Board of Directors - Nov 13, 2026

November 13, 2026 · Board of Directors

Subscribe via RSS: Metrolink Board of DirectorsMetrolink Meetings

Agenda

6. Approval of Consent Calendar Items: 12.A-12.J

All Consent Calendar items are listed at the end of the agenda.

7. PUBLIC HEARING

7.A Adoption of the FY27 Metrolink Operating and Capital Budgets, the FY27 Salary Resolution, and Approval of Operating Forecasts for the Four Years FY28 through FY31 Under the terms of the Joint Exercise of Powers Agreement (JPA), the Authority is required to adopt a budget for the succeeding fiscal year no later than June 30th of each year. The Proposed FY27 Budget consists of the Operating Budget and State of Good Repair/New Capital Projects Budget. Consistent with multi-year budget planning, approval of the proposed budget forecasts for the fiscal years 2028 through 2031 is also requested at the time of budget adoption. In addition, the FY27 Salary Resolutions are submitted for approval as part of the Budget Adoption process. It is recommended that the Board:

Attachments (196)

Agenda Items

  1. 00:23:57 Public Hearing Following a public hearing, the board adopted the FY2026–27 operating and capital budgets, using state rail assistance to maintain current service while discussing funding conditions, future capital needs and Olympic readiness.

Transcript

Warning: This transcript is automatically generated by machine and may contain errors, including misheard words, misattributed speakers, and omitted passages. Always listen to the audio or video recording before assuming the transcript correctly reflects what was said. Do not rely on the transcript alone for quotation, reporting, or any other purpose where accuracy matters.
Good morning, everyone.
It's my pleasure to call the Metropolitan Board of Directors
meeting to order in our meeting with the safety briefing
by Hillary Conzel, our chief safety, security,
and compliance officer.
Good morning, Chairman Shafie, board of directors.
In the event we have to evacuate the building,
we will walk out the exit here, down the stairs.
We'll exit the lobby of the building,
and we'll turn to our right, and we'll
We'll meet in front of the Metro customer service station.
We'll take headcount there.
In the event of a medical emergency,
we do have our LA County sheriffs in the room
who will render aid.
We also have an AD at the security desk
that we can utilize if necessary.
In the event of an earthquake,
we'll get under the tables and desks,
wait for the rumbling to stop
to see if further evacuation is necessary.
And in the event of an active shooter,
will deploy the Run, Hide, Fight tactic.
Thank you.
Thank you.
If we all join us, Helen Tran, if you would lead us
in our Pledge of Allegiance.
Please rise, open up your heart.
Ready?
Begin.
I pledge allegiance to the United States of America
and to the Republic for which it stands,
And Helen, I wonder if you might introduce yourself
as one of our new board members.
Good morning, everyone.
I am Mayor Helen Tran with the City of San Bernardino,
and it's an honor to be on this board as an alternate.
We're delighted to have you.
Thank you for joining us.
Madam Clerk, roll call.
Director Nguyen.
Director Goh.
Here.
Director Tenamer.
Vice Chair Bergson.
Here.
Director Spiegel.
I'm here.
Director Vargas.
Director Molina.
Second Vice Chair Tremblay.
Here.
Director Engler.
Director Barger.
Director Sandoval.
Here.
Dr. Solis, Director Olson, Director O'Connor,
Director Camacho, Director Allen,
Director McCallum, Director Marquez,
Director Tran, Director Armendariz,
Chair Chaffee, we do have a quorum present.
Thank you, Madam Clerk.
Now, where are we with public commenters?
Do we have any this morning?
I have not received any request to speak,
but I will make this the call for anyone
wishing to speak on our public hearing right now
to turn in their speaker cards to our assistant board clerk
so that they can be called on during the public hearing.
And then all the written public comments
that were received were emailed to the board with the packet.
Thank you.
At this point, we'll go to our consent calendar,
which are items 12a through 12j on our agenda.
Any speakers on that?
None.
Directors, comments, questions?
We have a motion to approve.
Seconded.
All right, any objection?
Abstentions?
Seeing none, the item is approved.
Now we go on to our next items.
Our CEO has requested that we change the order slightly,
that we look at 8A before we go to the public hearing,
which is 7A, Mr. CEO?
Yes, thank you Mr. Chair.
So again, just doing a quick flip of those two items
because item 8A does involve elements
to the ultimate adoption of our budget
to be under consideration by the board on 7A.
What I want to share with the board
is that in consultation with both our chief of audits
as well as our chief financial officer,
if there is the interest on the part of this board
to proceed with the request from LA Metro
and the motion that's been presented by LA Metro
to this board, we have a solution,
if it's the desire to do this, to direct myself, our CFO,
and the director of audits to develop a scope of work
consistent with that motion and to set a not to exceed
limit on that scope of work of $250,000
to perform the audit, the review,
and analysis of the Alstom contracts,
both the former contract that Alstom had
as just our mechanical contractor
and then in the current contract
where they provide both mechanical operations
and some facilities work.
And that Mr. Shamber, our CFO and myself
will identify the funding within the existing
proposed budget that you will consider after this item
to fund that activity.
So, Mr. Chair, I just wanted to make sure
that you're aware if the Board's desire
is to proceed in this direction, we can accommodate it
and we can identify the resources necessary.
My one request, though, is given how lean our budget is
that we do establish not to exceed amount of $250,000.
Mr. Chair, that is just the staff presentation
and I will turn it back to you for board consideration.
Rector's, Director Marquez, I see your light on.
All right, I have to move on.
Questions?
Let's see, oh, go ahead, I'm sorry.
I've been told that I was the maker of the motion at Metro,
so I think it's probably appropriate
say a few words. Let me just first, by saying that I want to thank MetroLink and the Metro staff
for all the work behind this item and for the work you do every day to keep our trains running.
In hindsight, I perhaps could have done a better job of bringing this forward to the audit
committee as opposed to bringing it through Metro. And so I wanted to say that I own that.
So my apologies to the chair and to the board for doing that.
It doesn't take away from, I believe, the need to do this audit.
I just wanted to state that the path that I should have taken is through the audit committee.
So I just want to state that unequivocally.
That said, I think that we all understand this has been an incredibly challenging year for all of us
and that we've had some challenges over the course of that time, and I believe the motion
really is intended to help make us a better agency, and we may discover in the course
of that audit that in fact we're doing just fine, or we're not, and how do we get better.
So I've put this forward, I'm not going to read all of, I'm not going to read the motion,
it's there before you, but I'm certainly happy to answer any questions, but I think at the
At the end of the day, this will be an important step for us to be able to take as an agency
to ensure transparency, but also to ensure the safety for our writers, our employees,
and to work to make us an absolute, continue to make us represent ourselves as a world-class
agency.
So I put that forward, Chair.
I just, again, want to apologize to my colleagues for the path through the process in which
this comes to you, again, should have gone through the audit committee, did not do that,
so I just want to say back to you, Chair.
Thank you, Director Sandoval.
Did I see a light?
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and Tim, thank you for that.
I have a couple of questions of the CEO on this item, and then I have a more macro issue
That I want to talk about from a governance standpoint, which isn't a CEO question
It's a question for members of the board to discuss and respectfully so
a couple things that I'm unclear on
the letter from
Stephanie November 6 letter says that
Our board is to direct our chief auditor to conduct a full audit
The motion says by contrast that the audit needs to be conducted
Request and coordinate a comprehensive independent and transparent audit
first question is
Am I correct in thinking that the motion is for an independent outside?
Firm to conduct that audit rather than Metrolinx staff and I guess maybe that's a CEO question as to how the CEO understands it
Director Tremblay, as great as Liz Lazardi is and her staff is, we don't have the skill sets to do this in-house.
We will have to go out and identify a specialist, an expert in the field to conduct this, so it would be our intent to do that.
The letter wasn't consistent with the motion, so forgive me for 43 years of law practice, I tend to go in the weeds.
Two more questions, depending on the RFP and procurement process, Darrin when would a reasonable
expectation for an outside time range be before the audit results would be provided to the
board?
I'm just trying to, you can't pin down process that much, but what would be a reasonable
time period for expectations?
I would, Director Tremblay, I would say, given if direction is made today,
I would imagine a couple-month process to do a procurement.
Again, with a dollar amount limit, but not to exceed of 250, I'm able to,
the CEO is able to approve that, so we can go on a bit of an accelerated timeframe.
I would imagine any expert in this field would probably take at least three months
to develop a response, a complete audit, possibly longer.
But if we give them a shot clock that is three months,
I think that given all the work that's gone in over the course
of our own staff's effort in trying to be transparent
in all that we're doing on the mechanical side,
that by the end of the fiscal year,
we would have a possibility in maybe early first quarter
of 2627. So end of FY27 or beginning of FY28 budget year, right? Yes. Okay. And the next
question is, the audit results will be publicly shared with all members, staff, and if so,
in what manner? I just want to know how that's going to unfold. Given the nature of the motion
coming from a member agency, and we'll be using public funding for this purpose, it's
It's a very public and transparent process.
Those results would be brought back to you through the director of audits unit and have
that consultant present the findings.
Okay.
All right.
Darren, thank you for that.
I want to switch to a little different conversation.
And, Tim, Director Sandoval, this is not a criticism in any way of what has occurred
here.
And I'm in support.
I intend to support the motion.
Because we can't just say safety is foundational.
We have to back that up.
We have to make sure that safety is foundational.
But this also raises a governance question for me.
And I really appreciate your thought about picking a,
potentially having to pick a different path.
We've had a different committee structure this year,
so that's been challenging.
I spent many decades in Don's chair
on representing public entities.
And not just that, but one extremely large JPA
elsewhere in the state, which had
members that the communications between those members
could have been improved.
Let me just put it that way.
And so could the relationship.
And I've represented another JPA where
the same thing has happened.
So I look at it from that standpoint.
You can look at this through multiple lenses,
but this is kind of the elephant in the room.
Someone could say, hey, this is a great idea, let's do it.
Its safety is foundational, and it is.
I absolutely agree.
Someone differently could also look at this
like we're staring down the barrel of a gun from LA Metro,
and Metro's saying, unless you adopt this,
a motion, an audit, LA Metro isn't going to pass its budget.
I don't like being in that position.
I knew that's what you were getting to,
and I have the highest respect for you.
I'm not just buttering you up.
I do.
So I wanted to just bring that to the attention of my colleagues
and ask that we think about some different ways
to try to improve our communication.
Lots of times we sit here, and I feel like we collect,
and I'll use this collectively, we're not
sure what our respective staffs have come up with.
We're hearing about stuff for the first time.
And like you, I don't ever want to be a rubber stamp.
I think there needs to be a higher degree of communication
to avoid this kind of situation in the future.
Not with respect to the audit.
You know, the odds of the audit, we'll get that done.
But I'm thinking more about improving process
and communications.
And a couple of thoughts on this that we might just think about.
One is that we have, we go back to a system
with an executive committee that also meets
with the five CEOs for our member agencies
on a regular basis, and I understand Brown Act,
I understand all that stuff, but I
think we need to have a better degree of communication
from that standpoint.
Or maybe if we're not ready to make moves to day,
we could think about this.
I know there's typically an annual workshop session,
which I think, Doug, you've done in January or February.
Maybe we have something through the new chair
early this year.
If that's the case, then I would like to ask
for an agenda item.
So we talk about some options
that I think would improve the communication.
So there isn't anyone, and I'm the small fish here.
Hey, I'm from Ventura County.
But I think there are multiple lenses
to have looked at this.
And I don't wanna dwell on the negative side.
I want to focus on the positive and move forward.
But I don't like being in this position inherently.
I don't react well.
I don't react well.
And people don't react well to what they might perceive is.
I don't think it was, what they might perceive is a threat.
And that's not the way that this board, in my opinion,
ought to be conducting this.
So all in support of the motion.
I'm hoping that we can have more of a conversation.
I really appreciate what you said at the outset.
And I have gone on now way too long.
But I wanted you all to know how I felt.
Thanks, too.
Supervisor says, Director Spiegel and Supervisor, sorry.
Either way, Karen, too, that's my name.
I couldn't have said anything better.
I think you hit every point that I had.
It really was, read your motion.
That was hard, but the letter from Stephanie
was over the top, and there was a blatant threat.
And I understand L.A. pays the majority, uh, uh, a large.
We all understand that, and just like he just said,
he's a low man in totem pole.
But we all pay proportionately for what our budgets
are counties, and what we receive
is a benefit of this organization.
So we can't judge because there's more money here,
because we're all part of that spoke in the wheel.
Maybe you have a couple of spokes and we only have one.
But the point is, is we have to work together.
And this was really, and I appreciate your apology
and that we should have done.
I appreciate it so much.
And I'm glad you started off with that
because it certainly toned me down
because I was, tap my, I was kidding.
But it just, and the lateness of it,
you know, to be very last minute, you know.
and it just was, it just was very disappointing,
if nothing more than just saying disappointing,
of colleagues of an organization
that some of us have been part of for decades.
To suddenly have this, I think it's made me
one other time and all the time I've been involved.
It's been a long time guys.
I came on this board many years ago
and I had a two week, two, two month gap,
two year gap when I ran for supervisor
and then got back on this board.
So I love Metrolink.
And we've had great working partnerships.
And we don't always agree.
But we have to learn to agree and work together.
And I know, but I've heard not just you,
but there's other members of the counties that feel that way.
But they don't sit up on the dais.
And I think Yuri Morris was because you sit up here.
You understand.
You have to work together or the organization cannot function.
And I think that's the critical aspect of all this.
I don't think I need to say anymore.
I have a question for our CEO.
We are looking at five member agencies,
and one has put this forward.
Are the other four informed, and what do they think of it?
Mr. Chair, that's for this board's determination,
to be frank.
This is a policy call.
We can do it.
We will identify the resources to do it.
I think when we go through it, should we go through it,
we are gonna come across in shining colors
because of our operations and team.
So I think that there's a consensus
that if the board is desirous of proceeding with this,
everybody's on board to deliver.
So we're kind of in the lead on this at the request.
The other member agencies are not
been presented with this request.
All of the members of this board of directors
received the letter.
At least, that was the intent, because you were all
copied on the letter that was sent.
My sense is that, at least it's been my experience
in a little over five years, is that if you as board members
receive that, you are going to consult your member
agencies to get their feet in your executives at your member
agencies, and they would have let you
know if they had a problem.
I have not heard of that and so we will, which is not the reason that we can make sure we
walked in with a solution, but because this is pure and simple, it's a policy call given
the nature of the request.
But I have not heard any opposition from member agencies to this request.
Again, you would have checked with your own executive teams.
It's your member agencies and I'll leave it at that.
OK, yes, Dr. Spiegel and then Director McCallum.
I think the audit is not really of concern
because we've all made comments throughout this whole process
of concerns.
So some of us held back because of the cost.
And we're talking, what, a quarter million?
$300,000, whatever.
It's very clear in the motion, I think in the motion,
but at least a letter to take it out of the budget for 2027.
Somehow we'll have to move things around.
Somehow we haven't been happy with some of the challenges
that we've overcome, because we are overcoming them
with some challenges that it creates.
So I think, yes, I think we all should have at least
had a conversation with our CEOs.
And I think, Darren, haven't you had it with all of them?
Most of them are not with all of them.
But I do know that members of this board of directors
had consultations with their respective chief executives.
So if I had not had the direct conversation,
I do know we have members of this board
that had it with their respective CEOs.
On a normal day, I would say we should delay this.
But the fact that we have been delaying
a budget that should have improved already,
if we agree that there's an audit necessary,
Making us do that through the budget process should have done without a committee. I think mr. Sandoval is very correct
It should have but we're here now and let's make the best of what we're at
Director McKellan. Thank you. Thank you very much Tim. Thank you for your initial comments. I think
director trimly and director Spiegel
Said everything. Well that was on my mind
supportive of doing it and I will
second director Tremblay's motion to
approve it
with the spending cap I assume
All right, I guess my own concern is the budget is tight and another quarter million in there
I don't know, but it is useful information also
with that with the
Motion to approve the metrol request with a cap of $250,000
in the objection I
7. Public Hearing
See none all right that is approved now. We've come to our public hearing which is item
7a
so
all right, I'm going to
Open the public hearing and as required by applicable laws and agreements
This hearing is called to order to receive public comment
They propose fiscal year 2026 27 Metro League budget
members of the public have been notified of this public hearing and according to the political requirements
Turn it over to CFO Tom Shumber to give a brief
presentation Tom
Good morning, chair chafee members of the board
Well, the day has finally come. I'm very happy to be able to say that
I'm here to present the FY 27 Metrolink operating and capital budgets for your consideration and adoption
It's been a long road since we started work on this budget in September of last year
During that time we've evaluated eight service scenarios to arrive at a schedule that provides the best possible service for our riders
With the funds we have available
Some of the options we considered were quite alarming, but in the end this is a good news story.
At last month's meeting we pulled this item from the agenda at the 11th hour.
We had a Hail Mary plan as Darren would say. The California State Transportation Agency or CALSTA
published a notice of funding opportunity which made 67 million dollars available to a handful of passenger rail agencies
operating in the state.
Metrolink submitted a request for $20 million of that funding.
If successful, we could avoid further service cuts through June of 2028,
while keeping the member agency support requirements within their targets.
Having lobbied the state for months, we felt that the odds were in our favor.
We requested that the member agency CEOs postpone consideration of the budget
At the October meeting to allow time for CalSTA to make a decision on our application
Just last week as you all know we learned that we successfully secured our full 20 million dollar ask
We quickly finalized a budget that incorporated this state rail assistance to retain the level of service. We're operating today
No further cuts are necessary
Thankfully our customers were spared the disappointment and frustration of losing the service
they rely on to travel the region for business and pleasure. Next slide please.
I'm going to walk through the budget starting with the environment that made
this process so challenging this year. I'll review the assumptions upon which
the budget was built. I'll go through the highlights of the operating cap and
capital budgets and conclude with a summary of the entire budget. Next slide
please. Midway through fiscal year 26 we realized that the ridership and fair
revenue forecasts produced by our consultant were significantly overstated.
In fact, Fairbox revenue ended the year 14 million dollars under budget. This was
sobering and we realized that not only was fiscal 26 off, but our ridership
expectations for fiscal year 27 would need to be recalibrated to this new
baseline. Second, we learned well after the FY 27 development process began that
some of our member agencies had specific targets for the level of support they could provide
for this budget year. The post-COVID burden on our member agencies has grown steadily
with our fare box ratio down from the mid 30 percent to just 12 to 13 percent today.
The challenges ahead of us were becoming more evident.
In addition to disappointing fare revenue and funding limitations, we must absorb inevitable
cost increases in several of our largest contracts.
We made every effort to reduce costs throughout this process, including an over 16 million
dollars slimming of costs from the first compiled budget in January.
The operating budget you are considering today is just 0.6% greater than the FY26 budget.
In the end, these factors took us on a lengthy and tireless path to produce a balanced and
palatable budget. Next slide. Okay, let's dive into the details of the operating
budget. Next slide. Here are the assumptions upon which the budget was
constructed. As I've already mentioned, service will remain at the levels we're
operating today. Due to the urgency of processing these scenarios and the
significant costs that would have been incurred, ridership and fair revenue
forecasts were done in-house. Fair increases to one-way tickets, SoCal Day
passes, and weekend passes were implemented in early October. This helped
to close the gap, but it was also long overdue. Despite continually rising
operating costs, MetroLink had not increased fares for 13 years. Due to
geopolitical events, gas prices skyrocketed almost overnight and have
state elevated sense. When gas prices go up, people turn to transit as a more
economical way to travel. For this budget, we have assumed the gas prices will
remain elevated throughout fiscal year 27, which is reflected in our ridership
forecast. In order to make the budget work, our CEO contributed 12.3 million
dollars of formula state rail assistance, which comes to Metrolink directly, and
And there was an additional $6 million of the 20 million we were just awarded of flexible state rail assistance from CalSTA applied to the budget.
No new fair promotions were budgeted, but the 50% student youth discount and the 50% mobility for all discount will remain, both funded in part or in whole by grants.
On the expense side CEO direction was to hold cost growth to 3% whenever possible
and less mandated by existing contracts. No new headcount was proposed. Salaries
were budgeted slightly different this year and prior years each position was
budgeted at the top of its scale. We have adjusted that to only 90% except when
employee has already exceeded that point. Salaries reflect a 3% COLA effective
July 1st, but no merit increases will be given. Travel and training were targeted
for a 33 percent decrease from the FY26 budget and no special trains were
budgeted. Next slide, please. Here's a quick look at the service levels which we
all are familiar with. Weekdays are running at 20 percent fewer trains than
under optimized service, which we were operating for much of fiscal 26. Weekend
service however remains the same at 60 trains a day on weekends. Next slide
please. You have the detailed operating statement in your packet but here are
the highlights. Operating revenue is projected at $88.6 million including
farebox, fare subsidies and dispatching and maintenance away subsidies paid by
other railroads that operate over our tracks. That's a 15.2% increase over the
FY26 budget and is reflective of the fair increase induced ridership from
high gas prices and state rail assistance. Operating expenses are
budgeted at 355.3 million or a 0.6 increase over the FY26 budget. I
previously mentioned the increases in our major contracts including our train
operators, equipment and facilities maintenance, sheriffs, and our
maintenance-of-way contractor. Another notable experience is fuel expense, sorry,
is fuel. Fuel is budgeted for an 18.5 percent year-over-year increase that was
developed in cooperation with our fuel consultant, our fuel hedge consultant. I
guess it's anybody's guess where that's going to end up. You know, these events
are a bit beyond our control but that is a substantial increase in our budget for
The resulting member support requirement is $266.7 million, which is 3.5 percent under
the FY26 budget and it meets the requirements set by our member agencies.
Thanks to the infusion of state rail assistance, this support requirement is the same as it
would have been under the budget I brought to you last month, but this one is without
significant service cuts.
Next slide, please.
This slide shows annual fare revenues, including subsidies since FY19, amounts are in thousands.
It clearly tells the story of how we got to the financial situation we're facing.
Despite the flattening in fiscal 24 through fiscal year 26, we still project a fare revenue
increase in fiscal 27.
I've already mentioned a couple of reasons why this is a reasonable assumption.
We are increasing fares to a limited number of ticket types and expect to continue seeing
the induced ridership due to the price at the pump.
Note that despite the hit in fiscal 26 to our budgeted revenue, in other words, our
actuals against budget, actual fare revenue still ended roughly flat when compared to
prior years.
Next slide, please.
Again, total operating support from the member agencies is $266.7 million and this chart shows
that distribution among the member agencies.
With the addition of state rail assistance, all agency targets were met.
Next slide, please.
Moving on to the capital budget, next slide.
The capital program is critical to keeping Metrolink operating and operating safely.
Consistent investment is required to prevent the backlog of capital projects from growing.
In addition, with costs rising to the level we are seeing today, deferring maintenance
means we will have to spend even more to do the same work down the road.
This budget reflects roughly what is needed to keep the system in a state of good repair
annually.
Not hitting that mark can result in unplanned and emergency maintenance that can be both
costly and disruptive to service.
The capital budget is made up of two components, state of good repair and new capital.
The state of good repair request for this year
is 142.6 million, a 3.7% increase over the FY26 budget.
The new capital budget is 10.9% or 30.1%
beneath the FY26 budget.
Details of the project that make up these numbers
are in your packet.
The total capital request is 153.5 million,
roughly equal to the FY26 budget.
Again this request satisfies all member agency funding targets.
Next slide please.
A quick look at the breakdown of the 153.5 million capital budget
between the member agencies support requirements.
Next slide please.
And a summary, next slide.
The combined operating and capital support request
from the member agencies is 420.2 million.
That amount was 428.6 in FY26.
Year over year, that is an 8.4 million or 2% increase.
I'm sorry, decrease.
That concludes my presentation.
I'm happy to answer any questions.
Thank you.
We'll start with asking if any members of the public
have signed up since the clerk made the announcement to put
in their speaker request.
Do we have any responses?
I have not received any speaker cards since making the announcement under the request
for public hearing speakers to sign up.
We do have written comments which have been distributed to the board and they'll be made
part of the record.
Correct.
Okay.
With that, the public hearing has been opened.
We're not having any further requests to speak.
So we're going to close the public hearing and bring it back to this board to ask any
questions they'd have and then make a decision.
Thanks Mr. Chair. A couple of questions on the 20, Tom thanks for the
presentation and thank you to you and your staff to Darren to all the
Metrolinx staff this has been a very challenging period for everybody.
Question with respect to the CalSTA grant were there any conditions attached
to that grant that we should know about that were of that are of substantive
importance in terms of our being able to realize these funds. We're still working
out those those conditions there will be some but we haven't finalized that with
CalSTA. I would say the biggest one to be aware of is if we take this money the
expectation is to provide the service. That was the scope of the request was if
you give us this money we will operate service at today's level. We will be
doing that today if we adopt this budget for fiscal year 27. If we wanted to
accept the money for fiscal 28 that would also be implied that we would be
providing the same level of service in fiscal 28 and if not a requirement that
the state is not forcing that they're just simply saying you ask for this
money to operate today's level of service through fiscal 28 and if we take
that money that's their expectation and in mr. Shamberer under this is what
happens when outlook goes down you don't there's late breaking news that not
everybody gets. Sometime late yesterday afternoon, Mr. Hubler and I received a
text message from the Deputy Secretary of CalSTA that included the signed letter
with conditions from Secretary Omashakhan. That was an iterative process
between Metrolinx staff and the Secretary's office, so there are
conditions at this point that have been identified. They have been done in
consultation with us. As Tom indicated, those conditions are that we need to
operate the service, but there's also some reporting elements that we just
would need to be doing as a general. We would be doing it as a general practice
anyway. One of the key issues that we focused on is making sure that any
condition that the state would place on us is wholly on Metrolink and there is
no condition placed on a member agency.
So we have been sure there were originally there started some conditions that I said
that the member agencies would need to do certain things.
I said that as a non-starter and the state understood that.
So I believe the conditions that we have that again rolled
in very late last night are very manageable for us to comply with.
I think the other item that we will have work to do though is one of the conditions is
that to work to identify.
It doesn't say identify, work to identify a funding stream
that can sustain this level of service beyond June 30 of 2028.
So we do have an expectation that come a year from now
or so we have a plan for a sustainable,
we've been working on a plan.
You don't have a plan.
We're working on a plan to make sure we have the funding
to deliver the same level of service at a minimum.
So let me come at it from a different angle
than with respect to these conditions.
Based on what we know now, as of last evening,
our staff is confident that Metrolinq
will be able to meet these conditions.
Yes.
Second question is, if I'm understanding
my numbers correctly were committing 12.3 million
of formula SRA monies that are typically used
for capital grants for funding FY27 operations, right, Tom?
Can you clarify, because I think in October
there was a different item with respect to,
it was a different number that was utilized.
I think it was 10.8 million.
So there's a difference between those two numbers.
I'm thinking about my elementary school math.
Would you please clarify, do we need an amended resolution
in order to do that?
Or is there any housekeeping that needs to be done?
Because now it's going to be $12.3 million of SRA monies.
I don't know that we need an amended resolution for that.
We're adopting the budget with that $12.3 million in there.
You may have to do something, Tom, though,
with the state in that request.
And I'm seeing one of your former employees, Ms. Farinas,
who's handling that grant that we do need to update.
She's giving me a head nod like this.
Yes. This board is going to have to act on a resolution that increases beyond the 10.8
so that we have the official resolution.
I know what you're talking about.
Yes.
Okay, sorry about that.
Yes, the resolution to approve applying or allocating that funding.
Yes, correct.
Okay. And more pertinently, for member agency purposes, what will some, and if so,
which of the capital grant matches no longer have SRA formula funding?
How are you going to discern that?
You discern which member agency gets what amount of that funding?
Well, which which which projects will see funding lost?
Because we are moving that grant funding from capital to operating, right?
We're not going to have the amount of capital funding we ordinarily have.
So which projects are going to go to the cutting board? Right.
So not to put too fine a point on it.
We have traditionally preserved that money as matching funds for grant pursuits.
And so there are no existing projects that are losing their funding,
but we cannot apply for as many grants without finding another matching funding source.
Well have you been able to identify those projects which we anticipated that we would
have applied for, but now we will not be able to apply for?
I don't think I am aware of that prioritized list, but we do in capital program delivery
have a prioritized list of needs.
My view is I think it would be important to communicate
to the member agencies what the ultimate answer
to that question is so that people know
what capital projects might be deferred
in terms of applications.
I think it's important to know.
And then that's available, Director Tremblay.
We can put that together.
And as recently as, most recently,
the Federal Railroad Administration
announced grant awards that we had applied
for funding for some projects that we were using.
We intended to use SRA dollars as match.
Unfortunately, we were not successful in that,
so then we no longer need those resources.
The project is still necessary,
but since there was not a grant award,
we have that funding available to us.
But we can prepare that so that there's a clear understanding
of where we have funding that can cover these operating costs
and what projects then end up maybe having
to be put in advance.
Okay.
All right.
Thank you, Tom.
Thank you, Darren.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Uh, Director Spiegel?
I think it's the last slide, the last slide.
I've always looked at that year-over-year variance, and when there's, it's kind of interesting
on that.
And how does that happen when there's some agencies that end up having a less amount
than they did in previous years?
Because we're, I'm just trying to figure out how that works.
It's complicated.
That's the answer.
Our budget model is extraordinarily complicated.
There are over two dozen, if not more, allocation formulas
for every line item on the operating statement.
And so those can vary from year to year.
Very slight changes can change those numbers
in ways you might not intuitively think
until you run the numbers.
And in this, the adopted 27 has the reduced amount
that Metro and OCTA asked for.
That's correct.
Interesting.
Maybe I won't.
Okay, thank you.
You're welcome to stop by the office.
I'd be happy to walk you through that.
You'll regret you ever asked,
but I can do that for you.
Director Sandoval.
I'm sorry, Dr. Mar...
Yeah, go ahead.
Marquez.
Marquez Sandoval.
Well, I saw director said it first, so go ahead.
I'll defer to my senior colleague, director Marquez.
Go ahead.
Oh, you did?
OK.
Let's not battle with that one.
All right.
Again, I want to thank the MetroLink team
for securing the $20 million.
I know it's not the way in which we
wanted to finalize our budget, but it is what it is.
So just thank you to you and your team
for, I'm sure, very stressful nights
over the course of many months.
I have two questions.
The first has to do with we're voting on the budget today,
but there's the next cycle budget process.
And typically, what happens is, if I understand correctly
and correctly if I'm wrong, is that we start engaging member
agencies around December.
And then, so it's a process and we start engaging each other
and we work towards finalizing a budget,
I believe in May, June, if I'm not mistaken.
I'd like to better understand
what that process is going to look like.
So that's my first question.
The second question has to do with,
we will be hosting, let's say we,
Los Angeles area will be hosting the Olympics.
And I understand we have a lot of money
to be able to support ridership during the Olympics.
But my question has to do with how are we
going to be able to, and granted, there's
been a change at the federal level in terms
of the makeup of Congress, both the Senate and the House.
So I don't know if that tends, maybe it looks better for us.
But clearly, we're not going to be able to deliver
of services that are needed for the Olympics
if we don't have additional funding.
So my second question is, what are your preliminary thoughts
about how we make sure that we're
able to meet the needs for the Olympics, which
is literally less than a year and a half, am I correct?
It's about a year and a half away before the Olympics come.
So first question is about the budget process.
Second question is about the Olympics.
Director Sandoval to your first question because of the application process we
did to get the state rail assistance dollars from the state we got a head
start on 2728. We know what our contracts look like for FY2728 we have
asked the escalators are included we know what those are. We have certain
assumptions that I've put before our finance budget and finance team as to
what we can expect for assumptions for FY27-28.
And we've already started it,
and Tom's team will be getting a little bit more deep
with all of the member agencies,
but we also generally know where our member agencies are
as far as what they can afford.
We know from correspondence from Los Angeles
and from Orange County,
what the expectation is as to the funding
they have available for FY27 and 28.
And as well, do we have it in writing from Riverside?
And while not in writing from San Bernardino,
we do have it verbally about what they can see
as being an increase that they can foresee for 27, 28.
And we are staying, our budget team is staying
within that construct.
With all of that, that's when we start to apply
the 14 million, so we have the six million first
for this fiscal year, but for fiscal year 27-28,
it gets us through June of 28.
That's when we apply the 14 million,
as well as some additional Metrolinx state rail assistance
dollars to get us through that next fiscal year.
So this gives us, I think we are much clear
on where we are now given what we have been informed
by through this last year.
So there, I do know Tom is working on a schedule
related to the continued conversations
with the member agencies,
but we generally know where our member agencies are
at this point as it relates to what they can contribute
for 2728.
As it relates to the Olympics,
this does only get us through 2728.
I will put as much lipstick on this pig as I possibly can.
If we had to go with the past budget,
a budget that was gonna be presented in October,
we were gonna be looking at significant service cuts
that would have meant reductions in workforce
of our engineers and conductors.
The exact opposite direction we need to be going
as we look forward to 28, July and August of 28 in September.
So we are positioned with this budget
to at least maintain our service levels and our workforce
at the service levels we have today.
So much will depend on what we see out of Congress
in the coming six to nine months,
and what this new Congress might mean
to support the games in Southern California
late summer of 28.
And I know the public transit providers
will be putting on a full court press in DC
to try to make sure we get what we need
to provide some level of service.
And then the only thing I'll add is that our direction,
My direction to our team has been,
we will do everything we can to have every piece of equipment
that we currently have available.
So overhauls, locomotives that are in a place,
those types of things.
We will have equipment ready.
The question will be, will we have the engineers
and conductors and the mechanics to deliver on that?
We can only do that, and never to steal the thunder
of Director Tremblay, who sits on our LE28 ad hoc committee.
We have heard loud and clear, our member agencies
are not going to cover that excess cost.
So everything is gonna be putting our efforts
into advocating for this region in Washington
with probably a little bit of help from Sacramento, hopefully.
I hope that covers your questions, so thank you very much.
Just going back to the first question
on the budget process, am I to understand correctly
that you've already started engaging
each of the transit agencies?
Or is that something that you'll begin in December?
No, we have already initiated that conversation
with the chief executives of all of those agencies
a meeting probably two months ago.
We said we need to know what,
even though we think we have an idea
based on correspondence we've received,
we need certainty.
And I think what was,
Tom what was the date we were asking for that information?
Today.
Today, yeah.
So we have made that ask.
And so I don't know if we have any new information
probably not given everything we have,
but Tom, do you have anything to add at this point?
I don't, but my email's been locked up for 24 hours,
so I don't know that.
I'm sure it's coming here.
I would know it's there if it was there, but.
Yes.
And when will staff start meeting with member agencies?
Staff to staff.
That will probably be.
That's typically how the budget process works.
Yeah, and I have produced a calendar
and shared it with the MAC,
so they are aware of what the plan is,
but the plan is to start meeting in January,
early January, probably the first MAC in January.
We need that time in December to compile and analyze
and work through the numbers,
and then we'll engage every MAC meeting,
every BAFCOM and board meeting between then and June,
which is the typical process.
It's just this last year was just a pet down.
So there will be plenty of communication.
Thank you, Chair.
Dr. Marquez?
Thanks, sir, appreciate that.
Hey, Tom, good job, first of all.
I have a couple questions for you regarding Fairbox and other sources of revenue.
I think we were quoted $88 million.
I just want to make sure, is that obtainable?
We're not going to be second-guessed at the last minute.
We've got to make adjustments, but that's something that we feel very strongly that
we'll be able to achieve about $88 million.
Yes.
I'm comfortable with that forecast, spent a lot of time with it, and analyzed it eight
different ways over the course of the year.
And so we've really looked at what the fuel impacts are,
what the fair increases are,
and then sort of what's the underlying organic growth.
So, yeah, I feel good about it as good as anybody can.
I mean, it is a bit of art and science.
Nobody can know the future for sure,
but I feel good about the approach, yes.
You're making me feel better, so thank you, I appreciate that.
Second question I have is about the Olympics also.
In LA-28, I know we're meeting with them.
Are we communicating with them, do we know exactly
what their expectations might be in the future?
Director Marquez, we have a group called
the Games Mobility Executives that involve,
it's the CEOs of the agencies as well as Caltrans,
LADOT, of course LA Metro.
It's been an ongoing iterative process
and the numbers that we started with
are not the numbers we're at today,
But those are also numbers that we're at today
that did not recognize the change in Congress
that may give us a chance to see our numbers refreshed
in a more, I'll call it positive direction,
but we don't know that yet.
And so that's why I think over the course
of the next three to six months,
the level of full court press in Washington
is gonna do that.
LA 28 has said our job is to deliver the games.
They have been reluctant to say that it is their job
to deliver funding for public transportation
to support workforce and attendees at the games.
So I'll leave it at that.
I'm optimistic in one sense in that we
have an opportunity right now in Washington DC
to see these numbers plussed back up to closer where
we had been a year ago.
Thank you.
Time will tell.
Thank you, sir.
My last question is basically the equipment itself, as far as we've had issues this past
year, breakdowns and so on, it will get supplies to keep our running stock working correctly.
So my question is, are we going to gear up for the Olympics, meaning that we're going
to get our stock at a higher level?
Yes, absolutely.
I think, Darren, you just mentioned that we are going through those rehabs and things
with all the equipment.
have as the maximum amount available that we can. The money is going to be in the budget to do this.
Yes. Thank you. Director Tremblay. I would only add that that is a good practice for Metrolink
to have in general. It is not, because of LA-28, we need our equipment in a good state of repair,
regardless of whether the world's coming to Southern California or not. So that has
been our direction is to make sure our fleet is ready to go regardless of the circumstance.
Director Trevley go ahead. Thanks Mr. Chair, so as one of the members of the
ad hoc, LA 28 ad hoc committee, mercifully I'm not going to talk about LA 28 today,
but I reserve that right to talk about it in the future, but I was going to
bring this up later, but it actually has to do from a budget process standpoint.
There were three motions that I made in June that were unanimously adopted by
this board, and we're going to consider one of them under 8D, under fair changes
and annual looking at that, but there were two others.
One was on having staff bring us structural,
suggestions for structural changes to the presentation
and preparation adoption of the budget.
And I think maybe that question has already been answered,
but I am curious to know on that point,
whether or not we're going to see something.
The motion, I think, was to have something by December.
But the other part of it was,
And this was ours issue.
If I recall correctly, the consideration of rollover
and surplus funds, year over year.
And I think we need to look at that.
So finally coming to the question,
when is staff intending on bringing those items
to the board?
Those are both agendized for December.
Oh, I could have just asked that question.
I would have loved to have done it sooner,
but I thought this budget would be adopted by September.
You could have entered to be on that one time.
Yes, we'll get that to you.
Okay, thank you.
Questions?
I just like to thank staff for the tremendous work
they did in going through eight different scenarios.
That was a lot of stress, and you came through it fine,
and I hope that we're at a solution point.
Directors, the public hearing has been closed.
We've asked all our questions.
I move to approve.
Move to approve.
Second.
And a second.
Any objection?
Seeing none, the budget is approved.
Thank you for your presentation.
Thank you.
We'll go on to 8B, we're talking about some proposed employee reclassifications
which include salary adjustments, and Alberto and Laura who we call our Chief People Officer.
Sir.
Good morning Chair Chafee, members of the Board.
I'm here to request that the Board considers our proposal to reclassify several employees
in the organization and accordingly adjust their compensation.
Next slide please.
As background, we're doing this based on HR policy 2.1.
This is a process that my staff started back in March of 2025.
It was decided that we would align this request
with what happened today, the adoption of the FY27 budget,
and that's why it's taken us this long to bring this item
to your attention.
HR policy 2.1 is very specific in that we are
to conduct periodic reviews of our salary
and compensation, as well as our classification plans.
That is what my staff engaged in to arrive
at the recommendation that we're making to you today.
Next slide, please.
So, as I mentioned, this was started back in March of 2025.
We received 44 requests by our fine staff to be reclassified.
My staff engaged in its due diligence,
and we analyzed each one of the requests.
We spoke to the chain of command of the requesting employees.
We checked in with the chiefs of the divisions
that they belong to, and we arrived at the recommendation
to move forward with 28 employees.
So, not all 44 were successfully moved ahead.
As part of this reclassification process,
we also are calling upon 6.0 HR policy regarding
reclassification.
That policy says that if I move somebody to a higher grade,
I will also consider a higher pay grade,
and that is what's happening with 28 of these employees.
Next slide please.
As a bundle, two of my colleagues, Chief of Technology
and the Chief of Customer Experience,
reorganized their departments.
And that resulted in us having to reclassify some
of those employees, and they will also receive some
of them, 5% increase in their salary, only 4 of the 11 will be receiving
that as a result of the reorganizations.
Lastly, the finance and strategy divisions collectively requested
that we look at three employees in their divisions.
We did that, and we are requesting
that these three employees be reclassified.
The result of the analysis is that they are working
at higher levels than their current classification.
Next slide, please.
So in summary, we are proposing to reclassify 42 employees.
We are proposing salary adjustments
for 35 employees, between 5 and 10%.
The cost is $267,601.
That is included in the budget that you just approved.
These changes would become effective retroactively
to July 1 of 2026.
Next question or next slide please.
So, my recommendation is that the board approve the proposed
employee reclassifications and the salary adjustments
that go along with those reclassifications.
Next slide please.
That concludes my presentation and I'm happy
To answer any questions questions
And the clerk any public comments
Not on this item. Thank you
They have a motion
You can second the objection I was approved. Thank you sir for your present. Thank you all
All right
to item 8c
talking about
pair and return of wheelsets and we call gearboxes and
there's a
Recommendation award a contract when you hear from wardrobe tour bar a manager of inventory control
Morning chair chief members of the board
Next slide, please
locomotive and passenger car wheels wore over time
to keep
Rolling stuck in service the worn-out wheels are
Replaced with rebuild ones
Those rebuild those worn-out wheel sets are then sent to a qualified supplier
who presses on new wheelsets, who qualifies them according to our internal specifications
and FRA requirements.
So contract number EP25427 will allow the materials management department to ship out
worn out axles to that qualified supplier, get those new wheelsets pressed on and ship
back to us to keep in stock to make sure that they're available when you are needed by our
maintenance contractor. Next slide, please. An invitation for bid was issued by the contracts
department on April 7, 2026. Two bids were received by the deadline with UTC being the
lowest bidder. They came in at about 35% below our independent cost estimate. That bid was
found fair and reasonable. Next slide please. So it is recommended that the board authorize
the CEO to award a contract number EP254-27 to UTC Ras Inc. for the repair and return of
of locomotive and car wheelsets and locomotive gearboxes
for a not to exceed amount of $7,326,433
for a base term of three years
with a single two year option exercise
the discretion of the CEO.
And this recommendation is subject to resolution
and timely filed protests.
Next slide please.
That is my presentation
and I'll be happy to answer any questions.
Questions, directors.
When there's a 35% difference,
I kind of get a little alarmed
that there was something missing in their bid
or something, that's a large discrepancy.
Was our independent high for a reason?
Were they coming in with some great prices?
I just don't want to have something
change that whole process.
It always alarms me when there's that big of a gap.
Yeah, so there was, especially in the gearbox repairs,
we had previous quotes that were much higher
than they came in, but they are reasonable
because we did have one supplier repair
one of those gearboxes around the bid price.
But we had increased our bid or our estimate
because of that other quote.
So we're not sure what's gonna be the winner
and kind of increased our estimate.
So that.
You're comfortable with this person?
Yes.
Yes.
Okay.
Thank you.
Any more questions?
Yes.
Thank you Mr. Chair.
So thanks for your response to Director Spiegel.
But same issue when you have something 35% below the ICE
are you satisfied that because this is our rolling stock are you satisfied that
the contractor is in a position to return those sets to us based on the
required timeline yes so and I don't even talk about la-28 but we need it we
need them so I want to know that they're gonna I want to know that you're
satisfied that we're this isn't gonna be strong yeah they're not gonna get
strung out over a long period of time,
particularly given the low amount of the bid.
And we did include some liquided damages
into the scope of work, where they're
required to return those wheelsets within a certain time
frame or start getting penalized every week
that they're late.
And the suppliers, a well-known supplier,
I mean they were our supplier recently.
So we're just, yeah.
Thank you.
I see none.
May I have a motion?
Moved?
Moved and second?
Objection?
That is approved.
Thank you for your presentation.
Now we come to AD where we talk about annual consideration
of fair changes.
We have one public speaker.
Madam Chair, would you call that person?
Peter W.
I know the current fair adjustments
are only about a month and a half old,
but how much new revenue have we generated
from the increase of the senior disabled daily pass
from $750 to $950 for Monday through Friday service
and $5 to $6 for weekends, and how much additional revenue
do we plan to generate?
Because we need to think about these things for not only
our regular operation, but Super Bowl for the 2028 Olympic
Games, where we're going to have events on the world stage.
We want to have our fair system be
understandable to out-of-town visitors
and our machines being working properly.
I had trouble putting a $10 bill in your machine
at Fullerton because of the rain this morning.
It took five tries, but I'm here because the machine
underneath the elevator on track one, the dollar bill
acceptor was slightly damp.
So they need to get out when we're
going to have these weather systems and clean off
and at least try to dry off the machine
so you don't have people getting their bills rejected.
With OC Streetcar opening in Santa Ana,
perhaps maybe adding some ad wraps onto the three routes
serving Orange County to promote that service
might help us bring Orange County service back up
to the pre-service cut level, because now you're
going to have a connecting train in Santa Ana
for people that work at the courthouse
and other employers within the downtown Santa Ana area.
Thank you, Mr. Warner.
At this point, we would like a presentation
from Henry Eichler, our senior manager
for market insights and analytics.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the board.
Today's item responds to a board request
for a board policy for an annual review of fairs.
This will allow the board to consider fairs
more predictably, alongside service levels,
operating costs, and available funding.
Next slide, please.
Last month, Metrolin graced fares
for the first time in 13 years.
When the board approved the fare increase on June 26,
members expressed concern about the 13-year interval
between increases and the impact
of larger adjustments on riders.
Board members called for a regular consideration of fairs
and the chair specifically supported an annual review.
An annual review, as recommended,
will give the board an opportunity
to consider smaller, more timely adjustments
while balancing affordability, ridership, service needs,
and financial sustainability.
Next slide, please.
As requested by the Board, staff recommends the Board approve
the following amendment to Metrolinx Fair Policy.
The Board will consider potential changes to fares
as part of the annual budget development process.
This review will consider budget requirements
and the share of operating expenses
that are covered by fare revenue.
The amendment establishes an annual review process
As part of this annual review, staff will bring to the board
an agenda item with an assessment of fair performance,
including revenue and ridership results,
and any recommended fair changes
for consideration during the budget development.
The board will retain the discretion
to maintain existing fares or approve adjustments
based on that assessment.
Next slide, please.
Also like to mention that the preliminary results from the October fair increase are encouraging
Our fair revenue has exceeded the forecast and the estimated ridership decline
Associated with the increase was approximately half the projected decline
Staff will return to the board in March with the full assessment of the October fair increase
based on several months of data and any recommended fair adjustment for
consideration during the development of the FY 28 budget
today staff requests approval of the fair policy amendment to
Establish this annual review that completes my presentation
Thank you, mr. Eichler. Are there questions? Yes, go ahead. Mr. Fumbly. Thanks, mr. I apologize to my colleagues for asking so many questions today
Thank you, Director Spiegel. I'm quoting from 7.1, the Metrolink Board will
consider potential changes to fares as part of the annual budget development
process. When in that development process will this occur? We will come to the
board in March. So it will it will be March when you come to the board on I
just want to share I heard you correctly it will be in March of next year that
that you'll be coming back to the board for consideration.
Okay, all right, and that's gonna include Fairbox.
The data backing that up, Hennig will,
and by the way, thank you again for the presentation.
The data backing that up is going to be Fairbox recovery,
range of fair options, projected impacts to revenue,
ridership, et cetera.
There'll be a data set accompanying that
so we can look at that in context.
Yes it will report on the performance of the past of the October fair increase
just to see whether or not it has performed as expected and based on that
performance we will make recommendations whether or not an adjustment to fairs a
further adjustment in fairs would be needed got it thank you thank you mr.
questions I think this is important item we can't go 13 years not look at our
of her structure, and I will get to her if I, once in a while, get a word in.
Director Spiegel is my classmate on the CSOC, and so we kind of have this back
and forth once in a while. Anyway, I do appreciate you. So we just can't go 13
years and the consideration changes. It could be up or down. It's not necessarily always
an increase. And I hope we look at the different kinds of events we may have, especially event.
Are we charging a proper fare for that? Olympics are coming up. Maybe that should have a different
fare schedule than our normal ridership. All those kinds of things, I hope, are part of
of the consideration.
Sorry, Director Spiegel.
You took my words.
I was asked by several folks in different areas
if we were going to increase like other countries have
for the Olympics.
I guess that's a standard thing.
I don't know if you've researched that,
but it's a standard that they increase their transportation
fees when someone else hosts an Olympics.
So I was just curious if that was even thought about.
Well, that option is definitely on the table.
A definite decision has not been made.
And that is something we would bring to the board.
Same thing.
Thank you.
All right.
We'll move to.
I'll second this one.
Thank you.
Any objection?
I don't pass this.
Thank you for your presentation.
Now we come to our first quarter, customer experience update.
We do have one public speaker, Mr. Warner.
I've always wanted to know how mental link is doing
with this particular subject.
I've been writing the service since Orange County Line Service
started in March 17, 1994, and Oceanside was introduced
as the maximum destination in the system.
So what are we expecting to gain from this
as we look forward to two major international events
and the opening of Orange County Streetcar
and the possibility of several thousand
new Santa Ana boardings.
Thank you, Mr. Warner.
All right, this is a report, generally presented
by Jose Hernandez, and again, Mr. Eichel.
Eichel will be back.
Thank you.
In this item, we will provide the board
with an update on our marketing initiatives
during the first quarter and related performance results.
Next slide please.
Next slide please.
During the first quarter,
we have seen strong ridership growth.
Ridership was up 11% from a year ago,
supported by both World Cup travel
and high gasoline prices.
That ridership increase was mirrored
in the number of new mobile accounts,
which grew by 12% year over year.
Mobile ticket adoption continued to grow
and reach 64% in Q1, that is up two points from a year ago.
We have also seen an increase in repeat ridership,
which is a measure of ridership retention
and is defined as new riders who travel
more than one day per year.
Total fare revenue during Q1 was up 7.4% from a year ago
and revenue from our corporate partner program
grew by 12% year over year.
Finally, our after-ride customer survey found a steep decline in customer
satisfaction driven primarily by decline in service reliability. That is based on
more than 4,000 customer survey responses received during Q1. Next slide, please.
And I will hand this over to my colleague. I'm slightly shorter than you're
I have to readjust.
Good morning, Board Chair.
Good morning, members of the board.
My name is Jose Hernandez.
I'm the senior manager of marketing here at Metrolink.
And I will be speaking to our marketing results for quarter
one.
Our strongest result in quarter one
was by far among existing student writers.
During this quarter, we had our back to school campaign,
which resulted in a 24% increase year over year
in student boardings, which exceeded our 5% goal.
as a result of this campaign.
Also, we noticed an uptick in student monthly pass purchases,
an increase of 45%, which indicated
a shift towards more value and also indicating
more frequent travel among students.
First time student purchases did hold steady,
so our next round of outreach will put more emphasis
on getting new students to take the train
and take that first trip.
We're also working with the Department
of Public Social Services.
this is a new partnership for us,
to better reach low-income riders
who have California EBT cards,
to better inform them of the EBT mobility
for all discount that is available to that demographic.
And we are also preparing targeted outreach
to bring back lapsed riders where their service,
where our service will meet their needs.
Next slide, please.
All right.
I will speak to our CX Innovation and Partnerships
achievements during Q1.
The corporate partner program generated $1.45 million
in ticketing revenue, which is up 12% compared to last year.
This was supported in part largely by our partnerships
with IE Commuter out in Riverside and San Bernardino counties.
Sponsorships and special events generated another $88,000
in cash, in-kind support, and event revenue.
We also secured a new three-year renewal
with Insomniac events to continue offering
special train service to their events
out in San Marino County.
And for everyday trips, we launched a refreshed mobile app
in conjunction in partnership with our freight collections
team.
The new refreshed app makes it easier for customers
to plan a trip and to buy their tickets
and manage their travel within the Metrolink mobile app.
Next slide, please.
On the service communications and safety side,
Safety was a primary focus of our communications during Q1,
during our precautionary service suspensions
down in South Orange County.
We worked with local media to explain
why service was paused down there
and what our writers needed to know.
Those interruptions garnered a lot of media interest.
As you can see, it was a very visual story
that generated 774 media mentions for Metrolink,
including some earned media and TV interviews
by Metrolink spokespeople.
During Rail Safety Month, which was in September,
we also reinforced safe behavior around the trains
and promoted the launch of our new app,
the Metrolink SafeRide app,
including through Spanish language media
to let customers know of this new method
to report any safety or security concerns
that they found on the train or on the platforms.
Next slide please.
And I'm going to wrap up with a quick recap
of customer concerns during the first quarter.
On-time performance complaints were still top on the list,
even though the number of complaints
was down 37% from last year.
Prisoner complaints increased by 56%,
driven by stepped-up fare inspections
and policy enforcement actions.
But we also heard from paying customers
who have told us they wanted to see more fare enforcement.
And I also want to point out our customers appreciate
our employees.
19 out of 21 commendations recognized employees
for going above and beyond.
And our conductors received the highest satisfaction
ratings of all service aspects measured.
Feedback like this is important.
And we use it to improve service and reduce pain points
for our customers.
Major focus during the second quarter
the transition to a new call center provider which will greatly improve
service to our customers and that completes my presentation questions I
see none this is a receiving file act item there's no action required so let's
move on to at item 8f which is our November legislative event mr. Dunn you
have a lot of new faces to cultivate thank you very much chair chafee
members of the board. Next slide please. In state matters as has been discussed
and previously noticed to the board, Metrolink was earlier this month awarded
20 million dollars from cycle 2 of the flexible state rail assistance program
that will allow it to avert substantial service cuts that otherwise would have
taken effect beginning of the next year and for the foreseeable future.
Metrolink was the only rail operator in the state to receive its full requested
award from the program, underscoring the exigency of our need.
I would like to shout out my boss, if I may.
Our CEO, Mr. Kettle, has been a tireless advocate
for the railroad in Sacramento this year,
first calling attention to this critical need for operating
funds in spring and throughout the year
with the state transportation agency and with state lawmakers.
We always knew it would be extraordinarily difficult
to get a legislative set aside of operations fund
from the state budget process.
We're profoundly grateful to the state for recognizing ours
and the needs of all passenger rail operators in the state
in making available these flexible
state rail assistance funds.
We're also extremely grateful to each of our member agencies
and the nearly 60 legislators, universities, business groups,
labor organizations, advocacy groups,
and others that sent support letters to CalSTA
for our application, all of which
contributed to its success.
To each, you know who you are.
we sincerely thank you.
We're also working with the California Transit Association
on strategy and long-range planning
to secure a stable source of operations funding for transit
and for passenger rail in anticipation
of the day these funds expire.
At the CTA fall conference held last month in Monterey,
it adopted its legislative platform for 2027,
which includes transit operations funding
as a priority objective.
And we will support and work with CTA
to provide updated, timely data to support the need
for both capital and operations funding in 2027
with the new administration.
We will keep you apprised of these efforts next year
as that process unfolds.
Moving to the election, on November 3rd,
the great majority of the Metrolink delegation
in the Senate and Assembly were re-elected
with a few exceptions.
In the Senate, Ben Allen of Santa Monica
ran for higher office and Brian Goldsmith
won election to that Senate seat.
Sarah Hernandez won election
the Senate District 26 seat vacated by Maria Elena Durazo, who became LA
County Board of Supervisor for District 1. Senator Hernandez's district
encompasses as much of Central and East Los Angeles. In Orange County, Senator
Tom Unberg ran for higher office and Avellino Valencia won that seat, which
represents Northern Orange County and a small unincorporated area of LA
County. Finally, in Senate District 36, which covers portions of both Orange and
in LA counties, Senator Tony Strickland was defeated
by Chris Duncan in a close race.
In the assembly, all MetroLink delegation members
were reelected but six, either due to retirement,
term limits, seeking other elected office
or election outcome.
These are Tom Lackey in Assembly District 34,
representing parts of Kern, LA and San Bernardino counties,
is succeeded by Charles Frederick Hughes.
Jeff Gonzalez in Assembly District 36,
representing Imperial and portions of Riverside
and San Bernardino counties,
is succeeded by Ida Obezo Martinez.
Jackie Irwin of Assembly District 42,
representing Ventura and portions of L.A. County
is succeeded by Deborah Klein Lopez.
Leticia Castillo in Assembly District 58,
representing portions of Riverside
and San Bernardino counties,
is succeeded by Clarissa Cervantes.
Sharon Quirk Silva in Assembly District 67,
representing North Orange in LA counties,
is succeeded by Mark Palito,
and Valeno Valencia in Assembly District 68
representing Orange County,
is succeeded by Jesse Lopez.
Next slide, please.
At the federal level,
the larger than expected turnover in seats
in both the House and Senate does not materially affect
Metrolinx advocacy priorities addressed in your report.
The railroad will continue to push
with the American Public Transportation Association
and others in the transit ecosystem.
Restoration of the advanced appropriations provided
by the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act or IJA,
authorizing law into the next federal funding bill
to extend or replace the continuing resolution
under which the federal government is operating,
which expires December 11th.
Beyond the numbers cited in your report,
Metrolink generated 5307 formula funds,
which broadly fund public transportation projects
in urbanized areas are unaffected
by the lack of advanced appropriations.
But 53-37 formula funds, which fund the state of good repair,
take about a 20% hit by their exclusion.
In addition, federal discretionary grant programs
supporting passenger rail are reduced substantially
without these advanced appropriations.
Thus, we will advocate vigorously for the restoration
in the FY2027 appropriations bill when it is considered.
As for the federal election results,
since preparation of your report,
Congressman Ken Calvert has been declared the winner.
over Congresswoman Young Kim in the congressional district 40
race, representing Eastern Orange County and Western
and Southwestern Riverside County.
The only other metro link congressional delegation race
not yet called is district 23, representing principally
the high desert with portions of Kern, LA, and Riverside
counties, where incumbent Congressman Jay Obernolte
maintains a 1.8% lead over challenger Tessa Hodge,
with 95% of the votes counted.
Other changes in delegation membership
are noted in your report.
That concludes my presentation.
I'm happy to answer any questions.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Questions?
Yes, go ahead.
I have a question.
The email that we got said 28.97 million,
but all throughout this whole meeting,
all I've heard was the 20 million.
Can you explain where this delta is,
or is that a mistake?
No, there's actually two different grants.
I was gonna touch on it during my remarks,
but since you raised it, Vice Chair Bergson,
so the 20 million is from CalSTA
for the purposes of the operations of our service
that allows us to continue operations
at our current service levels.
The nearly $29 million grant, also from CalSTA,
comes from a different bucket.
It's the TIRCP bucket, and that is specific
to another initiative that we started the pilot project
on on the San Bernardino line, contactless payment,
where you pay with credit card or your phone.
We prevailed, received the full grant allocation from CalSTA,
nearly $29 million, to implement contactless payment
throughout our system.
There's some other technology elements.
And again, I was going to tip my hat to our customer experience
team and Lisa Barr and our chief of technology, Kevin Gray,
for pushing this initiative.
We will be the only railroad in the United States
distance fare based that will have contactless payment
throughout our system.
And we will have it before the Olympics.
That's great.
Right, guys?
Yes, all right.
Yeah.
All right, more questions?
Thank you being on top of all the new people coming in and I'm sure you'll have a lot
of cups of coffee or something else.
Thank you for your good work.
All right, now we do come to our CEO.
Very good.
Thanks.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Since I just got one or two of those items out of the way, yes, very excited about the
$29 million grant.
It has been a successful pilot on the San Bernardino line and it's been a learning experience
all the way through on it.
So we're looking forward to having that available.
Earlier this week was at the Commuter Rail Coalition's
annual summit, our 32-31 sister railroads there.
And I was able to share this news about this grant.
And we talk about contactless payment
in a system that is distance based.
It's not normal.
And so the fact that we're innovating in this
is a really, really cool thing that we're doing.
So looking forward to seeing how that all plays out.
Obviously great thanks to all of you member agencies across the board, as Mr. Dunn indicated,
on the $20 million allocation from CalSTA.
I don't believe that program would have been put in place were it not for our advocacy
over the last year telling the story about our challenge.
And I think it played out because of the short – the very short window we had to submit
applications and the extraordinarily short response it took for CalSTA to award us our
full ask.
So our advocacy paid off.
My thanks to the budget and finance team for going so far above what should have ever been
expected of anybody to deliver a budget that you approved today, Board.
So thank you to Tom, Christine Wilson and Joanna Olmos.
The whole team is involved in it.
But Tom and Christine, we missed her hat today, by the way.
Christine Wilson's hat.
But please, my thanks guys, you were amazing.
Lastly, yesterday, I was able to participate
in a meeting with Senator Katherine Blakespear.
Katherine Blakespear represents South Orange County
and North San Diego County and has been a champion
for the low sand corridor.
She requested that we share our progress
on being prepared for El Nino, Super El Nino,
and I was able to tell our story about our preparations
for the amount of ballast, riprap, track inspections,
what we most recently did in the last week and a half
where we literally raised our track,
lifted our track through San Clemente up a few inches
so that we will try to avoid water intrusion
on our track system that can really,
that can trigger a signal issue,
which means we have to run slow trains.
That was done by Luis Carrasquero's team,
our deputy chief operating officer,
and Herzog, our contractor, to make that all happen
so that we have even better preparation
for the Super El Nino.
So far, it's working.
We will be tested, I think, in the next couple of days
with this weather that we're dealing with,
but we will certainly be tested
as we look towards the Super El Nino.
Great. Senator Blakespear appreciated where we are,
the level of work we put into it to be prepared
as much as we can be given the unknowns.
Mr. Chair, that's it, wraps up my remarks.
Thank you.
Thank you, and particularly thank you
for all that you've done and working at Sacramento,
and yes, dealing with the five member agencies
and all their budgets,
and that was quite an accomplishment
and somewhat stressful, I think.
But, oh yeah, okay.
And also staff, just going through this,
it's been difficult, but it's been a learning experience.
I think we're ahead of the game as we go forward
because of that experience.
And I say thanks to staff for the birthday remembrance.
And we also have Director McCallum,
I think you've got a cake too, so happy birthday to you.
With that my favorite sentence, we are adjourned.