the city council. They didn't
councilmember Riley vice mayor gee here and mayor Iverson here and I'll ask you
all to stand please for the Pledge of Allegiance
of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation
under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you we did have a
closed session tonight and there were no reportable actions. The next item is to adopt the agenda.
I will move we adopt the agenda with no changes. City Manager, is there anything you're aware of?
Mayor, I have no changes to the agenda. Thank you. Do we have a second? I'll second it. All in favor?
Aye. And we have an agenda. With that, we'll start with items for the good of the city. We
have a few tonight, starting with E1, the recognition of the first graduating class
of how Arinda works our Citizens Academy.
Okay, Mayor and Council Members, we have Cole Hayslip coming up. Cole, there you go,
to present the first graduating class.
Mayor, Council Members, I am so very pleased to present the first graduating class of How,
how Arundah works. This was a six week long course where we tried to teach about 30 residents
how Arundah works. Everything from planning to public works to our police department and we were
so happy to also have some of our partner agencies participate as well. MOFD, East Bay Mudd,
Central San Republic and Recycle Smart all participated in this program.
Right now I'm going to ask the Howe graduates to come up to the center of our stage, and
my hope is that we'll be able to take a photo with the City Council and our graduating class
before allowing them to share about their experience.
I was going to read the names but I don't have the name list, do we have that handy?
I think we may have left that.
I apologize.
We'll go straight to the photo.
Yes.
I'm going to ask my fellow council members to come on down.
We're going to do a big group photo.
What is the chief?
No, please, please, please.
What's up?
You're going to be there, right?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
The chief.
I'm on Facebook.
I actually put people in charge.
Yeah.
We'll get back to you.
Oh, everybody came.
Look at this.
So excited.
I know.
We've taken a photo.
We'll do the photo.
It's me, yeah. And we'll get them off to you guys. Yeah.
Cole, would you like to go ahead and do our presentation?
Yeah, so there's no presentation tonight,
just an invitation for any of the Howe graduates,
if they would like to come and give any public comment on the program,
their experience, any feedback, that would be appreciated.
Hello. My name is John Chobalco and I'm a resident of Orinda, of course.
I was able to attend the Howe-Orinda work sessions for the last six weeks,
and I thought two things about them really.
I wanted to thank Cole for the work they did on.
I did a great job coordinating all of this.
And I'll speak for myself.
I thought that all of the sessions were very informative.
It was really great to kind of see, I mean,
I don't know what we missed, if we missed anything.
I feel like I got the full experience of everything
that happens kind of behind the scenes around Arinda, which
I thought was great.
I thought it was very informative.
I appreciated it.
I hope a lot of people take up this opportunity
when it comes up again.
and please just come on up and introduce yourselves.
Hi, James Blaisdell.
I also was privileged to be part of the program.
Appreciate all the work on behalf of the staff.
I've also been on the traffic safety advisory committee
for about a year and a half.
So this certainly helped expand my knowledge
of how ARINDA works and all the critical people.
And I think I pretty much knew this already,
but this program really reinforced it.
We have a real small lean staff in this city
and they work really hard
and they do the very best they can
with the limited time they have and manpower.
So I'm very appreciative of that.
Thank you.
Thank you.
I'd also just comment that a lot of the participants
are on our commissions and committees
and one of one or two of them are campaigning right now.
So it's fun for us to get to see people
that we might know through one thing
and see them get to know the whole city picture.
Please go ahead.
Hello, my name is Hula Vera, and I'm a high school student.
And it was really cool learning about Arinda
because I've been living here for multiple years,
basically my whole life.
And it was just really cool knowing about how the city works
because I never really knew, I just lived here.
But it's really cool to understand
what's actually going on behind the scenes.
Thank you.
Hi, good evening, Judith Santos.
And I've been a Arinda resident for about,
however old she is, 15 years.
So thank you so much for investing in this community leadership program.
It not only helps us learn how the city works,
but it also strengthens your civic infrastructure that leads to meaningful community engagement.
So thank you again for this investment as a community capacity building program.
Thank you. Was there anybody else?
That was a perfect segue.
I would mention that commission and committee recruiting happens in the month of February.
So for any of you who are interested in continuing or doing more,
please be on the lookout for those commission and committee interviews. Um,
and if there's no one else from the public,
I'll see if people from the city council, uh, Dias, have any comments.
I just want to thank everyone for participating.
And as we all know,
Arinda runs on volunteers and a very lean staff that work very hard.
And it really takes a village to make Arinda as wonderful a place to live as it
And I love having programs like this that do develop the infrastructure and the people who can come up and serve our city and and help make it the wonderful place to live it is so thank you all for participating it means a lot to all of us.
Echoing those thoughts, of course, and also I know that, you know, there's a lot of you here tonight
I recognize a lot of familiar faces as our mayor pointed out is as
like us volunteers who are deeply engaged and care a lot about Arinda and you know, so
Aside from coming up to the podium and telling us what you think
I just want to encourage everyone who's been through this program in addition to thanking you tremendously
including the young people there.
I was very impressed, Sylvia, that you did this,
to share, you know, your thoughts,
because this is an inaugural program.
So what did you like?
What could we do better?
Just please share with us.
You could do that via email or when you see us.
Well, I will certainly echo my thanks as well.
I know that in today's world,
time is probably the most precious commodity any of us have,
So the fact that you were willing to spend your time,
it's just really meaningful.
It's meaningful to all of us.
And I agree with my colleagues.
I hope that if it was a good experience,
you'll encourage others to attend in the future.
And if there's things we could do better,
I hope that you'll share that with us as well
because it is really good for us to help people
in the community better understand our community.
So thank you again.
I'll just add that I think it's really exciting
that we've launched this program.
I feel that with the information you all have gained
that you will feel more and more in love
with our beautiful Orinda, and happy to do more
because you understand more.
And the more you put into something,
the more you get out of it.
So I look forward to seeing you all volunteer elsewhere.
Okay, can I say one more thing?
I forgot to, if I recall correctly,
I think maybe this program was the brainchild
of our incredible city manager Linda Smith,
and certainly as we're hearing from the participants,
was implemented beautifully by Cole.
So thank you both.
Thank you.
If I could just thank Cole again
for putting in the extra amount of time
that it took to put this on,
and I know that we're looking forward
to doing another session,
probably in a different time of the year
to make sure we get the most participation.
And just to remind all of the recent graduates
of how that we have upcoming commission
and committee recruitments.
And in your new Arinda Way,
which probably has landed in your mailbox recently,
there is a QR code in the back
and you can learn all about encouraging you to apply
to present a statement of interest that you'd like to serve.
We see this program as a pipeline for people
who may ultimately want to sit up at the dais one day.
and we'd love to have you join us
on commissions and committees.
Thank you.
Yeah, thank you again.
It was really a privilege getting to meet you all
and looking forward to seeing more of you.
With that, we'll move on to E2,
a proclamation declaring October, 2026
as Breast Cancer Awareness Month.
Do we have our theme photo?
I will start by reading the proclamation.
We have a fun visual for tonight.
The Miramati women's volleyball team
went all out with the Dig in Pink program.
They even had the boys team
wearing pink t-shirts in the stands.
It was a terrific effort and a really nice way
to raise awareness for this important issue.
I will read the proclamation.
Whereas for nearly four decades,
the country has recognized October
as National Breast Cancer Awareness Month.
And whereas it is a time annually devoted
to educating everyone about breast cancer,
including metastatic breast cancer,
the importance of early detection
and access to timely high quality care.
And whereas one in eight women will be diagnosed
with breast cancer in her lifetime.
And whereas men can also get breast cancer
and an estimated 2,670 men will be diagnosed
with invasive breast cancer in the United States this year.
And whereas early detection through regular screening,
self-exams and awareness of personal
and family health history significantly increases
the chances of successful treatment and survival.
I'm not gonna read the whole thing,
but now therefore I declare October 2026
as Breast Cancer Month in the city of Arinda
and encourage all residents to learn about the risks,
symptoms, and importance of early detection.
Participate in local and national efforts
to advance research and stand with all individuals
and families impacted by breast cancer,
offering compassion, understanding, and hope.
Oh, with that, I'll see if anybody from the public
or the council would like to say any words.
with that we will move on to item E3 proclamation declaring October 4th
through 10th of 2026 as fire prevention week in the city of Orinda now I know
what you're thinking every week in Orinda is fire prevention week but this
is a very specific thing that our fire agency does to talk about a specific
issue where they want to raise awareness and for this year it's about battery
related fires and injuries so I am going to read it because the whole point
is to raise awareness on this very important issue. Whereas fire remains a
serious public safety concern both locally and nationally and the presence
of lithium ion batteries in many household devices introduces unique fire
risks and whereas safe charging practices are essential to preventing
battery related fires injuries and property loss and whereas using only
manufacturer-approved chargers and cords, avoiding cheap or off-brand alternatives,
prevents battery damage and reduces the risk of fire, and whereas charging
devices on hard flat surfaces instead of soft materials helps prevent
overheating caused by trapped heat and reduced air flow, and whereas unplugging
devices once fully charged reduces heat buildup and stress on batteries, and
whereas charging large battery-powered equipment such as e-bikes, scooters, and
power tools outside and away from exits helps prevent rapid growing fires caused by high
capacity battery failures.
And whereas safe charging is especially important during air travel, requiring passengers to
keep devices visible while charging and promptly report any signs of battery malfunction.
And whereas fire prevention week 2026 highlights the importance of making smart choices every
time we plug in, reinforcing that safe charging is a superpower.
And whereas the 2026 fire prevention week theme, charge into fire safety, safe charging
is a superpower, focuses on the everyday charging habits that can help reduce the risk of lithium
ion battery fires and keep homes and communities safe.
Now therefore, we proclaim October 4th through 10th as fire prevention week throughout the
city of Orinda.
And I wondering if we have someone here to say a few words tonight?
The mayor, he's on his way.
There's a little bit of confusion.
So he's on his way, but he's not here yet too.
The fire chief is going to say a few words.
So we might have him pop in during a public forum or thereabouts.
Would anybody else like to make any comments?
Thank you, Mayor.
Can I tell everybody to, if you haven't already done it, to pull out your phones, charge your
eyes over to a reindeerady.com and go to get alerts and sign up for Nixl and CWS and Watch
Duty if you haven't already done so.
Which is a wonderful segue, if there are no more comments, to item E4, the presentation
on community warning system by Lorena Herrera, the Contra Costa County Alert and Warning
Program Manager.
Good evening, my name is Lorena Herrera and I'm the Community Warning System Manager for
Contra Costa County's Community Warning System.
I appreciate the opportunity today to talk a little bit about Community Warning System
and give a program overview for the council.
Is there a clicker?
Oh yes, I can pull it down.
Is that better?
Okay.
We need this forward, read this back.
Okay, perfect.
Thank you.
All right to give it a little bit of an introduction the Contra Costa County's
community warning system is Contra Costa County's all-hazards alert warning
system. It's designed to alert the community of any emergency or disaster
that may be happening at their location. Our mission is to empower the community
to take informed action during emergencies through timely accurate
alerts, public education, and strong partnerships with local agencies. I
I was requested to provide an overview of how the system functions, but I also wanted
to give a little bit more insight onto our program functions.
The community warning system provides a coordinated whole community approach to alert and warning
by not only delivering timely, actionable alerts, but also by building public trust
through outreach and education efforts.
We also support our public safety agencies across all 19 jurisdictions in coordination
so that we are able to send out alerts to the public in a timely fashion that is accurate.
We also integrate with the Contra Costa County's Emergency Operations Center during large-scale
disasters so that we ensure that all alerts going out to the community across all of Contra
Costa is not only coordinated through the Emergency Operations Center but also
coordinated through our public information functions at the county level.
We conduct trainings to ensure that we are up to date with all system
capabilities but also we support jurisdictions across the county and any
type of exercise that they may be having at their jurisdiction. So for example,
if there was an evacuation exercise in which they would want to bring the
community warning system to support in you know testing the capability we
would support the local jurisdiction in in those endeavors. And also again our
role is really to sustain the county-wide alert warning capabilities so
that we are not just looking at certain areas of the county we're sustaining it
for all of Contra Costa County all 19 jurisdictions unincorporated and
incorporated. So what is our current status and readiness? So as you may all
know the 20 we the community warning system operate 24 hours a day, seven days
a week, 365 days a year. We maintain operations every day, every hour to make
sure that we are ready to send out alerts to the community in the event of
an emergency. We also have built-in redundancies that allow us to continue
setting out these alerts, should there be a time in which some of the technology falls
short?
As we know, when there is an emergency, technology is always the first thing to fall short, right?
So we at the county level make sure that there are multiple redundancies in place so that
we can continue to alert the community during these times.
We also ensure these redundancy by conducting routine testing and maintenance.
So we maintain our system, not just on when we are able to test it on a daily, weekly
and monthly timeframe to ensure that not only our process is in place to be able to send
out alerts, but also our technology is essentially top-notch so that when we get called to send
out an alert, we are able to do that effectively.
We've also standardized our countywide alerting process throughout all 19 jurisdictions.
There is one process that is designed to make sure that we get the accurate information
from the field and able to deliver that alert in a timely manner.
We have fully trained staff that issues accurate, timely alerts with the information that is
received from the field to the community.
And then we have a list here that you can see that are multiple alerting methods.
We have sirens, those don't really pertain to ARINDA because sirens are along the industrial
corridor of the county that have hazardous materials, facilities that alert the community
of any shelter in place.
But we do have phone, text, email.
We also tap into the integrated public alert and warning system, which is a federal system
that allows us to send out wireless emergency alerts, emergency alert system notifications,
As well as national weather service, weather radio notifications, should there be an event
in which other forms of communication are unavailable?
And our traditional website and social media, which all of our alerts are posted here, so
if there's ever any question as to whether the CWS had issued an alert, you will be able
to find that information on our website and social media.
There's been a lot of questions about how CWS sends out alerts.
So I wanted to make sure that we broke that down tonight.
I'm going to use a fire as an example.
I think that's the easiest example.
But when an incident occurs, such as a fire,
the public safety agency that is responsible for that incident,
whether that is a law enforcement or fire agency,
will request a CWS alert via our Sheriff's Office Dispatch
Center.
Our dispatchers are trained to take in this information
and call a CWS duty officer to confirm the details
of this critical, the critical details for the alert.
We will then communicate directly
with the public safety agency in the field
to confirm these critical details
so that we ensure that we have
not only the accurate information,
but the most up-to-date information.
And then once we have those details,
we are able to send that alert to the public
so that we make sure that the public can trust
what they're getting.
I know there's been questions about how long this takes,
so I wanted to break this down too.
So from the time that an incident occurs
to the time that our dispatch center is contacted,
that is very incident dependent.
That can go anywhere from zero to three plus hours
depending on the incident because the incident commander
or that public safety agency in the field
must determine that this incident rises to the level
in which the public must take protective action.
So we don't control this portion
of the CWS alert activation process.
We rely heavily on our law enforcement or fire agencies
to make that determination.
Once our dispatch center is contacted,
our policy and all of our duty officers are trained
to deliver a CWS alert within less than 15 minutes
or as fast as humanly possible.
All of our duty officers are trained.
We train, again, weekly, monthly, daily,
to make sure that our capabilities
are top-notch across the county.
So, once we have all of those critical details,
we've confirmed them.
We review this with the incident commander in the field.
We then send that alert out to the public.
And here's a representation of the notification tools
that get issued.
So essentially, we have all of these tools at our disposal
that I mentioned earlier.
We have Sirens, which, again, doesn't pertain to a render.
But I wanted to make sure that we covered all of the tools
here.
Phone, text, email, website, Facebook, X,
the wireless emergency alerts, the emergency alert system,
or NOAA weather radios.
When we get the confirmation of these critical details,
we send out these alerts through all of these avenues
simultaneously with essentially a click of a button.
So I wanted to make sure that you guys had this representation
here so that you guys could see how an alert is essentially
created and then sent out to the public.
So what type of alerts are you guys going to get?
So for a fire, which we were discussing earlier,
you're likely going to be receiving an evacuation order
or an evacuation warning.
If there is a hazardous materials incident,
we train our incident commanders across all 19 jurisdictions
to issue a shelter in place or request a shelter in place.
And then we, of course, have the capability
of issuing lockdowns, avoid the areas,
or even attempt to locate our risk-missing persons,
any type of law enforcement activity
that may require a protective action as well.
So why I'm here today.
So this is a good opportunity for us
not only to discuss the community warning system,
but also to continue to encourage our residents
to sign up for the community warning system.
I talked a little earlier about how we have the ability
to issue alerts to the wireless emergency alert system.
However, this is a limited capability
and we want to make sure that when we send out alerts
to all of our residents,
that they're not just getting it through one method,
they're getting it through multiple methods.
So when you're registered to the community warning system
and we issue an alert, you're gonna get that
as a phone call, you're gonna get that as a text message,
you're gonna get that as an email.
You're gonna see that across all of our social media
platforms in which you register.
And if you decide not to register
for the community warning system,
then we have actually a limited character capability
in which you're only getting 360 characters.
So we continue to encourage our residents
to register for community warning systems
so that you're getting significantly more information
with more incident details,
potentially even covering road closures.
If there are shelters already in place
and we've expanded areas of evacuation,
you're also going to be provided with that information.
So we continue to encourage our residents
to register for the community warning system
for these purposes.
So how to register?
Step one is essentially go to cwsalerts.com.
Council Member Mulcahney earlier
mentioned a community warning system,
So I really appreciate that.
We continue, again, to encourage our residents to register.
All you have to do is essentially
click on the Register to Receive Emergency Alerts
icon on our web page, and then complete a profile.
It should take no more than five to 10 minutes.
And you can register up to three phone numbers,
up to three emails, up to three addresses.
And what we see in many times is that our residents
are not only registering themselves,
but they're also registering their loved ones as well.
So if you haven't registered,
please register for the Community Warning System.
And then finally, looking ahead,
we continue to advance our system reliability and redundancy.
Again, this is an ongoing 365 days a year capability.
So as such, we need to make sure that we're continuing
to evaluate the reliability and redundancy of the system
to support our community.
We continue to strengthen our public's understanding
of the community warning system and opportunities
like the one we have today is a clear example
of how we participate in different forums
to strengthen that understanding.
We continue to encourage the boosting of,
we continue to boost our registrations
by encouraging residents to sign up
and explaining what the difference is
between getting registered and not getting registered.
And then we continue to refine our coordination
with public safety partners so that we are able to issue
these alerts in a timely fashion.
And then we also do, I didn't talk about that tonight,
but we have a whole training program in which we talk
to all of our 19 jurisdictions, law enforcement
and fire departments to continue educating them
on what their role is in activating
the community warning system is and what our role is
in delivering that information to the public.
And I think that is all.
So thank you very much and if you have any questions.
I'm sure we're gonna have plenty of questions.
I also have a number of speaker cards.
And so even though this isn't,
this is just an item for the good of the city,
I'm gonna use our usual format of we'll do questions first.
We'll take public comments
and then we'll come back up for comments again.
So any questions from the city council?
How do you test the system?
Is there a periodic schedule of testing
to make sure that it's working properly?
Yeah, so we have a couple of different layers
of testing that we do.
So for example, we test our sirens telemetry test.
We have a daily telemetry test.
We have a weekly, what we call growl test,
as well as a monthly full siren test
that we make sure that the technical
or the hardware technology of our system
is currently running.
We also have a different platform
in which we're able to test our WIA capabilities
to make sure that we are not only testing
those capabilities internally,
but we are also able to continue testing our duty officers
to make sure that they're getting that information
accurately out in a way that doesn't affect
the community on a day-to-day for the testing purposes,
but that we're able to continue training ourselves
to have those standards.
And how do you prevent things like a number of months ago, we all received a tsunami warning,
which was somewhat ridiculous since there was no way a tsunami was coming to Arrinda.
How do you prevent those sort of warnings going out that don't pertain to the area that's
receiving the warning?
So for the tsunami one, that was a very unique incident.
The county has taken measures to provide those recommendations back to the National Weather
Service, which were the ones that initiated those alerts.
Those alerts are not originated from the community warning system.
However, we continue to advocate for the National Weather Service to provide notification should
they issue alerts in Contra Costa County so that we are aware of them and can essentially
coordinate with them better so that things like that you know are prevented
in the future. I can't necessarily say that that won't happen again because
that isn't something that originated from the community warning system but
we definitely have ramped up not just the community warning system but the
county's Office of Emergency Services has ramped up their communication to
the National Weather Service to better coordinate those messaging. And the
coral area, I guess, is how do you make sure that pertinent
warnings get to the specific residents or homeowners that
need to know, for instance, if there was a fire that was a
threat to them, and not to the whole community. We don't want
everyone evacuating all at once if there's a specific area that
needs to leave.
Yeah, I'll go back to my process. If it's okay, I'll go
back to the the CWS alert activation process. Because
that's a really good question. So one of the things that we're essentially the
community warning system doesn't unilaterally make the decision to send
out an alert. It actually requires for the public safety agency that's
responsible for that is incident to request an alert from the community
warning system. So they determine the area that's affected, they determine what protective action
the community needs to take, and then if there are any shelters or road closures or things of
that nature, that is all determined by the field from our incident commanders. Thank you. I've
heard critiques right in the community that there are times when folks in the past did not get
And I think this was probably specific to shelter-in-place incidents out, you know,
by the refineries, right, Martinez and surrounding areas.
And so focusing, you talked about the testing for the sirens.
I'm really sort of focused here on the testing for the texts, right, messages.
And also just I had a few clarifying questions for the calls.
do those go just to cell phones or also to landlines?
OK, so you have the notifications.
So let me ask the first one.
So can you talk a little bit about what
is a little more about what that testing is
like for the text messages?
Because this is something that we're
getting everyone to sign up for.
And you heard I'm the, you know, we're
all we're all super supportive of it.
But the reason why is we rely on it, right?
And so what are sort of the challenges?
How are we solving them?
I just wanted a better understanding
of how we know in an emergency the text will get through.
How do we deal with, you mentioned redundancies
in terms of sending messages,
but what are the challenges with power being out,
with cell phone coverage being down,
which we have in a lot of places in Orinda.
We got a lot of hills.
my own house sometimes I don't have self coverage when the power is out or the cell phone towers
are down. So if you could just talk a little bit about that. Yeah, absolutely. So you had a couple
of points in that question. So I'm going to try to break it down. Sorry. No, it's okay. So
essentially for the testing of, so we'll leave the sirens out of it because I understand that we're
in Arinda. So essentially for the testing of the capability we have in the past tested essentially
areas of Orinda with in partnership with local law enforcement as well as fire
agencies and so we usually test our system as part of a larger initiative
so that usually goes hand-in-hand with like an evacuation exercise or you know
in 2019 Orinda had a major the La Mirinda area I should say La Paeda
at Orinda and Moraga, had a major initiative
to boost registrations, and at the end of that,
we did support essentially the testing
of the community warning system in that area.
But to further the answer to your question
is we are currently looking at the potential
and what the parameters will look like
for sending out a county-wide wireless emergency alert.
I don't have a date right now.
we're currently in the discovery phase of what is going to be required to send out an
alert that way. But we are currently looking at different ways to essentially not only
partner with our local jurisdictions, but also having a more essentially testing process,
a more robust testing process for the community warning system.
Okay, so...
And then...
Okay, go ahead.
Go ahead, no.
And then I think you mentioned...
do we deal with cell phone towers being down or power outages on the so that you said there's
redundancies in place so you can send messages right right okay yeah so oh so you're talking
about like if there was a major power outage which we've had in the inner rinda we had
an area different areas of lumbarinda so this is where we talk about personal preparedness
right? We understand that during emergencies, technology is going to fall short, and that's
the reality in which we have to live with, right? But we talk a lot about personal preparedness.
So if one sees fire, don't wait to receive an alert. If you feel threatened, leave, right?
We also talk about the National Weather Service weather radios. So in the event that there is
a significant disruption to communications in which we know that that's happening, in fact,
I remember back in 2019 where we did issue an alert via the National Weather Service
weather radios because we had a major public safety power outage.
So in those instances, we are going to be utilizing our more different level different
tools.
But again, it comes back to personal preparedness.
So we want to make sure that the message isn't that you need to heavily rely on the community
warning system while we want to make sure that you're registered.
also a partnership between the community. So again, have your GoKit, have a National
Weather Service weather radio if you're able to get one. And then also, if you see fire
and you feel unsafe, don't wait for the alert, leave now.
And do notifications by phone, because you mentioned part of the redundancy is that the
go out via email and, you know, so if your cell phone's down but your laptop's charged,
you can look at that, right, see what's going on. But do they also go to landlines or is
it just cell phones?
Yes. No. So we have an entire reverse 911 database that we've incorporated into the
system. So we have included AT&T as well as Comcast landlines. So that not only are we
we relying on self-registrations, right?
We are relying on all of those different data sources as well.
Okay, mm-hmm.
O'Reilly and then we'll come back to this one.
Sorry.
Go ahead, Vice Mayor.
It was just you guys were both raising your hand.
Go ahead, O'Reilly.
Okay, so I'm a little confused.
I initially heard there was all this testing going on.
I heard sirens and we were testing sirens
and I heard testing daily, weekly, monthly.
And then when you were talking about the texting,
is there testing going on for texting or not?
I heard you say that we were going forward to a date
in the future to do this testing,
but I also heard you were testing every day.
So are you testing every day?
So what we're doing is there are different levels
of testing that we have to do, right?
So we, I discussed the sirens.
The testing that we do is to ensure that the capability of our duty officers when we create
an alert, when we send out the alert, those processes that are required to send out an
accurate and effective alert to the public are things that we will continue to test internally.
Now, what you're referring to is, essentially, the external testing.
Those we do in coordination with public safety agencies when there are major initiatives
such as an evacuation exercise,
or like a major outreach initiative that at the end,
you know-
How often does this happen?
That depends on the jurisdiction.
In the last five years, how often does that happen?
Once in a year or?
With a different jurisdiction or with-
With a Rinda.
In a Rinda, we had, I believe the last time
that there was one was in 2019.
Okay, not yesterday, not today.
Right, but again, this is very much something
that is driven by the jurisdiction.
So, we don't lead these, yeah, these outreach efforts.
But you were thinking about doing one sooner than later.
What you're referring to is the wireless emergency alert system testing,
and that is a countywide initiative that would potentially be happening, yes.
That would include ARINDA.
That would include ARINDA.
And that is potentially happening in this year or next year?
I don't have a date currently.
Again, like I mentioned earlier,
we're currently looking at what those parameters are going to be look what are going to look like
and what it's going to be required to be able to do a successful test okay and again you're
saying that we would have to drive a test here if we wanted it we would have to help create the
motivation um so there are different component again like i mentioned there are different
components to our testing i'm talking about the wireless emergency alert test that is a very
specific component of community warning system that is driven by the county. What you're referring
to is like testing the landlines, the cell phone, like the landlines, the cell phones, the text
messaging. Those type of alerts require significant, they require a different level of engagement with
the jurisdiction that is requesting that alert. Okay, I get it. Yeah. Thank you. Hi, I've seen
some of the data in the past, but I was just wondering, can you tell us at this point how many
people in Orinda or what your registration is for Orinda and the surrounding area?
Yeah, so I can tell you what the self-registration accounts that we have. I want to be careful about
equating that to a single individual because, like I mentioned earlier, some people are not just
registering themselves, but they're also maybe registering their household along with them.
But in total, the self-registration numbers in the city of Rwanda are 7,704.
And then in total with our reverse 911 database and Comcast, we have 13,697 registered accounts.
One question I had is, you know, phones get put on do not disturb or sleep mode.
I only know how Apple phones work, not Android, but can you explain what the override features
are in the system?
Yes and no.
I mean, I can provide that information to the council so that it can be distributed
for the community, but essentially, you know, you would go into your phone and then they're,
you know, what you want to do is create essentially a contact for the community warning system.
We have a phone number and I can provide all those details.
And then you put them as an emergency bypass contact so that if you do get a phone call
from that caller ID, it will go through on your cell phone.
All of that is on our website, not only for iPhones, but also for Androids.
And I can provide that information to staff after this so that that can be distributed.
And then in the event of a fire where we're doing the Zone Haven or Genesis zone evacuation,
I'm curious because what we're used to seeing here are more of the police Nixle alerts.
We haven't had a lot of fire alerts, but will people get multiple alerts then from
the CWSA like be on the watch and then warning and then evacuate now?
I mean, how will the staging of sort of heads up to go now work in the system?
Yeah.
So if you're talking specifically to a fire, we have two different essentially templates
or language.
So we have an evacuation warning, which is essentially a prepare to evacuate.
And then there's an evacuation order, which is leave now, right?
It's a lawful order to leave now.
Those are determined by the incident commanders on the field.
They determine whether the situation warrants a warning or if it warrants an immediate evacuation,
so an evacuation order.
Again, like I mentioned earlier, we don't unilaterally make the decision on what alerts
need to be sent out.
These are very much dependent on what the public safety agency is evaluating on the
ground and what they deem to be the protective action that is required by the community.
Are there any other questions? I think Council Member Malkin.
Just a follow up to Council Member Riley's questioning, which is, you described sort
of the wireless emergency test system was county-wide test of basically sending out
a CWS alert to see if it's received. No, it's a wireless emergency alert test.
So that is a component of the CWS's systems capabilities.
Right.
What you're referring to by that nomenclature though is countywide, a text goes out and
you're testing to see if me on my phone is a resident, if I've signed up, received it.
Is that what you...
No.
Is that what that meant?
No.
So, wireless emergency alert is not a text message.
A wireless...
Have you guys ever received an AMBER alert?
Yes.
We have the same system technology capabilities that is used to send out Amber Alerts.
That is the wireless emergency alert system.
So when I refer to a wireless emergency alert system test, that is what I'm referring to,
not the phone calls, text messages, and emails.
That is something that is dependent on residents to essentially subscribe to the system.
That's a different level of test.
Okay.
That I mentioned earlier that would require an initiative brought by either the jurisdiction
in which then we would have conversations
about what that would look like.
Okay, the one that I hate to keep,
the wireless emergency test system,
has that, is that only county-wide
or can that go to a specific jurisdiction?
Right now, what we're looking at is a county-wide test.
We aren't looking at like a jurisdictional specific test because the level of planning
that goes into it is potentially significant.
Like I mentioned earlier, we're still looking at what all of that requires and what permissions
we need to get.
So that is countywide.
It last was tested in 2019 and it may or may not be tested sometime in the next year.
Is that sort of where we're at with that?
No, so like I mentioned earlier, the wireless emergency alert would be a countywide initiative.
That has not yet been tested?
That has not yet been tested.
Okay, thank you.
Yes.
And then the last time Arinda's texting was tested is 2019, correct?
Texting phone calls, emails was tested in 2019.
There's just fiction-specific, okay.
And if Arinda requested that that test happen again?
We would need to work with city staff as well as law enforcement agencies and the fire agency
to make sure that we are in alignment with what that would require.
Okay.
I'm not sure what it means, but that's okay.
Yeah.
I think I'll wait till discussion for the rest.
We're getting into it.
Okay.
Thank you.
Yeah.
Can I ask a question?
Yes.
So is there overlap between the county alert system and Nixle and can you explain that
because I think there's some confusion
about the two systems.
So I'm not going to speak on the jurisdictions, Nixle,
because I'm not entirely sure how they utilize Nixle.
We know that traditionally,
and what we see across the jurisdictions,
is that Nixle is utilized for day-to-day communication,
whereas the community warning system is only utilized
when there's an imminent threat to life or safety or health,
and there is a protective action that is being requested
of the community.
Okay, Vice Mayor Jay, did you have a question?
That was actually very helpful.
If there are no other questions,
I'm gonna do public comment and then we'll bring it back up.
And we have a few cards.
So, Jeff Blum, you're our first speaker and Anne Wecht,
and I'm sorry if I'm mispronouncing that,
please be ready to be next.
And we'll ask all public speakers
to limit their comments to three minutes.
City Council, Mayor.
My concern is about the duty officer.
The question is, 15 minutes, we all
know people have got real life, they've got to get up
and do various things.
What's the coverage on that duty officer?
And the reason why I ask these questions,
it looks back to the grand jury findings
to talk about how long it took, what
the lapse was between the incident person communicating
back and then there were delays because duty officer wasn't
available or something like that.
That's the biggest concern because we've
got a great response team from our public services
with fire and police.
They get there, get the job done right.
If they make the determination there's an emergency.
I mean, 15 minutes is a long time.
But if that's really what it is, that's fine.
But are there two people?
Because somebody's got to get up and go
take care of functions, eat, and stuff like that.
The other concern I have is when you register,
register zone, that way it registers for where you are. But what I've heard members of my
neighborhood talk about, I've forgotten my password, and they've tried to get a password
reset to get into register, and they can't. There's no support. At least that's the experience
they were saying. So those are the big issues that I have, and I'm sure some of my colleagues
colleagues will have some other things to say.
And then after that Susan, if you would like to start with a big answer.
Good evening Mayor, city council members and Ms. Herrera.
I'm Sue Wecht, I'm a Linda Downs Firewise leader.
I feel it's my responsibility to bring to your attention
problem my neighbors and I experienced with four trial CWS alerts. In 2019 we
had a targeted evacuation exercise in Arinda Downs and Sleepy Hollow. In 2020
we had a citywide evacuation exercise. In 2022 and 23 we had a La Marinda
community virtual evacuated wildfire evacuation exercise. After each of these
These exercises my Firewise Block Captains and I sent a text message to our neighbors
asking them if they had received the alert.
The response of those who were registered fell into three categories.
First, yes, they received the alert, second, yes, they had received the alert but it was
delayed in some instances by a couple of hours, third, no, they never got the alert.
My question is how can we be certain every Arinda resident who registers for CWS will
get an alert?
We want all our neighbors to experience a safe and effective evacuation should the need
occur.
In order to do that we need to be confident CWS will be able to issue an order to not
some but all residents who have registered.
We hope you will make solving this problem a priority at CWS and our Council and we Firewise
leaders are ready to work with you.
Thank you.
Thank you very much.
Susan and then after that Sandra McGonigal.
Thank you.
After a little bit there.
And good evening to the City Council and also to the community warning system representative.
I'm Susan Anniker and for the past seven years I've been the Firewise leader for Arinda
Woods and in 2019 I registered for the community warning system, excuse me, and I continue
to encourage members of my Firewise neighborhood and greater Arinda community to do the same.
In 2020 and 2022, when CWS sent test alerts to Orinda, I received the alerts.
But for some reason unknown, when the alert was sent in 2023, I did not receive it.
My concern is, should there be a major public safety event and CWS issues and an evacuation
and CWS issues in evacuation order,
some of my neighbors and I will not receive it.
So I urge CWS to act sooner rather than later
and investigate this problem.
I think this is very serious.
As a firewise leader, I'm happy to help
in any way I can, so thank you.
Thank you.
Sandra McGonigal and after that,
and I'm probably mispronouncing that.
Hi, I'm Sandra McGonigal.
I want to thank everybody on the council
for your time and dedication to this
and this important subject.
I just have a very small comment to make.
I'm a firewise block captain in the Arendelle Downs
and back in 2019, I've been a firewise leader
for about seven years as well.
And I've seen the system work in my case,
but I've also seen a lot of my neighbors
that have not received the message,
either by text or by email or by call.
And I think it's really important.
We have some people in the neighborhood that are widowed.
And I think it's important to pull together
and try and do a system test.
I don't know how you go about doing that,
but hopefully you can figure that out
and appreciate your time on this.
Thank you.
Thank you very much.
And Bette, you're my last speaker card.
Anybody else who'd like to speak,
Please just come on up to the podium after the speaker.
Thank you, Council.
My name is Betty Mitchell Lottie.
I'm an Orinda resident and very concerned about fire safety.
So as a Firewise leader, I encourage people always
to sign up for CWS alerts, and we use this brochure.
I came tonight with two simple questions.
And after the presentation, I have many more.
So my first question before the presentation was,
how does it actually work?
I feel like when I'm talking with residents,
I need to know a little more detail and granularity.
I have encouraged households to sign up
all of the cell phones within their household in one account.
Before I came here tonight, I wasn't
aware that there was a limit of three to be signed up.
other people throughout the community have told me that CERT recommends one cell phone
per one account. So I don't know what difference that makes, but I need to know that in order
to be able to promote this program in the way that I have been and I'd like to continue.
The other question I have related to the details
is location, if I'm in, I've signed up long ago.
And of course, had great trouble this past summer
trying to log in.
The program director, Leslie, someone,
had to help me personally to be able to sign in.
So I don't know how big an issue that is.
But if there is an evacuation sometime, of course,
we all hope there isn't.
but if there is, if I'm located in Arinda,
I expect I'll get a text and an email
because that's what I've set up on my profile.
But if I'm in San Francisco or San Diego,
will I still get that alert?
I don't know the answer
and I haven't been able to find it here.
And so those are the kinds of detailed questions.
So that's the first one.
The second question I have is,
and it relates to some of the other questions
people have run it, how we won't know how well it functions unless we do a test.
I followed the PowerPoint. It looks really good, but I don't know and I feel
like we're depending so strongly on this system. I mean, I have my go-bag ready,
okay? It's not that I'm not aware, but how do we know that CWS is going to work?
work. If I'm in the community and I'm promoting this to people, I need to know I can depend
on it. So I hope that we'll be able to do an Arinda test and that you guys will support
it. Thank you.
Thank you. Is there anybody else from the public who'd like to speak on this? I'm seeing
none will bring it back. I'm sorry. Oh, thank you. I haven't asked about zoom tonight. Please
go ahead. Michael, go ahead, please.
I'm going to turn it over to the mayor.
I'm going to turn it over to the council members.
Hi, can you hear me?
Yes.
My name is a good evening mayor and council members.
My name is Michael Livingston.
I'm a property manager for a portion of the bed.
No block downtown for the past 30 years.
I have some comments regarding item.
I five on the consent calendar regarding sidewalk bending.
the city. Do you mind if you
calendar items. So I'm happy to pull that if you can wait that long. If not, I'll ask
you to just raise your hand for public forum.
I will try. I've got a 13th birthday for my granddaughter. I'm trying to go eat some cake
on, but I would like to speak on this and so I'll keep an eye on it and come back to
you.
Public forum will be the very next item, so why don't you raise your hand for that? We'll
work here and right in the front. Thank you. And with that, city clerk, nobody else on
Zoom? Not on this side. Great thanks. I will see what council member comments we have.
Anyone want to lead us off? Sure. Council member Hoxie? It seems clear we need a test. While we've
been sitting here I tried to register and it is not as easy as you would think and I would love
for the community warning system to actually go back and look at that registration process and
work on making it simpler and also some sort of confirmation back to the registrant that they
actually are registered because it's very difficult to tell whether you've
actually completed their process and you've actually registered. So I think
that's step one is having people have some confidence that they have completed
the process and are actually registered with the community warning system and
then I think strongly we need to have an ARINDA test of the system and maybe we
need to give everybody some time to make sure as many people as possible are
actually registered and then in conjunction with our police and fire departments and duty officer
and all those systems at some point I would hope in the next year we could figure out how to
schedule a test just in Arinda of the system to make sure that as many Arinda residents as possible
are actually receiving those notices because it is the primary communication message, you know,
messaging, and I think it's just really important that everybody be receiving the messages.
Yeah, I do feel like we have, there's a lot of questions. I think there's a lot of really
good questions raised by those who made public comment as well, and you know, I also, I would
like to see, you know, I'm quoting Betty who said, you know, we won't know how well it functions
until we do the test, right?
But also, I feel like there's other questions about CWS.
And I'm wondering if I would like to see this come back
as another agenda item to us sometime
in the next few months, if we could,
just to have some of these questions answered.
I looked at my phone, and I got four notifications
during the 2023 virtual exercise from CWS
on the same day, all timely.
On the other hand, I do remember that people saying
that they didn't get notifications here.
And if we were able to do another test,
then maybe we could talk more before we do it.
I don't know if this needs to come back to the council
or it just needs to be dealt with,
but I was just, you know,
I'm wondering if our city manager has any thoughts
on sort of how we can resolve this.
But if we were to do a test,
we could then coordinate with our community leaders
in advance so that we could really sort of have,
you know, be able to assess response well through community leader volunteers.
I would suggest that we just give this back to me to work on with CWS and with
the office of the sheriff and with the police chief and figure out how we can
move forward.
We have some other planned exercises for this coming year that we're going to be
working on, including a ContraFlow exercise.
and maybe we can pair that up with working with CWS.
But I think it would be best if you push that back to me
instead of trying to place it on the agenda again,
because I don't know,
I can't compel another agency to come speak on this item
multiple times.
Other comments?
Oh, I think it's critical we continue to focus on this
and I totally support the idea of it landing
on our city manager's desk and guiding us.
I would agree. I think there's been an awful lot of good questions raised. And just like
a number of our residents mentioned, I remember in the various times that this happened, I
had one time when I didn't get the alerts. I had another one where I did. So I think
there's an awful lot of good questions that came up. So I think this is one where, given
all the effort we're putting into emergency preparedness, this probably requires some
more exploration with the county. I had three comments. That answer really scared me about
that the only way to override a do not disturb is if you have entered the phone number as a trusted
contact. I remember that instruction from when they first set the system up years ago and thinking
that's a horrible system. I assumed the answer tonight was going to be that it's now just
standard that there's an emergency override built into the phone operating systems. And the fact
that we're every individual who signs up including our kids our elderly parents
are expected to go in and make that a permitted contact is a huge
vulnerability so I'd like to make sure that somebody is addressing that I mean
it's sort of above our pay grade but that's scary number two the thing about
family registrations I thought I was the only one who dealt with that but the
thing about the you can't find out if you're it like my husband enrolled a
bunch of us and I can't figure out if I'm enrolled or not that the fact that
three people tonight had issues with recovering passwords verifying whether
you're enrolled another big vulnerability and the third thing is we
had four firewise block captains tonight that made me so happy because knowing
that in a worst worst worst case scenario every neighborhood in Arenda
that gets firewise certified means that you've got this grassroots neighbor to
neighbor block captain system. We're very small groups of, you know, four, five, eight houses are
safe as a group and are going to get out together. So please, what I hope you heard tonight of all,
if nothing else, is be a firewise neighborhood. That is the ultimate fail safe. Because then if
one person gets the word, that block will get the word. And I didn't have anything else before we
move on anything any further? Just a big thank you for all of you for coming and talking about this.
Agreed, some great comments tonight. And if also the the issue of backfilling, right, the 24-7
coverage that was raised, I think it would be important to sort of get some responses from the
county. We'll follow up with seed Lorena and thank you Lorena for coming tonight and speaking with us.
We appreciate that and I'll follow up with her. Yeah, really appreciate it. Obvious, a very
important issue to all of us and thank you. I want to hit the public forum
because we have three people who I think need to speak as quickly as possible so
I'm going to mix up the order and then get to the speaker cards. We had the
person on Zoom who wanted to do address sidewalk vending from the consent
calendar. I then have a Justine Lamb who couldn't stick around for item K-1 who
wanted to speak as early as possible. We then would like to pick up Chief
who was going to say a few words on the fire prevention matter and then I'll
get to the rest of the speaker cards so I hope that's okay that we'll take them
in that order and this is public forum sorry public forum is where you can
speak on any item that is not on the agenda or if it's an agenda item and you
can't be here when that item comes forward you're welcome to make those
comments now and we ask anyone to limit their comments to three minutes Michael
You can go ahead now.
Thank you.
Good evening, mayor and council members.
Michael Livingston, property manager for a portion of the Bevmo block for the last 30 years, wanting to comment on item I five on the consent calendar regarding sidewalk bending my business tenants on Moraga way and Brookwood road express concerns to me that a map of allowed areas for sidewalk
the city was going to deal with it.
And the sidewalk vending in the theater district is not available
for review.
Also whether potential conflicts with outdoor dining and
merchandising have been taken into account.
In the.
Code.
Also,
I understand that some portions of the sidewalks on Moraga way.
in order to deal with that in
the allowing or disallowing of
bending permits.
So I think we would really like
to see more program details and
some locations discussed by the
council and provided to the
business community before we
would support adoption.
And getting to this permit fee
and structure and allowing
parties to begin applying for
permits seems a little
premature.
Thank you very much.
We're not allowed to comment on
items in the public forum. So
the city manager has heard that
and might be able to follow up
after the fact. I'll plan on
giving Mike a call. Thank you.
Thank you. Justine Lamb. Good
evening, Mayor and Council. I'm
speaking about the item K-1 and
the future of the community park
playground. My name is Justine
Lamb and I live in Arrinda and
I'm mom of a toddler. That
the city of Toronto. And we're
going to be doing more than two
times a week at least. I helped
create the website petition,
better playgrounds for Arinda,
where we collected over 113
signatures since Monday morning.
Thank you for investing in this
project and for listening to
residents. I'm asking the
council not to approve either
current design as presented
tonight. Instead, please direct
staff to work with residents on
is authorized. The families who commented on our petition expressed three clear priorities.
First, natural materials and a design that fits Arinda. More wood, stone, and trees,
with spaces that work with the landscape and invite children to climb, explore, and create.
Second, much more shade in overall play areas, especially like a day today when it's super, super hot.
smaller equipment and seating so families can comfortably use the park in hot weather.
Third, sand and water play. Families are repeatedly asked to keep the sandbox and the water features.
These are places where children can dig, build, experiment, and make up their own games.
The two concepts in the city survey are useful starting points, but as presented they rely
heavily on plastic and rubber, and neither includes a sandbox. We'd like to see an alternative that
puts families priorities at the center. Let's focus on creating a unique and beautiful playground
that uses natural materials and encourages imaginative play and for decades to come.
We also have some, I also have some questions regarding the design. We wanted to know what
guided the current designs, what choices are still open, and how community feedback will
shape the next version and when we'll have a chance to review it. Thank you for your time.
And for this time I respectfully
ask you to pause approval as
presented and direct staff to
develop a stronger alternative
with residents and bring it
back for public review.
Thank you.
Just to anticipate the rest of
the K-1 comments we do ask
people not to cheer or jeer for
any speakers in city council
meetings that I know it can be
tempting.
Next, chief Isaacs, we're
going to see if you wanted to
say a few words about we read
also love fire prevention so please come on up. Good evening Madam Mayor and Council Members.
Thank you for the opportunity and the continued partnership we have with the city of Veranda when
it comes to fire prevention. We hear so much about wildfire prevention. We sometimes forget
about the other parts of fire prevention so this year is the battery safety message and if anybody
has questions or needs any additional information please do not hesitate to contact our office and
and talk to the fire marshal.
We would be happy to provide additional information
on how to safely charge your batteries
because we all live by these things
and I happen to have two of them.
So it is something that the fire service
has seen an increase in in battery fires
throughout the nation, throughout California
and even in our county.
So we ask our citizens to really pay attention
and charge their batteries appropriately
and take all the fire safety precautions.
So again, thank you very much for the partnership,
truly appreciate it.
Thank you, we really appreciate you getting that
in front of people this year.
Yep.
Any other comments or questions?
Great, okay, I have two more speaker cards.
I've got Carrie Moss and after that Ava Moss.
Good evening, mayor and council members.
My name is Carrie Moss.
I'm here tonight to address a topic
I know you've heard before,
the infamous no left turn on Ivy Drive as it currently stands the city is
forcing early morning or into intermediate traffic directly into the
del Rey elementary school zone shortly before 750 a.m. OIS staff and zero
period students are trying to get to campus for a 750 a.m. start time because
they cannot turn left at Ivy Drive the vast majority of OIS families must be
pushed onto Coral Drive precisely when Del Rey Elementary students are arriving for their 8am
start. Just last week was a particularly harrowing morning for myself. I was dropping my older daughter
off for her 750am Jazz Band class at OIS and at the Ivy Drive turn there was zero backup.
Moraga Way was completely clear but because I followed the posted rule I was forced to travel
an additional mile towards Delray Elementary. Traffic was significantly backed up and I
waited through three light cycles between El Camino Moraga and Coral Drive. In a bottleneck
crowded with young children on scooters, on foots, parents pushing strollers, when I finally was able
to make a safe unprotected left onto Coral Drive, I had to navigate a steep hill right alongside an
elementary school or riding his bike towards Delray. Thankfully everyone was
safe but I shouldn't have been on that road to begin with. My commute did not
need to cross paths with vulnerable elementary students but this return
restriction forced me into it. I know the residents of Ivy Drive have voiced
concerns about speeding traffic on their street. Their concern regarding unsafe
teenage drivers is also undoubtedly valid. However we cannot protect one
residential street by actively increasing the risk to elementary school students on another.
Right now, to keep Ivy Drive clear at 7.45 a.m., we are routing rushed middle school parents through
crosswalks adjacent to Delray during their peak arrival window. That is an unacceptable safety
trade-off in my view. I am asking this council, as I emailed last week, to prioritize empirical data
over neighborhood assumptions, please authorize a temporary 30 school day trial run where the no
left on IV sign is bagged. This would allow us to safely distribute early morning traffic rather
than forcing a single point of failure at Coral Drive. If the data shows an unacceptable risk
to IV drive itself or its residents, the trial could be instantly reversible simply by removing
the covering on the no left-hand turn sign. In addition, if it's in any way helpful,
I'd be very glad to install a dash cam so you can see my experience four days a week. Thank you.
Thank you. And the next speaker is Ava Moss. You've got, we'll ask comments limited to three
minutes. Hello, my name is Ava Moss and I'm a fifth grader at Wagner Ranch. I'm here to voice
a concern about a white Tesla that drove down the walking path for it next to my school.
I'm bringing it up because I was a witness, I was just walking to school like any other day,
and just like many other kids that live near Wagner, and you must understand my surprise to
see a Tesla go on a public walking path full of kids. Even after several ports on this,
nobody has done anything about it except a Wagner dad that helped put up a temporary
station. Why am I bringing this up? Because I witnessed the Tesla honk at my friend's little
brother that was walking on the path. I should probably bring up that also this is a path
that leads to a school right before it starts. This is about 7.50am and it starts at 8 o'clock.
I should write before it starts where kids that could be in TK and they turn around to
see a Tesla driving at them and then it honked at them to move out of the way. I suggest
putting at least at the very least a metal pole and a sign that says to not go on this
path, also adding a fence where the road car drove off to skip traffic. This occurred right
next to my school with kids that can be as young as four years old. They are put at risk
because nobody wants to do something about it. Thank you for listening to me and I hope
that soon when I walk to school or back, I will see some progress on this. I hope you
see me as an equal on this matter and you make sure that a problem like this doesn't
have to go into a ten-year-old's hands again. Thank you again and good night.
I know you're tempted to clap I we cannot comment city manager are you able
to say a few clarifying words on the topic we appreciate the public's concern
and raising it to us about the incident that occurred on that pathway we have
since initially after receiving the report which wasn't initially right
after the event we decided to install a barrier we put up an a-frame initially
to basically, in case it was a mistake,
tell people not to drive down those pathways.
And then subsequent to that,
we've installed delineators in the middle
so that a vehicle can't go down that road
without knocking over the delineator.
If that's where we're at, we've got other issues
that we have to deal with and we will deal with them.
Thank you very much.
I think all of us and every member of the school board
heard about it.
So appreciate the further color commentary.
Before we conclude, oh before public comment forum, is there anybody else on zoom? No, mayor. I
would like to make a matter initiated
to
Try either a pilot program of getting data without the no left on ivy signup and collecting data or
Collecting data in some way that doesn't leave that in the situation where we left it what I thought I remembered from when this council
discussed it, and I was outvoted for one,
was that we weren't done done,
but we wanted to do something
which involved continuing to collect data,
and I don't remember what the objective
of my other council members were,
so I would like to make a matter initiated
to try that pilot program for 60 days,
so there's a little bit of time to gather data,
with a reminder that the Delray school time change
was not a material factor when we discussed it last time,
And I thought that was material to tonight's feedback.
And I'm curious if there is a second on that matter initiated.
Shouldn't we discuss that during matters initiated and not now?
Matters initiated can be any time in the meeting.
I would second it as a matter initiated.
OK, great.
Bring that back.
And to clarify the process, all that means
is that it will come back as an agenda item to discuss.
It doesn't mean we're going to do it.
It just puts it on a future agenda.
All in favor?
Aye.
I was that unanimous or were there any nays nay okay four ayes and a nays so
that will come back as a future and I agenda item to discuss I have a couple
public speakers for k1 that have informed me they need to go home also
they okay we will leave public forum open and we will include those zoom
speakers on item K one at this time. They're in the room. Okay, great. And
city clerk. I'll ask you to please and see the order of speakers. Oh, I'm
sorry. In the room. I thought you meant on the whole thing. I'm sorry. Hi,
thank you for letting us reopen public comment. I'm learning a lot about how
things run today and I need to get home to my son. Um, thank you all for
taking the time today. My name's are I've lived in a rinda for six years
and I'm the parent of a five year old and our family is at a rinda community
several times a week. I'm echoing many of the points from my colleague Justine
Lam and many other members here today. I'm so grateful that the city is
investing in the park and because this is a once-in-a-generation decision for
the heart of downtown I respectfully ask the council and its feedback on item K1
to one hold off on approving either current design as presented, two to
direct staff to work with residents on a stronger third alternative featuring
natural materials, open ended play, shade and accessibility, and three, bring the revised
concept back for public review before a final decision, equipment order or construction
authorization. Regarding item I6, I ask that the council confirm before approval that this
contract does not commit the city to either play area design or its materials. My reasons.
Limited community input. The survey asked residents to choose between two themes with
comparable equipment and offered no way to choose neither many residents chose
the nature theme because they wanted a natural playground but as presented both
concepts rely on composite equipment rubber servicing and fencing no notice
was posted at the playground itself and many families who use it daily learned
about the project only in the last few weeks. Play value research on nature
based play spaces suggest that natural open-ended environments support more
imaginative and imaginative unstructured play than fixed equipment over large
areas of safety surfacing. You can see this at the park today where many kids
prefer the treehouse above the tennis courts to the existing structures.
Materials and heat. Unshaded rubber servicing can exceed 160 degrees in
summer and the Consumer Product Safety Commission has documented burns to
children's hands. Accessibility doesn't require rubber everywhere. Accessible
routes can be paired with certified engineered wood fiber, a natural material
that stays cooler and can meet ADA servicing standards.
Sand, shade, and water.
Neither concept includes a sandbox,
and Arinda has no free public water play despite summer
temperatures over 100 degrees.
Shade matters most of all for keeping play surfaces
safe in the summer.
Staff has said that the project is at 30% design with materials
not yet selected, so there is still time to get this right.
Many neighbors share these concerns
as reflected in the better playgrounds for Arinda position
that Justine just shared.
Thank you for your time and service to Arinda.
And I would,
oh,
Sarr Warner and she had speaker cards for both K1
and for item A6, the contractor approval
for the first phase of the park.
And I think is Rachel Spears, our next public forum.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Hello, mayor and city council members.
My name is Rachel Spears.
I'm a resident near Wagner Elementary School.
I'm here to comment on agenda item K1,
the Arinda Community Park play area.
As a mom of an elementary, a middle,
and a soon to be high schooler,
I am concerned about the two playground designs
that were proposed.
My comments echo a lot of the concerns
that have already been presented here,
but I wanna just talk specifically
about my concern about the limited age use
of this type of playground design.
I think that parks should welcome open-ended
and imaginative display that invites a wide range
of demographics from the youngest residents here
to the oldest and even like senior citizens.
I think parks should be for everyone.
I think things that are universal that we all need,
shade, sand, and water echo again some of the comments
that have been here.
These things should be inviting
and should welcome everyone to the parks.
I like using the parks as an entire family.
And I know that sometimes when a park appeals
to one demographic, I can't get my older kids there.
Or if it leans too old,
then I can't get my younger kids there.
We like to use the parks together.
I'm really excited about the prospect of the park updates,
and I'm really glad we're taking time to focus on that.
I'm also really excited to see that so many residents
really do care about the park as the heart of the city.
And I think that we can work together
to make something beautiful.
To that end, I have one ask and two questions.
My ask is that we have more transparency
and more forums for input
before we select one of these two options.
And my questions are how far into this design process are we
and how much change can we expect from our feedback?
Has, and then the second question,
has a design firm been pre-selected
or is there an opportunity to seek new proposals
from other design firms?
Thank you again for your time and for your focus on this.
I know it's a complex process that's been in the works
for a long time and thank you
and we hope we can work together with you on this.
Thanks.
Thank you very much.
Is there anybody else for item K-1 who needs to speak
before the item comes up?
Come on up.
Yeah.
My name is Tracy Burnett and my children are two
and six years old and they have grown up playing
in Arinda Park.
It is a restful and luxurious location
to escape the constant stimulation of devices
and passive entertainment.
Together with the friends they have made in the park,
my children have enjoyed exploring the trees, shrubbery,
sand, wood chips, and even the grass
when they were crawling on their hands and knees.
After adventurous play, they always retire to the sandpit
for soothing sensory input.
The removal of a tree from near the sandpit
one or two years ago made that more difficult
due to the lack of shade,
yet they gravitate toward the sandpit anyway.
There was broad consensus that Arinda Park
would serve more people for more hours each day
if only it had more shade trees,
kept its sandpit, and absolutely did not get
the smelly rubber safety material placed all over the ground.
That material breaks and smells bad in the heat of the sun,
and my family avoids playgrounds that habit.
On the online survey,
it was required to select between two options with rubber on
the ground and no option was given to refuse to select one.
Therefore, the data collected by that survey
does not reflect the community's desires.
Furthermore, I am concerned that in the nature playground which tonight's agenda indicated
was selected more often than the other one, the structures for older kids are too close
to and attractive to the structures for the younger kids.
Please analyze the comments on park plans made by the public and prioritize what matters
most to the community.
families are happy to help collect and analyze public comments for the benefit of the city.
Thank you. Thank you. Is there anybody else for the public forum part of our meeting?
Great. And I appreciate all of you with younger kids who are here, whether it's for public forum
or for K-1, we know that it's a very difficult thing to sit through a city council meeting with
littles. With that, we will go to council reports. And I think we'll start on this side.
Okay. All right. I think that's my right vice mayor G. No, I don't have anything today.
Can smell recall Connie. Um, we I attended the Cal cities conference in Anaheim. And
there were a lot of good panels I know we always still have a full agenda ahead of us
so I'll keep it brief. A couple things to note. One is there was a panel on zone zero
regulations and wildfire prevention in general and in attending it I felt that
maybe we should be presenting it in terms of what Irinda was doing and so I
made not public comment but asked a question and also directed folks to
everything that we were doing in the room so told them all about Irinda
Reddy and the work we were doing and one of the presenters was the director of
of the State Department of Board of Forestry and Fire Prevention and connected with him
afterwards and he's actually interested in coming and talking to us in Orinda and also
in highlighting what we're doing.
So that's a useful connection, I think, that we'll follow up on.
And then the second, there was a panel on eBikes, but the presentation was very similar
to the presentation that some of us saw at the East Bay Division meeting we had
last year but obviously it's a continued focus and beyond that there was a
resolution that was voted on by all the delegates and it passed and it was to
form a local committee. It was amended during the process of the resolution's
Committee during Cal City. So it started off talking about forming a committee
to explore a Citizens Initiative and it ended up becoming a committee to explore
a policy or legislation statewide that would basically focus more on local
control over housing decisions. And so Arinda, after conferring with the city
manager about the amended resolution it seemed within our platform so we voted yes and it it was
almost unanimous um and i think those are sort of the highlights of cal cities i'm sure the city
manager will will address anything else that i forgot but that was that was sort of the more
important parts uh policy ways thank you for adding some color because i heard them talk about that
at the mayor's conference but didn't uh understand where that had come from councilmember hoxie i
I have nothing to report.
I just have four things since our last meeting.
We had our annual interfaith breakfast on September 22nd.
Wonderful chance for the leaders of the various churches
and religious organizations to come together
and talk to each other about what they're doing.
And obviously, senior community building
and dealing with preschools and the impact
that TK has had on the economics of preschools
are things that for two years now
have been kind of our bigger themes.
We did the coffee with the mayor on September 23rd
and did talk about, in addition to just small business
questions and support, but the question of maybe
a merchant's association came up.
And there was a lot of support for that,
to see something for our storefront physical businesses
in town, so we hope to follow up with that.
We had Senator Grayson's wildfire task force
on October 1st, which is a cross agency
with the police, the fire, the mayors,
folks like Caltrans, PG&E all getting together
to talk about where are there roadblocks and obstacles
to doing better on fire preparation
where talking to each other can break down barriers.
This one there was a long presentation on insurance
and all the things that we want
in terms of our fire preparation
resulting in more insurability and actual discounts.
It was a fascinating conversation and we look forward to sharing more of that with the community.
The answers were not there yet, but there are really high level from the state all the
way down to the most local of groups and cross-functional agencies working on getting the insurance
companies and all the agencies and people working on fire resilience to get together
on shared standards and shared pricing.
And then last we had a mayor's conference in Lafayette just last week and nothing to
report from that.
So with that we'll see if there are no questions the city manager reports.
Thank you mayor and members of the council.
Just a couple reminders of upcoming events.
There's a memorial service for the owner of the Casa Arenda restaurant.
It's a public memorial at the restaurant on October 12th from 11 to 130.
There's also a celebration coming up for tourists at November 1st in the Founders Auditorium
from 1 to 3, so just make sure those are on your calendar.
And then we have Safer at Scale, the Weathered Premier at the Arinda Theater, followed by
the panel discussion.
That will be a special city council meeting because we want to make sure everyone can
attend that. So that will be on October 29th with the doors opening at 6pm, the movie,
the film showing at 7, followed by the panel discussion which will be the public meeting.
And that will be around 8.10. And just wanted to also note that the city, I looked at the
agenda for October 20th and we don't have anything that is timely in nature
and a very light agenda compared to tonight and so I'm recommending that
that be canceled and we'll send out a cancellation notice for that meeting.
Just a clarification you just said Taurus. That's Taurus Yeager, the founder of
the Friends of the Nature area and a bit of a luminary in Arinda so I hope
that's November 1st from I believe 1 to 3 p.m. for anybody who'd like to come
and recognize her retirement. Any other? No, I just wanted for the city manager I
don't recall there's been so much going on whether this was announced last time
but we did get confirmation on the from the assembly members Rebecca Bauer
Cajun's office and then we also heard from our congressman about funding. Do
you want to? We are, well the congressman's funding I think that they're still in
the extending of the budget cycle so we don't have that appropriated yet, but we were set
for an appropriation for federal funds for a million dollars for the North horrendous shaded
field break. And then we are the recipient of a grant from through the budget trailer bill from
Rebecca Bauer Cahan's office of two million dollars towards assisting with fire fuel reduction and
community mitigation efforts. Thank you. Thank you and if there's nothing else we
will move on to the consent calendar. The consent calendar items that are voted on
all as one item unless something is pulled for questions or public comment. I
either would like to pull or have public comment on items I3, I6, and I7 with a
note and city attorney if you can help me I 6 the public commenter has already
made her comment so I don't know if others want to further address that or
leave it on the the consent calendar but I was only going to pull it for the
public comment there I was going to pull I six to ask questions about the public
comment so great so I would suggest we pull I 3 I 6 I 7 is there anything else
I think we should pull I-5 just so that we can explain why it's on our agenda.
Okay so anything else? So that would be a consent counter for items I-1, I-2, I-4
and that's it. I will move we approve items I-1, I-2, I-4. Do I have a second?
second all in favor aye apologies for everyone waiting to still talk on K one
because we're gonna keep doing this item I three very quickly the cost savings
available by doing slip lining versus pipe replacement is an incredibly
meaningful innovation and I just wanted to see if our director of public works
could just quickly explain the significance of why these slip linings
are so transformational. The pipe was, I believe, 12-inch diameter corrugated
metal and it was shallow and completely in destroyed condition. So the original
plan was to do an open trench excavation and then it turned out we were able to
work with a property owner it was a somewhat I won't say typical but not
uncommon case where a pipe goes from collecting water in a public street then
continues on through private property where it ultimately reaches say in this
case a small creek and it made sense rather than to say put a manhole in at
that junction point where it leaves public to private we worked with the
property or then to continue the work onto their property and in that case
with all their improvements and such backyards, landscaping, trees, it wasn't
feasible to do an open trench so we worked with the contractor to do an
alternate method where we do slip lining which is a case where basically you you
have a way where you can pull the pipe through. You make sort of a little pit in front where
you'd otherwise trench, but you don't have to trench the whole thing. And you pull the
pipe through from the other end, so you don't need to. It's a trenchless method primarily.
So we were able to do that. Property Planner did contribute some funding to cover their
part of it. We ended up as it shows you know doing the project for you know a
little less than anticipated so it was kind of a win-win for us. Thank you. I
only mentioned that as we look at the private storm drains and sort of what
private owners can expect to maintain those kind of a nice thing to realize
that there are more options today than there used to be. I didn't have any
questions. I just wanted to highlight what we were talking about and I would move that we adopt I-3.
Do I have a second? Second. All in favor? Aye. Great. Next one, I-5.
I don't know if that's city manager or whoever pulled it. I pulled it just so the city manager
I hope could just explain quickly why it's on our agenda and why we're bringing it up at this time.
Sure. We are trying to respond to changes in state law that allow sidewalk vending.
And with that, we brought back an ordinance so that we could adopt some restrictions that
we thought were reasonable restrictions on how to implement the state law. And with that,
we needed to establish a fee to establish where permitted sidewalk vending could occur.
should be noted that there's a large chunk of sidewalk in the theater district, which
is all private, so it's not public. And so that wouldn't be subject to, you know, people
being able to set up and sell off those sidewalks. So I'll give Mike a call and talk to him a
little bit more about it to answer some of his questions. But that's really what's behind
us establishing a fee for the permit that was part of the ordinance that we adopted
to create additional guardrails for us in implementing the state's law.
Would you like to make a motion?
Sure.
Let's move.
We approve item I-5.
Second.
All in favor?
Aye.
Aye.
And then item I-6.
Councilmember Malcomi, your city manager?
I'm not sure what the question is.
Yeah.
So I'm just.
To the extent that.
If, if we.
We've received a lot of public comment about the design of the park.
Right.
And so if.
If we were to approve this.
Given that we're also on a separate agenda item being asked to provide
wedded to choosing or giving feedback
on one of the two designs?
Or can we approve this and that and then
still provide feedback that is?
By approving this, can we still incorporate
sort of the extensive public feedback we're
hearing about natural materials and more shade and all that?
If you could sort of address that.
So I think I understand where we're going.
And I think there's an easy explanation.
this is for the ADA improvements only for the park and this is not for access to the
playground. This is about the access up from the street all the way to where the kinder
gym building is and creating an accessible parking area up there adjacent to the park
so that we can meet our accessibility requirements for the park overall.
And so by improving this, we are not in any way limited in re-evaluating the design and
providing feedback consistent with how the public comment has been.
That's my understanding.
I just want to clarify.
That's what I thought, but I just want to clarify.
With that, I would, unless there's, sorry.
Would you just say that the two are unrelated?
It's a completely different step.
different phases of work in the park
that are not related to one another.
Yeah.
Please stand separately.
Okay.
With that, I would move to approve item I-6.
Do we have a second?
I'll second.
All in favor?
Aye.
Aye.
And with that move to I-7,
and this was mine to pull, so I will address it.
And don't worry, it's not meant to be controversial,
but I was actually happy that our new system
having proclamations that are city proclamations, not just something the
mayor does, um, are things that are agendized this way. And also this one
has signs. Um, you know, I think United against hate is very important and I'm
really glad we're doing this. Um, but I had this comment last year and we
didn't have a chance to talk about it. Uh, my understanding of hate speech and
hate crimes is that it has to do with being in a protected class. Someone who
would be subject to discrimination.
And so I was surprised that socioeconomic status
and immigration status, which are temporal,
they're not a fundamental identity, they're a status.
You can go from being one socioeconomic status
to another.
And I'm not aware of there being hate crimes around those that
are not otherwise race or religion.
I went to the United Against Hate website,
United Against Hate Week website.
And it defines it as hate incidents and crimes
involve evidence that bias, hatred or prejudice
have occurred based on the victim's real or perceived
race, ethnicity, religion, ancestry, national origin,
disability, gender, or sexual orientation.
I also checked a few others, the UN definition.
This is a California originated United Against Hate thing,
And all of them did not include socioeconomic or immigration
status.
And I only bring it up because I think
that hate crimes are such a really shocking, outrageous
thing when they happen that I didn't want to dilute it
by being so inclusive that we lose the power and shock
of what a real hate crime and real hate speech looks like.
And I would suggest that we use that we delete those too
and stay with United Against Hate Week definition.
But just a question to the group.
I guess I would strongly argue against excluding those.
I mean, I'm not exactly sure.
I think what you're asking is or saying
is that there aren't hate crimes based on immigration status,
or there aren't hate crimes because someone is an immigrant
or perceived to be an immigrant, or because someone
is perceived to be socioeconomic status.
I guess it would be low income, right?
And at least with regard to immigration status,
I mean, we're seeing people who are sometimes
multidimensional, so maybe hard to actually discern.
But we are seeing people who are literally being,
from my perspective, sort of terrorized by ICE
because they are perceived to be an immigrant.
And sometimes, ICE is wrong, they're citizens.
We're seeing citizens getting put in detention, right?
And while it may be, you know, mixed motivation there,
as we often see with acts of hate,
because on some level, to be hateful like that,
you're, you know, to me it's an irrational,
it's an irrational fear.
It's an irrational emotion to be, you know,
it's emotionally driven and it's not, you know,
but so it could be a mix of racism and, you know,
other isms, but it is definitely motivated by, you know,
I mean, just the other, literally just this weekend, right?
A group touring on a South Asian radical history tour,
this anyway, walking, which was led by one of,
a BART director actually who runs this tour,
they were as they were doing a tour,
talking about sort of historical racism,
someone walked over and said,
go home, like screamed at them.
A couple of people screamed at them.
And so that's anti-immigrant too.
And so I think, you know, as an immigrant,
as a child of immigrants, I guess I would know,
I want that word in strongly and that's why.
And country of origin is in.
Right, but immigration status, if someone is just sort of,
I mean, there's an anti-immigrant sentiment now
that's really strong, right?
I don't want any more H-1Bs here.
They're not saying I don't want any more people
from X country or Y country.
They're saying I don't want any more immigrants.
This is really, I mean, there's a lot-
But is that hate speech to say I don't want H-1Bs?
This is united against hate proclamation.
I mean, I don't know if we're trying to,
I think the general sentiment is that we want to curb,
you know, treating people hatefully.
What is hate anyway?
Is it unkindness?
Right?
I mean-
Way worse.
Worse, but we're trying to curb treating people.
Yeah, I mean, if someone, we're seeing,
we do see incidents though,
of people literally being physically attacked, right?
And I think some, how do you know it's because
they're from ex-country as opposed to anti-immigrant?
Isn't that all kind of mixed up in some of these incidents?
Because, and I was thinking about this,
would a white South African have been subjected
to that treatment versus, there was a story I read
in the news, and I think it's why I reacted strongly enough
to want to bring it up, where a Sikh truck driver
was stabbed at a Wyoming truck stop.
Yeah.
And I just thought, you know what,
When that sort of thing happens,
I don't wanna dilute this to have it be
all things nice and well-meaning.
I wanna say we are united against hate speech
and hate crimes and that was targeting
race, religion, country of origin.
And immigration status.
Anyway, we're sort of dominant.
Or it could be, I mean.
That's what other people think.
I don't understand the motivation of narrowing it.
I think it should be broad and inclusive.
It shouldn't be narrow.
It's really, it's about stamping out hate, period.
It's my gut.
I agree with leaving it the way it's worded
because I do think right now the issues in our nation
regarding immigration in my mind
certainly fall into the category of hate.
I would feel less strongly about socioeconomic status,
but the reality is, is I think immigration
to be in there. Well, and if you think about the unhoused folks, they are also mistreated
based on their socioeconomic status. So I feel like if we're going to adopt a resolution,
I like the resolution that was written. You know, I, we have heard comments over the years about
people's First Amendment rights to say what they want, but that's different than acting out in a
hateful way, in a public way that is actually a crime. And I think it's really important to note
that we are trying to say that we do not approve of hate crimes, that we stand against acting that
way towards our fellow people in our community. And so from that perspective, I like the resolution
as it was written, and it being more inclusive. By the way, those are wonderful points. And I
I really appreciate being able to have this dialogue.
It's why I think it's nice
that our city proclamations are agendized.
And as the one who brought it up,
I would suggest approving I-7 as written.
I think those were really lovely points.
Do I have a second?
Second.
In favor?
Aye. Aye.
Thank you all.
Moving along, let's do K-1,
the Arinda Community Park play area replacement project.
Honorable mayor members of the council,
Hanh Nguyen from our engineering team.
If you need to move the mic all the way down high,
you should do that.
Thank you.
Good evening, mayors and council members and everyone else.
Well, we heard a, I don't think you need
to hear my presentation.
So actually, that's kind of the purpose.
We're here to basically to update to you
the, of our status of our project
and our design phase and et cetera.
With here, with me, again, I'm Hanwin,
I have our consultant, calendar associate,
landscape architect, Marie Maude.
And then hopefully Todd will be joining us
to give us some insight.
So let's go.
Wait, back up, sorry.
So the background, just the overall project purpose
is that we need something new.
We need to create an all inclusive for everybody.
Consolidate the three, right now our playground equipment
are kind of spread out, so we want to consolidate it
so that as a caretaker, a parent can keep an eye on,
You know, your kids, you don't want one over the other side and across the park and then one, you know, clear by. So that's kind of the purpose. And then also, of course, as a city, we want some, you know, for maintenance easy maintenance.
So that's kind of the purpose of the project itself.
background on it. In 2016, 10 years ago, we did assessment. And two years later, we created a
masterpiece, a master plan, I'm sorry. And then that master plan had an upgrade, and it ended up
to be quite costly. So we end up what we did was we did in four phases. The first phase is just
approved. Thank you. That's the ADA and the restroom. And then the second phase is this
basically the replacement of the play equipment. That's the play area. That's the second phase.
The third phase will be the ban shelf. And then the fourth one will be an overall of the
pathway and et cetera, common area. So that's the fourth phase we're looking at. We're on the
second phase so right now on the second phase we are just looking at we had a
goal and our goal is that to stay within the budget the budget that the CIP gave
us was 1.2 mill so and that include construction and soft cost for CM
consultant for the management so it's and then also consistency to by the way
way. And then the other goal was to be all inclusive, to make sure everybody, you know,
what we addressed, which original one, and then consolidate the play area, and then address
the maintenance part of it. And those are the four elements that we pass
forward to our consultant. We say, take it, please, look at it, and design, come up with
something. So with the current maintenance and that, Todd can, you know, can help us on that as these
are just the two that I can think of and also is just black out that basically we have it. It's
right out there and we need to make a change or improve better. We don't want to go back to the
same mistake. One of them was that we have a wooden structure, and right now it's being closed off
because of dry rot. Our area right now, you know, we're in the dryer area, it causes dry rot and
that causes a safety issue for us and also maintenance. Our guys, our maintenance group
have come out there often to make sure there's no splendor for the goods, make sure it's sand down.
So it does cause quite a bit of a maintenance. Sand, the second part is sand. We have sand out
there right now. And you can see the second picture it's that it migrate. And what I hear
is kids going out there and I'm pretty sure my daughter is guilty at start. Have a cup
and she'll scoop it up and then go out to the water fountain get some water because that's
the beautiful part of it. Mix it up and play with it. And then you know what? It's good.
Bring it out to the slide and put it on there. See how it falls. So it does migrate and it does
causes a little bit more maintenance, yes, for our staff. So those are the two that
we can come up and that we are hoping that we can improve on it or see what
else we can do. So those are the direction that we give calendar. So with
that they came up with two identical, yes, they're identical, but we're looking at
theme now because we want everything to be equal, that both equipment has the
same element, different elements. So we came up with two, they came up with two themes for us,
it's a nature theme. In the other words, the art deco theme. And with that, what we did was we had
a survey monkey, we came out and we did quite a bit, these are the two elements that we did.
We had one concept A or concept B. And yes, they are similar, it's just the theme that we're looking
at what kind of theme we want. Actually, not we. I checked that back. The community wants.
What they want. So that's why we had the... These are all of our different elements that
we went to get the residents involved to give us their input. We did a render newspaper,
store posting, concert in the park, farmers markets, booth, we had the national night
out information table on July 4th actually. Actually, that was the first time we went
out there. I remember we would put that on the several monkey on the third and the fourth
was the survey monkey went live. And then as we did also was the we did posting at the
itself for a while. These are some of the photos that the gathering and then the booth.
Well, here's the result. After six weeks, we had 394 responses. And so that was overwhelming. And
there's 85 picked in nature theme. So that's kind of overwhelming. So that's the one that we would
I would like to present to you today
and hopefully Maria can give you the,
is it everything completely done?
No.
And I'm hoping to answer some of that question
that the residents had, the panel came up.
So hopefully Maria can answer that to everyone.
And then, so the purpose today is just to give you
how we went, how we came about to this 30% right now.
and then we'd love to have your comments on that.
With that, I will turn it over to Maria.
Before you go, I just want to just make one quick comment
on the survey itself.
There were specific questions, there's choices, right?
Yes.
But there was also open-ended feedback
that we were able to obtain as well.
And I believe we got over 150 open-ended comments
in that as well.
And we can kind of touch on that
to give some feedback to the council.
Yeah.
Maria.
questions. Thank you. Good
evening, Council members.
Marie my with calendar
associates. Um so the next few
slides I will be walking you
through the details of the
proposed nature inspired
playground design and how we
developed it based on. The
stated goals that had shared.
Okay so the nature theme was
setting of the existing park amenities, which would still be remaining for the
next few years, and also complements the charm and the small town ambiance of
downtown Orinda. The nature-based design elements can reflect a number of things
including trees, plants, organic curvilinear forms, color palette with
earthy tones, as well as just exploration and discovery. And we'll be utilizing
this nature theme to guide our selections of the play equipment, the
colors, the materials to support creative and imaginative play. So this slide
shows the proposed nature themed playground concept and to orient you
or or window way is toward the bottom of the plan image. The community center
building is towards the right and the big lawn is towards the top left. The
play area edges up against the existing asphalt pathway that lines the lawn and
a central plaza is proposed to welcome park users and also provides a high
visibility location that could be a potential donor recognition space. One of
the challenges as Ha mentioned of the existing playgrounds is that the
taught and youth areas are separated by the big expanse of lawn so to remedy
that with this design, we are combining it.
So there will still be separated taught and youth areas.
There were still will be age separated areas,
but they are consolidated and adjacent to each other in a single footprint.
And that will make supervision easier because, again,
you know, gardens can see both their younger child
as well as their older child from one kind of vantage point.
Next slide.
And then a proposed low fence would enclose the new playground, and so that would also
help with rental supervision, kind of preventing kids from darting out or wandering away.
This playground's proposed would be much more inclusive than the existing.
It has the resilient rubber safety surfacing that you see in there, kind of the larger
expansive of blue as well as the tan and the greens.
That would provide for year-round access to and throughout the playground by someone in
a wheelchair.
It allows for play events that would be directly accessible to someone in a wheelchair.
And it's a little hard to see with the size of the image
there, but the foreground in the image
does show an inclusive carousel, which is a spinner that
allows both able-bodied as well as a child who
might be in a wheelchair to play together and spin together.
And the foreground also shows nature played play panels,
for example, one that highlights a butterfly's life cycle.
So again, just kind of pulling together that nature theme.
The rubber surfacing can also support imaginative play.
So as I mentioned, the structures
are set in a kind of green field.
Kids can kind of imagine they're on an island,
and they can hop from island to island.
The tan area is crossing the oceans
to get to other play equipment.
And there can be other patterns as well
that we can incorporate into the rubber.
And then lastly, the proposed play equipment
is proposed to be a durable and low-maintenance mix of metal
and plastic, rather than the current mix, which
is metal, plastic, and has wood elements as well.
And that is to try to prevent kind
of that dry rot potential in the future.
OK, taking you through a little bit more detail
into the specific pieces of equipment,
this is the proposed youth structure.
It's quite tall, hopefully more exciting,
but it has a 10 foot high tube slide,
eight foot high net climber.
So just the height and the vantage point
is usually pretty exciting to kids
and also giving them just that vertical
and horizontal challenge with the various net play,
the overhead ladders and other, a wide range of climbers.
And all of that helps build children's confidence
as they develop their physical strengths,
spatial awareness and coordination,
kind of navigating a more complex structure.
And this structure also includes play panels
and musical and sensory play like drums.
This slide shows a closeup of the tot structure area.
That is the tot structure kind of focused in the middle.
That structure will be about six feet tall,
kind of the tallest platform will be six feet.
So both taut and youth will be a little bit taller
than the existing structures.
The play panels, a little bit hard to see,
but they do have metal cutouts that mimic leaves
and kind of with a branch patterning.
And then we can see in this image,
the brown shade cloth,
kind of the triangular pieces along the top.
Those are to provide for shade over the taut structure.
As we've heard, shade is very important and also good
for comfort for the user.
So we'll be working with a manufacturer
to incorporate either more elements of shade
or enlarging the ones that we have,
but basically just to overall increase the amount of shade
over the play equipment.
And then to the back right of the image,
there are two vertical spinners where kids
can spin sitting or standing.
And also a spring rock in the shape of a ladybug.
So it does introduce motion and kind of a different type
of play that the existing equipment doesn't have.
And the equipment color palette across the playgrounds,
mostly tans, yellows, light greens
to fit with the nature theme.
But also trying to provide for some brightness
and some fun energy.
And then moving to the swing structure,
We're proposing three bays.
So one would have two bucket swings.
The other would have two belt swings
for the tot and the youth aged kids.
And then the middle would have an adaptive swing
and a multi-user seat for more inclusive play.
So the adaptive swing is similar to the one
that you have out there now.
It allows for a child who may not
have good upper body strength to still play and experience
that swinging motion.
And then the multi-user swing enables like a guardian,
for example, an adult to sit facing a younger child,
a toddler, for example.
So that can be a really neat way to kind of bond.
And also, it makes the playground multi-generational.
And then these are images of potential inclusive play
equipment.
As I mentioned, the current design
does already have the inclusive whirl or that carousel spinner.
We also have the expression swing in the design with the adaptive seat.
We don't currently have the inclusive rocker, but that is something that could be added.
We certainly have the space for it.
Okay.
So, yes, as the city manager mentioned, we had a survey, online survey, and got pretty
good response just in terms of what we've seen with other municipalities, almost 400
comments.
But I do want to mention beyond the questions specifically
about theming, which I had noted.
And we also asked a number of other questions.
So we had asked questions for respondents to, for example,
rank preferred play area amenities, rank layout
and design options, as well as rank play experiences.
And from those questions, we found
that the majority of respondents wanted more play equipment,
so just kind of more play events.
And in particular, climbers was very high priority,
very high preference for that, and then shades.
So those kind of preferences came out of the survey.
And then in addition to specific questions,
we had the open-ended write-in comments.
And out of the 394 respondents total,
we had 156 people, so about 40%, provided write-in comments.
So you can see the breakdown there.
Again, shade was a comment that was very strong.
A third of commenters wanted more shade.
A fifth wanted just nature in general.
And then more specifically, they wanted more natural materials.
So as you've heard, things like woods and boulders.
And then, let's see, 1 in 6 also wanted sand play to remain.
1 in 12 requested water play.
And then 1 in 12 comments did not want rubber surfacing.
So it's not like we're not statisticians,
but we're using the results to help guide
what the priorities would be so that the playground, the design
does reflect community priorities and community
preferences.
So with that, when we see a third wants shade,
that is a strong comment, so we do want to accommodate that.
Particularly if it aligns with the stated original goals
of the project, which was more inclusivity,
consolidated playground, let's meet the budget.
And then low maintenance or reduced maintenance.
So those were the four guiding principles for us
as designers developing this initial draft design,
and then we'll be looking to refine it
to better incorporate and better address community comments.
Okay, actually I do wanna go back.
Okay, so shade, we are looking,
we would be working with the manufacturer
to incorporate that, as I mentioned.
In terms of nature, you know, between nature,
sand, water play and rubber,
I think the trade-off that we counsel the city
would be evaluating is, you know,
how would a commenting that fit in with those goals?
So, you know, we know that sand play is more maintenance.
It does certainly provide a richness of materials.
The young kids really love it.
But it does migrate, as Ha mentioned.
So that's going to be the trade-off.
With water play, water play can get very expensive.
With water resource management, safety, water, safety,
and sanitation, water splash pads basically
have to be designed like a pool system.
So you're looking at a minimum six-figure investment.
And so, again, that's going to be the compromise
with the balance that we would need to consider and strike.
Maybe instead of the very tall youth structure equipment,
in order to afford play, does that structure go down?
Does that shrink?
Do we eliminate other pieces of play equipment?
kind of what do we kind of give up in order to accommodate that so that would
be kind of the process that we'd be going through and then with rubber
surfacing you know with the state of gold being we want this playground to be
more inclusive rubber surfacing really is the gold standard in terms of
providing that year-round access yes we do have the option with the engineered
wood fiber but the reality is you know with public park you know municipal
staff. They're not going to be out there every day raking. That's, you know, you kind of don't
have the budget for that. Most municipalities don't have that kind of budget. And so again,
there's a trade-off there to be made. If we do want to prioritize inclusivity, then
the engineered wood fiber, you know, most of the time it will fall out of compliance.
and then sand, of course, is not an accessible material at all.
So with that in mind, if we're staying with our original goals,
we would be looking to incorporate more shade.
We'd be looking to try to incorporate more natural
materials, probably things like maybe boulders,
incorporating boulders as seating,
maybe wood benches, that kind of thing.
But as we see with the existing playground,
the posts are rotting out.
And that's really where the decay,
it becomes kind of a safety issue, right?
And so that's why it's closed.
And wood does decay more quickly,
does deteriorate more quickly than metal.
So again, that's kind of a decision point
or what do we prioritize?
So with that in mind, we were not anticipating
to incorporate the sand, the water, the rubber surfacing
as we refine the design.
But certainly do want to hear from council
and appreciate all of the comments
that the community have provided to us.
So now we know what their priorities and preferences are.
So with that, in terms of next steps for the play area,
assuming the design moves forward mostly
with the adjustments that I just mentioned earlier,
we'll still be working with a vendor to adjust
and select final equipment that could begin tomorrow.
So design development is like a roughly 30% level
construction document completion.
So they were really still just looking at,
okay, what's the colors and materials,
trying to finalize those types of selections,
finalize the layout.
so now is a great time if we want to kind of course correct or make kind of
further adjustments now is kind of a great time to do so. But assuming things
move forward we've been looking at preparing construction documents later
this winter putting the project out to bid next summer in 2027 would allow for
construction to start in the fall of 2027 with a grand reopening of the
playground in spring of 2028.
And then as Haa mentioned, kind of the four phases,
phase one having been completed or will be completed shortly
later this year.
We are currently in phase two, so designing the play area.
Again, that process will take us through spring of 2028
for construction completion, hopefully.
And then the future phases for the overall park renovation,
renovating the bandshell and picnic area looking to start that winter of
2027 to 28 and then phase four kind of renovating the rest of the park so like
the remaining common areas and the pathways winter of 28 to 29 and with
that our slideshow is done and we're happy to take any questions thank you
sure there are lots of questions one quick one can someone remind me when
this park was built? How old is it? Old. So, I mean, how long is the... I'm kind of
getting at the wood that's rotting. But so, when do you think we built this park?
For the record, Todd Trimble, Parks and Recreation. I don't have that answer. I
don't know if Siva or somebody from Public Works would. I know that the... just
going on my experience and being here for almost 10 years, the equipment has
been here the whole time. I know that it's probably been several years prior to that as
well. I've heard from long-time community members of other elements and place structures that were
there prior, but that's what we're up against now. At least the current elements are certainly at and
probably nearing the point of no longer useful life. We're seeing that more and more every day.
you know this park like all our playgrounds and hot lots are inspected annually and
and this is the park that requires regular maintenance to stay
to keep up with the safety certifications and things that are required every year.
The structure that's rotten is probably 10 to 15 years old? Oh yes. Okay. I would say
in that range. I know the area that we're talking about that's currently being reinforced,
the larger area for the younger kids area that's what we're talking about primarily,
that would be replacing. Those have wood elements that are being replaced and repaired on a very
regular basis across the lawn there. The structure, the older kids structure that we showed that
is closed temporarily is being reinforced, but those have been reinforced multiple times
over the last 10, 15 years.
Thank you.
Other questions?
Do you know the last time we made significant improvements
for this play structure?
I'm afraid not in the time I've been here.
Most of our improvements have been replacement
of worn out and broken wood structures on the bridge,
on the other structures on the,
what I would call the younger kids side.
Of course you have the swings there.
we routinely replace in swing buckets and belt seats and things like that.
It's an ongoing type of thing.
Obviously, the replenishment of the engineered wood fiber, the sand,
all that stuff is an ongoing effort that probably could have occurred more frequently.
Although I have a question for Director Trimble while you're up here.
Did the parks and rec commission look at this or not yet?
Yes, they have. I mean, as you know,
this topic has been on a number of council meetings,
a number of park and rec commission meetings.
When I started here close to 10 years ago,
the master plan had just been completed and our goal at that time was really to
replace the elements in that one area there that we're talking about mostly.
Um, so, uh, the parking rec commission did review this, uh, at their August meeting.
Uh, they were in favor of, of the, uh, the proposal and the time that I've been
here, I must tell you that, um, and it's really kind of partly led to this.
Cause I've, you know, in addition to the half a dozen times I was out at the
farmer's market and the fourth of July and different things, of course, over the
time and being, you know, you know, spending 40, 50, 60 hours a week, pretty
close, you know, to that area.
and we've got a lot of people coming in, so I've spoken over, you know, hundreds of people
over the years, whether it's me out there trying to ask the nannies to some of the nanny
groups to get off the tennis courts, which they're obviously drawn to because of the
enclosure. The biggest comments we received, my staff and I, are consolidating the ages.
Some sort of modest, as Marie mentioned, enclosure area to keep kids in and dogs and bikes and
other things out. And we just thought that, you know, in the
area that we're having, we're not talking about a lot of
space, unfortunately, 13,000 or so square feet, we're trying to
come up with some designs that would appeal to the biggest
group. So when I was out there, you know, there were certainly
people had ideas, I was surprised to hear of a lot of
community members who felt there was nothing wrong. This is a
great park. And why do we even have to change it? But, you
You know, and I understand that to a degree,
but the great majority that I spoke to,
not that other people didn't have some specific requests
were nothing but excited to see, you know,
the possibility that we're looking at.
So the end.
Oops.
No, go ahead.
What is, isn't there a way to incorporate
more natural materials while maintaining accessibility. There was some reference to
the rubber surfacing as opposed to a different type of surfacing. Is that a cost issue? Is it
a maintenance issue? Can you talk about that? I think the reference is to the port and blade
resilience surface provides many advantages that Marie and both Ha mentioned. Certainly,
You know, I certainly oversaw the maintenance of the facility the majority of my time here.
It's up to the transition of public works, you know, a few years ago.
The engineered wood fiber is technically compliant, and I think that's what some of the community
members were referring to is maybe reduce the amount of port and place surfacing and
replace it with what we have now, which is the engineered wood fiber, which is again,
technically compliant, but it's certainly more difficult to maneuver and to move around
in if you're a child in a wheelchair. Again, our goal was to try to appeal to the widest
margin.
Yes, I was hoping that the consultant could sort of address that and talk a little bit
about the cost differential, too, and accessibility.
Yeah, sure. So as I mentioned, I'll go through the various options that we have for surfacing.
So rubber poured in place, so PIP, rubber surfacing, is again the gold standard, gold
standard because it does provide for year-round access. It's unitary, meaning it's, you know,
it knits together and it's poured like concrete and then it kind of hardens and it provides
that spongy feel. And so, you know, whether you're in a cane or a wheelchair, a kid,
I mean, it provides that nice spongy surface. It is expensive. It's anyways, I don't need
to get into the dollars unless you ask for it. But yeah, it is on the higher range in
terms of cost. And then you have things like rubber tiles, we don't recommend that it tends
to have, like, a lot of edges that tend to lift over time that create kind of trip hazards.
So we don't recommend that. So then, you know, the alternative, the primary alternative to
poured in place rubber would be a material called engineered wood fiber. So it's engineered to
knit together. It has a specific kind of particle size. But all of that is to provide for a surface
that provides for that sponginess so that the kid falls, that they don't injure themselves,
but as well as kind of knitting together to, in theory, provide for wheelchair access.
And so when I say in theory, it's because, you know, yes, when you install it and you
compact it, you know, properly and whatnot, and you maintain it, then it does provide
for the kind of that well-knit, more like compacted surface.
And so if you're in a wheelchair and they have tests to check for this, you know, if
you turn in a wheelchair, you'll be able to turn, like the effort to turn is not more
significant than, you know, another type of surface.
So that's kind of how they gauge things.
There's kind of the, in theory, and then the practical side is just, yeah, every day your,
you know, maintenance staff are out there, kids are playing as soon as the kid plays
there or they're digging right because they like that material and they want to move stuff around
and it's fun then they create like a divot that's no longer accessible there um or they slide down
and their the the action of their feet kind of hitting the ground will kick that material out
you know at slide exits um at swings right kind of that swinging action so and then spinners if
if we have spinners and they're running around.
So just that action, there's a lot of kind of high use areas
where that engineered wood fiber would realistically fall out
of compliance very quickly.
I mean, unless you had someone there raking very regularly.
So that's just the reality.
I mean, every municipality kind of deals with
and has to consider, right, the kind of the balance
between the materials.
of the utility and the cost.
Is that what we have now, the engineered wood fiber?
Okay.
Yeah.
Yeah, you have, it's engineered wood fiber
and then there's sand that's migrated.
Can I follow up on your points about the material?
So the port in place, rubberized.
Can you explain what happens in terms of the long haul?
can it be cut, can it be destroyed, how do you repair it?
I understand there can be problems with that.
I'm also concerned about the comments
about the smell and the heat.
So can you talk about that a little bit
in terms of experience of...
I see some of the advantages to it,
but I also am concerned about its long-term maintenance
and what it looks like if it's damaged over time.
Yes, so everything, there's a maintenance required
of any material, right?
I would say with the poured in place rubber,
the frequency of maintenance would be much less.
So once the material gets poured as installed,
assuming it's kind of normal wear and tear,
it should last a number of years.
manufacturers, the vendors do recommend going in and kind of reapplying a binder to help
kind of maintain the integrity of that top layer. And so, you know, assuming you follow
all of those recommendations, I mean that it should last, you know, seven, eight, ten years,
it seems is what we've we've seen is what our other clients have seen on kind of an average basis.
Certainly, sometimes the installation is not quite good.
They don't mix the binder that well.
So then some of those instances, it
may start sloughing off a little bit more quickly,
a little bit more premature deterioration sometimes
happens.
But we've worked on resurfacing, resurfacing projects as well.
So what we do then is instead of having to re-pour
the whole layer, you would scrape off the top layer.
They call it the wear core.
So you scrape that off, and then you can reapply.
So there's ways to kind of, over time, repair,
maintain that surface.
The flip side of engineered wood fiber, any material that moves
is you will have to, it's made of wood,
so it will deteriorate over time.
It will compact.
it will move. And so wood fiber you attend to have to replace more often. I don't know.
Maybe every few years. I don't know where your maintenance schedule is, but yeah. So
there's, again, there's kind of pros and cons to each material. And then I think you asked
about heat and smell. So yes, it's a unitary surface, so it does kind of retain heat. It's
a virgin rubber, it has a binder. Once that kind of cures, then there wouldn't expect
to be too much off-gassing, but there is just still that smell. That is one of the tradeoffs.
I will say just in terms of options, it is one of the primary options out there. I think
In terms of safety, what we can say is, you know, it meets all of the state environmental
standards.
It meets the playground safety standards.
So certainly there can be preferences regarding the material.
Other questions?
We have to use just one surface.
So would it be possible, perhaps, where we have intended more accessible items to have
the rubberized surface and maybe in some other areas to have the engineered hardwood surface?
That's one question.
Another question is, would it be possible to incorporate more grass or other natural
things to make it cooler?
I'm concerned about the height of the equipment proposed for the older kids.
experience on the school board was kids fall off equipment. They think that the rubberized surface
is going to protect them from their fall and we had a lot of broken arms after installing that at
some of our school sites. And it was due to the height of the equipment on it and we actually had
to lower equipment. I also have a lot of concerns about the slides, those tube slides. Kids sometimes
don't come out of the tube. Parents can't get in there to get them out. They don't know what's
going on in there, animals can get in the tube. You can get animals in the wood bark, so that's
a real problem too because you can't really see what's in there and so you can get scat from wild
animals in the wood bark. So that's another maintenance issue that I think we have to think
through. That's a big problem with sand, that's why the schools took all the sand out. It wasn't
because kids don't love sand but it gets tracked everywhere and you have problems with animals who
also like sand. I feel like there are just a lot of questions about what's being proposed
and I'm personally concerned we don't have enough time to go through it tonight in the
depth and detail that I think this larger project as someone said we aren't doing this every 10
years. It's probably been 20 or 25 years since we last did this. I know there are new kinds of wood
that are pressurized and don't splinter and are weather resistant. I mean, there may be other
materials that could be used for this equipment. I haven't done the research to
extensively know what all those materials are or might look like. But as an Orinda homeowner,
I would kind of like to have a spectacular park that meets the needs of our community. And I just,
I don't feel like this design gets us there.
By the way, we're still just doing questions.
I understand.
You're in a really cool role here.
I'm going off track.
But I do think there are a lot of questions
about what has been proposed.
Yeah, and I think we're going to be, this is a little,
and we're not done.
We're just, this is a little in the spirit of a workshop
versus a decision.
So I would hope that both the question and the discussion
portion after we take public comment will be interactive.
So I hope that we continue in this vein.
And please, I know there's lots.
I thought she had a question that wasn't answered,
that can we do multiple surfaces?
Do we have to do all or nothing?
Yes, can you please?
Yes, so you can, and we do that quite often.
It's kind of a primary way that our other municipal clients
try to bring the cost down and kind of balance that,
like balancing that kind of desire to improve accessibility
as well as the maintenance and the cost.
So yes, we can kind of lay out the rubber
to provide for access, like basically accessible path
or path of travel to each piece of equipment.
And maybe in kind of the areas in between
would be like engineered wood fiber.
You could do that.
I think the, again, kind of the pros and cons
The other point is having two materials. You do introduce seams. And so this seems like the rubber has to dive down, it has to kind of terminate, and then the thigh bar comes up to it and so it always creates like a lip, which, you know, is pretty commonplace but yeah just kind of understanding that.
it would kind of reintroduce some of that maintenance concern for for staff but certainly
it also reduces kind of the square footage so hopefully in the big scheme of things it may be a
lesser effort overall. One of the things and I can understand this in the midst of
the actual layout of the playground equipment and all that but I'm curious given so many of the
comments as well as the experience of living here and having kids play there
and all that. The shade is so important and I can appreciate the umbrellas that
are you're showing but was there any consideration given to more trees around
around the around it or whatever to kind of enhance the feel of and provide more
shade? Yes so the orientation of the playground related to trees I mean the
the existing trees are already kind of in the optimum location.
We can certainly and we would be looking at introducing trees that would probably have
to be kind of in the middle of the play area and there's kind of pros and cons related
that like kids running and you know they're going to run into the trees or they're trampling
the trees.
So those would be things that we kind of take under consideration.
Putting trees kind of close to the path doesn't really provide any shade.
that's not ideal. So I think we're kind of realistically looking at some type
of shade structure over the equipment and the play area is pretty big. It's, I
don't know if we want to put like a ginormous you know shade structure over
the entire play area. It may end up being you know we would want to prioritize
the little kids because their skin is more sensitive and incorporate maybe
more integrated shade in like the youth structure, for example, would be a way of doing it, you know,
or we would be looking at like standalone shade structures over the entire but the downside to
that is play equipment needs a certain like vertical clearance so that kids don't try to
climb the shade structure and it ends up being like seven feet plus. And so there's all of these
kind of considerations where you end up with a shade structure that's kind of much very
quite tall in comparison to what it might otherwise need to be.
And then the structure gets big, posts get big, foundations get big,
kind of the cost starts increasing. So those are all the things we're kind of trying to balance.
Other questions. Really our questions. Have you designed sort of wooden? Oh, I'm sorry.
Go ahead. Have you designed wooden structures like the kind we have before and how long do they
usually last. I think the one we have has been there at least 22 years because I spent a lot of
time in that play again 22 years ago. I agree with you. But so, I mean, we have dry rot now,
we're just trying to, I'm just trying to, what is the lifespan of more natural materials generally?
So what I thought the youth structure looks like the post was buried in the ground or in the wood
fiber. I didn't dig. I do know that kind of designs have changed or kind of improved over time.
So the more kind of modern, recent, they do have like metal anchors, if you will, that the posts,
the wood posts then gets kind of bolted to. And so that helps kind of elevate the wood pieces kind
of above ground. So that does help with like decay, like reduced decay and whatnot. And vendors will
say I think I think they probably claim 30 plus years if not more but those
would those do tend to be kind of more recent like Robinia is a fairly recent
it's the last 10 years material so you know they haven't been proven to kind of
that end in terms of playground use but there are wood options out there. Are they
more expensive?
I would say probably comparable.
It depends.
The trade-off between wood and metal posts
have more to do with the complexity
of the structure and the height.
So with metal structure, like what we showed in the design,
we can get quite tall.
And it's very cost-effective.
With wood, we would tend to max out a certain height
and certain complexity, because we
have to think about the structural strength of the wood.
And so something that's too tall, too thin, right?
There's some limitations to that.
So let's say if we did want to go wood,
we would be looking at probably simpler structures
and what is shown less tall.
Things like spinners would need to be metal and plastic,
I think.
So we wouldn't be able to do a one-for-one replacement
throughout.
But we'd probably be looking at potentially a mix,
if we still wanted to meet kind of that inclusive goal.
Other questions?
So it just seems like, again, you could have a mixture.
Or you could have some items that are more naturally
prone to being metal, and some that
might be more like a playhouse or something that
could be more wood, that maybe what we're hearing
from our community is a mixture of materials,
not all or one or the other.
One of the things I was worried about and didn't know
was the shade and the area for parents and caregivers
to sit and watch the kids play
and not having that be in brutal sun as well.
Have you?
It looks like the whole middle of the proposal
was just the poem play and that there wasn't,
I couldn't see where there was an area
for caregivers and parents to sit in.
Yes, and we would wanna provide shade over for them as well,
or shade for seating areas, yes.
But I think on the plan,
we were showing a large picnic perimeter,
picnic table perimeter around where all the shaded trees are.
So the people that are there with their kids
would have the respite of having the shaded area.
Which is a kind of a popular area now
where the existing trees along Arenda Way
Fortunately, we had to remove some of the larger mature trees
that are kind of on the driveway a few years ago
due to some disease which did provide shade on that portion.
But the existing five or six trees on the back
are the arborist shows that they're healthy
and that provides a lot of shade for that back area.
And in the design will show that Marie did
that we kind of are instilling more tables
and seating areas along the back there
with more of an engineered wood fiber material
keep that natural and not to have the port and play or pavers something like that around the tree
bases of the tree and the tree roots. So I think for people who, you know, I think we showed for
the caregivers and people who are going to be more or less mobile, there's optimal shade along that
way and then trying to add more shade throughout that she indicated. I want to just add, I did,
we did a quick research, I should have known, because there's a sign right there in the driveway
that the park itself the player itself was built in as a bicentennial project so 1976 50 years ago
I know it's been changed out the amenities have been changed out multiple times since then
and then regarding the resilient play surf scene you know Pine Grove right across here has
that surface and has had it for over 10 years I know the Public Works has done some maintenance
recently on it but there was really little maintenance now it's certainly not as large
but it gets a lot of use. So like Marie said, with the maintenance, it's been a popular area.
It does have kind of a modest shade structure over it with the sales, but
has fared really well for 10 plus years with really no maintenance.
Minegrove has a rubber surface.
Resilient port and place surface, yeah.
And can I ask one?
No, there's still more questions coming, so please go ahead.
what's the life what do the vendors say is the lifespan of the of the metal structures
i'm just comparing with the wood yeah i mean 40 50 years easy yeah i don't know if you i don't
know if you remember or if anybody remembers who uh framed our four goals the the goal of all
inclusiveness where did that come from prior council you guys i think it was a combination
of us and the beginning. I mean, like I said, over the years, those are some of the comments
that my staff and come to in the office and people just being in the park was the inclusivity,
the combining of the areas and the security of the fencing and those types of things.
But it wasn't a council decision that these are the things that we prioritize.
Not that I recall specifically, but as far as the more inclusivity and the surfacing
I think is something that has evolved.
Evolved.
Yeah.
Just to be clear, the distinction of inclusivity is being, I think, defined two different ways.
One is incorporating both the playgrounds that's more inclusive for families, and then
there's the accessibility issues.
Yes, yes, yes.
Consolidation versus accessibility is what I was doing.
And I think the inclusivity and consolidation was definitely part of the parks master plan
that was approved back in 2017-18, that time around.
Right, but I'm just trying to make it wheelchair accessible.
Right.
That, who decided that?
And I'm not hearing a clear answer, but that took us...
Well, that evolved.
I will say a lot of that was driven by me because I have a lot of experience with that.
And if you want to find funding for a project, you might want to make sure it's accessible.
Because if it's not, you're not going to find funding for it.
Right.
Other questions?
I only had one, and that was the tube slide versus an open slide.
How do you make that recommendation?
Yeah.
So for a structure that that's tall, it would need to be a tube slide so that kids can't
inadvertently or intentionally try to exit the slide that high up.
I figured it was something like that.
I didn't have any other questions.
And we do have some speaker cards.
Please.
Admittedly, the park's been a long-term topic.
And I have a feeling still will be.
But the reality is, remind me, have we
tried to get grant money for the park?
We have not yet tried to do that because we
don't have a kind of a design.
enough of a design to go out there and see if there's funding available, but we would pursue
state park money available. Okay. We are getting, is it 10 o'clock where we have to extend the
meeting time? As I call the two speaker cards out Rachel and Lauren who've been waiting forever
to come up and talk, we just real quickly need to do a resolution to extend the meeting.
City Manager, how long would you recommend giving the other item? 30 minutes. All right,
let me just round up to 10 30 is what I will make a motion for do I have a second or a different
proposal was it 10 30 for both items yes so I think the best plan is to cut it off sooner
than that because you're gonna really you always go we go go up to a deadline so create a shorter
deadline and then we'll extend it I'd like to suggest 10 30 so we can keep going but it's up to
weigh in so we can keep going beyond 10 30 no so we can just go through and get to 10 30 and try to
to get this done. Okay, but the way it works with the deadline is you get it done earlier.
Second, all in favor of 1030? Aye. Any nays? Sure, nay. It passes four to one. We will
really try our best. With that, Rachel and Lauren, please come up. I truly appreciate
your patience. I know you guys have kids, or at least I know Rachel does. Good evening,
there Iverson and his team council members,
I really appreciate the opportunity
to talk about this subject because I have four children.
My oldest is eight, my youngest is one,
where you spend a ton of time at the park,
a ton of time at the library, that's where we go a lot.
I don't wanna repeat everything
that all the other parents have said tonight.
I agree with all of what they've said,
more natural materials, more space for open-ended play,
More shade.
I feel like these designs that are proposed
were proposed by somebody who does not know this community,
does not know how the kids currently interact in the park
and on the play structures and in the sand.
I love the term sand migration.
I'm going to start using that with my kids.
When the sand is migrating to my car,
the sand is migrating to my house.
I love that.
But I think it is so important to minimize
the unnatural materials in these playgrounds,
the proposal that set forth, I hate, I hate both of them.
There's nothing natural about the nature design
aside from the colors selected
and that there's nature in the title.
I know how my kids interact with the current playground.
I know the sand is probably a pain to maintenance.
It is so much fun for the kids.
It is probably the most used feature in that playground.
My kids also go to the water fountain
and bring the water back in spite of me telling them,
stop doing that.
They will spend hours in that sandbox,
even my eight-year-old, digging holes, filling the holes,
putting water in that sand, digging another hole.
It's what they spend most of the time doing.
I agree with Councilmember Hoxie that the height of that
playground is too high.
I do not like those long tube slides.
I think you're gonna get young kids up there.
They're gonna get stuck just like they do
at Heather Farms Park.
I think it does not need to be that high
to be attractive to older kids.
It just has to be more interesting.
And I think the design that is being proposed
is not interesting.
It is inclusive maybe.
It is low maintenance.
It is so boring.
And it's gonna get very old, very fast
to the kids in this community.
There is not enough shade in most of our playgrounds,
aside from I think Pine Grove does a pretty good job
with the big sale.
I think, I'm asking the council to really consider
what you want this space to look like
for the next 20 to 30 years.
I do not see this proposal, either of these proposals,
as something that I want to go to with my children.
Thank you very much.
Thank you, and Lauren.
And then I'll ask if anybody else would like to speak
who hasn't just come on up after this speaker.
Hello. Thank you, Mayor Iverson and council members for your time and attention on this
project. I can really see how much you all care about getting this right and it's appreciated.
And yeah, hopefully it can be for the next 50 years because that's amazing. My name's
Lauren, oops, Lauren Desmond. I'm a mom of three and a recent home buyer in Arrinda.
We moved here two years ago from New York City. And when we visited to make our decision,
we came to the park and it was our first impression of Arrinda. I actually met one of the other
their moms that spoke earlier, just coincidentally.
And I sometimes feel I spend more time
in this park than in my own home.
I can tell you who does Tai Chi at 9 AM.
I can tell you which children nap
in the shade in the afternoon.
I know the caregivers.
I know the walkers.
I could go on and on.
And they all know me.
At least maybe they know my face.
I want to echo the previous comments
and respectfully ask you to please reconsider
and engage the community in a meaningful way.
Surveys are tricky.
You know, the questions can be complicated.
People can be answering a question in one way
that they think means one thing.
I have a communications background,
and it's an art form.
We, myself and another mom who was here earlier,
we started a website.
We didn't know what to do.
I had filled up the survey monkey
thinking I would get something back.
and then seeing that this was progressing,
we said, well, let's see who else might feel the same.
Let's start a website.
Let's show that there's some traction here.
And we started it yesterday.
We have over 120 emphatic responses.
People have reached out to me to say, what can I do?
How can I donate?
How can I get involved?
People really, really care about this park.
And, you know, I do too.
So I would say there's, I don't wanna get into
all the nitty gritty of the details,
but I think there's just two sides to every decision
and that has to be really carefully looked at.
So the first one that I will address
and maybe the only one is consolidating the playground.
Having two separate areas is kind of the magic right now.
So I understand and appreciate my kids are small
needing to keep an eye on a toddler
or you know, needing to keep everyone safe.
But I would encourage you to look into Jonathan Haid
if you haven't read The Anxious Generation.
And one of the most important things that he talks about is the importance of children
of all ages having safe, independent play, where they can be a person in the world and
not have someone on top of them.
So this park is one of the few places where kids, middle schoolers, high schoolers can
go, their parents know that they're safe, and they can be there.
And I see them there too.
So I think many people, just kind of to end, can resonate with the experience of giving
a child a complicated, exciting, colorful, new expensive toy and having them play with
the box.
I just share that to urge you to think a little differently here and keep it simple.
I wish we could keep the park the way it is, truly.
I don't have the maintenance costs, but yeah.
So thank you so much for your time and we're here to help however we can.
Thank you.
Thank you.
And I'll just ask if there's anybody else, the speaker already spoke one time.
I will say yeah, you can't speak a second time on the same item.
So it was public forum last night.
Nope.
Because you were speaking on item K1.
I'm sorry about that.
And with that.
Excuse me, through the mayor.
Yes.
We have a zoom.
I'm so sorry.
I knew habit.
Yes, please.
Jordan.
I'm so sorry.
Can you hear me?
I was on field.
Okay. Yes, Jordan, go ahead.
Thank you so much council members for listening to us. I am a mom I recently moved here from San Francisco in January, and I think what we, you know, there's really kind of only one large playground, which is this one that needs to be redone, and I think a lot of us feel similarly.
is to just have a third option and maybe revisit.
If you have been to any of the playgrounds
in San Francisco with the large cement slides
that everyone loves, there's different sizes
that you can get or anything that's as rock and sand,
tunnel tops, play scape is great.
And as well, I think that is the vision
that we are looking for.
I know we have expressed these things,
but I would really urge you all to even just go
look at pictures or walk around it and experience it. It is safe, it is the free play that all of us
want that the kids love to do and it's year-round play and I anyways I just I really appreciate
consideration that's that's happening and I think a lot of the parents feel this way and
I would be happy to go and do we live in the Delray area and go and talk to all the parents and get
more input if that would be helpful. If it's going to be done, I think it needs to be done
the way that the families want it to be done. Thank you for your comment. And then I'll ask
if there's anybody else from the public while we're doing Zoom and have the room. Okay, great.
With that, we'll bring it up for public comment. I mean, up for discussion deliberation. I'd love
I love to go first this one time, maybe not the only time.
But, you know, the famous song,
they paved paradise and put up a parking lot, right?
We are replacing nature with fake nature and it's so weird.
We're replacing trees with shade.
And I realized we had,
I had actually run into Rachel who I didn't know,
but we were just talking over the weekend
and her comments resonated so strongly with me
that I realized I'd been harboring all of these doubts
and disappointment and figured it was just me
because the city manager and I were,
I was asking questions and she said,
look, people complain about sand.
That's just not the people who are here talking tonight.
People don't come out to a public meeting
to talk about how much they hate and fear
animal scat in the sand, or, you know,
the bad things with water and other materials.
So I realize that we're hearing a lot of one group,
and we're not hearing the group that complains day in,
day out in the city.
Staff have to hear those complaints.
But my overarching reaction to,
even when I took the original survey,
is for God's sake, this is a park.
And let's be a park, and let's be a playground at a park
like the magical one in Walnut Creek
that's got a little water fountain in the sandbox,
and the kids love that,
and it's got the boulders and little fake train
that you sit on,
the Lafayette Reservoir play structure
that kids can literally get lost in.
And it's not tall, it's nets and wood,
but it served my family for more than a decade.
And at Pine Grove, I went there a lot with my,
as my younger kid, it was built,
my other kids were aging out,
and I never once interacted with my kids
at the Pine Grove Playground.
They played and I watched.
And so as I heard this, I'm finding myself wanting
to just replace what's there now.
Let's fence in the top lot,
because the problem with the two separated
is that your little one can run into traffic
while your kid over there gets hurt
and then your little one is gone.
So for sure a fence may be combining, I'm open to that,
but I would just replace a lot of what we have
with different wood and rope and things like that
before we go rushing to make everything rubber and metal.
So that's just my initial reaction.
And I'm sure we all have lots to say.
I definitely think that I don't want to move ahead
with these concepts at this point,
mostly because, and one of you said it really, really well,
This park is so important to this community.
I mean, I'm not questioning the survey results
and I'm not questioning the, you know,
the fact that, you know, it's very, very, very hard
to get all the input that you want and need,
but we have been working on trying to deal
with improving the park for a very, very, very long time.
It is not going to cause this guy to fall for us to,
you know, take more time to get it the way the community would really like it, and clearly
there's enough groundswell and I, the trade, the trade-offs are very real. I can see some
of the, you know, pluses and minuses and I think that the safety and the maintenance
and all that is very real consideration. But, you know, I mean, quite honestly, what's
out there today, my kids were playing in and my kids are in their early thirties people.
So I know that park's been there in the exact same way for a long time.
So I just think that, you know, I understand how challenging the consultant's job is to
try to balance everything the city's asking for, but I just think we're just not there.
We're missing the park.
I'm marked right at the moment.
And I am very concerned about the height of the structure and I have to admit, my first
reaction just even looking at the visuals was this just doesn't look like a render.
And so consequently I fully respect the need to do a really good job with materials and
maintenance and I have mixed feelings about the sand. I can totally understand
that I almost you know I can completely understand kids liking and loving it. I
can also understand all the problems we have with it and a little bit of the you
know safety and health concerns of sand. I you know there is just no way to keep
animals and things like that out of it. So I have mixed feelings about some of
those things, but I think we're just not there yet.
And if this is in the end gonna cost us more
or take more time, it's just too important
to our community not to do that.
Yeah, I guess my concern is like,
what should the process be to get to a place
that we're all more comfortable with?
It seems clear at this point, we're not comfortable.
I'm certainly not comfortable
and I have worked on a lot of playgrounds.
I feel like the community wants something different.
We want something that showcases our community.
As someone said, for some people,
it's their first introduction to Orinda.
And we want it to reflect who we are as a community.
And I don't think that this quite does that.
I absolutely believe in the accessibility issues
and want to make sure our playground is accessible
to all children of all abilities.
And I think that's something very important
that we need to make sure to incorporate.
And unfortunately, or fortunately,
depending on your perspective, it
will require some of that rubberized surface
because they're really, you can't push a wheelchair
through that whatever they call it, the wood chip stuff.
But I don't think it all has to be one thing.
And I think we may want to think about doing
more different areas or different sections
so that it appeals to different types of kids
and different families and maybe more things
with imaginative play, like playhouses or different,
I'm not an expert in all the options that are out there,
but we certainly all can do some research
and figure out different types of options
that are out there that might be more interesting
to different groups of kids.
So I just feel like the whole process needs
a lot more thought and discussion.
And I don't know, I would love to bring in community input
in a more reasonable process.
The people who stuck it out to be here tonight,
I really appreciate your being here with us
to discuss this because it's not something
we're gonna do every five or 10 years,
and it is a big expenditure for the city,
and so we wanna get it right,
and I just would like to take the time to do that.
So what comes to mind beyond what we've all been saying
is that so often we talk about retaining
our semi-rural character and how important
that semi-rural character is.
And when I look at this rubber product,
I think maybe in another universe that's semi-rural,
but to me it's not.
And I also think about grand babies,
little babies, and the idea of them, you know, down on the crawling and smelling and having
that off gas come, it just doesn't appeal to me. Maybe it's a bit, wouldn't be so bad
if they were bigger kids, but, and I don't know if that gas takes off, you know, minimize,
does it always put off a gas? Or is it just when it's newer, it's a gas, gassy, gassy
I don't know anyone I would love to study this further. I'd love to
Figure out how we can expedite it. I don't want to spend 10 years. I want it to be done
As soon as possible and be the best possible thing we can come up with
So yeah, I've raised the question. What's the process?
so I I do want to
Yes, and I would say I do want to give some context though for for
Sort of the members of the public and thank you so much for being here with you know
Little ones that are gonna be waking up in a few hours. So appreciate that
You know
As you've heard this park has been there for a really really long time
I I spent a like every day there myself
22 years ago when I had a four-year-old a two-year-old in a newborn, right and
went from there to the community center and back and I remember the sand play and that was big with the toddlers so
but it's but it has been here for so long that there has been a desire and a plan to move forward with us really for
really long time and in order to
to
Do this in a city with a limited budget right and limited staff
We have had we need to design in order to get funding to make improvements
And we do have heard a lot of people who have been asking for years and years and years
for different improvements.
So that is sort of the context.
And so I wanted to let I want to let the public know that so they know that the consultants
and staff are bringing to us, you know, I think to a certain extent what we asked in
terms of a design that is accessible, that is, you know, we there was a lot of it was
interesting for me to hear the comments about keeping the two areas separate
because we've heard so many comments about bringing them together because I
as a single caretaker can't be with two different kids at the same age at the
same time so it's sort of like that problem has to be solved one way or the
other right it can't be you know we have to choose and so we've so we you know
like most decision-making we are trying to take all the commentary at the same
time. So I just want to thank that, thank staff and consultants for what you did
bring to us and the process that this went through, right? At the same time, you
know, we did the survey because we wanted public feedback and we got some of it
through that, but we also got like, you know, if the survey had like 394
responses, we've gotten this week probably 130 if we count the survey
that you all just put out overnight, right. So we can't ignore that, especially when I wrote down
to this public comment resonates and the feeling of this, you know, it's just, so I think it's a,
you know, I appreciate all the work that's gone into this, but we do need to pause it a little
bit more and have a process and incorporate this. And, you know, as you're all talking about this,
I was thinking, gosh, I do feel like, you know, focus groups and sort of maybe even
in the park, right, to talk about how can we do this and, and, you know, I wrote down
someone talked about how they like the Pleasant Hill Park and, you know, I want to go look
at that now myself and so go back and look at this park.
And I know, I know the treehouse has been a hit for years and I'm sure it's not safe
enough but you know, so you know know that we have to incorporate safety and accessibility
and you know the inclusivity of keeping kids together from a safety perspective for caregivers
but and I think those are still values that that I want to see in a redesign and I don't know how
we go from here but I those are sort of because you know we're we're it's it's a lot it's important
to say we don't want this and we want more of this but then to actually with the park say this
is the design we want because not everyone's going to be happy right so someone mentioned cement
slides but also like there's you know my kids hated those right so I mean I never and I thought
they were on set right so we need to how do we move forward I guess is the can I give you a
suggestion please tell me that you want me to come back to you with a different process and I will
work with the team and we'll come up with um we'll put our heads together and come we've got a lot
of feedback from you tonight about general things that you want to see but let us come back to you
with a process that focuses more on public engagement, and maybe we can, I mean, obviously
it's going to be potentially a scope change to some of the work, but I think I could probably,
with the help of staff, come back to you with a more refined process, and we can have a
conversation about the process that could guide us in the next steps.
That's great, and I have one request with that.
And some of what gets brought back to us because, well, some of us are getting ready to hit
playgrounds again the second time around, but it's been a long time since I've been
hanging out at playgrounds.
I would love to see more images of what people think are great playgrounds or what people
are, you know, what's out there.
And yes, we can't afford the super deluxe, super, you know, $500 million Presidio playground.
But I would love to see some more images of some of the things that we've talked about.
Sure.
We can do that as part of the process.
I have one other request, and thank you, that's great advice.
If you can preview some of the phase four and five, so the paths that you're talking
about, and I know we're not even close to ready to design those, but if people can appreciate
that those will also be wider and smoother.
And so there was an image that had a fenced tote lot
and then a nice wide flat thing with people
biking and walking on that.
I think it will help us also project
the context for this playground.
So just as just pencil sketch, I think
that would help the conversation have a little context
if you're able.
And I'm so proud, because I'm closer to all this stuff,
because my kids were playing in playgrounds very recently.
And I will say the Walnut Creek and the Lafayette Reservoir I think are really magical examples
where imagination is front and center.
So I would throw those out as excellent role models.
I think in the spirit of our 12 minutes, we are ready for the world's fastest item, K2,
unless anyone has any final thoughts on K1.
Let's move on to K2 and see if we can speed run public health and safety practices relevant
to Senate Bill 1123. Darren, you're going to do your best work here in under three minutes.
Cliff's notes. Good. We've all read the package. Good. Okay. Good evening, Mayor, members of
the City Council, members of the public. Darren Hughes, associate planner, going through the
starter home revitalization act, just a very brief overview. This is, this allows up to
10 units on up to 10 parcels. So we've talked about this a couple of times. We met in March,
directives, came back, saw the ordinance passed in July for the other aspect, right now we're
here for public health and safety. So the first thing, blanket prohibitions versus specific
findings. We've talked about this in the past, we've discussed this with HCD, you know, the idea of
blanket prohibitions on new parcels within 100 feet of evacuation routes or any additional
measures that go above and beyond what the state law actually allows for, and it's basically
indefensible. So what we're looking at is what we have on the books already and what we could
potentially do to meet specific findings for denial when a project comes to us and doesn't necessarily
check off all the criteria. So the first thing, we did this little exercise where we looked at maps
and what could potentially qualify under this law. This first one is just fire hazard spherity zones.
Nothing in the red is allowed.
That's the very high-fire hazard severity zone.
If it's in the red, it's dead.
So we looked at the other portions.
Vacant parcels, we've got 48, assuming probably to be 47
based off of an SP9 application.
That could potentially qualify.
The parcels are small enough.
They're under 1.5 acres or max 1.5 acres.
26 of them are adjacent to evacuation routes.
22 of them are not adjacent to routes.
And these are parcels that are listed within the housing
element.
This one should be designated remainder potential,
not vacant parcel.
I apologize.
762 sites, that sounds alarming, but it is not nearly as
alarming as it should seem.
This is ultimately a paper exercise
where staff wanted to look at what could potentially
come forward if someone has a developed parcel
and decides to designate a remainder, which
is an existing use, so an existing house,
and then make a portion of their lot
eligible for this particular act.
But ultimately, when we are looking at this,
we're seeing there are a lot of issues
that face the potential for development here.
Topography is one of them.
You often have houses built up towards the front
of the streets.
How are you going to actually get a driveway past them,
especially on some of these longer lots?
A lot of the rear portions of these parcels
are within, can't actually even be developed
because of easements that exist for them,
access considerations, there's just a lot that goes on to,
or goes into this.
And ultimately there's a very wide gap
between what is possible via paper exercise
and what is actually plausible.
So overall in Orinda,
we're looking at severe physical constraints,
steep topography, inadequate size for access requirements,
geotechnical hazards that exist on a lot of these parcels.
What we're really seeing is that these parcels
that have not been developed so far
are not developed usually.
There are a myriad of reasons,
but one of the biggest ones is that they are difficult
to develop on.
People haven't even been able to figure out
how to get one single family residence on them,
let alone split it and create a whole bunch
of different residences.
That doesn't mean that that's not happening to some degree.
we are getting a trickle of SB9 applications
where we do see a residence proposed
for one of these lots.
There are ways to approach this,
but generally speaking, these are not the ideal lots
when a developer is looking for easy opportunities
to say, hey, how do we split this up
and maximize profit on this.
So one of our biggest pieces,
and we've got Chief Isaacs here to talk to this
from, to speak to these points and answer any questions
from MOFD's perspective, but we're looking at the WUI code
and the fire code and billing code regulations.
This is where health and safety kicks in.
This is our bread and butter.
What I really just want to stress here,
I'm not going to represent these policies,
but what I want to stress is that over the past couple
of years, we've seen an increase, a significant increase
in coordination between our two departments
as we have standing meetings
and we now even have a permit tracking system
that their staff has access to
that we kick projects over to them.
And I will get calls as soon as Casey Irving sees something
and says, hey, this is actually kind of interesting.
Let's talk about this.
And so we get these things to the table much earlier
and work with the applicants to talk about what's feasible.
And part of that is we're seeing even SB9 permit applications
where someone wants to demolish an existing home
and can't even do that and replace it with a new home
because of the water considerations and the things
that they would have to do that make that project financially
feasible for the applicants. So there is a lot that's going to go into the way MOFD looks
at this for health and safety purposes that allows us to meet these findings and deny
a project if it's not going to be able to comply with the myriad of regulations in play.
Slightly smaller, much smaller. There's the drainage and storm water C3 requirements.
This is within the MMRP for Planet Rinda.
This is listed in the safety element.
If a developer cannot demonstrate
that the site can safely capture and drain stormwater
without destabilizing the hillside, the map may be denied.
So while this doesn't add incredible costs to a project,
it does add costs and does make a project not necessarily
pencil out in some of the steeper terrain.
Evacuation constraint threshold.
This is something that we looked at briefly. We don't recommend it. Basically, the tools that
we have to evaluate, to evacuate evacuation constraints and how a project might impact that,
especially for these smaller projects, just don't necessarily provide us with any meaningful
input or meaningful way to look at these projects and say, no, this isn't going to meet
certain standards. Something that we are looking at and that we are recommending as a pathway
forward is to consider some objective subdivision standards. This is allowed within the state law.
So two primary things that we have proposed, one is access management. So when you have a parcel
that has frontage on two different streets, you could potentially look at a requirement that any
access from that parcel be sidetracked to the smaller street in order to reduce that friction
on the main route. And then curb cut limitations. So trying to say, hey, we are only going to
allow curb cuts, a certain number of curb cuts within a certain distance of each other. We want,
if, you know, a parcel is going to be subdivided, then it should have one driveway that is shared
from multiple units. So we would look at those as standards. Our recommendation for that would
include up to $20,000 estimated by Public Works to try to consider a code amendment
to address these subdivision standards. One thing before I wrap up that I wanted to bring up,
just so that you have the full context, we had a couple of new bills that were signed into law.
One, SB 11, well, yes, 1116 amends the Starter Home Revitalization Act.
It basically relaxes some of the restrictions that are involved with that and gives a little
bit more flexibility, around 10-foot setbacks at the front, exempting stairs and bike storage
from the floor area, allowing for parcel sizes to go down to 960 square feet in certain circumstances
instead of 1200 square feet, voiding private CCNR prohibitions. So it does a few things
but it doesn't really impact health and safety and viability for these projects.
And then AB 1751, this is going to sound alarming.
It allows townhome communities up to 150 units
on lots of smallest 600 square feet
with a lot of the same conditions as this build.
Sounds crazy, but at the end of the day,
Orinda is not full of the green fields
that are right next to highways
that these types of subdivisions are really viable on.
We don't really have a whole lot of worry.
We're making our primary argument
that even up to 10 homes is pretty outrageous
for a lot of these parcels.
We've seen one total application
that is going to be proposing four homes
and we are in talks with someone else
who is actually meeting me at the counter tomorrow
to potentially look at another lot
for I think three residences on that one.
So this law sounds like a lot,
but it is just not something
that we project seeing occur in Orinda.
So with that, I do close the presentation.
If you have any questions for me or for Chief Isaacs,
we are available.
Before we do, we need to extend the meeting just a little bit,
five or 10?
Five.
Do I hear five?
Five.
All in favor?
Aye.
Aye.
Any questions before I open it up for public comment?
Seeing none, I don't have any speaker cards.
Is there anyone from the public who would like to speak,
or anyone on Zoom?
I hear none.
I bring it up for discussion.
and direction.
So I'm not sure what staff is looking for us to tell them.
So we are looking for direction on whether or not
we should pursue subdivision standard changes
to deal with the access management and the curb cut
limitations and a budget of about $20,000 to do that.
Seems self-evident to me that we should do that.
I would concur.
We're only asking for direction tonight.
OK.
mean I just don't see why we wouldn't look into doing that. It's just another way of helping us
have some guidelines for people who might come to us with that kind of proposal. Any other comments?
I would support looking into it. Again, I think this is unfortunately one of those things being
foisted on us that I sincerely doubt we really agree with and so to the extent that we can,
you know, put guardrails on it. That's what we should do.
And I thought the suggested changes were just common sense about things like access management,
so I think they're the right thing to do for the city.
Yeah, I agree with that point. I think the suggested changes are, make sense. You know,
these, a lot of these laws that come down are of what size fits all, and they work in some places.
and here I don't see as the staff report indicated a lot of application in practice frankly just
because it doesn't work with our topography but yeah I guess the only question is you know are
we wasting twenty thousand dollars but I to me this this feels prudent yes okay great does that
feel like direction I feel like I've gotten great direction consensus direction and with
that we will move on I'm very sorry council member Riley didn't get to give a big speech
We're on to the next item. Are there any other matters initiated tonight? Seeing none, we
can, I'm going to go ahead and have us go back to the closed session that we have on the agenda,
just because we had planned on going back, we may decide to, am I seeing a, nah, I think we're done.
So in that tonight we are going to adjourn in the memory of Beatrice B. Heggy, the wife of
Arinda's first mayor, Richard Heggy, who lived to a hundred. She passed away on July 31st,
had an incredible life in her own right of just an incredibly accomplished woman,
and her obituary is in this month's Arinda News if you'd like to see more.
So in her memory, I move we adjourn. Thank you.
Was she? Yeah, we had the whole like, she's amazing.
Okay.