We're going to call them to the dais.
Good afternoon.
As it is 11 43 and we would like to begin the meeting,
can we have all council members to the dais so we can begin?
Good afternoon and welcome, excuse me, it's still morning.
Good morning and welcome to the Public Works
and Transportation Committee meeting on this Tuesday,
November 17th.
The time is 11 43 and this meeting shall come to order.
before I call roll up I'd like to give instructions on how to submit a speaker card for items on this agenda if
You're here in person and would like to submit a speaker card
Please fill out a card and turn it into a clerk representative either
Ten minutes after this being began or before the item is read into record whichever comes first
Online speaker card submission were due 24 hours before this meeting begins
So we will no longer be accepting speaker cards online
But again if you are here in person and would like to submit a speaker card
the meeting started or. The two
and Chair Onger.
I'm here.
Thank you so much.
And I do show that Councilmember Walg
is participating via Zoom.
City Attorney, do they need to make an announcement
while participating remotely?
Councilmember Walg, can you please state for the record
while you're participating remotely?
And if there are anyone 18 and over in the room, or, yes.
yes.
Okay and you would also need to turn on your camera is that correct? Yes when
participating remotely. Yes thank you so much see you. So with that we have four
members present again the meeting beginning 1143 we will now go to in the
order of the agenda unless the chair has announcements. Great. We will now move on
to item one which would normally be your minutes but we have no minutes to
this is a special meeting.
We will now move to item two.
Determination of scheduled
outstanding committee items,
which is also known as your pending
list and I have one speaker for this item.
Uh, do you all have anything
for the pending list?
No changes from the
administration at this time.
Thank you.
OK, let's hear our speaker, please.
Thank you so much.
I have missus out of Alabama
for item number two.
Yesterday, the park and
Recreation Advisory Committee met.
on the agenda was the review of a document called the Park Assess Inventory and Condition
Assessment, 373 pages, that looked at all the parks that you had. It made some identification
of safety and hazard issues at these parks. It looked at graffiti and vandalism. It looked
that many issues, there's some recommendations that were in this document. One of them said
that the city needs to do a comprehensive assessment of the Americans Disability Act
compliance. We out of compliance in many parks. So when is this document going to come to
this violence? They did it yesterday, so I think it's essential that this document comes
I'm wondering and I look at their agenda and there are things on their agenda that this
body doesn't review.
You don't have any time up there baby but I'm gonna stop right now.
You still have 48 seconds.
Okay.
Apologies.
Our stuff.
Thank you so much.
And that concludes your speakers for item two on this.
Councilmember Gail.
And an update and where are we with waste management to give us because we have many
new council people here that don't know the history behind our relationship, our contract
with waste management. So what I'm asking is that not only that we present, where are
we with waste management in terms of our contract? Secondly, where are we with California waste
solutions? And the other one that I see on the street, because we're out there cleaning
the streets every day, the other one, you have a civic core, driving around in their
trucks and sometimes I just see them as cruising around the neighborhood, at least in my district.
So what I'd like to do is get a staff report. Where are we with waste management? But also
where are we with the franchise fee that we ask waste management to collect from the taxpayer
$35 million a year? How are we investing that money? Because if you look throughout the
state of California and the country, you're not gonna find cities asking your
waste management to collate an additional franchise fee that the
voters never approved for years ago, but yet they're collecting it. And where is
the city investing that 35, 36 million dollars that I am paying as a taxpayer
for my picking up my garbage and extra fee. And so anyway, so what I'd like to do
considering the council members are practically new,
don't have the background and the history
since we're gonna be negotiating
these contracts real soon.
One is give us an update on waste management
and what is the current contract.
And secondly, what is our current contract
with California Waste Solutions
since they're in court every day,
singling things out.
And other groups on the sideline like Civic Corps
that are out there in the neighborhoods,
some neighborhoods picking up the trash as well.
So at least in public works,
we all have that background information
and know be prepared for what the future agendas
are gonna be calling for.
And, but anyways, so those are three requests
that I would like to have scheduled for this council
to have knowledge and understanding
of what it is the real role of public works
in the city of Oakland.
And so with that, hopefully we can schedule those items and have them come back as soon
as possible to move forward.
Thank you.
Okay.
We would be happy to support you with bringing those motions for information and requests
through the rules committee.
And thank you.
I'm also going to work with you offline to do the updates.
Do we have a motion yet?
make the motion for the. For this item. It was a motion by
council chair. I apologize it sounds like comes with a long
for you. We already have a motion in a second where you
stayed. All right so we have a motion by council member
others seconded by council member Houston to approve item
two as is on roll council member guy on. Houston I long.
I will take the roll.
I and chair under I item number
two is approved with four ayes
to be approved as is now moving
to our next item item number
three and number three is a
resolution amending the city
council resolution number nine
one zero nine two CMS
authorizing the city to accept
an appropriate loan and grant
funds under the state of
the program for the 285 12th Street project and the amount not to exceed $35,873 and $35,873,066
and I have one speaker for this item.
Thank you.
All right let's hear from our staff first please.
Great thank you.
I'm Emily Ellers with the Department of Transportation.
resolution amends a resolution that was passed by this council in March 2026
it's a technical amendment it changes the legal name of the state
affordable housing loan recipient the total award the city's funding and the
project is unchanged but because the original resolution named the payees the
state now requires an amended resolution before releasing the funds so the
The original loan payee named in the application was 285 12th Street LP.
Since that time 285 12th Street LP has changed to 285 Development LP, a California limited
partnership affiliated with the East Bay Asian Local Development Corporation or a bald sea.
The total AHSC program loan amount remains the same, about 20.4 million, as well as the
funding for the three city projects, about 14 million.
that that concludes my presentation I'm happy to answer any questions you may
have all right let's hear from any of my council colleagues no all right let's
hear from the public speakers I have mrs. Sala Obala for item number three so
this is an item that is 35.8 million dollars and nobody have nothing to say
You don't have any concerns or issues related to how this housing project.
Now understand that this is a project that will eventually result in two housing developments,
$184,000 of affordable unit, is that right?
No, no, you can't say nothing, you can say it like this, no, or yes.
Okay, so knowing that this is a project for housing,
knowing the amount of housing that would be available,
does anybody know where this housing is gonna be?
And does anybody wanna speak to who will be able
to access this housing and who is a developer?
Are there any impacts, anything?
But nobody has nothing to say.
Okay, I just have an opportunity to say this.
You get a chance to choose who is funding,
who's gonna get the money.
So do you wanna know who's getting the money
for this project?
I get so confused sometimes when I do a lot of work
to write down a lot of stuff
And you guys don't have any questions.
Okay, so I'm gonna just listen
and see if y'all have anything else to say.
About this $35.8 million for housing.
Thank you so much for your comments.
That concludes our speakers for this item.
I believe council member Wong has her hand raised
in cyberspace.
Yes, I do.
Thanks to the chair.
So this project is actually in district
First of all, thank you to the staff for your hard work on this and it sounds like this
is mostly a technical update.
One thing I just wanted to clarify it sounds like, just understand why this is coming before
the transportation, Public Works and Transportation Committee, even though a substantial portion
of this grant funding is going to abolish the Affordable Housing Development is because
there is a supplemental component which is really transforming the street
around with this portable housing development, correct? Does this work? Okay, yeah,
through the chair, that's absolutely correct. The affordable housing
sustainable community strategy is a grant and loan program, so it's it
provides funding for affordable housing, in this case a loan to Ibalzi of about
twenty million dollars, and it really tries to prioritize housing that's near
transportation options so it also funds grant money for the city to deliver
transportation projects and in this case we got about 14 million dollars to build
three partially funds three projects near the affordable housing site so the
projects need to be within a mile of the affordable housing site in this case the
grant funding the HSC grant funding that the Department of Transportation is
managing is funding the 7th Street connection project in West Oakland the
MLK complete streets project kind of West Oakland downtown border and then the Broadway transit project
Okay
So much and I'll make a motion to approve staff recommendation
Okay, we've got councilmember Houston IRL and then no algaio after that
Miss Emily just wanted to know this came to council 320 correct and just for the public is
the only reason why this is coming back is because of this name change is that the only reason okay because I want the
public to understand because sometimes they don't understand this wouldn't it came back if
The name change now I got a question
With the name change does this change any of the agreements terms and deliverables? I just want the public to know mr. Emily
The reason we're here is that
Loan payee name changed from 285 12th Street LP to 285
Development LP. It's just the name change nothing about the loan terms the projects nothing about the terms of the agreement change and
The state is requiring us to come back to council with an adopted resolution that changes the name
Before they'll execute the agreements. Okay through the chair
So the only reason why you're back right now is because of the name change. Yes. Okay. Thank you
Councilmember gayo this information how many units are we projecting for the
development I believe this particular site delivers 65 affordable housing
units how many 65 55 6 5 6 5 yep we were awarded to hsc grants one for this
project another for a different project liberation park on 73rd Avenue
combined equaled the 168 units referenced in the report and the
timeline for the completion of development is I can't speak to that
but we can follow up with planning and building and HCD I believe it's under
construction now okay and it's affordable housing low-income affordable
housing yes thank you I'll give this a second if we don't have one yet no
there's no second there was a there's a motion by councilmember long seconded by
councilmember guy oh to approve item three to be forwarded to the December 1st City Council agenda on roll councilmember guy oh
Councilmember Houston. I won
I
chair unger I
Item number three is approved with four eyes to be forwarded to the December 1st City Council agenda and that would be on consent
Yes, please consent. Thank you so much. We will now move to item four
Item 4 is a resolution awarding a construction contract to OC Jones and Sons Inc. for the Embarcadero West Rail Safety Project
Phase 1 number 1007091 the lowest responsible and responsive bidder in accordance with the project plans
specification state requirements and with the contractors bid in the amount of
15 million two hundred and forty thousand five hundred eighty six dollars and ninety-eight cents
authorizing the city administrator to approve and execute
Change order to construction contract up to twenty five percent on the original contract award amount and
Adopting CEQA findings. I have two speakers for this item. Thank you. That's great. Thank you. Let's hear from our staff first
Good morning council members. My name is Audrey Harris supervising transportation planner with the Department of Transportation
Today I'm here on behalf of our team
To request that you consider the resolution awarding a construction contract
for the Embarcadero West Rail Safety and Improvements Project to OC Jones & Sons, Incorporated, the lowest responsible and
responsive bidder.
The Embarcadero West Corridor is a one-mile segment in the Jack London neighborhood of Oakland where freight and passenger rail
cars, people on bikes, and pedestrians all share the same space with no physical separation from the railroad tracks. On
On average, about 65 trains use this corridor daily
with reported incidents occurring approximately
once every five days, on average,
contributing to people and goods movement delays.
This project is a part of a series.
Today before you is phase one.
The project will improve rail safety
by modernizing the crossings at Market Street and Oak Street
with new gate arms, high visibility crosswalks,
sidewalk improvements, safety lighting,
and a new traffic signal at Oak Street
with rail preemption to be responsive to approaching trains.
The project will also upgrade
an overweight vehicle railroad crossing and route
to heavyweight standards on the Embarcadero West Corridor
between Middle Harbor Road and Market Street
to safely accommodate permitted
overweight trucks accessing the port.
Once construction is done on this element,
This will eliminate the current overweight vehicle route
that is currently on 7th Street through West Oakland.
Additionally, the project will construct
protected bike lanes on Embarcadero West
between Oak Street and Alla Street,
connect people to the Bay Trail along the waterfront
and on Oak Street between 3rd and Embarcadero West
to connect people to the two-way cycle track
that is currently under construction
by the county's Oakland Alameda Access Project.
And finally, the project will install
comprehensive wayfinding signage in the project area
to provide direction for people navigating the space
to local and regional transit opportunities
and parking facilities.
With an authorization to award this contract
by full city council in December,
we anticipate the construction to start in spring 2027
with a completion in 2029.
The project is fully funded by state grant funding
from the Trade Corridor Enhancement Program,
where these funds are specifically designated
to improve infrastructure on high-volume freight
and trade corridors.
The project was advertised in July,
and in September, the city received five bids
for the project through a competitive bidding process.
In alignment with the city's small, local,
and local business enterprise program,
Bid discounts were offered to encourage local participation.
And after the application of these bid discounts,
OC Jones and Sons Incorporated emerged
as the lowest responsible and responsive bidder
with a bid of 15.2 million,
which is approximately 35% below the engineer's estimate.
Staff recommends the City Council award this contract
to OC Jones and Sons Incorporated,
a company located in Oakland to advance construction
on these critical safety and access improvements.
That concludes my presentation.
Thank you for your consideration.
I'm available for questions.
All right, council colleagues, council member Houston.
Yes, thank you, Ms. Harris.
Question, this is 100% state for state funding, correct?
That is correct.
Okay, and change orders are 25%, right?
comes in like 3 million eight hundred ten thousand one forty six point seventy
five right okay so with saying that if they do go and reach that amount of
change orders where does that money come from where does that money come does it
come from BB does it come from other grants where does that money come from
and is it any I'm asking another question and see if you could put them
together. If that money comes from another source where we could be using
that money for something in the city, is it any way possible to add that into the
grant funding so it won't take money from another project? To answer the first
question, this project is a part of a series of improvements through the
Embarcadero rest rail safety and access improvements, which is largely in part
funded by state other state grant funding through the California State
Transportation Agency and so in the case that we do reach that capacity this
project does have those funds available to it and to answer the last question we
wouldn't need to take away from another project if another city project if we
had to incur that maximum amount. Through the chair you would or you wouldn't? We
would not need to take away. You would not. Oh, that's good news. So again, one more,
just last question, where would that $3,810,000 come from? If they do go 25% change order.
That funding would come from 100% state grant funding through the California Transportation
Agency. The change orders? Yes. Cool. All right, thank you. We've got Councilmember
Wong in the queue and then we'll go to Councilmember Gayle.
Thank you. So this project is in both in my district as well as council member five district.
So this is a really important project. I will say that one thing I hear from rail stakeholders
is especially around bike lanes in some of these sort of rail corridors in Jack London
and that sometimes that bike lanes are being recommended
to be placed in areas that actually collide
with some of the rail and heavy freight traffic,
I was wondering, has there been engagement done
with the port and rail stakeholders to ensure
that there is not going to be a conflict of interest here?
And I'm all for bike lanes.
I just do agree that maybe placing bike lanes in areas
which could create dangerous conditions for both riders
as well as our heavy freight.
And that traffic isn't, shouldn't be in the same corridor.
Has that been done?
Yes, coordination that has been,
we've been coordinating with the Port of Oakland,
Union Pacific Railroad
and the California Public Utilities Commission
that all oversee different elements of this project.
The protected bike lanes on this project
specifically on Embarcadero West between Oak Street and Alla Street on the side
streets adjacent to the residential complex and the fence off area near the
Amtrak station and the designs and do ensure that vehicles and emergency
vehicles can navigate this space adjacent to the protected bike lane
element. And then the other segment of the protected bike facility is on
on Oak Street between Embarcadero West
going north up to Third Street
to connect to a 2B constructed two-way cycle facility.
And again, these designs have been intentionally coordinated
to ensure that vehicles and emergency vehicles
can navigate the space on the corridor itself
and making turns off and on it.
Okay, that's great.
And I don't know if this is within the, this is fact at all,
I have heard from the dialysis center
that some of the proposed bike lanes,
again, I'm not sure if it's exactly this project
or just related ones that I've heard,
including even just from some constituents
who use wheelchairs there that there is very much a need
for kind of an ADA accessible loading zone
in that there may have been some impact to their ability.
Since again, this is a dialysis center,
you have a lot of folks who are using wheelchairs
or otherwise disabled,
and that some of the projects in that area
were raising concern in that community.
So I do wanna see this happen,
but I also am hearing some concerns
and I just wanna make sure our address
as part of this project?
Through the chair, thank you Council Member Wong.
That area is a part of improvements
that'll come through a different project
called the Second Street Transportation Hub.
The team has coordinated with the dialysis center
to ensure that we're sharing our designs,
iterating on those designs to ensure
that we're enhancing the accessibility
at that segment on the Second Street
between Harrison and Alice,
specifically adding dedicated paratransit loading,
accessible passenger loading,
and ensuring that the corners at the two segments
have upgraded curb ramps that meet accessibility standards.
Okay, okay, good.
I will make a motion to accept that recommendation.
Councilmember Gaia, you might need to press your button.
What is the role of BCDC on this?
I mean, the extension of the trail, the Bay Trail, where is that going to continue to?
The project, the protected bike lanes through the project are an additional element connecting
people to the Bay Trail that exist along the Water Street segment of the corridor.
But it would be extended to what location?
We have two speakers for this item, Ms. Asala Olavala and Kevin Dalley, in any order?
Kevin Dalley, thanks for the opportunity to be here. I'm very happy to be here. Thank you.
Any other questions?
Okay, council member Houston, you good?
Speakers?
Yes, we have two speakers for this item, Ms. Asala Olavala and Kevin Dalley, in any order?
Kevin Dalley, thanks for the presentation.
I'm a cyclist, and for many, many years I regularly took the capital corridor from the
Jackland and train station to the South Bay, so I definitely appreciate the need for some
of these changes there were way too many fatalities and injuries related to the
train both in that area and in other areas there's problems so with with the
bike end of things there's the bikeway separation is not continuous these are
not trivial problems to solve but I am hoping that Oak dot will continue to
look at this, the bikeway separation is not continuous. Also, many bike riders have to
leave Clay Street to either turn on water or Second Street before the end of the protected
bike lane. Bikeways are often blocked, as they are now. It would be good to look at
other forms of traffic calming, possibly speed humps or cushions in the street in
addition to or instead of the bike lanes. If we can slow down the traffic, if I'm
hit by a car that moves 20-15 miles an hour, I'll be injured much less severely
than if they're traveling at a faster speed. So I think we do need more hard
traffic calming physical traffic calming in addition to what we can see
here thanks so this item is identified as phase one how many phases to this
and what is the total cost when all phases are in place the first thing I
what I want to recognize in the report is it says that the project will benefit a historically
under-invested neighborhood. So Embarcadero is an uninvested neighborhood. I mean we not
it's underserved. It's a community that's not getting attention. Why did y'all put that
in there? I don't know. Then when you look at the document as far as the breakdown of
what's gonna happen with this project phase one.
You're gonna improve safety and accessibility
in the corridor for surrounding neighbors and businesses.
You're gonna reduce travel time
for freight and passenger rail.
Do we have the ability and the jurisdiction
to create entities or spend money
for reducing the rail system?
I don't know how that's gonna happen.
How are you gonna reduce travel time
for freight and passenger rail?
I don't know.
You're gonna reconstruct so that truck routes rerouted
and you're going to direct heavy truck traffic
in alternative ways.
You're gonna deal with sidewalks,
you're gonna deal with crosswalks,
and you're going to expand transit opportunities.
that's a whole lot of stuff.
But I want to see the breakdown per item,
how much you intend to spend for each thing,
how much you're going to spend on the crosswalks,
how much you're going to spend on the sidewalks,
how much you're going to spend on the rerouting of trucks.
Thank you so much for your time, Mrs. Nye.
Okay, thank you.
All speakers have been called for this item.
Councilmember Houston, did you have something further?
Yeah, I just wanted to say that
With Mrs. Ababada said about underserved communities,
next time this money comes around,
can we trick a little bit of this down to D7?
Just putting it, that's why I'm going for this one,
because I want some of that money to come down to D7,
because we got some infrastructure down there
that needs to be really done,
that's been underserved for so many years.
I can go back 20 years, so thank you, Ms. Harris.
Thank you for your comments.
Having motion by Councilmember Wong,
And item number one, seconded by council member Gail to approve item four to be forwarded to the December 1st City Council on roll council member Gail?
Aye.
Council member Houston?
Aye.
Wong?
Aye.
And chair Unger?
Aye.
Item number four is approved with four ayes to be afforded to the December 1st City Council agenda on consent?
Yes please.
Correct.
Thank you so much.
We will now move to item number five.
resolution authorizing the city administrator to award and execute a professional services agreement which with
Hf nh consultant for a future solid waste
Franchising consulting services in the amount not to exceed one million one hundred and fourteen thousand eight hundred and sixty-eight dollars
appropriate two hundred thousand dollars from fund 1710 for fiscal year
AB262027 and adopting CEQA findings. I have two speakers for this item. Thank you. Okay. Let's hear from staff
All begin, okay, good afternoon
Chair and committee members. I'm Rebecca Parnes recycling program manager with Oakland Public Works
I'm happy to be with you today to present a proposed resolution
Authorizing a professional services agreement for future solid waste franchising consulting services. I
recommend the council adopt a resolution
Authorizing the city administrator to award and execute a professional services agreement with HF and H
Consultants for future solid waste franchising consulting services and amount not to exceed 1 million
one hundred fourteen thousand eight hundred and sixty eight dollars
Additionally, I recommend council resolve to appropriate
$200,000 from fund 1710 for fiscal year 2627 and
Make appropriate California Environmental Quality Act findings
The city of Oakland has three solid waste franchise agreements that were adopted by City Council in 2015
These three agreements reflect the largest agreements the city enters into on behalf of the community
with an annual revenue of around 200 million dollars.
So having outside support help us negotiate
future franchise agreements is essential
as it's the single largest agreements we will enter into.
So the current agreements that we have
are the mixed materials and organics collection services
contract with waste management of Alameda County.
It began July 1, 2015 for a 10 year term.
This city executed one of two five-year extensions
and it's currently set to expire June 30th, 2030.
Next, this city has the residential recycling
collection services contract
with California Waste Solutions.
This contract also began July 1, 2015,
and it's a 20-year contract set to expire June 30, 2035.
Finally, the city has a disposal services contract
with waste management of Alameda County,
which started July 1, 2015.
It's a 20-year contract through June 30, 2035,
and the city has two five-year options
to extend this agreement.
Current priorities for the city's future franchises
include rate affordability and transparency,
a clean Oakland support for compliance
with state recycling and landfill diversion mandates
and fostering a competitive procurement environment.
and apologies that I have forgot to progress our slides.
Okay, and then part of the consultant scope of work
will also include equitable community engagement
to further refine broad and specific
franchise priorities and terms.
Okay, so the review panel selected the most qualified
and lowest cost consultant, HF and H consultants
to support staff with this process.
HF&H has supported over a hundred cities
throughout the state of California
with franchise agreement negotiations.
Some of their past clients include San Jose, San Diego,
Santa Ana, Irvine, Bakersfield, Los Angeles,
the city and county of San Francisco,
Albany, Emeryville, Castro Valley,
San Leandro, Dublin, Alameda, Livermore,
the Central Costa Solid Waste Authority, and many more.
Additionally, the city of Oakland is a client of HF and H.
HF and H has supported us with franchise-related tasks
for over 10 years.
They've helped us with our current franchise agreement
and are very familiar with the positives and challenges
of our current agreements.
We've been very happy with their work
and the technical expertise that they've provided us.
Additionally, HF&H has proposed partnering
with the subconsultants, R3 Consulting Group.
R3 is a local, a certified local small business
here in Oakland.
We've also been a client of R3,
we've worked with them for over 15 years
and have been very happy with their support.
They also have experience supporting
over 100 jurisdictions across the state
with similar solid waste and franchise agreement
negotiations and procurements.
Having outside consultant support, as I mentioned earlier,
is really essential.
The city goes into negotiations once every 10 to 20 years,
whereas solid waste companies negotiate
with jurisdictions across the state all the time.
So it helps level the playing field
to have an expert that does this all the time,
like HF and H and R3, on our side.
And additionally to round out HF&H's consulting team,
another subcontractor that they have on board
is Environmental Justice Solutions.
Environmental Justice Solutions previously supported
the city of Oakland with equitable community engagement
for our Equitable Climate Action Plan.
So staff recommends the city council adopt a resolution
authorizing the city administrator to award
and execute a professional services agreement
with HF and H Consultants for future solid waste
franchising consultant services in an amount
not to exceed $1,114,868.
Please let me know if you have any questions.
Thank you.
Okay, thank you for that.
So I just wanna note for everyone,
this item is specifically about potentially engaging
a consultant, it's not a broader discussion
about the contract with Waste Management
or California Waste Solutions.
So let's try to limit our comments to our prospective
consulting garbologist, Council Member Houston.
Yes, through the Chair.
And I'm not sure if I can ask this question,
but I wanted to know were they,
the company that did the negotiation, the prior one?
Through the Chair, they weren't,
HF&H was not the consultant that helped us
with our prior contract negotiations.
With waste management.
You said they'd been working with us for 10 years,
what companies or what negotiations have they done
with us in the city of Oakland?
You said 10 years.
Yeah, through the chair.
There's a number of things they help us with.
They help us with our annual rate increase
with both waste management and California waste solutions.
They have done a performance evaluation of waste management
as is established in the franchise agreement.
They've helped us with performance issues
with our service providers.
So when there are items in the franchise agreement
that our contractors are mandated to provide
when they don't do that,
there are protections for the city
to ensure we get them to perform
and they've helped us with that as well.
Okay.
I haven't spoke to them,
but have they reached out to any other council members
like Noel Gayo and Carol Fife were in my district
where we have the most intense illegal dumping.
And is this illegal dumping reduction,
is it written into the new framework?
Will it be written into the new framework
of the design on how it addresses illegal dumping
in our districts?
So I believe that they have spoken to us at closed session.
And again, this is just about whether you engage
this consultant not about what the terms
of the contract with waste management are gonna be.
Through the chair, there is part of the outreach
that we intend to do.
Part of the scope of what we're contracting for
is not only engagement with the public,
it'll also include engagement with council members
and engagement with service providers.
So service providers the city currently has
and doesn't have.
Okay, so through the chair, so there you go.
Are we gonna approve this before they talk to us?
We're, through the chair, we're hiring a consultant
to help us build out what we want
a future franchise agreement to look like.
Council Member Gallo.
Thank you.
This consultant company, what are some
of the neighboring cities that they're also doing work with?
I heard San Francisco, LA,
what other other neighboring cities?
Yeah, through the chair.
So they've supported in Alameda County,
Albany, Emeryville, Castor Valley, Stanley, Andrew,
Dublin, Alameda, Livermore, outside of Alameda County.
Recently they've supported San Jose,
Central Contra Costa County Waste Authority, San Ramon.
Okay, thank you.
Well, so they have the history of waste management
serving Alameda County.
Anyway, so for me it's what timeline, what is our timeline to renew our contract
with Waste Management California Waste Solutions?
What timeline are we under?
So our current term is set to expire June 30, 2030 for the mixed material and organics contract
and that's the one contract that we have with waste management.
The residential recycling collection services contract with CWS
doesn't expire until June 30, 2035.
But infrastructure for solid waste collection and management
is highly regulated, and the goal of part of this process,
as I mentioned, was to facilitate competition.
And if we don't provide a long enough timeline,
other companies won't have the time they need
to build out that infrastructure
and seriously consider bidding on a future contract
for the city of Oakland.
So right now we're under a timeline,
June 2030 is when we need to finish the renewal
of the contract with Waste Management
and California Waste Solutions.
With Waste Management, June 2030?
2030.
Yes.
2030.
And does that include also dealing
with the franchise fee agreement that I,
well, that I'm questioned daily
by the residents of Oakland paying that fee
when they never voted to approve that fee.
And secondly, what I'd like to know is how,
and I've asked financially, how are we using that money?
because we're one of the rare, rare cities
that collects a franchise fee that the voters never approve.
And we're looking at, good, what,
35, 36 million dollars a year
that we're asking Waste Management to collect from me
in the residence, but I still waiting for,
are we using that money to invest public works
to clean the streets?
What are we using that money for?
And that'll be part of the presentation
information that the council can receive through this study. Yeah, Kristin Hathaway
assistant director through the chair, the franchise fee is reflected in the
city's budget so we can provide that information but the way that the city
budgets the use of the franchise fee is in the city's adopted budget. That
should be part of this presentation or study because it's Oakland is one of the
few of any cities that actually collects a franchise fee and collects the fee for
California waste solutions gives them their money and so I think I just want
to be clear with the new council that I have what is to that Oakland's going
through because the reality is from the day we signed that contract again I've
never seen Oakland at the level of the illegal dumping in blight that there is
in our streets today. So I just want to make sure that the investment that the
public makes, because my garbage bill just went up to $300 so I saw I got the
no-fill waste management. And so we have if not the highest garbage bill in the
state of California. But I just want the public to clearly understand the full
picture that we're under considering the fact that I was part of that when you
know we didn't hire waste management and we went did all kinds of crazy things
with my city council and I don't want to repeat that process again because we
lost a lot of time and money doing that now but anyways thank you for that
information yeah and through the chair just for the comment on franchise fees
every every city across the state of California that I'm familiar with
charges franchise fees through their solid waste rates. It's a very common
practice. Every jurisdiction doesn't have the exact same rate of franchise fees
but it's very common. Well you know we've been through court many times
to the public all right so it wasn't that it's not that every city is doing
that. We're one of the rare cities that does that based on the judicial and I've
been included in that debate discussion with the courts anyways thank you for
that thank you councilmember Wong I thank you for this item so just to
confirm since I know the existing franchise fee and basically concerns
that maybe those either essentially being passed down into our rate
structures of the current issue that the firm that you are recommending is not
in fact the same firm that supported us the last time. What was the firm that
supported us last time on the negotiation? Through the chair I'm gonna
have to follow back up on that. Apologies that I didn't come prepared with an
that was back in I think 2012 but I can circle back.
Rebecca, I think it was RC3.
Okay.
No.
Thank you.
RC3.
Okay.
Great.
And you anticipate based off of your working with them that the same mistakes that were
made last time will be repeated with this new firm that this firm has demonstrated
is going to bring a higher level of expertise so we don't replicate those same mistakes?
Yes, through the chair, that is the intention.
Councilmember Houston.
Thank you through the chair.
Ms. Rebecca, I want you to repeat something that you said that was really important and
I don't want to get past the public.
It was real important. It caught my attention. You said that hiring this company will allow us
city of Oakland to get other companies ready to be
competitive if we need to
Repeat that because that was that was powerful
Okay, so through the chair
part of the reason why we're starting this process now and
Working with an outside consultant is so that part of their scope of work will be to conduct interviews
with other solid waste service providers
To understand what might make them more interested and willing to bid on future solid waste franchise
Agreements that the city of Oakland could release in the coming years with the goal of making the procurement process more competitive
Through the chair. I'll move this
Okay, I will second this and let's hear from our speakers. Please. Thank you so much for that. I have miss Asada
Allah Bala and Kevin Dowley
Not in Kevin Dowley has waived his opportunity to speak
But I read in this document that doing this
Will help reduce illegal dumping and and so when you go through this process of getting these consultants
that's gonna
facilitate reducing illegal dumping so I
Hope that's true
The one thing I want to see that can come out of this is
The ending of the responsibility of the city of Oakland
to collect
unpaid bills
for
waste management
through some
Mistake, I don't know why you did it you agreed that if people do not pay their waste management bills
then take it on our responsibility to collect their money, a private entity, we are a public
entity.
So now you come up with we have to do it because we don't want the services to end, it would
cause a problem.
But it's no way, I don't know if now you'd legally do this, I don't know how a public
governing body takes on the responsibility of making sure that a private company gets
it's money, and you go through a process of putting a lien on people's property if
the public body doesn't get paid. So if there's nothing that can come out of this in July
30th of 2030, the city of Oakland is no longer responsible for making sure that waste management
gets its money. That's their problem. We got enough problems, and I hope somebody will
to support that lastly it says that you're going to be it's my time oh it is
I'm not gonna stop so you don't have to say anything thank you so much miss
all the Bible that concludes your speakers for this item and I do have a
motion in a second I have a motion by council member Houston seconded by
counts chair under to approve item 5 to be forwarded to the December 1st City
council agenda on a roll councilmember
I chair Wong I mean councilmember excuse me
Councilmember Wong councilmember Wong
councilmember Wong I don't I'm not sure if they
if they can hear councilmember Wong
you see so far I'm about her
council she's unmuted councilmember Wong
Okay, I don't know if she can't hear us and Chair Unger.
So we have a motion by Houston State University and by Councilmember Unger to approve item
number five to be forwarded to December 1st with three, four ayes, on consent, on consent.
Thank you so much.
That now takes us to item five, excuse me, six.
Our last discussion item item 6 is a resolution authorizing the city administrator to award contracts to
One Ron do Pratt or ink in the amount not to exceed one million four hundred thousand dollars to provide collision repair and body shop services for light
vehicles for a three-year term January 1st 2027 through January 1st 2030 and
two one-year options to renew in response to the requests or
Qualifications to turbo auto body LLC in the amount not to exceed
$700,000 to provide collision repair and body shop services for light vehicles for a three-year term and two one-year options to renew in
response to the RFQ three
experienced auto body in the amount not to exceed
$1,000 to provide collision repair and body shop services for light vehicles for a three-year term and
Two one-year options to renew in response to the RF Q and for
Falcon collision repair ink in the amount not to exceed one million seven hundred fifty thousand dollars to provide collision repair and body
Shop services for heavy vehicles for a three-year term
January first twenty twenty seven to January first twenty thirty and two in your options to renew in response to the RF
you and five making findings pursuant to Oakland Municipal Code that contractors
contracts involved specialized services and six adopting a CEQA findings I have
one speaker for this item thank you all right let's hear from Mr. Battersby
thank you chair under Richard Battersby assistant director of the Bureau of
maintenance and internal services of Oakland Public Works at full strength
That's about 300 employees 100 million dollar a year budget. We are larger than most city departments and under my purview
I have sewer maintenance storm drain maintenance
Facilities and I'm here today to talk about an equipment services contract
We have here today the collision repair contract, which is one of 174 contracts that the bureau
requires to function
We are returning after previously presenting this item
In July, it's about seven million dollars
estimated contract value over a three-year period with two potential one-year extensions
at the July council meeting and
By the way not to go back over background
But this is a very specific and intentional RFP for a contract that was previously awarded to a single vendor
In order to increase Oakland business participation
We decided along with our colleagues in purchasing that it would be best to do a multiple award
instead of winner-takes-all we will take that $7 million pie and break it up into different
pieces with the goal of engaging more Oakland-based small businesses.
Not just small businesses, excuse me.
When we came in July, even though we did a good process and our colleagues in purchasing,
I thought did an outstanding job, Council challenged us to go out and reach more Oakland
businesses.
And I'm happy to say here today I think we fulfilled that challenge and I hope you'll
agree with me.
Back in July we awarded Quality, which is an Oakland based body shop, $1,050,000.
And we awarded Moeller Brothers, which is the incumbent shop, $1.75 million for the
heavy duty.
We're here today to talk about the remaining 4.2 million of the $7 million contract.
So staff recommends that we, oh, and as part of the outreach, I just want to throw the
numbers out there.
Purchasing reached an additional 23 small or light duty body shops, 15 of which were
Oakland based, and reached out to 19 potential heavy duty collision repair shops, seven of
which were Oakland based. As a result of the RFP, staff recommends that we award the contracts
to Ron DePratt Ford in the amount of $1.4 million, which is approximately 40%, Turbo
Auto Body, an Oakland based vendor, $700,000, which is approximately 20%, and Experience
auto body $350,000, which is approximately 10%.
And that's on the light duty side.
For heavy duty, staff recommends awarding
to Falcon Collision Repair $1.75 million.
There's only two heavy duty body repair vendors.
So with that, I'm here to answer any questions.
I know it's kind of, it's a little bit confusing
because we've been here before, did a partial award.
So if there's any questions, I'm happy to answer them.
The council member Houston.
Yes, first off, I wanna thank you.
I wanna thank AC Lake and director Garland
for hearing the council, for hearing us
about Oakland based businesses.
And when we dealing with auto body and fender,
Oakland has the most auto body and finger fender
in Alameda County.
And when we first started, we started off with six companies.
And it was Dixon.
There was only one in Oakland.
It was Concord, San Leandro, another San Leandro,
another Concord.
And that's where I feel that you guys went out.
And you brought in four companies now.
And even though Mueller and Quality,
I had originally just wanted the money to go to quality
until we got all Oakland-based companies.
And at Council, we decided to put Moeller in there,
which is okay.
I'd like to make a motion too,
because we still have Dixon here,
which is in 1.4 million dollars.
I'd like to make a motion where instead of 40%,
we turn 20% which is to be 80% local participation
to cut Ron DuPrat in half $7700,000 not to exceed
so that percentage should go up to 80% local participation.
How does that sound?
Through the chair of the questions for me,
Council Member Houston, I think that's entirely doable.
And just to explain the presence of Ron Bupret and Dixon,
not only were they the lowest cost,
but the majority of the Oakland fleet
are comprised of Ford.
And so we're required to have support
from a Ford dealership.
We do have some closer Ford dealerships.
Some of them don't have body shops
and the other ones didn't bid,
but we have to send stuff to the Ford
to calibrate all of the fancy safety devices,
the ADAS lane keeping.
You can really only get that done at the dealer.
So that being said,
I don't think it will impact our operation at all.
This is kind of like having a menu at a buffet.
So we're gonna be sending work out.
If we run into any challenges,
we'll be sure to work through them.
Okay, through the chair, like AC Lake to repeat that
so that my colleagues can understand it
and the community can understand it, AC Lake.
Great, I think I would state it as follows,
that you would be amending the light vehicle allocations
to reduce the Ron DePratt forward to 700,000
and reallocating that 700,000 equally
between the remaining local businesses.
That's exactly what I like, thank you.
And I want everyone to thank you for working together.
I know it's 80%, I want 100%, but we almost there.
We gonna get there, we gonna get there, so thank you.
and I'd like to move this.
Oh, we gotta take a motion.
I wanna do a motion for what A.C. Lake just said.
I think your motion is to adopt the ordinance as amended.
Adopt the motion, right?
Yes, but, when I say but,
we're cutting that in half, that 700.
Explain.
That's as an amendment.
That's the amendment, yes.
Okay, yes.
Do we have any other council members
wishing to speak on this?
Councilmember Guile, you need to press your button.
Next thing, one, two, and taking that action,
you'll get the work done.
Yeah, through the chair, we are gonna get the work done.
Thank you for your support, Councilmember Guile,
Councilmember Houston, and Chair Unger,
and Councilmember Wong remotely.
We really appreciate it.
We're kind of struggling with contracts now, us,
and procurement, you're going to be seeing us here a lot.
So thank you for your support.
All right, no, I'll second the motion,
but I wanna, you do this daily for a living.
And I wanna make sure that this,
what you're doing is a quality job
to get the work done here in the city of Oakland.
And I mean, I can make all kinds of amendments,
but I wanna make sure that I get your
professional recommendation.
Based on this, you're doing this work,
so okay, so it's, you're okay with this,
All second the motion. Thank you. Okay council member Wong. Do you have a comment?
Council member Wong you just need to unmute yourself so you can begin your comments. Oh
Thank you
Thank you. I just wanted to say thank our staff for listening to us and I see a lot of the
the auto buy shops including in
District 2 so I really appreciate the work that you all have done listening and but also ensuring
to councilmember guy who's comments that a quality job can still be done
And at the end of the day, this is about providing services high quality services to a resident
Do we have public speakers? Yes, we have miss a side of the bottle for I'm sick
It is not a fair position
for the city
to advocate for local businesses
when at the same time I'm
I'm making the request that you advocate for people who are in Oakland and are citizens
of this city.
At this point you have nothing that applies to preference or priority because you are
a citizen of Oakland or that you are legally authorized to be in this country.
And at some point, you have to take under consideration that saying that we need to
have our businesses here in Oakland prioritize, and it's hypocrisy to say it doesn't matter
that you're a citizen.
You get in line with everybody else for services and resources and benefits.
That's unacceptable.
Is there an extra cost related to 60 miles is where this Dixon, California business is?
Do we have to tow business, these cars, are all of them towed or all of them drivable?
If they are towed, where does the cost or expense comes from?
The same thing for Concord, if they have to be towed, what's the funding source and can
that's what we are looking for
when you estimate.
What's the amount of money we
have available for towing.
To these.
Outside of the city vendors and
thank you mister Houston because
of you.
We now have an opportunity to
have.
Businesses that are locally
represented because if you
wouldn't step up I don't think
this would have happened.
Thank you so much for that and
councilmember hewston second it by councilmember guile to approve this item as
amended with the amendment stating that the
lightweight the light vehicle allocation
for awarded to
ron
DePrat ford to be reduced to seven hundred thousand dollars and reallocating the additional seven seven hundred thousand dollars
equally between the remaining local businesses and
with that on roll councilmember guile
Council member Wong and chair item number six is approved as amended with
four ayes to be forwarded to the December 1st City Council agenda and
that will be on consent. Thank you so much and that takes us to our last item
which is open forum I have three speakers I have miss Asada ola Bala
Kevin Dally and Blair Beekman if you're online please raise your hand thank you
I wanted the director, excuse me director, I want you to hear this please.
I want to take time to thank some of the members of the Tree Service Department, Ms. Cecilia
Garcia, Amanda Montes, in the public works, I hope I'm saying the name, in public works,
and Dennis Lorx in the Department of Transportation.
My sister is dealing with a situation with sidewalks and trees and she's had to contact
people.
They don't know me and she doesn't have my last name.
But in doing it, these three people have been exceptionally helpful and I'm suspecting that
a lot of people that have to deal with staff in these departments get the same kind of
good treatment.
So I just want to thank them and a lot of times people do the work for the city but
they don't get a chance to be recognized.
I wanna do that.
The second part of, thank you again for your staff.
The second part of what I'm experiencing
with this situation is there are people
who are in the city, who do work.
They do challenge.
I apologize, Ms. Olubala.
That open forum is one minute, so my apologies.
Thank you so much.
Our next speaker, we will do those
who are participating in person.
Kevin Dalley?
Yeah, Kevin Dalley, good news.
we get to test out the new charter,
there's a vacancy in the Oak Dot Director
and the charter gives the council the power
to approve or disapprove of anyone the mayor nominates.
I am hoping that the council and Public Works
and Transportation looks at this possibility
and individually, perhaps as committee,
you decide what the priority will be.
For me, any director has to have a priority of traffic safety, which includes pedestrians,
cyclists, and motorists, ADA access including progress on the consent decree and paving.
Looking forward to working with Megan Weir as acting director.
Again, she's done a great job with International Boulevard Safety and many countless other
items.
Thank you.
Thank you so much for your comments.
Our last speaker Blair Beekman, you are unmuted, you may unmute yourself.
Hi, Blair Beekman.
Wow.
In San Diego, they just made a really important decision at their council yesterday to end
their AOPR program, their flock program, and their smart street light program.
Wow.
It's a lot.
Look to them, look to see examples if it's the right way to go.
Oakland has chosen a community process to decide the future of block and the future of technology.
I think that's pretty interesting, you know, it'll be a community process to really hash out the best future, a future of peace and not war.
Good luck how to do that and really look to what San Diego is doing.
I hope they can keep it together and really practice accountability in reducing all the
tech.
Good luck on better accountability and best practices for all of us in the future.
Thank you.
Thank you for your comments.
That concludes our public speakers for open forum.
All right.
We're adjourned.
See you at the next one.