated system.
It's based on one estimate that we got
for one particular garage, so it may vary
when we look at different garages, they have different needs.
the city of the city of the.
needs and the cost may vary, but that's a rough estimate as to how much it would cost
to bring back the gated system.
And it's without having full data to analyze the usage and potential revenue that results
from that.
If we assume full compliance and looking at the usage that was pre-pandemic, we can estimate
that it will generate between $2 and $3 million more per year, again, assuming full compliance
and a similar usage as to the pre-pandemic levels.
And can you remind us how much, so if we can anticipate,
if we go back to the gated system,
two to three million a year,
how much are we making right now approximately?
And I know it was less than a million,
but what are we netting per year?
So to clarify, the net was roughly about $880,000 or so.
Net engrossed, we generated last fiscal year,
was about $8.5 million.
And so gross is where I, when I mentioned the extra $2 to $3
million, I'm referring to gross revenues
in terms of the garage.
If the costs take the same, then we're
going to net those extra as well.
But if we're also going to incur additional costs,
then when we subtract the one-time $1.5 million
investment and the $1.1 million annual cost
in staffing, then we're going to generate a delta of approximately a million dollars
or less more in terms of one million or less more after accounting for the additional costs.
Now, there are other options as well, so this includes the option to go to a get it system
and bring back attendance to operate the garages, but there's also other technologies that
we would like to explore, there are camera compliance systems
that can take an image of a license plate
when it enters the garage, when it exits the garage,
track the timing, track payment compliance.
Isn't that what we have right now and it's not working?
No, right now we rely on the enforcement,
on the license plate recognition system,
on the enforcement side, so basically,
we don't track the license plates when they enter the garage,
we don't track them when they exit.
vehicles enter the garage, they park,
and then our enforcement team needs to drive around
with the automatic license plate readers.
And when they attempt to enforce
and they drive around the garage,
that's when that technology kicks in.
But we currently don't have that technology
in our gates per se.
Can you talk more about,
so these are lots of options on the table.
What is the rollout for improving the system?
because I think we've all identified a lot of problems.
We don't make money off of our garages when we stood.
Many of these garages aren't open
on key dates including weekends.
I remember Black Joy Parade,
I thought I could park in Dalzell garage closed
and people are sitting in double parking on the streets.
It's, you know,
tens of thousands of people coming to Oakland.
Winner, you know, technology is one thing,
enforcement is another thing,
operating hours, capital improvements.
What is the plan for actually rolling out these changes
And when will you come with specific budget asks to this body?
Sure.
So we're issuing an RFP to enter into a long-term contract solution.
So the RFP, we're anticipating to have it done within the next year.
I'm jumping a little bit ahead, but the next item, we're requesting a one-year extension
for the current contract.
And so we anticipate that through the RFP.
We will receive, we will be receiving solutions provided by the different vendors that we
anticipate will submit their bid through the RFP and that's where we'll learn exactly
what's out there, what options are out there, what solutions are out there, what's the
latest technology, what's the most cost-effective solution that we can put out there.
So that's part of it.
Other things that we can do outside of the RFP process includes better marketing, better
a way finding science maybe look at market analysis to see what rates are appropriate for the different garages and see if we can be
more competitive. So there's different things that we can do even outside of the RFP process but in general that's we're
looking to to find a long term solution through our RFP process.
But good to the chair. The plan is that some of the options that are Jose is describing in terms of structuring a new revitalized
garage structure. And again, as you mentioned, not every garage is going to have the same
need, the same solution, the same things available to them. Just high level, some garages we
may want gated arms because it's a security issue and that's just how we want to control
access for other reasons. Other garages, as Jose mentioned, if you've gone to some of
our suburban parking garages in the area, they'll track you on your entry, they'll track
you on your exit, and it's very similar to a pay-by-plate system except you capture every
single car coming in and out and so there's no leakage. We want to explore
what is right at each one of the locations and the plan is to have
options for those and the funding elements of them included within a
budget proposal so that the council consider it during your biennial. We
would then need time to implement and fully roll in which is why we're looking
at extending the current contracts for a calendar year so that by roughly
halfway in through the next part of your mid-cycle budget we can transition to
something new.
I will also mention, Jose noted it earlier,
that our significant capital investment
and life safety needs for these garages,
if we're going to continue to operate them as assets,
and those also need to be considered
as a component of your budget process.
We also will be looking and understanding
our management structure for how we ensure
that we do not, we fully utilize
to the best of our ability resources in supporting them.
That's another component of this ask as well.
Okay, thank you, I will, okay, thank you.
I will pass it on to my colleagues,
council member Brown-Danongar.
Excellent, well first of all, thank you so much for,
when the item came prior, we all requested more detail,
and so I think that the report this time around
definitely fulfills that.
And so in the attachment number three,
I did like how it actually breaks down the various priorities and the investments based
on life safety, compliance, et cetera.
But as I was reading through the report, I guess one of the things that I was thinking
about is, I mean, I think ideally maybe the garages could in a way pay for themselves
there were actually modifications made to the payment structure. And also, I noticed
that some of the garages lack, they don't all have the license plate reader, for example.
And so as I'm looking at this, like, Attachment Number 3 showcases, like, priority number
one, two, three, I would like to make the recommendation that one of the priorities
Is actually around the license plate reader to actually capture the folks who aren't paying for the garages
And then I also noticed in the report that the when was the last time the cost of the um
Per the cost per hour per day was updated
the rates have well, the rates were increased in uh
A handful a couple of the garages during this last fiscal year
but for the most part, the parking rates have not been updated in several years.
Yeah, I mean, the table, I forget which attachment it is, but I thought it was interesting that
there were the, some of them had like an hour rate, but not all of them had like a full day
fee, and so I would be interested in what the cost, like what's the going rate for a full day
in one of the garages, like I guess like Bay Area-wise,
and maybe we would make that upgrade as well.
So I wanted to offer that as a recommendation.
And then I do like the analysis of,
I think one of the things that I brought up
was around like the garage infrastructure.
And so hopefully we can make that
higher on the priority list.
infrastructure and payment accountability?
No, it definitely will do.
And on your earlier point, we are planning to do a market analysis and update the fee
structure in this current year's masterpiece schedule amendment process.
Excellent.
Thank you.
And just to clarify another point, so we currently do use the automatic license plate reader
technology.
that we're having technology difficulties
trying to utilize it inside of garages
because of the enclosed structure
under concrete and whatnot.
So, but we will look into definitely
exploring that further
and actually implementing something that works.
Council Member Unger, then Wong.
Are we in arrears to our operators?
in terms of, yes, and so we have the authority
to execute a new contract and pay them in full.
So we have paid them through the end of July.
This last couple months we're working on finalizing
the necessary steps to be able to issue the pending check.
Okay, and is the money we owe them already budgeted for
and doesn't have to come from anywhere new?
So is this more of a prompt payment problem than a budget problem?
Related to the item we're discussing now, this is an information report on the
garage, is your next item on the contract extension would allow us the contract
authority to continue to pay the provider through the for another calendar
year, which is the just to be clear is the next item on your agenda. We do have
budget authority, we do you also need contract authority in order to be able
to cut checks and then we have to execute the contracts
with the vendor.
Got it, for the extension.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Councillor Melanque.
Hi there.
Thank you for this report.
I think what I am curious about is, first of all,
I had murdered in the prior report that was delivered back
in the July time frame that there were a couple of garages
that really stood out is losing revenue.
I think one of them includes like the Medical Hill location.
So is there a plan since what I'm looking at,
some of these capital priorities to really focus
on ensuring that those that are losing revenue
are getting sort of the gated model to come back.
And perhaps this sounds overly simplistic,
but just in understanding the challenges
around the Gate List model and the ALPR technology,
I mean, this is a very perhaps layman's view on this,
but it's like, why wouldn't we just use Gates
where you couldn't exit without paying?
To the chair of Councilmember Wong,
just to note a really key distinct challenge
that the team is overviewing just as we talk
about controlling access and policing access
and entry to our garages.
Gated technology is obviously the easiest way
to ensure that everyone coming in pays.
Gated technology is also more expensive
because you have to pay for attendant staff
to ensure that people can enter and exit.
So it is a more secure technology in that way,
but it is also more expensive
in terms of your operating cost.
What we're also exploring is the ability to use
not the current license plate reader system,
I should not use acronyms, which as people enter
and then you patrol around the garage and police,
but an automatic system which captures license plates
of every vehicle upon entry and exit, which does exist.
And again, where one of those options may be better
than another will be dependent on the nature
of that particular garage, the type of infrastructure,
the number of entry and exit ways to that garage,
the need for security in that garage, some garages,
you may want to have an attendant in a gated space anyway
because you need additional security on that facility
no matter what.
Some do not have the overhead mounting location.
Some do not have the overhead mounting locations
by which to put up an LAPR reader or whatnot.
So that is the consideration we're having.
And to your point, we will also consider,
again, as we look at each of these different sites
individually, the particular need
to drive better net revenue performance at the garages individually, which includes the
rate structure and everything else.
Assistant Director Seguer, anything else to add to that?
Correct.
I agree.
So, yeah, we're looking into, like I said, a market analysis to find the proper rate
structure that will drive in more vehicles, but also with the potential to the gated system
or a better technology system, then we can ensure compliance in that.
And, of course, we'll generate more revenue.
Okay.
That's helpful.
a number of our garages have
EV chargers but many of them are having challenges with that.
Can we speak to that?
It seems like they might be installed
but they're not operational.
Is there a reason for that?
We don't have the information in terms
of the interoperability of those.
I do know that we are contractually obligated
to provide you the charging stations through various garages. But I can look further into.
I was not aware that they're not properly working so I can look further into that. Okay. Okay.
Thank you. I appreciate it. Thank you. That's it. Thank you, Councilman Luong. Just to wrap
this up and I know the next item is relevant so I'll complete my comments here. I wanted
to, well firstly, I clearly have a lot of criticisms of the way that our parking garages
have operated and I understand that this is not due to finance departments fault. I know
I just want to be clear that this is a history of some bad decisions and outside factors
that are not in your control and I appreciate that you were trying to get to solutions so
we get more revenue, which the city desperately needs.
I do also want to state that I personally,
just based on the analysis that I write here,
I don't have a preference on gate lists or gate,
but I want to confirm the timeline with which
you will come to us with recommendations
for a new vendor with whichever system
you recommend us moving forward with.
Sure, so we are, our current RFP timeline
would have us come back to you around March or so
in the spring with the recommendation for the new vendor.
That's currently our plan to come back in the spring
and have that after the RP process has been completed
and we'll provide you with that recommendation then.
Thank you, and then, so the vendor,
picking a vendor is one thing, but there was an aspect
of the report that talked about connectivity issues,
which is, to my understanding, the city's responsibility.
have we resolved the issues with Wi-Fi
in Dalzell and City Center West
so that citations can actually be issued?
So we have explored options such as alternative,
like I'll say antennas or receptors for better connectivity,
but the RFP process, so it'll be
for the management of the garages,
but we're also within the process.
We're inviting folks to provide us with our solutions,
so their solutions will include technology options
that are out there.
And so we, through the RFP process, we can there select the vendor that provides us with a comprehensive solution that includes technology improvements and all the needs that we have.
Or there's a possibility where we, through the same process, we can select one vendor as the garage operator and then another vendor as the solutions to our, if we bring up gated systems to provide the gates or to provide whatever technology improvements we need.
So we do think that we'll find a long-term solution through our RFP process.
process thank you and just to clarify even though you are going to be issuing
an RFP so we can go through a new process is the current vendor willing to
make changes so that even in the next year if we approve the next item coming
that we will have better utilization of the garages and more enforcement we are
in constant dialogue with them and I we have regular meetings and in which they
provide us with updates in terms of the needs and whatnot I yes they they are
are willing to we can definitely work with them to to to make changes I mean
the inner I would just add that as it relates to some of the infrastructure
things you've been mentioned or in connectivity there's your conversations
that finance is having internally within the city because those are things we
need to resolve regardless as a safety issue in those garages so those remain
priorities that we will be looking at regardless of which particular vendor is
to operating the structure.
Thank you.
We can move to public comment.
Calling in the names that sign up to speak
on item number three,
Mrs. Sato Olavala, David Boatwright and Blair Beekman.
I'm sorry, Mr. Dalley,
do you not have a speaker card for item three?
I believe I filled it out online Sunday night.
I have them for a four and on.
I think I did.
Unfortunately, it's impossible to look it up online.
if the chair is willing.
I'm sorry I checked just
recently and noticed that you
did not sign up for item three.
We do have you sign up for item
three.
It is an unreliable system as
you know and it does not give
one feedback.
Okay again the name set did sign
up for item number three.
No I didn't click on it.
It's possible I missed the
second or third click that's
required.
I would appreciate if the chair
would allow me to speak and I'm
willing to do it after everyone
else.
I'm confused on how you expect to make money at this park garage because we need to get
an indicator of how many city vehicles are parked in that garage. It's a parking storage
space
because
it's it's it's a large number
because you have so many space occupied
by city vehicles
you're not going to make money
the other thing i'm concerned about them i've said this before
you do have a special battle
battle
nation process
for people come to the meetings
and for the
people who go to the ice center you're not going to make money
unless you can demonstrate that you are getting money
from the ICE center and you're not willing
to have a public discussion on that.
I don't understand if I got a ticket on October the 27th
because I wasn't supposedly legally parked in the garage.
I parked in the garage thinking it was legal
at eight something in the morning.
I was here all day and I didn't get a ticket until 6.57.
So if we have constant supposedly patrolling of the garage
and I wasn't supposedly valid, why did it take you all day
to give me a ticket at 6.57?
The garage closes at one o'clock.
Do you have the ability to have enforcement
up to one o'clock over at that garage or any garage?
It's another question that I have.
But the other thing is that you have had the opportunity
to put what y'all calls the stations for electricity,
is that that's taken up space.
Okay, anyway.
David Boatwright, district four.
I didn't see any reference to the conference center
parking lot in the report for this item.
And it'd be interesting to hear
if that's gonna be discussed sometime today,
because I think that parking lot was in the red
for several years, may still be.
Thank you.
Thank you, at this time,
all names have been called for item three.
Council Member Brown.
So I can make a motion to, I vote.
I apologize, we have a number of speakers today
and I have to be fair to everyone that did sign up.
There will be other items
that I know you have signed up for.
I'm not allowing it, I apologize.
I appreciate it.
I will give you, this is your warning.
this is your warning that you will be out of order.
Okay, so I was gonna make a motion
to receive and file this report,
and I also just wanted to make a slight comment.
I know that, I think it's the 12th Street Garage,
there was a great investment from Ava Community Energy
for those EV charging stations would also be interested
in how we can explore more opportunities like that,
because I'm pretty sure that that was actually financed
by Ava, I believe, and so I think it could be
a good addition across some of our multiple garages, both indoor and outdoor.
So, so moved, second that.
Thank you. We have a motion made by Councilmember Brown, seconded
by Councilmember Unger to receive and file this informational report and
committee on rule. Councilmembers Brown.
I Unger I Wong I and chair Ramachandran.
I thank you. Motion passes with four I's to receive and file this
informational report and committee reading in item number four.
adopt a resolution authorizing the city administrator to amend the professional services agreement
with city of Oakland parking partners for operation and management of municipal parking
facilities to extend the term for up to one year through December 31st, 2027 for a total
amount not sorry for a total amount over the amended term not to exceed four million one
hundred thirty three thousand and thirteen dollars waiving the competitive request for
We have four proposal qualification requirements under Oakland municipal code section two point zero four point zero one five one point B and
Adopting sequel findings and we have four speakers that signed up to speak on this item
Thank you
Good morning again finance committee members again minimus assessor Luda assistant revenue tax administrator with the finance department
Today I am presenting an item regarding the proposed extension of the city's parking operator contract with city
of Oakland parking partners or COPP. The City entered into the original agreement in 2014
and following three extensions the contract is set to expire on December 31, 2026. COPP
continues to manage the City's parking facilities which serve businesses, employees, residents,
visitors and City operations. The City is releasing a Request for Proposals or RFP for
and the proposed extension would provide additional time to complete the procurement process while maintaining continuity of parking operations.
Through the RFP, the city will evaluate future management options, including operational improvements, revenue opportunities, and the potential return to a gated parking system.
The proposed amendment would extend the agreement for one additional year with no change to the current payment rate.
this concludes my presentation thank you for your time and I am happy to answer
any questions thank you once again I know this department inherited this mess
and I appreciate your efforts to try to get to the bottom of thoughtfully
resolving this I will support even though I a couple months ago I was the
one that wanted to have this contract and by the end of this year I understand
that a comprehensive RFP takes time I'm happy to move the item my only request
Is that for the time period that we still have with parking partners. Let's see how many changes they can make and what
how we can work cooperatively with them to get enforcement access and
safety capital improvements
And I'll make the motion council member
Brown
Excellent. I will also second that and I also wanted to emphasize that, you know, I see the the timeline
which you know, hopefully it can move a little bit more speedy and I think that my hope is that while
This RFP process is
Occurring. I'm hopeful that some of the the
Easier lower hanging fruits around updating our garagas and in some of those maintenance efforts can still occur
So that it's just not paused and stopped
And are you able to speak to that a little bit? Okay. Yeah
So, yeah, we're, in the current fiscal year, we are, we have the, the budget that was budgeted,
obviously, so we have to look into existing resources, including even within the contract
itself, if it allows for any, any maintenance or, or that, that type of work.
We're also desperately looking in, in different areas to see if there's any prior savings
that we could carry forward that, that, that, that can cover some of these costs.
So we're exploring any possibility in the current fiscal year.
we go into the fall and into the next fiscal year we'll have a better
opportunity to more properly budget any available resources that we have for
this and so yes we we will not wait for the new vendor to or for the new
contract to take place before we start making some of this needed improvements.
Okay we'll move to Council Member Wong-Tam.
Thank you.
Just one comment I had before we moved the vote.
I just would really encourage your focus on, again, this is, I'm looking at the report that was discussed in this committee last time.
This item was discussed and there is at least a handful of lots where the revenue has been zero.
I'm actually not entirely sure how that's possible, but there's just a straight zero
for a number of these garages, and I really want to focus on really resolving the issues
with those garages.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you for that.
I can speak on that as well.
So there are a couple.
So there's a wide range of parking facilities that the city owns, right?
So some are really big parking garages in the downtown area that obviously have a lot
there's a lot of traffic and what not.
We also have a couple of parking lots
that were donated to the city.
And basically there's a couple parking lots
that were donated with the condition
that the city offers free parking in those areas.
They're like commuter zones where they park there,
then they hop on an AC transit bus or whatnot.
And so you may cease a couple of the lots
that really don't have any revenues.
And there's also a couple,
So we don't have that, but our vendors still provides
maintenance for those lots, so that's why they're included
in the portfolio, and there's also a couple of lots
that are, that collect the revenue through the means
of parking meters, and so those parking meters are registered,
I'm sorry, and those payments are captured
as parking meter revenues, and so that's,
they also don't reflect garage revenue.
So there are certain things, as I've noted,
that impacts how we reflect the revenues
for the garage portfolio.
Okay, gotcha, that's helpful.
I mean, I'm seeing in this report
that it's like Piedmont lot.
This is 119 spaces with Grand Avenue, that's 81.
Anyways, I don't need to belabor the point.
It sounds like there's an explanation,
but if there's anything where there are actual issues
that are not being reflected
in some of what you just explained,
I would just encourage that we resolve that, thanks.
I agree with you.
And we're definitely looking into improving compliance with a gated or a better technology
system we're looking to come to within close to 100 percent compliance and obviously that
will result in capturing all of the revenues that can be captured in those garages.
Okay.
Thank you.
Thank you.
We can move to public speakers.
Calling in the names that sign up to speak on item number four, David Boatwright, Asada
Olobala, Kevin Dalley, and Blair Beekman.
You know I don't know if it's
going to be in the parking
garage.
You know Kevin deli I do
encourage you guys to look at
your software on.
Signing up to be a speaker but
let's talk about parking
garages both this contract in
the previous item.
I finally sent some
information to chair on my
chondrin about my thoughts on
garages I'd like to see a
presentation by both finance
and street parking should be working as a system.
When we had a presentation in January
to Public Works and Transportation Department
on the Montclair parking garage,
Michael Ford discussed how parking garage prices
are set in comparison to street parking.
I'm not hearing this from the finance department now.
Usually street parking garages have a lower rate
than street parking to encourage people
When they parked for a longer period to move into the garage, what are we doing here?
There's a paper in 2015 by Pierce Wilson and shoot discussing how to optimize the use of public garages.
Goals are ready availability driver should be able to find the space high occupancy parking spaces should be well used serve many customers.
Revenue, the goal shouldn't be to maximize revenue,
but to recover the marginal cost of operations.
Remember, we get revenue from sales taxes
as well as from parking garages.
We want people to move in, park there, enjoy Oakland,
spend money in Oakland, walk around the lake in Oakland.
It's not just getting every single cent out of it.
So let's go back, have a joint presentation
by Oak dot and finance about this subject.
Thanks.
So your first contract with, uh, city of Oakland partner parking
partners started in 2014 and you've had, uh, several extensions up to, uh,
that will expire in 2026.
So this is a $4.1 million contract.
So in my head, who is City of Oakland parking partners
that we continue to give money to, $4.1 million.
Who is it?
So I looked it up.
It says the City of Oakland parking partners
is not a private company owned by individuals.
It is for profit, partnership,
and contracted operating entity
hired by the City of Oakland.
It is not a Better Business Bureau accredited.
I only could find two reviews.
Then I found something else.
The name of the Pacific individual who runs
or owns the private business entity,
City of Oakland Park and Partners,
is not publicly named in any official document.
Who is these people?
Y'all giving this 4.1 million dollar contract to.
who is this company that they say is not private,
it's a partnership, where's the performance evaluation
over the period of time that they have worked for you
that says they are credible enough to continue
to give a contract to.
David Boulroy, District 4.
I look at city parking lots as kind of a service
that's provided by this city.
I know people ought to pay for it,
but the city ought to keep that in mind
when they're raising rates and things like that.
And I'm wondering if the city's ever looked
at trying to raise the revenue
by reducing the cost of parking in these parking lots
to get more people willing to pay those fees.
Thank you.
Thank you for your comments, Chair.
That concludes all speakers on this item.
Thank you before, I know we have a motion and a second,
just very quickly, two things noted by public speakers.
Can you talk about who is parking partners?
Can you hear me?
Oh, thank you.
So City of Oakland Parking Partners is a joint venture.
They are, the partnership is between Wellington,
CMA, LLC, and SP Plus Corporation.
And so they are a joint venture.
they are part of the process that we requested
that they provided their filing agreements
in terms of their partnership
and also their DBA with the county.
That shows exactly who they are.
Thank you.
And I will just make a statement that I do know
that changes to the rates have been considered
over the years so that we could have more volume
if that's a factor, especially post-pandemic.
we have a motion to approve the recommendations of staff and support this item to the December
1st City Council agenda. On roll council members Brown, under Wong, and chair Ramachandran.
Thank you. Motion passes with four ayes to support this item to the December 1st City
Council agenda and to the maker of the motion. Is this on consent? Thank you. On consent.
that the change of the order to the agenda to hear item seven next item seven
is to receive an informational report on the implementation and performance of
the city of Oakland's prompt payment policy and there are 12 speakers on this
item thank you go ahead I will just briefly introduce this item and pass it
to director Johnson one of the reasons that I brought this informational report
request forward was because of understanding the vast number of contractors with the City
of Oakland, businesses, nonprofits, small businesses that frequently do not get paid
on time when they're supposed to, when there's a contract.
We also know that in the racial equity report that we heard about, about a year ago, I believe,
this was one of the factors that was discussed when you not only have businesses contracting
with Oakland, but specifically minority-owned businesses in Oakland that don't get paid
on time, that affects your ability to operate as a business.
We did hear this item a few months ago, and I understand that the numbers that are stated
here with the 90 percent plus compliance rate doesn't exactly correspond with the reality
that we hear on the ground that people are not getting paid on time.
And I know that the report is narrow on the prompt payment policy, and there's lots of
other factors including our contracting process but the goal of this conversation today is
to hear from community members that have been negatively impacted by the city's failure
to pay on time and I know that this is the beginning of a conversation and there's lots
of steps to be had but I think folks were coming in at 9.30 am on a Tuesday morning
and to our finance department for trying to problem solve not only the specific payment
policy but the broader conversation of let's pay people when they're supposed to be paid
if they're doing business in Oakland.
Director Johnson.
Without belaboring it too much, again, this is a report that was brought before.
I would just note at the high level, the average compliance note amount over the last three
or four years is 96%.
I would note that the prompt payment policy applies to Oakland vendors and I will also
note that the timelines for prompt payment apply when the vendor is in contract with
the city of Oakland, as sort of alluded to earlier,
a major component of delayed payment
from the perspective of vendors is contracts
and work happening prior to the actual contract taking place,
which is the timeline that prompt payment aligns to.
We're happy to hear the feedback from members of the public
and take anything into consideration if the council
has no additional questions on the report
or has additional questions for it.
I'm happy to answer those as well.
Thank you, we can look to public speakers first.
Calling of the names that sign up to speak
on item number seven.
In no particular order, you can line up.
And then when you, before making your comment,
please state your name for the record.
Marsha Brady, Jeffrey Lohman, Lynette Hart,
Kevin Dalley, Asada Ola Bala, Josephine Guzman,
Jan Brady, Kathy Adams, Chadwick Spell,
Stanley Cooper, Alex Isperon, and Renee Johnson.
Again, in no particular order,
you can come up to the mic.
If you are ceding time to anyone in particular,
please state that before you begin
so I can adjust your time.
Are you Lynette?
Okay, so we have two people ceding time to you,
so that will be a total of four minutes.
Madam City Clerk, before the speaker begins,
we wanna see if we can get the mic
operational at the podium.
I don't know if that mic is live.
Ma'am, could you speak into it just a bit?
Good morning.
There we go.
Okay.
Good morning, Finance Committee and Council members.
My name is Lynette Hart.
I'm president of Low Train Consulting,
located at 340 Grand Avenue here in Oakland.
I have over 25 years experience in human resources
with public agencies,
and I was forced out of the city of Oakland in 2023.
I watched their last meeting regarding the HR contracts,
I have to say to all of you
and I was struck by council
member guy old call to grow on
supervisors directors and
managers through training that
is exactly why I'm here I did
that work for the city and I
wasn't paid for it. In early
twenty twenty four open public
works issued an RFP for on site
professional development
training for supervisors and
aspiring supervisors my
business partner thirty year
we had to have a comprehensive
competitive process then we
waited months we learn that O.
P. W. administrative manager
Tom Morgan found out about my
company apply that I had applied
and the entire R. F. P. was
canceled. I felt a complaint
against Tom Morgan in twenty
twenty alleging race
discrimination harassment
failure to promote and
I thought another complaint against Tom Morgan,
complaining he discriminated against me.
I believe the cancellation of the RFP by Tom Morgan
was further retaliation against me.
Months later we were told the training would go forward
because our price was the one the department could afford.
On June 4th, 5th, 11th and 12th, 2025,
we arrived at 615 AM and provided breakfast,
snacks and catered lunch.
We trained 28 city employees using role plays
we've been working on this
for a long time. We've been
working on this for a long time
and we've been working on this
for a long time. We've been
working on this for a long time.
We've been working on this for
a long time. We've been working
on this for a long time. We've
been working on this for a long
time. We've been working on
this for a long time. We've
been working on this for a long
time. We've been working on
this for a long time. We've
been working on this for a long
time. We've been working on
this for a long time. We've
been working on this for a long
time. We've been working on
this for a long time. We've
been working on this for a long
time. We've been working on
we gave the city a eighteen thousand dollar discount from our RFP. We submitted our invoice
on June 17, 2025. In July 2025 I was told Tom Morgan said we would not be paid because of me
and that I had no right to work for the city because of my complaint. We were later notified
via email payment was coming. The next day we received notification it was cancelled.
It's not a complaint, it's just
going to happen.
As of November 17th, 2026, we
have still not been paid.
Yes, I filed a complaint against
Tom Morgan and I have every
right to do so.
Yes, we performed the services
and know we were never paid.
The matter has now been
escalated, but this council
needs to know what happened.
A city employee was able to
cancel a contract and withhold
payment, apparently because of
This is one example of how internal progress towards growth of our own supervisors, directors,
and managers is stymied because of individual, I had unchecked bias in leadership.
This is a clear example of how individual biases in leadership block us from growing
our own and advancing.
Here's what this means for small businesses.
If a minority-owned, Oakland-born small business can deliver excellent work, give a discount,
and still not be paid, what business would risk doing business with the city of Oakland?
Small businesses cannot absorb unpaid invoices.
We cannot wait years for a payment that was approved and then canceled.
To conduct this training such as the one we did, the administrative cost for us was thousands
of dollars.
Thank you.
Good morning, city council.
I'm Kathy Adams, president, CEO of the Oakland African-American Chamber of Commerce, speaking
on behalf of the Oakland Business Coalition
and our Multicultural Chamber of Commerce.
We're here today because our small businesses deserve
to be paid on time for work they have already performed.
The Comptroller's Report indicates that 96%
of city contracts were paid
within the city's prompt payment policy.
However, that number does not tell the whole story
because the city does not track payment to subcontractors.
What about our small businesses and subcontractors?
are they being paid on time?
Our businesses cannot operate on promise.
They have employees to pay, insurance to maintain,
suppliers to compensate, and families dependent on them.
When payments are delayed, businesses suffer.
Some may not survive.
Today we're asking the city to take forth specific action.
Transparency, report payment performance
for small local business enterprise separately
so we know who is actually being paid on time.
accountability required prime contractors to pay their subcontractors properly
with clear payment requirements written into every contract
communication establish a transparent
process so businesses know the status of their invoice
who is responsible
and when
can they expect pain
published information on the city's website
followed through direct finance committee to monitor progress
and provide a report
by February of 2027.
Let me be clear, we cannot talk about economic development,
equity and supporting Oakland businesses
while one of those same businesses
to struggle to collect money they have already earned.
Our coalition is committed to working with the city,
but we need measurable results,
accountability and follow through.
We're not asking for special treatment,
we're asking for fair treatment.
Let's make Oakland a city where small businesses
and can succeed, grow, and trust the contracting process.
Hello, my name is Chad Bixpel, Oakland Business Coalition,
Watch Your Group, and the Oakland American Chamber.
Representing also, NAMAC, Mario cannot be here, so one
of the things we wanna make sure we understand is,
building on what Kathy said, this ordinance for prop payment
was mainly done for small businesses and local businesses.
but yet this ninety six percent does not include subcontractors.
So, this is where we need to make sure the reporting is actually accurate and encompassing
everything that's covered on this ordinance, not just what looks good.
Number two, what we're asking for is track the money through every tier.
So that means automatically changing these contracts, making sure that the primes are
in their contract required to adhere to this ordinance with their subcontractors, not being
and that's what a lot of them
are told. Number two close the
gaps created by different
funding arrangements with paid
by the city paid by a bank paid
by. Grant whatever it may be
close the gaps in the different
funding. Arrangements to make
sure prop payment is here to
number three enforce protections
already on the books enforcement
is a number one issue we have in
the city- not just a prop
payment with everything that we
do. Contracting you name it.
enforcement enforcement
we need more money you divert some things to
enforcement within the city government let's do that because I bring more
business back to Oakland. Number four fix close out and release
retention. You should not release all the funds to a prime unless they
can show that their subs are actually paid period. If the project is completed
they should be paid already. Number five put dates and accountability behind the work.
have to be there as long as
you have dates and
accountability it should be
there.
And there's a number of
different companies and I will
do the ones I have here- that
was found in this very study
that we're never paid or when
they have a disparity at a
difference in what being paid.
They have not gotten their
money.
Good morning city council I am
chef Renee Johnson owner of
blackberry so and the founder
of Lincoln thrive when his
in Oakland, I have experienced this frustration recently.
I had a contract for $50,000.
And yes, I'm a small business, but I'm a company as well.
So it took them over two months to pay me,
and I raised so much mess in Oakland
that I really feel like my file was just set aside.
If I did not have the wisdom and the courage
and the energy to fight for my money,
I felt like I would still be fighting forward.
There was no sense of urgency.
There was no priority, there was no system.
And the thing that made it so hard is that
I still had to run my company, not my small business,
so I had to pay all my vendors, all my staff,
everything based upon you guys.
The kicker part is this.
Everybody, and I sent this in an email,
every single one of you guys do not understand
the courage that it takes to be a small business.
The energy, the willpower to be a small business.
And me, I stand up for Oakland all the time.
I would love to see the love.
The other thing, the constant thing that I hear,
heard the whole time when I was fighting for my money,
is that's just the way it is.
That's the policy.
There's no other system.
There was no resolution.
And if I did not know the people that I know,
I would be still probably fighting for my money.
Kathy Adams, the City of Oakland,
the Oakland African-American Chamber of Commerce,
I tagged and emailed everybody in this,
and a lot of people are
the other side of the city of
Oakland or in the city of
Oakland to get my money do you
think how think about how we
feel that small businesses in
Oakland.
There's no sense of urgency
there's no kind of
accountability there's no system
and the word I heard constantly
is that's just how it is.
That's not acceptable for us
we're small businesses but we
own companies.
And we and you guys we take
care of the city of Oakland.
here representing the Oakland Metro Chamber of Commerce.
First we want to thank Chair Romachandran and her office
for bringing this informational report forward
and creating an opportunity to discuss
the city's prop payment policy.
For many small business owners in Oakland,
securing a city contract is a significant opportunity
for them and we know that the delayed payments
can create a real challenge, especially for businesses
operating with limited cash flow already.
While the report shows overall compliance,
even one delayed payment can impact a business ability
to meet payroll and operating expenses.
We hope that this report serves as a starting point
for a broader conversation to evaluate
the city's current practices and identify practical ways
to make its procurement and contracting processes
more efficient and transparent
for small businesses here in Oakland.
This means looking at the entire process
from the contract awarded to the execution
to the invoicing and payment,
and identifying opportunities to reduce
that administrative barrier
and strengthening that departmental accountability
within our small businesses doing these applications.
If we want to create more opportunity
for our small businesses to grow,
we need to secure city contracts
and ensure this process is just accessible
and efficient and works for them.
We appreciate the time and look forward
to continue collaboration.
Thank you so much.
Good morning, Chair and committee members.
My name is Alex Izzvron.
I'm a board member of the Oakland Chinatown Chamber
of Commerce and a small business owner myself.
I want to thank the committee for bringing forward
this important report and discussion on prompt payment.
Paying businesses on time is a basic business practice
and a matter of fiscal responsibility.
We have serious concerns that the city has
incurred nearly $394,000 in late payment interest,
especially at the time when the city is facing
significant fiscal challenges.
While the city reports a 96% compliance rate,
that number doesn't fully reflect
what we're hearing from our members.
This raises concerns about gaps in how payments
are being tracked and reported.
We've heard from members who have experienced
significant payment delays with some having to go
to their reserves or take out loans just to keep their businesses operating.
Others are discouraged from doing business with the City altogether.
So we urge the committee to strengthen payment tracking, report payment performance separately
for small businesses and establish greater accountability across City departments and
prime contractors to ensure subcontractors are paid on time.
As Oakland works to expand opportunities for small minority owned and women owned businesses,
we need to make sure that businesses can count on being paid for the work they've completed.
The Oakland Chinatown Chamber alongside our multicultural chambers and broader business
coalition stands ready to work with the city on meaningful reforms that support our local
businesses.
Thank you so much.
Derek Lawrence.
Good morning chair and committee members.
Derek Barnes speaking for the Oakland Business Coalition.
The staff report says 96% of payments are on time,
but look at what the number measures.
The clock starts once, and invoice is deemed valid.
It stops at the prime contractor,
and staff acknowledges that the city doesn't track
how long invoices sit in departments,
which is where most delays happen,
nor the length of time it takes for the primes
to pay their subcontractors.
When the city auditor measured the whole cycle,
He found 47 days on average more than double the city's 20-day standard capital improvement projects paid late almost half the time
that's awful and
Nothing in this report tells you whether a single
subcontractor got paid in June this committee asked for supplemental report and
It isn't in here and all we see is an old May 18th report
So three ask first report invoice to payment days by each department every month
Second make proof of subcontractor payment part of the complete prime invoice and invoice the seven day pay rule
The state already requires third ACA Baker is now gone name an owner and
The date for every prompt payment task that's already on the city's own work plan
None of this costs new money and creates legal risk. We wanted to make sure of that in working with the city
City enforcing its own rules and saving interest payment and costly claims should be the goal here
Small firms can't wait 47 days. Please ask staff to come back with answers to some of these questions
Will the city report invoice to payment days by department starting from the vendor when the vendor submits and by what date?
Can the city tell this committee whether any?
Prime paid its subs on time and if it does not what changes are needed ASAP for the for the prime
Contract to require proof before the city pays the prime. Thank you
this is
What cannot happen at the end of dealing with this item?
You cannot say
receive and file
Somebody sitting at the dais has to say,
I commit to coming back with a policy resolution
or ordinance that will correct the issues
that we have been presented today.
I commit to look at the recommendations
from the African American Chamber of Commerce
and any other areas that were brought up,
and I will come back.
If you end this with saying receive and file,
that's like saying nothing's gonna happen from here on.
So who's gonna make that commitment?
You have the capacity to say right now,
we will commit to a resolution, an ordinance,
a policy change that deals with these issues.
I see too many times that you have informational reports
and that's it.
So let's see what you're gonna do.
If your name was called and you still
wish to speak on this item,
please come up to the podium or raise your hand
on the zoom to be easily identified.
Okay, at this time all names have been called.
Thank you.
Dr. Johnson, is there any follow up
that you are recommending?
I could defer to Councilmember Unger first
and then I think he has some comments to make initially.
So our office is working on some contracting reform
and prompt payment reform.
It's a long process, we've been working on it,
along with the city administration,
we are going to be bringing legislation around
prompt payment and contracting reform.
That's underdone.
Excellent, well first off, thank you so much
to all the public speakers that showed up today
to speak on this item in the various chambers of commerce.
I think I first wanna start off by saying
that in my first year in office,
literally the first week, so January 2025,
myself and my team, we literally spent months
receiving requests from small businesses and non-profits
trying to track down when they were going to get paid.
And to one of the public speakers' point,
someone had said, well, you know,
that's just the way that it is.
And I just think that that is entirely unacceptable.
And so I worked tirelessly
to support every nonprofit that had reached out to me
and every small business to ensure that they got paid.
And that took up a lot of my energy in the first year.
And so here, today we have so many small businesses
and representation from multiple chambers
speaking and saying the same thing.
And so while I know that Council Member Unger
is working on some legislation
to hopefully help improve things in the process,
I'm grateful for that.
But a couple of the questions that I have,
I think first off, as the public speaker mentioned,
I know that ACA Baker was kind of leading some of the work
in and around this subject.
Who has been selected to kind of fill that gap
in this moment?
This is my first question.
Yeah, through the chair.
So Michelle, ACA, Michelle Phillips will be taking the lead
on the disparity study response
with support from Interim Director Laurel Bosel from Tufts.
See, we also know that that is a large umbrella
of things that need to be worked on
with the findings from the disparity study.
And so what you're, so both of those two folks
are gonna be working on like the whole bucket.
Correct.
And then the other question that I had from the report.
Just kind of curious as I was looking at the table,
are we able, and this question is to our Finance Director,
are you able to identify, you know, what change occurred?
Like when I'm looking at the number of interest payments
and you just kind of watch it grow over the years,
do you know what specifically contributed
to that shift and change?
Like did we change our process internally
or there was staff transition?
It's the first table where you see like in 2022,
there was only 167 interest payments.
And then in 2023, you see this huge shift up
And it kind of like, there's these ebbs and flows
and I'm just curious, like are we,
have we been able to identify why things have,
we're shifting and changing?
Through the chair to council member Brown, there's no,
at least from the perspective of finance,
which collects us, is trying to collect this information
from the departments.
There's no clear trend that we're seeing
as to why that's necessarily happening.
I could speculate that some of it has to do with turnover
and staffing or changes during the pandemic.
I can also speculate that it may be tied
the cycles of how many contracts go out in particular years, but that would, again, mostly
be speculative at this point.
There is no really identifiable data-driven reason why they're going up and down.
The solutions at the margins are things that look like technology.
The solution in the long run is more direct and aggressive management and better procedures
and policies.
And so on with the current
Work that's being done in this space
has any technology been identified and we also heard from the
Speakers that how there's a gap in actually recording prompt payment for subcontractors
That's something that we are working to make sure that we are actually
capturing that that information
so the city's
ERP does not contain a comprehensive contract managing structure, like that's not a data
system that we have to comprehensive manage the contracts, the subs, the timements in
a way that's integrated with our financial system.
That does not exist on a technology basis.
We are exploring mechanisms to improve that technology.
We are also exploring mechanisms to provide E-checks, which at the margin will cut down
on time as well.
That's something that is on your way and is being progressing, and that is within finance
that we're working to do so that we don't have paper checks going out to vendors, and
that should reduce some amount of delay, but a lot of this requires technology solutions
and again integration of both the contracting software, or the information on the subs,
the scopes, and whatnot is included with financial information, and again we don't have a structure
that does that right now.
I see.
And then isn't it seat well?
Oh, go ahead.
If I may just add through the chair, we are exploring a partnership with Finance and Duas
for the B2G system which is a technical solution
that they've been implementing that does allow
for payment tracking for subcontractors
who are a part of this small
and local small business enterprise program.
I see, yeah, because my next follow-up question
as always is comparing other jurisdictions
and how they kind of manage the process
and then even at the state of California,
how do they manage ensuring that the state law
around prompt payment in the timeframe is actually met.
I don't have any comparables in this report right now.
I'm happy to ask, to look into that more,
to see if there are other local municipalities
that report similarly and have some more values.
Okay, thank you.
Thank you, Council Member Long is online.
I'll just make a brief statement in between.
After we hear from this body,
I will make the motion to hold this in committee.
I think there's a lot more work to be done.
I did not know that comes on the wrong way
of bringing an ordinance.
I would appreciate if you wanted to coordinate
with our office as we have ideas in the works as well.
So we're all on the same page.
I think it's great that this body
is certainly committed to not just hearing a report.
In fact, we've already kept this in committee two times,
and I think it's important that we keep this in committee
until we have some clear answers.
Staffing challenges and changes are certainly an issue
I'm concerned about, so I would love a follow-up update
on some of the steps being made if you are amenable
to doing that at the first finance meeting in January
or sometime in January, 26, perhaps.
Yeah, the city administration would be amenable to that.
I apologize, the new calendar has been published,
I just don't have it on hand yet.
Perfect, yep, that works.
Thank you, Council Member Wong-Ganangar.
Thank you, and thank you Chair Ramachandran
for identifying this item, I appreciate it.
I did wanna just underscore that we do need to see
a work plan to actually remedy all the issues
that all the public commentaries highlighted,
and I think that it's just important that we move beyond
an informational report and into an actual plan.
I think the other thing is I thought that the last time
we discussed this item that we had asked for a supplemental
to break out the compliance of payments,
especially to disadvantaged businesses.
And I am not seeing that.
I would need to check my notes,
but I could swear that that was a request
that either myself or another colleague made on this,
and so I don't see that in this current report.
And the other thing that I am just curious about
is can someone explain how I know
for the capital improvement projects,
this is one of the key departments
that continues to struggle with compliance
that's got a 54% compliance rate.
I it's my understanding that these are some of the larger contracts that the city issues out and yet
then when I look at table four, which is the
sort of the the interest
The amount of payments that the city is owed due to the interest it's only 29 000
For the total house. How is that possible to both have such a low compliance rate?
Have large contracts and also have the penalty be that low
was that was that a question to the department that is a some comments and
then that last one is a question to the department understood so to try to
answer the question from Councilman Wong I think I heard why is why are the CIP
project or the CIP related items a high value number in terms of non-compliance
It may be that there are a lot because of there's a window for this, there may be lots of contracts that are moving a day or two past the compliance policy, but because interest rates accrue based on the number of days, it may just be that there's a high number of these.
interest rates accrue based on the number of days.
It may just be that there's a high number of these that are going a little bit non-compliant,
which will drive a high non-compliance rate but not necessarily a high dollar value.
That may be what's occurring there.
I'm not particularly sure if that's what is happening, but happy to look into that further.
And if there's a, I think I heard a request to break down the contents of Attachment A,
provides the list of vendors by non-compliance and to separate them by
local small local and other I think was the request and I think we can provide
that in the next supplemental report when this returns. Okay great thank you.
Council Member Unger. So it strikes me that our failure to pay promptly falls into two
And I want to go back to the
two categories.
The first is subs.
And is it the right way for us
to be responsible for prompt
payment of subs or should we
somehow get the primes to have
more responsibility there?
Through the chair to council
Merengar, my recommendation to
be that we explore changes to
our contracting templates and
our contract rules that require
to be paying because a prime vendor refuses to remit payment to the subcontractors, and
that will require a structure by which we can routinely track whether or not those prime
contractors are compliant in that process, and that is, again, I think part of what Duest
and now ACA, Phillips, are working on in terms of ensuring that we have the software systems
to make sure we can manage it, and to ensure that we have the, we do the compliance activities
with the actual departments, because it's a management element as well.
And the second sort of bucket of failure, I think, would be outside of even the 96-4,
which is that people are allowed to start work without a signed contract, or they don't
understand all of the processes to get paid.
And so, even though they're not included in that, you know, 4%, they feel that they aren't
being paid on time.
How do we improve the process to make it more clear what people need to do in order to get
paid, and how do we not let people work without signed contracts?
I'm going to take the second of those first.
It is not acceptable that the city of Oakland is directing work without a contract instrument.
it's not an acceptable practice,
it is one that we have been moving aggressively to stop.
It's not appropriate, it puts the city at risk,
it puts the local or non-local vendor at risk as well.
It's not an appropriate practice.
It means that we haven't completed information
regarding insurance and a number of other things
that might be legally required.
Departments should not be directing work to vendors
prior to having a contract instrument.
And to your point, yes, at the time
that we establish a contract, we should be very clear
about what the processes are,
based on that contract instrument for receiving payment,
and then we need to hold the departmental staff accountable
for ensuring that when those invoices are admitted,
they are properly paid on time.
To the first part of that, I'll just note,
obviously, the other piece is we need to make
our contracting practices easier for our vendors
to be able to get into contract with the city,
and so trying to look at, you know,
What are we asking them for insurance requirements,
making that easier for a staff to understand as well?
And then how many times are we asking them to sign
the schedules instead of just having them sign the contract
and having that integrated in the contract body?
Thank you.
Councillor Wong, no?
Oh, sorry, that was a rub in hand.
Okay, great.
I think if my colleagues can be adjourned
councilmember Hueso speak I'll make a motion to adjourn to a special meeting
thank you due to the presence of councilmember Houston a quorum of the
city council was noted and a motion made by councilmember sorry chair Ramachandran
seconded by councilmember Brown to adjourn the finance and management
committee meeting and convene as a special meeting of the full council at
at 11.01 AM.
On roll, council members, Brown?
Aye.
Unger?
Aye.
Wong?
Aye.
And Chair Ramachandran?
Aye.
Thank you, motion passes with four ayes.
Thank you, this is a very, very important item.
And I always speak and say this,
when I have experience, that's when I can speak to it.
We've been talking about this for 15 or 20 years,
same thing when I was a contractor and I'm so glad this is brought up and I'm
so glad everyone came out here to speak on it and I had to go up to another
meeting but I just want to be say something but I don't want to repeat
what others said the contractors the primes when they get paid they're
supposed to pay within 15 to 20 days so the contract that the city should have
just just from my personal experience the prime should be the ones that have
have to be responsible.
We should have that in our documents to pay
because let me tell you, let me share this with you,
Council Member Unter.
When I was a contractor, I've seen contractors
and you can speak to them out here
that didn't get paid for a whole year.
Subs, that's brutal.
When you got payroll, you got insurance.
So I'm just happy, that's why I came down here
because I had personal experience with this.
So I'm so glad this is finally coming to put some teeth
it because it's never really had teeth and I'm gonna say it one more time we've
been talking about this for 15 20 years the same thing so I'm glad my
colleagues and I love working with my colleagues and I'm just so glad you guys
are addressing this and listen to the voices because everyone out here they
have experience all right I just wanted to share that with you so thank you so
Thank you so much.
Thank you, Councillor Hee-Shee.
Councillor Unger?
Okay.
Do we have a motion, a second?
Okay.
If anyone is...
The motion was to hold in committee and hear it again in the January 28th, 26th Finance
Committee meeting for updates.
And for clarity, I believe that also included the request for additional information from
Councilmember Wong and the purpose of holding it in committee I understand is
to have an update on the status of legislation moving forward. If there's
any other requests we should put them on the record now. Yes for me the update
would be an understanding of staffing the issue not staffing issue an
understanding of because we can write all the legislation we want we need we
we need compliance to be impacted with what we have right now.
So to understand what the city administration and DUS are and finance are collectively doing
to manage compliance activity and relevant software purchases.
Councilmember Brown.
And I would add to that legislative update and timeline, right, and so I know we heard
councilmember Unger is working I believe just on a singular piece of the issue and we know that
the entire umbrella of issues addressed in the disparity study is broader and so I would like an
update on the legislative timeline and implementation as well if that makes sense. And just a point of
clarification so you would like that as part of the continued supplemental report as instead of us
bringing legislation? I think it's both and. Okay. Because the legislation is
gonna come from Councilmember Unger, specifically on what he's working on, and
so what I'm hearing from my colleagues is that there's still multiple gaps. Yeah,
we can bring the administrative component. And I also recognize that by
January date, you're not gonna have the whole, it's not, it may not be ready
legislatively, but there could be a timeline that says, hey we've identified
XY and Z and this is what we're working on. I think that that's a part of my
expectation. That's something we can meet. We've been working on it for some time.
Okay. And so that's my second. And to clarify my ask for additional information,
it's also an understanding of the work plan to be in full compliance. Sorry, it's the
work plan for the disparity study because that was presented. Okay, just
I just wanted to make sure I'm clear,
because that's also being heard at LAC.
No, for the, for the, for the administration compliance,
for the contracting improvement, absolutely.
And I'm happy to send my questions and notes
over via email, too.
Okay, before seeing the record, just to clarify,
we have a motion made by Chair Ramachand
and by Councilmember Brown to continue this item
to the January 26th, 2027 Finance and Management Committee
with the request of staff to provide
in a supplemental report the understanding
of what the city administrator and the West and finance
are collectively doing to manage compliance activity
and relevant software purchase,
the legislative timeline and implementation
and the understanding of the work plan
that was referenced to be in full compliance activity
for the contracting improvement.
Am I missing anything else?
Okay, on roll, Council Members Brown?
Aye.
Unger?
Aye.
And Chair Ramachandran?
Aye.
Thank you, motion passes with four ayes
to continue this item to the January 26, 2027
Finance and Management Committee agenda.
Going back to the order of the agenda today,
reading in item number five,
receive an informational report regarding
of the annual equal access to services ordinance
compliance report for fiscal year 2025 to 26
and we have three speakers on this item.
And just to the chair, I wanna identify
that item six is more time sensitive,
but we are happy to make both reports brief.
Let's see if we can be brief on both.
We'll try to get through them quickly.
Good morning chair members of the committee.
Andrea Mariano, acting human resources director
of the Human Resources Management Department.
Today, we would like to present our equal access annual report
among another item to the committee.
And we do this report every year to really look
at our language access.
Equal access is one of the first of its kind in the country
and has really led the work in language access and equity.
The purpose of the report is to make sure
in the city.
We are trying to make sure that
we are holding those high
standards in closing language
equity gaps throughout our
service models in the city here
to present that report will be
made town and then I'll come up
in how many minutes will you
require we are trying to close
out by eleven thirty for the
next minute five.
Five per item with two yeah if
it could be shorter.
and members of the committee, my name is Mei Tam.
I'm a program analyst of the Equal Access Program,
and we are part of the Human Resources Management Department.
So today we have an information report in front of you.
We do come here every year.
I will quickly go through and highlight some of the items
on this report.
This report serves as a city administrator
and new compliance plan and report
on the implementation of the equal access
to services ordinance for the period of July 1, 2025
through June 30th, 2026.
On page two, you will see a snapshot
on the compliance status.
Oakland has a high population of non-English speaker.
Per census data, 42% of our residents
speak a non-English language at home.
And other than English, Spanish is the most popular language
in Oakland, followed by Chinese as the second most popular
non-English language here in the city.
So the city has about 3000 public contact position employees
and among them about 600 of them are bilingual.
Following along on the report,
on the information report page three provides some definitions
in terms of which language groups we look at.
The ordinance call for a threshold language group,
meaning over 10,000 of Oakland residents
speaks a shared language,
that language group will be considered
as threshold language group.
So we identified them on this report for you annually.
On page four, you do see chart number three.
It identified the 10,000 resident threshold language group
for you, and also the 1,000 language group for you.
Down below on page four, it has a chart, chart four.
So the goal for the city to hire
certain number of bilingual employees,
and we look at census data as the basis.
So the total for Spanish and Chinese combined is 14%.
city of Oakland for last fiscal year achieved 19%.
So we have exceeded the threshold goal
overall here in the city.
Page five is a chart for all the data
spread out between departments.
Overall the city meet the minimum goal,
but it varies between departments.
Some departments hire more bilingual staff
versus some other departments
and the detail is provided in chart five.
We work with several language partners.
Our unit is very small, only two staff, including myself,
but we do contract with five different language companies
to bring in service to the city,
and we service all departments here in the city.
Each of our service providers can provide
and cover over 100 languages.
So that information is on page six.
In addition to some of the services
that we internally provide,
and also the contracted vendors provide,
The city has a robust training program.
All city employees, when they come in,
they are required to go through
the mandatory new employee orientation
and they will receive resources
and training on language access as well.
As a conclusion, equal access to services ordinance
was enacted to provide equal access to city services
for all city residents,
including those with limited proficiency in English.
The language access policy requires city departments
provide access without regard to race, national origin, or ethnic group. Since 42% of Auckland
residents speak a non-English language at home, the support of the Equal Access Office is crucial
in closing gaps in access to services and information provided by the city to all residents.
We recommend this committee and the City Council receive this information report that covers last
year which is 2025 to 2026. Thank you, colleagues any questions? Okay we can move to public speakers. Calling in the names
I sign up to speak on item five Kevin Dalley, Blair Beekman, and Mrs. Sato
Olavala. Okay and Mrs. Sato Olavala it's not a chamber chair that concludes all
Okay. I will entertain a motion to move this. Oh go ahead, Council Member Wong.
Hi. Yes. Thank you for this item. I have just a couple of questions. One thing I would
love to see in a future report, just when it comes to some of these charts, actually
the Delta, one thing that I actually noticed just by doing a quick comparison of last year's
to equal access report is that while we've had some progress
in some areas that it looks like,
I'm not sure what's going on with the Parks
and Recreation Department, but last year,
in terms of the Spanish-speaking public contact positions,
we were at 37%, and this year we're down to 9%.
So that's pretty alarming to me.
That's an alarming difference,
And I would like to understand what is happening there
in the Parks and Recreation Department.
Did we use a lot of staff members
of Spanish-speaking capabilities?
But I think those deltas are important for us to see.
Do you have any insight into that specific trend?
Thank you for the question.
I think last year was 10 years
since we have the AI-introduced administrative instruction.
we included some trends in the last report,
and we did not include it in this report
because last year is a special year.
We could come back next time when we do our next report
at the end of the fiscal year to do more charts
on the trending so we can compare data between the years.
Today, we also have members from the OPR,
Parks and Recreation Department,
and maybe they can provide additional information as well.
Good morning, Chair Maturandra and members of the committee.
My name is Sarah Herblin, Assistant Director
for Oakland Parks, Recreation and Youth Development.
The reason for that very large change
is how things are reported.
Oakland Parks, Recreation and Youth Development
has a large number of temporary part-time staff members.
In previous reports, the total FTE for the department,
which is around 290, was used as the base.
and then we counted the number of staff,
temporary part-time and full-time,
who had languages and did the math that way.
However, since many temporary part-time staff members
share a single FTE because they're not full-time employees,
that was an over-representation,
as you saw in previous year's data,
of our actual percentage of compliance.
So this year, I took the actual number of employees
who are public contact, and we looked at the actual number
of employees who speak the threshold languages,
and we did the math that way.
So it's a little bit more accurate to representing
the actual percentage of our staff who are available,
as opposed to taking individuals and dividing by FDEs.
Okay, thanks, that's super helpful,
and I think data accuracy is incredibly important,
and, you know, not to claim, you know, undue credit.
So thank you for your thoughtfulness
in doing that, and that helps explain it.
And then I think just in general,
I think one thing that I've noticed,
I've had my own staff just sort of call various hotlines
to see if, you know, the hotlines,
especially public facing ones are available
in different languages, and we've seen a number
them not have messages, availability in other languages. And I think something for example
like macro is something that needs to have, you know, languages, messages that are left
in those other languages.
Thank you for the comment. If anybody, any department staff notice any phone line that
you need multilingual messages and it's not done, just let me know, give us the script
and we'll create it for you. It's pretty quick.
okay thank you I know with only two people doing this work thanks for
everything that you working push this agenda within this day.
Councilmember Brown.
Okay I wanted to make a motion to move the item.
To the next council meeting on consent?
Absolutely.
I second it.
Thank you we have a motion made by Councilmember Brown seconded by Chair
Ramachandran to receive and forward this item to the December 1st City Council
council agenda on consent on role council members. Brown. Aye. Unger. Aye. Wong. Aye.
And chair Ramachandran. Aye. Thank you motion. Sorry item five passes with four ayes to receive
and forward this item to the December 1st City Council agenda on consent. Reading in
item number six adopts a resolution authorizing the city administrator to amend the professional
services agreement with international contract contact Inc and accent on
languages Inc to increase each agreement by four four hundred thousand dollars
for a total not to exceed amount of six hundred fifty thousand dollars per
agreement and extending each term by three years and we have three speakers
on this item our second item is to expand that contract amount for our
translation services while those amounts are really used me will explain how it
It is important to have them readily available immediately for emergency services, unexpected
community outreach events, and planned.
Good morning again.
My name is May Tam again.
I'm with the Human Resources Management Department, and in front of you I do have an agenda report
and also a resolution.
So this is a resolution to amend professional services contract with two contractors with
international contact ink and accent on languages ink to increase each agreement by $400,000
for a total, not to exceed amount of $650,000 per agreement and extending each term by three
years. Basically two vendors, they have the same scope of service as they provide translation
interpretation and bilingual testing service to the city. Both of them, we want to increase
the contract or extend the contract for three years and as a result the dollar is increased
as well.
In the background section you will see that both of these contracts were created through
a formal request for proposals, RFP, for on-call services.
So we do not have to commit the full payment, these are on-call services.
We call them as needed basis and the RFP is intended for five years with renewal provision.
We begin aborting them two years term, now we're coming back to make it the full five
years.
The original intent is five years, but we don't want to over commit and we want to see
how services go first before we commit to the five years term.
So both of the vendors are minority-owned small business enterprises and they have experience
providing service in the area.
They have the ability to provide American Translator Association accredited translators,
are also equipped to provide bilingual testing services as well. So approving this resolution
will enable the city to continue service to the community. Again, the work is to be
performed on as needed basis upon request by the city. So increasing the contract cap
as proposed does not itself obligate funds, but we do intentionally create a bigger gap
so that the city will have the ability to respond
to emergency situations, disaster situations,
or in the case we have to quickly provide the public
with information that we can really tap on the contract
and have services right away, you know,
same day or next day rather than coming back
and creating another contract.
Again, language access policies require city departments
to provide equal access to services without regard
to race, national origin, or ethnic groups.
Since 42% of Oakland residents speak a non-English language
at home, the support for this service is crucial
in closing the gaps in access to services
and information for all residents.
Today, we recommend that the committee
and the city council adopt this resolution
to amend this professional service contracts,
and I'm available to answer any questions.
Thank you.
Excellent.
Thank you so much for the report.
Always grateful when the fun,
which one is coming from is added to the reports
so that we can see that.
Page three of the report states,
a bigger cap would enable the city's resources
to respond to emergencies and disasters promptly,
especially with all the preparation
that the city is doing as it relates to El Nino
and other disaster preparedness work.
And so I'll make a motion to move the item.
Thank you.
Council member Wong.
Thank you for this item and yeah,
I just wanna echo Council Member Brown's comments.
That's really important.
One thing I was just wondering,
does this contract or do we have a separate effort
underway to ensure that our 311 system is multilingual?
I will say that is one system that I really,
really think we need to bring in
some multilingual capabilities.
incredibly noticeable to me when I look at the 311 report with so many of our
departments rely on that I am NOT seeing the same volume of 311 reports in our
areas where there are more LEP individuals and it really affects the
service delivery across the department and it's inequitable. So anyways, yeah is
that being achieved through either this contract or some other efforts?
I'll quickly respond to that.
So the city do have over the phone interpretation service, which is available to all departments.
Each department have their own dial-in number and PIN number, so each department should
be able to disseminate that information among the staff, and staff should be able to call
the line.
In the connection time to reach an interpreter, typically for popular languages like Spanish
and Chinese, it's less than 10 seconds.
So if you need service, call the number, you get an interpreter on the phone with you,
And nowadays you can even get the interpreters on Zoom or Teams with you as long as you provide
the connection number.
So these services are very valuable to the city and they do build a city per minute basis
so it's very cost efficient.
We do provide that information on our training to new employees as they come to the city
and through the years we also do trainings as well.
I understand maybe not all city employees have that information.
We will create another round of training this year.
Thank you for the comment.
in. Sorry, just to make sure, so this applies to the 311 hotline, and I'm also talking about
the app. The app, I definitely see is not, right now does not have multilingual capacity.
So the 311 center, the unit, the staff have access to that line. I do not have on hand
how exactly staff use that line, but 311 staff do have access to that line and we have seen
them use that line. I understand city have different subcontractor services
online portal services some portal allows the city to launch multilingual
versions some portals do not so if you're talking about the online version
it really needs the departments to look into it to see if the carrier or the
administrator have the ability to include the bilingual system into it.
Thank you. We have a motion. Do we have a second? I'll second it. I'll second that.
Oh, Councilmember Longo will second it, yes. Moving to public speaker, calling in the
name to sign up to speak on item 6, Mrs. Asada Ollabala, David Boatwright and Blair
Beekman. I can almost say this is a joke. You don't really offer true
opportunities for people who speak languages to participate in the
governance of this city. I go to school board meetings. They have the equipment in
the back of the room for translation. They have the agendas in Spanish and I
think Mandarin. They have, before the beginning of the meeting, interpreters.
anybody that needs Mandarin, Arab, Hmong, Spanish, raise your hand. You don't have
nothing. You don't have nothing. That's just an example. You're spending all this
money and you're underserving because I see people in another public governance
setting being served for language. And I don't know because I left a room because
is always insulting to even have something that says equal access when you don't offer
equal access in any other arena, particularly if you are a citizen. You say in your documents,
being a citizen is not a component that you consider when offering services and resources
in this city. But you pick one entity, language, we gotta have equal access. Then you say,
who needs to, you gotta survey. How do you get the survey? You come into the office to
get the survey. You don't know, you don't know who is in this city. They say it's 40-something
percent of people speak another language in their home. How do you know that? Y'all just
pick up stuff off the top of your head. There is no valid data that supports anything related
to language thank you for your comments miss olivala chair that includes all
speakers on this item and we do have a motion made by councilmember Brown
seconded by councilmember Wong to approve the recommendations of staff and
to forward this item to the December 1st City Council agenda on consent on role
council members Brown hi younger hi Wong councilmember Wong hi thank you
sorry thank you and chair Ramachandran hi thank you motion passes with four eyes
to forward this item to the December 1st City Council agenda on consent. Moving
on to open forum calling in the names that signed up to speak. David Boatwright,
Kevin Dalley, Asada Ollabala, and Blair Beckman. Kevin Dalley, I'll bring up this
topic again. The way that you sign up to speak in City Council meetings is
designed to discourage speaking, and I think the Council has chosen to do that.
In order to sign up online, you have to click on multiple buttons more than 24 hours in
advance, but once you're in the last 24 hours, it is not possible to go to the website and
look up what you have chosen to speak for.
You can go through e-mails, but that's not easy to do either.
The clerk does have access to that information, and frequently I really appreciate the clerk
that they have shared with me what I've signed up for
and noticed when I screw up and missed something.
Today I was a bit late, didn't have it happen.
What I'd like the council members to do next meeting,
pretend that you're just a resident,
sign up to speak ahead of time.
Figure out whether it is, figure out whether you did it,
check in with you next week.
We had a discussion on parking,
and I just want to share with you
some of the proposed initiatives
that are going on around parking.
You have the Lake Merritt,
and you should be getting some feedback
on what has happened
with the Lake Merritt parking meter pilot program,
because you instituted a meter system around the lake
with the intent that you're gonna make more money.
So let's get a report.
Is it happening?
We have the Oakland Chinatown load and parking pilot program.
We have the Montclair demand response parking meter program,
the transit funding program, the fine and pay for parking
Oak Park.
We've got a whole lot of programs
that are related to parking with the incentive that it's
going to increase more funding. So when you're going to get those reports I don't know.
Thank you for your comments Ms. Ollabala-Cherd, all names have been called.
Thank you, this meeting is adjourned.